r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Any-Competition-4458 • Jul 05 '26
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '24
Feanor was a little bitch.
Galadriel knew what was up.
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/DizzyRub5182 • Aug 27 '24
Why do all my posts get deleted?
I hope at least the mods will read this one? I noticed all my posts got deleted for some reasons and I can't post anymore, I wasn't warned or told anything so could I get an explanation please?
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/fantasychica37 • Sep 17 '24
I NOW HAVE A COMPUTER WITH A NUMERIC KEYBOARD SO I CAN UTILIZE AN ALT CODE
I AM UNÞTOPPABLE
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/YakutskPaloAlto • Sep 25 '25
Seriously, I don't understand why people find "not destroying the Silmarils to fix the trees" wrong
First of all, Feanor has enough valid, reasonable reasons to not break the Silmarils at this point.
Second, even if he has no valid, reasonable reason, or has no reason at all, this should not cause any accusations or blames, because it was HIS thing.
I see people saying "not breaking the Silmarils to save the trees means he's a terrible person." OK so now I'll have to say, asking a elf to break his Silmarils to fix the Valars' mistake and to save the creation of a Valar means that the Valars are terrible people. Also if someone says not breaking = terrible, does "not lending" equal "terrible"? HAHA.
I see people saying that a person who is not destroying his most important creation to fix the authority's mistake is "a terrible person", "a moron", "a shit person", and using all these toxic words. Well, they never used these toxic words toward the authority who actually was responsible for the mistake, the authority who actually wanted a irrelevant person who had no part in causing the mistake to destroy his most important creation to fix this whole thing.
Also a very apparent difference between the Trees and the Silmarils is: The Trees are easy to break (look what Melkor and the Ungoliant did), the Silmarils are not (can only be "unlocked" by the creator). So can I ask WHAT IS THE REASON to break something is nearly impossible to break by people other than the creator (which means this thing can be taken away but not easily destroyed) to fix something that is much easier to get broken? Like the Valars haven't even found Melkor and put him in jail again...I'm just wondering if they really broke this "hard to break thing" and fixed the trees, what if Melkor and the spider come and destroy the trees again? Where are they going to find some new Silmarils to fix their mistake?
Or let's just have an analogy here:
You have a cake, and you put a very nice cherry on it. This cherry is pretty precious in where you live, so you only have two. You put another one in your pocket.
Suddenly, a huge rat came, and picked away your cherry! You can see that he's jumping onto your desk, and enjoying the cherry.
Now, pick from these two options describing what you are going to immediately do:
A. immediately take the only one remaining cherry from your pocket and put that on the cake.
B. go catch that rat, so that it won't eat your food again.
Is ANY REASONABLE HUMAN BEING going to keep feeding the mouse with cherries?
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Feanor008 • Feb 26 '21
Fëanor did nothing wrong I Have Started a Youtube Channel to tell people Feanor did nothing wrong via music
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Sonseeahrai • Apr 12 '23
I asked AI to describe the first kingslaying in UwU language
Oh hewwo there! It's so nice to meet you todway! giggles S-s-s-s-sorry, I sometimes stuttew when I'm excited! blushes B-b-but I'll twy my best to describe the fiwst kingswaying fwom Silmarillion! S-s-s-s-so, during the Battle of Unnumbewed Teaws, which took place in the First Age of Middle-ewarth, the Noldowin King Fëanor was mortally wounded by Gothmog, the Lord of Balwogs. Fëanow's sons were angwy and despewate, and in the chaos, Fëanor's eldest son, Maedhwos, seized one of the enemy's bannews. But as they wewe wewe treating with the banner, they wewe ambushed by a gwoup of orcs. Maedhwos was captured and hung by his wrist fwom a cliff by the enemy. Fëanow's second son, Maglow, managed to wes- wescue him, but in the pwocess, they had to kill the guards who wewe watching over Maedhwos. This act of killing, even though it was done in defense and to wes- wescue a family membew, mawked the fiwst instance of kinswaying among the Noldow. It would later become a wecurring theme in the Silmarillion, as the Noldow's actions would lead to further stwif- stwif- stwif- twagedy for their people. blushes
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/EpicGamer2020X • Jan 24 '21
Fëanor did nothing wrong Valtard alert
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Electronic_Pain_6784 • May 12 '21
Im sorry Feanor is so charismatic and able the best middle earth high king fingolfin insidious finarfin is coward feanor did nothing wrong!
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Oklimatoa • Feb 04 '26
Which actor should play Feanor in a live adaptation?
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Doc_770 • Mar 14 '26
Manwe is a C*nt
Think about it. He was the leader of Valar. Yet he wasn't helpful at any point. Being almost all powerful, he didn't find the way to revive the Feanaro's mother (or at least to stop the split and conflict between Noldor), he allowed Second House to usurp the throne from First House, he banished Feanaro... He basically set up everything for a civil war among the Noldor to begin.
And when the situation escalated and the exit happened, he just refused to accept that he was responsible for the whole situation and decided not to do a thing.
Even after the War of Wrath, he refused to take any responsibility for his actions or admit to any mistakes. He's either very shallow, or just as prideful (in the bad sense) as Melkor. And he definitely doesn't deserve to be the leader of Valar.
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/bjpelcdev • Sep 23 '25
New to this, but Feanor did not actually do anything wrong
Read the Sil for the first time this year after having read Hobbit and LOTR about five times. One thing I can't understand is the prejudice against F, he was the greatest most powerful and gifted elf of all time and made some magic shiny gems. Fair. Not his fault the world around him lost their collective shit over his magic shiny gems. If everybody else could have focused on the real bad guy and got over the magic shiny gems then the first age would have probably lasted forever. Moral of the story to me is if the greatest smith of all time makes some magic shiny gems, just get on with your own shit?
And if a kinsman asks to borrow your boats, perhaps just say yes?
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/RiUlaid • Apr 07 '22
Kinslaying? More like Cuntslaying
Fëanor detractors always accuse the Ñoldor of cruelly slaughtering the Teleri at Alqualondë. They might ask "why did Fëanor need to kill the poor Teleri?"
To this I would counter: why couldn't the Teleri hand over the Eru-damn boats?
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/Amazing0rangexD • Jul 01 '20
Thought it would be time for a shadow of war meme to be here
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/disciple-of-lu-ten • Jun 06 '20
People who think feanor did many things wrong
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/richardwhereat • Feb 19 '22
Fëanáro, not Fëanor.
Why do so many people call him Fëanor instead of Fëanáro Noldoran, as if the þindar tongue was worth using...
Fuck Elwë, if it weren't for Fëanáro, Moringotto would have conquered everything.
r/feanordidnothingwrong • u/YakutskPaloAlto • Jun 11 '23
let's remember
guys let's all remember that those golfin fans are trying to white-wash him and make Feanor look bad.
