This is the Faulkner sub so I’m assuming most of you have read this one, however I’m still going to place the disclaimer that this post contains spoilers.
Darl’s clairvoyance in AILD is extremely inconsistent and does not serve this story justice and I’ve come up with some revisions on how to deepen the novel’s themes without taking away from the story itself.
So I want to start with Darl because, while the novel is centered around Addie, Darl is the main narrator of the story—especially when it comes to Jewel—and so we, the reader, are forced to trust him. The problem is he’s unreliable in a way that Darl knows things the reader has to continuously find out for themselves, but then he conveniently withholds things that would provide resolution to the smaller details and subplots.
A prime example is this (pg44): While on the trip to obtain $3, Darl projects back home to when Addie is dying and narrates the entirety of what was said by who and when and how and their facial expressions and the whole ordeal. He narrates Dewey’s secret and her conversation with Dr. Peabody. So obviously he has the ability to clearly see, hear, experience things as they are in a room while his physical body is miles away.
Example two is (pg 164): after the family crosses the river and arrives at Armstid’s home. Darl, again, projects clearly exactly what’s going on with Jewel inside the barn and narrates Jewel cursing and smacking at the horse, all while he himself is inside the home waiting for supper. I’ll place a passage:
But after Armstid gave pa a drink, he felt better, and when we went in to see about Cash he hadn't come in with us. When I looked back he was leading the horse into the barn he was already talking about getting another team, and by supper time he had good as bought it.
He is down there in the barn, sliding fuidly past the gaudy lunging swirl, into the stall with it. He climbs on to the manger and drags the hay down and leaves the stall and seeks and finds the curry-comb. Then he returns and slips quickly past the single crashing thump and up against the horse, where it cannot overreach. He applies the curry-comb, holding himself within the horse's striking radius with the agility of an acrobat, cursing the horse in a whisper of obscene caress. Its head flashes back, tooth-cropped; its eyes roll in the dusk like marbles on a gaudy velvet cloth as he strikes it upon the face with the back of the curry-comb.
The reader is meant to read all italicized prose in simultaneous visualization with the standard prose. So one thing is happening in the present with Armstid and Darl’s family while Darl is actively tracking Jewel’s whereabouts and actions from elsewhere.
Now here’s where the inconsistencies begin to show and I take issue with. First, I’ll start with a small one before moving to the major one.
If Darl is so clairvoyant and can see far beyond his surroundings and knows secrets before he should, why does he not know where the wagon is when he gets out the river? Or Cash’s other tools?
Vernon and Jewel wonder where the wagon is and Vernon says Darl ought to know to which he replies “I don’t know; I wasn’t there that long.”
A few pages before, they’re discussing what tools are missing. I’ll once again, place the passage (pg 145):
Vernon comes up, streaming, his tace sloped down into his pursed blowing mouth. His mouth is bluish, like a circle of weathered rubber.
He has the rule.
"Hell be glad of that," I say. "It's right new. He bought it just last month out of the catalog."
"If we just knowed for sho what else," Vernon says, looking over his shoulder and then turning to face where Jewel had disappeared.
"Didn't he go down 'fore me?" Vernon says.
"I don't know," I say. "I think so. Yes. Yes, he did."
So that’s two instances where his so called clairvoyance fails him. Yet he’s able to see through walls and miles down the road to see Addie die and can’t see his immediate surroundings in the water of something as large and heavy as the wagon with his mother’s dead body. Or not his mother, as he keeps claiming.
Which brings me to my second inconsistency and the real deal-breaker for me about this story’s methods. It’s the memory of Jewel working Mr. Quick’s field during the summer (pg 115):
I get that Jewel is an illegitimate son, so maybe that makes sense so why Darl can’t see past his stupid, angry wooden, lifeless face. But it doesn’t explain why he can’t read Cash. Cash knew why Jewel was going out late at night. Darl thought he was “rutting” with a girl, to which Cash replies it ain’t no girl it’s a married woman who got him all hitched up. But then Cash figures out the real reason and never tells Darl and Darl doesn’t know until the day Jewel purchases the horse. So again, he has the ability to see far and the first chapter tells us this clairvoyance works on Jewel because how else was he able to see him in the cottonhouse, yet he’s got no clue where Jewel or Cash went or what they’re up to and doesn’t know even Cash’s secret about Jewel while he knows Dewey Dell’s secret about Lafe.
