r/filesystems • u/Peter8File • 9d ago
Is there a study on NVMe SSD wear (write amplification) comparing ext4, Btrfs, and ZFS with LUKS2?
Hi everyone,
I’m trying to make an informed decision for a single-disk NVMe setup on my PC, and I’m specifically concerned about SSD endurance (TBW/wear-out) rather than pure performance.
I’ve been digging into how different filesystems handle writes, and I keep seeing anecdotal reports that CoW filesystems like Btrfs and ZFS can generate significantly more write amplification than ext4. For example, I’ve seen claims that ZFS can produce “extremely high write load” on consumer NVMe drives due to its transaction group and ZIL behavior.
However, I haven’t been able to find a controlled, empirical study that isolates SSD wear across these three filesystems under the same conditions.
My planned setup for all three cases would be:
LUKS2 full-disk encryption (which I understand should not significantly amplify writes on its own).
For Btrfs:
nodatacowdisabled (i.e., CoW active),compress=zstd,space_cache=v2, and dedup explicitly turned off.For ZFS: ARC cache size reduced to a reasonable limit for a desktop, and no dedup.
For ext4: standard
data=orderedjournaling mode.
My questions for the community:
Does anyone know of a published paper, benchmark, or detailed blog post that actually measures SMART data (like Data Units Written or Percentage Used) over time for these three filesystems on the same NVMe drive?
If no formal study exists, what are your real-world experiences with SSD wear indicators after months/years of use with these setups?
Are the optimizations I listed above (Btrfs dedup off, ZFS ARC limit) actually effective at bringing write amplification closer to ext4 levels, or is the CoW overhead still significant?
I’m happy to be pointed toward academic papers, Phoronix-style benchmarks, or even well-documented forum threads. I’d just like to avoid making a choice based purely on “vibes” if there’s hard data out there.
Thanks in advance
