r/filmmaking • • Aug 17 '24

Discussion Rich kids have ruined the American film industry

0 Upvotes

I recently watched a period movie about wrestling in the late seventies, which should have been AWESOME. It had no excuse not to be. Yet as I watched, i found myself bored. Like every scene was connected by an "and then" rather than by a "therefore/but." The antagonist was wooden and unrealized. The movie was just a series of depicted sensations and 'wouldn't it be cool if...' camera angles. So on a hunch, I looked up where the director went to high school. And sure enough, he went to a private boarding school in Connecticut. The antagonism was wooden because this director has never faced adversity. It's a series of sensations because he's had everything handed to him on a silver platter and knows nothing of struggle.

Movies were amazing when the Sydney Lumets and Stanley Kubricks of the world climbed out of squalid tenement houses and fist fought their way into the directors chair, skipping meals, looking for subway change in payphone coin returns, getting mugged and eating subway rats. But now American directing is being done by people who have faced less than zero adversity, so they literally don’t know how to depict it, because they have had frictionless lives. So the antagonism is wooden and abstract, and not a specter of a darkness we are all secretly pregnant with.

Thanks to unpaid internships, rich kids are the only ones who can get jobs in the industry anymore, and once they do, they only hire other rich kids, because they can pick one another out of a crowd. They only "feel comfortable" letting other rich kids direct films, and now films suck, because nothing, and i mean nothing, has ever happened to these people. They have no raw material to draw on. Everything is done for them by a gardener, or a tutor, or a cook. They have never had to fight for anything in their lives. And now they're in charge of telling the nation's stories to itself?

If you went to private high school and entered the film industry and are now a gate keeper, please pay attention to how many people you let through who went to public school. We are more colorful, we have better stories, we have interesting takes on the world, and we are actual citizens of the real world. Why wasn't sleeping in and getting bottle service sufficient? Why did you have to ruin American storytelling just so you could fill your days with something?

First people we eat, whgich shit goes sideways, are the privately educated entertainment executives, who probably hastened shit going sideways with their horrible zeitgeist-polluting decision-making anyway.


r/filmmaking • • May 27 '25

Question I hated The Substance -My inability to recognise satire in film. I hated it for being so objectifying, and for its ageism and a lot of other things. I did not at any point recognise the portrayal of satire until I did some reading/watching. I felt like a fraud. How do I get better at movie analysis?

0 Upvotes

I love movies and the art of filmmaking. I was very disappointed in myself when I couldn't tell there was satire. How do you recognise this? I also realised I might be bad at watching movies as a cinema enthusiast. I want to analyse scenes, characters, and nuances in movies in a better way. How do I do it? How can I be better at watching movies? Please also include any resources, reading/watching I need to do.

I don't think it was just this movie. There were several other obvious movies I couldn't really understand the deeper meaning at the first watch. Yes, not everyone can understand it, I am aware. ( A lot of people still don't know American Psycho or Fight Club are actually satires) but I wan't to be in the category of people who do get it at first watch even the most complex films. How do I do that?


r/filmmaking • • Jul 26 '25

Made the new poster for my film

Post image
7 Upvotes

Rate.


r/filmmaking • • Apr 24 '24

Question male gaze in film school

3 Upvotes

Hey all!

I am writing my final paper on the difference between female characters: written by men and women. I have been diving deep into the male gaze by Laura Mulvey and wanted to know if this phenomenon is still as integrated into the film industry as it looks to be. How do film schools and studies deal with the male gaze and subverting to it (if it even does at all)? Does anyone have any stories to share or examples to give? How does your course deal with the female experience or does it not separate this from the male experience ( talking to screenwriter students)?

Hopefully this makes any sense. I would be so happy if someone could help me, thanks a lot!

Love


r/filmmaking • • Apr 04 '25

Discussion I’m looking for the next John Williams.

0 Upvotes

Hi! I’m a 18-year-old director with a fire in my chest and no Plan B. I’ve directed, written, produced, and edited over 20 no-budget short films, won international festivals, and I’m currently halfway through production on my first feature.

I’m fully committed to becoming one of the greats, and I believe I’ll get there. But I know one thing: I can’t do it alone.

I’m looking for the next big film composer, the next John Williams, Ennio Morricone, Hans Zimmer, or whoever you think is the greatest. Someone who understands storytelling through sound, who wants to build something meaningful over the long run.

I don’t care how old you are, how experienced you are, as long as you think that your music can touch people or create great cinema, reach out. If you love movies like I do and want to create work that moves people, reach out. If you know someone who would be interested in talking, let me know. I don’t care about your resume. I care about your vision, your sound, and your obsession with story.