The scenario is the exact blueprint of the Armstid barn and Addie’s death, yet Darl’s clairvoyance miraculously disappears. It’s inconsistent and unwarranted. Sure, yes, you can argue that Darl physically turned and looked at Jewel in the barn, but it doesn’t explain that entire last paragraph which is him projecting Jewel in the barn, conjuring up him cursing to it and smacking it when Darl himself is in the house. Or Darl being on the windowless side of the cottonhouse projecting exactly how many steps Jewel takes from one window to the other. You can’t tell me Darl had no clairvoyance back then. You can’t tell me he conveniently didn’t know so the author could make the horse purchase more punchy. That’s pure authorial handwriting. If Faulkner needed the reader to stay in the dark long enough to deliver the punchline, then why use the character with the all-seeing eye to do it?! It makes no actual sense. Cash was right there!
Maybe okay, I can believe that it’s more inference and imagination than it is reality—that Darl needs a base: the horse, Dewey’s secret, for him to build a scene in his head about and daydream over. That would make the most sense to me. A matter of projection, rather than objectivity. So let’s take this daydreaming idea and put it into practice.
This is where my suggestion comes in, how I would personally retrofit the jigsaw pieces together to make a more coherent story, because a story and its characters should still be able to talk to the READER and provide information about things in their interiority even if they’re incapable of communicating with EACH OTHER, which is my biggest issue with this book.
So, Darl believes Jewel is rutting right? Or rather, Cash does as he’s the one who suggests it and Darl rolls with it.
How I would have handled this is, sure, maybe Darl does see a boy and girl rutting. And he fixates on that and applies it blindly to Jewel in the dark as the center of this clairvoyant daydream. But the rutting couple turns out to be Dewey Dell and Lafe. Out in the cotton field. And this can be a perspective shift from Dewey herself, mid act with Lafe when they hear something, and it’s Jewel passing by in the night with the lantern. Lafe runs off so they aren’t caught and Dewey is the one who follows him in the middle of the night. And maybe Cash can have followed them all too and seen it all. That way, the next morning when Darl observes that Cash is already in the barn bright and early with the chores done, Dewey by his side, this makes much more sense as to why both are out so early in the morning and then Jewel, who never knew he was being tracked, is still out worrying Addie and Anse until he rides up with the horse and Cash finally reveals and defends that he was working for Mr. Quick all summer.
That’s how I would have handled all of this information. Because THAT’S how you use perspective shifting. Exact same scene from drastically different viewpoints. Instead, what Fauker does is reveal information in fragments as only interior secrets that no other character can verify or be fact-checked against. THAT’S the problem I have in this book. Characters just say something as their lens of truth but I have no way to verify it against another lens because it simply never comes up for anybody else.
My way would enhance the dramatic irony because Cash would know Dewey’s secret and keep it to himself while Dewey believes it’s only Darl who knows the secret, because Darl’s the meddler who doesn’t know how to mind his own business and needs everything standing out in the light. (“If you say it, even think it, it’ll be true. So just say it.” pg 35) But he doesn’t know that Cash also knows either. So when Cash holds onto the information about Jewel and finally reveals it, it pays off because he blindsides Darl with factual information about Jewel he doesn’t know while also protecting his sister. It would add so much more to Cash’s characterization than just ticking off some carpentry facts for a page. He’s still being objective and he can give a list for all I care. But it would give him more depth, the drastic difference of how he and his brother handle information.
This still highlights how they don’t talk to each other and lack the capacity for real conversation while informing the READER about what they can’t say to the REST how I suggested needed to be done before.