Hi everyone, I’m a May 2026 new grad and was selected in the H-1B lottery. I’m dealing with a pretty complicated situation and wanted to see if anyone has experienced something similar, particularly with an H-1B change of status after an OPT discretionary denial.
In March 2025, I was arrested following a domestic incident for alleged simple assault/threats. I was released the same day, no criminal charges were ever filed, and there was no court case or conviction.
When I later applied for post-completion OPT, USCIS first issued a biometrics/fingerprint RFE and then a NOID asking for the court disposition, arrest/police report, and any other evidence or mitigating factors.
I responded with everything requested, including the disposition showing no charges were filed, supporting documentation, letters regarding my character and community involvement, and a letter from the alleged victim explaining what happened and supporting me.
Unfortunately, USCIS still denied my OPT as a matter of discretion. The denial acknowledged that no charges were filed, but relied heavily on the allegations/details contained in the arrest report and concluded that the negative factors outweighed the positive factors. They also raised public-safety concerns based on the alleged conduct described in the report.
Before the OPT denial, my employer had already filed my cap-subject H-1B petition requesting change of status for October 1. USCIS has now issued an RFE on the H-1B concerning the same March 2025 law-enforcement encounter and is requesting similar documentation.
My attorneys are preparing the H-1B RFE response, but there is now another issue because of the OPT denial.
I graduated in May 2026, and my attorneys believe my F-1 grace period ends on September 29, while an approved H-1B change of status would take effect October 1. They are concerned about the apparent one-day status gap and whether USCIS could approve the H-1B petition itself but deny the change-of-status portion, forcing me to do consular processing.
We also considered transferring my SEVIS record to another school. However, my SEVIS record currently shows COMPLETED, and my DSO told me that transferring to another school would not simply make the record ACTIVE again. According to the DSO, I would need to pursue F-1 reinstatement.
So I’m dealing with two separate but related issues:
H-1B RFE/discretion: Has anyone had an OPT or other immigration benefit denied as a matter of discretion because of an arrest with no charges, but later had an H-1B petition/change of status approved after responding to an RFE about the same incident?
F-1 status/cap-gap issue: Has anyone had an OPT denial while a cap-subject H-1B COS was pending and then dealt with a grace-period/cap-gap issue right before October 1? Did USCIS still approve the COS, approve only the H-1B petition for consular processing, or deny it?
I already have immigration attorneys handling the case, so I’m not looking to replace legal advice. I’m mainly interested in hearing from people who have personally gone through something similar and what ultimately happened in their case.
Thanks in advance.