Here’s a link to a scene that I just shot and edited for my upcoming high school underground fight club short film: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1_Tr4OhT4gwBZRMhNJ-g3Q9sroe4COdTY/view?usp=drivesdk

DM me or drop a comment. Let’s talk.

(P.S. This is not necessarily a gig offer, although we could discuss that as well)

Let’s make magic!


r/filmmaking • • Feb 26 '26

The producer is the most underrated role in filmmaking — here's why no film exists without one

5 Upvotes

I wrote a breakdown of what producers actually do across all four stages of filmmaking — development, pre-production, production, and post. It covers the full hierarchy (EP, Line Producer, Field Producer, etc.) and what separates great producers from the rest.

As Dino De Laurentiis put it: "If no producer, no movie."

Would love to hear from other filmmakers — how has having (or not having) a strong producer affected your projects?

https://venusrisingmedia.substack.com/p/if-no-producer-no-movie


r/filmmaking • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion Give me your thoughts on this shot from my recent short “The janice job” on YT.

Post image
2 Upvotes

lmk what y’all can pick out!!

Also if you decide to watch it let me know what you can get out of that too!


r/filmmaking • • Jun 02 '26

Question Exactly what is a producer?

0 Upvotes

i understand that a producer is usually someone who greenlights the film, and hires the director and everything, but what if the producer IS the director and also literally everything else due to the film having no budget. I’ve played every character in a film multiple times, and done literally everything else (music, editing, etc.) so in this kind of film what is even the point of a producer, and considering this type of low budget film what do the different producer types even mean?


r/filmmaking • • Oct 31 '25

Documentaries legit change things more than ppl think

1 Upvotes

r/filmmaking • • Feb 03 '26

Discussion Is “tool worship” holding back originality in visual culture?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Feels like we’re spending more time mastering tools than questioning why we’re using them in the first place.


r/filmmaking • • Oct 14 '25

what is this shot called?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/filmmaking • • Nov 17 '25

Film audience survey <33

0 Upvotes

Hello! My name is Izzy and I am an A-level media studies student, I am conducting a survey on my upcoming film 'Where bluebirds fly' and I would really appreciate if you could spare a minute to complete my survey, it would be greatly appreciated <3
https://forms.gle/Hsgoor5vcf4UKJSH8
(I apologize if this goes against any rules, please delete this post if so)


r/filmmaking • • Jul 01 '24

Discussion Do filmmakers still have any hope, like any possibility to survive at all??

0 Upvotes

When sora ai was first announced it freaked me out really bad, in just one year ai have improved from Will smith eating spaghetti to near photorealistic images, imagine what it can do after 10 years, actors, directors, writers, cinema photographers... It's like... inevitable that they're all going to be replaced cuz filmmaking can cost so much money while ai costs nothing... I deeply fear my dream has already ended when I haven't even started to direct anything, I can't accept cinema just dies like that... it breaks my heart.

Ai isn't cinema or any kind of art form, there's nothing real in it, there's no real performance there's no real emotions there's no effort in it, it's null, it's soulless, it is but a theif, it does not create, art belongs to humans and humans only, I greatly dispise this technology, it might be a somewhat useful and convenient tool for others but for me it's nothing but an abomination.


r/filmmaking • • Mar 01 '25

Question How’s the color grade?

3 Upvotes

I don’t have the funds to hire a professional color grader so I’m doing it myself. I like it overall yet I feel that something’s off?


r/filmmaking • • May 02 '25

Discussion Here's a question, how on earth do you distribute a film, I've been in the business 50 years.

0 Upvotes

Massive frustration. I worked myself to death finishing a film, I'm afraid to even mention to title, I seem to get banned every time I post. Social media is a joke. They don't allow socializing on social media. It's all so controlled. Here's the problem, we're being forced to self distribute but every single way to get the word out has been cut off. No forums, self promotion either banned or considered rude. I hope to finish my current slate of movies then I'm done. Just not worth it. We need a new system because I can tell you Hollywood is dying.


r/filmmaking • • May 04 '25

What are the pros and cons of going to film school?

0 Upvotes

What are the pros and cons of going to film school for aspiring filmmakers? And what does it truly mean to be a filmmaker? Does it teach all the stuff you need to know about filmmaking or being a filmmaker? Also can film school give you the skills?


r/filmmaking • • Jan 05 '25

Discussion Anyone on here that was wanting to become a director or screenwriter but failed to fulfill their dreams?

