Some personal context: I don’t share Leslie’s views on pretty much anything. Viewing it strictly from a professional standpoint, I think Leslie’s blog was an unproductive act of self-sabotage (and I can’t say I personally was saddened when it went offline). I also hid her Facebook / Twitter feeds after they became oriented around political trolling.
That said, I fervently believe in the importance of preserving her musical works.
My goal is not to change anyone’s mind. As Leslie’s primary album publisher, I am simply stating my case for the record of why I make the choice to materially support Leslie’s music with my time & financial resources, versus the many other things I could be spending my time and skills on.
1. The present-day reality is that financial support for Leslie’s music overwhelmingly supports the preservation work of Leslie’s music — not Leslie herself.
Leslie's work is unique. And most of Leslie’s best songs were never recorded or released.
The vast majority (approx. 85%) of the money spent on Leslie’s music today is going towards tracking down and professionally remastering lost recordings of the hundreds of songs Leslie wrote, but never recorded. Only about 5-7% of the money spent supporting our Leslie albums ultimately has gone to Leslie.
Of course, people have a right to make a choice about how they spend their money consistent with their values/priorities. But I do want to be upfront that the only thing that would be “not supported” here would be the ability for the listeners who weren’t attending her concerts 20-30 years ago to ever hear any of those songs.
This preservation work is inevitable, but makes much more sense to do while Leslie is still alive.
2. On a side-note, the preservation work of Leslie’s music has been a vehicle to enable much broader and vital filk history preservation.
We’re long past the point in which we can call up Gerry and get hours of carefully labeled Leslie Fish concerts in .wav format that were collecting dust on his hard drive. Instead, we’re now doing media preservation jobs on entire filk convention tape master sets simply under the premise that Leslie had attended, and that we may find a handful of her songs there.
The support for Leslie’s music directly enabled about $2800 of that media preservation/transfer work in 2023 alone. All of the reel & tape convention masters we transferred have been provided to the Harold M. Stein Memorial Filk Archive for preservation, and being made available both to the performers (and publicly) wherever possible.
It’s Leslie’s music that’s uniquely making this possible. There aren’t other filkers of that era whose work has enough mass appeal to provide the funding for these reel/tape transfers — nor is anyone else stepping up to offer to donate the funding to make the rest happen.
3. As a reminder, Leslie is roughly 80 years old. Her views on trans equality are consistent with the supermajority of her demographic peers. Yes, there is a material (roughly 50 year) demographic gap between Leslie and her listenership median age, which makes this difference particularly glaring.
4. Finally, having known Leslie for 3/4th of her adult life, the belief that Leslie will somehow change her point of view through public pressure is grossly misguided. Simply put, this has never happened once in the 35 or so years I’ve known her. This never will. Anyone anticipating this outcome is mis-applying their energy.
Also, other than in brief periods of Leslie’s life (like most filkers), music has never been a material income source. “Not supporting” Leslie’s music isn’t going to affect her financially, either.
5. Leslie’s complicated personality is integral to what made her creative output special. I would assert that much of Leslie’s creative product is rooted in the ability to passionately and fervently hold crazy and even unpopular ideas (such as the premise that Kirk and Spock were homoerotically connected) as true.
Most filkers I know of Leslie’s era are also complicated people. That’s, in part, what made their creative work unique.
While I would have loved the opportunity to work with “alternate world Leslie” that was straightforward to do studio recording with, and who treated her music as a serious business where she carefully weighed the consequences to other people (and herself) of the things she says and does — that wouldn’t have been Leslie.
That said, I’m on vacation with my (coincidentally, trans) SO. I’ve pretty much said everything I have to say, and won’t be promptly responding to any comments.