r/fauna • • Apr 03 '15

[Syntax] Statement concurrency

Original proposal - Use ,/;/. as statement terminators.

Points for:

  • Familiar syntax and the usual ; happens to be the reasonable default.

  • Compact

Points against:

  • Too compact + at the end of the line = hardly noticeable = asking for errors.

  • Familiar syntax for an unfamiliar feature.

  • It would be nice to use . for data access, this renders it unparseable.


Alternative proposal - use some symbols at the beginning of the line.

Points for:

  • Much more noticeable.

  • Lines up nicely with some creative indentation.

My points against can be read in the reply.


Additional proposal - something that looks like a barrier instead of .. Sounds like an interesting idea to me.


My second proposal:

  • Always terminate statements with ; and make them sequential by default.

  • Put ^ before statements that will continue execution immediately.

  • Do not line them up, let them stand out.

  • Put ... on a separate line to wait for all statements to finish.

My points for:

  • 100% familiar syntax if you don't need fancy timey-wimey stuff.

  • No confusion but not too heavy either.


Please do discuss.

0 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by