0 Upvotes

How long were you doing it for? And what do you do Now? At what age did you start ? and how did you deal with the situation? Where do you think you went wrong?


r/filmmaking • • Oct 07 '26

Question Ideas for my short film "Outbreak " inspired by the movie and game series "Resident Evil"

0 Upvotes

Hi there, my name is Kenneth and im from Singapore and I'm 23 years old, I'm currently brainstorming ideas or something pre post production for my short horror survival film inspired by the game series "Resident Evil",

Here is the Screenplay, you can have a look and let me know what you think of it

ScreenPlay:

Story is set in Raccoon City, where a test subject in a laboratory genre deadly T-Virus testing on a dead rat,which fails and escape the laboratory, it infects a homeless person, the next day, John who had a meeting with his superiors about a sales point presentation, he then encounter or realize that one of his colleagues fell very ill in the office, which she collapses and turns into a mutated zombie which infect the others, hundred, outside the city, John must fight and find his way out of the city towards the evacuated point. he encounters mutanted monster and infected zombies along the way and must fight his way out of it.

Some Game Elements will be in the film but I have been thinking of changing some of elements that will be useful to the protagonist.

Do let me know what do you think about I'm looking forward to your reply

Is the Budget 30k okay?

I haven't started on the script, but I will soon

Many Thanks

Kenneth

(Script Writer)


r/filmmaking • • Mar 21 '26

Guerilla filmmaker debating between New York and Los Angeles

0 Upvotes

Hi! My name is Michal, I'm an indie filmmaker planning on immigrating to the US sometime this next year. I will have a work permit/green card from day one since my husband is a US citizen. We are trying to decide whether moving to LA or New York. I have a creative portfolio with dozens of music videos I directed, produced, edited and colored back at home. I also wrote and directed 4 short films and wrapped shooting on my first feature (a guerilla 40k dollar project) this last summer, which is now in editing, and will hopefully be at it's festival circuit by the time we move. Anyways, The dream is to shoot my next feature in the US but of course, I will be happy to take any job in the film industry in either city as a start to make friendships, connections and learn the industry. We are coming with a pretty small amount of savings, but probably enough for a few months to help us settle. If it helps somehow - my husband is a professional drummer and drums teacher. He's looking into joining an indie band and to continue teaching (he has approx 50 private students back at home and 10 years of experience) I guess all of this might sound pretty delusional in general, but I would love to get opinions from locals! Thanks in advance :)


r/filmmaking • • Oct 16 '25

short film me and my friend directed

16 Upvotes

We're 16 years old, we shot this film during the summer, it's our first attempt at directing... We would like some feedback... watch it now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4hRZ9Odxjo&t=111s


r/filmmaking • • Jun 05 '25

Discussion I’m making a 900 hour long movie about a ceiling light

0 Upvotes

Answering the question of how long does a light take to die out and what does it look like when it happens…


r/filmmaking • • Feb 20 '25

Discussion Martin Scorsese: "study the old masters, enrich your palette, expand the canvas..."

0 Upvotes

How important is this in becoming an effective filmmaker? Like honestly?

And why the old masters? Who are the old masters?

No examples or contexts from Marty on this yet I see this quote mentioned all the time.

How would studying old films 'enrich your palette'????? Feels like poetic language for the sake of it


r/filmmaking • • May 08 '25

Hey

0 Upvotes

Hey, I’m 23, studying film in Los Angeles. I moved here from Israel about four months ago. I’ve been seriously writing and studying screenwriting for the past 4 years. I’m all about content that hits hard and brings your truth out for good and for worse.

I come from an artistic family—my father’s a producer with an Oscar nomination and a Cannes award—so I’ve had solid guidance. But truth is, I’m introverted and socializing here has been hard for me.

I’m writing this to connect with other people in the U.S. who are deep in this and can't do nothing else because thats how they are. If you feel that, reach out. No matter your level, gender, I’d love to connect, and maybe we'll make someone feel something one day.


r/filmmaking • • 26d ago

Discussion Need help with shortfilm

0 Upvotes

I have made a short film of 26 minutes. My first short film. It has its problems but it was made with good equipment and a good crew. It's everything I ever wanted to do. The film is ready. I wrote it, directed it and edited it. Even had a role in it. But now it's finally done. The quality is pretty good. It's in hindi language. I don't know what to do now. I'm feeling lost. I need to reach many people.

YouTube and instagram aren't giving enough reach even after I promote it with money. The trailer and poster didn't get much. I won "best debut shortfilm" in a film festival but I've understood that filmfestivals aren't gonna help me sell it or get fame. I really need this two things from it. Money (at least budget gets returned) or fame so that I can see how others feel and continue making more. It was made by my sister's savings. So I'm feeling really guilty that her hard earned money will be going to waste. I don't know what do I do now with film. I just have it in my computer. I really need help.