My gf and I have been together for six years now. We have an open relationship today that our friends and family don’t know about, where she has sex with mostly whoever she wants and tells me about her experiences later. She is quite attractive and has an ever growing list of potential suitors. It’s erotic and feels consensual, but it didn’t start that way.
She cheated on me several times, we fought a lot, and our sex was affected. There were a few years when she wasn't as interested in having sex with me. Over the course of our relationship, she cheated with five other guys and sexted or made out with several more.
It first happened at the start of our relationship with an ex of hers she said was a friend. She had met with him after I went out of town. While I was away, she called me and admitted that she had gone back to her “friend’s“ place the other night and that they had sex. I was heartbroken and pressed her for an explanation of what happened, how it happened, etc.
She said as they got ready for bed, she took off her clothes and was wearing a bra and panties. He spooned her for a bit and she eventually felt his boner press against her ass as he was rubbing it against her. Then he grabbed her hand and placed it on his hard cock through his boxers. She seems to have left out some details here but continued, saying he pulled his boxers down and presented his cock to her, then….paused.
I asked if she sucked his cock, feeling incredulous, and she silently nodded. I felt ill at her admission. “What was I supposed to do? He put it right in my face,” was her reply. Then, after she sucked it for a while, she tells me he flipped her into a prone position and straddled her, pulling down her panties and rubbing his cock against her bare ass, eventually penetrating her. He fucked her while she lay prone until he pulled out and painted her ass and back with his cum.
She said she felt pressured by him, that she hadn’t wanted to have sex and wasn’t going to talk to him anymore, so I tried to move on. A few months later, however, I went through her phone and found messages and photos they were still sending to each other. That's when things got worse in our relationship.
We were fighting constantly during this time. She would talk to me about getting a dildo for her to use, and tried to draw an analogy to her fingering me, saying she often wondered if her finger was enough. “It’s just like that. Maybe you want something bigger too.”
When I would try to initiate sex, she'd often tell me to masturbate while she was laying prone, and would offer me her panty-clad ass, but wasn't interested in engaging with me. She also told me that she didn't like giving blowjobs anymore, that her throat was sensitive, and stopped giving me oral.
Meanwhile, she was sexting other guys her fantasies of sucking their cocks, and had sex with a few of them as well. I came across her texts with a friend of hers and saw his giant 10" cock, how adoringly she spoke of it, his “beautiful porn cock”, and all the nudes she prepared for him. It all hurt and made me incredibly jealous and insecure about my cock. I asked her why she never gave me oral but that only made it worse.
She was in contact with another ex of hers during this time, we'll call him H. I was always jealous of their contact with each other but tolerated it because she told me their friendship was important. During the time we weren't having sex, she went to see him often and would occasionally spend the night at his place, though she reassured me that “nothing ever happens”.
There was a lot going on with our relationship, some things that I was responsible for as well, but we were trying to work through it. Later, on H’s bday, she spent the night with him and arrived very late to a date we had planned the following day. I also later found horny mirror selfies on her phone that she had taken the night before she left for his, where she was arching her back and parting her lips suggestively. She had stayed up at his place until 4 am.
About a year or two later, she finally came clean and said that she had sex with him that day. She told me she took a shower with him and started washing his body until eventually she was tugging on his “huge cock”. Then, she knelt in the shower and began sucking and deepthroating him. They left the shower and she rode his cock in his bed until he came. She wouldn't specify where he came, but I have a few ideas now that they've been having sex again.
We now have an agreement where she can fuck other people if we talk about it first, though that hasn't always happened. For instance, she met with a guy that I didn't particularly like but assured me that she wasn’t trying to have sex with him and just wanted to catch up. Turns out she got him alone in a room and dropped to her knees to start servicing his cock with her mouth, pulling back when she felt him getting close to kiss the tip and prolong the blowjob.
She said she was deepthroating him more vigorously when suddenly, to her surprise, his cock started pulsing as he began filling her mouth with his cum. She said she was annoyed that he didn't warn her but still cleaned up his cock and swallowed everything. She came back home to me that same night.
Challenges aside, our sex has improved. She even gives me an occasional blowjob now that she's been eagerly sucking other guys' cocks. She tells me details but doesn't share pics or videos. She mostly has sex with H.
I was a little jealous at first, hearing about how she was giving him blowjobs, kissing his balls, and dutifully swallowing his cum whenever he finished. Those were things she never did with me. In fact, she told me she didn't like the taste. But here she was getting on her knees to worship him. She once even admitted that she liked the taste of him better after I expressed my surprise with how regularly she let him finish in her mouth, though she later insisted she never said that.
I caught an audio of them in our bedroom once while I was away for work, and she still doesn't know about it. She told me they had sex, she sucked his cock, and he fucked her in prone and doggy positions. I listened to the audio and learned that she strongly underplayed the blowjob.
Listening, I hear the sound of a belt coming off and hear her say “thanks H”. After, I hear spitting, and then sucking sounds. It's clear she's giving him a blow job while kneeling before our bed. I hear sucking sounds, kissing, gagging, lips popping, slurping, gasping and whimpering. It sounds much noisier, wetter, messier than how she ever is with me.
Eventually, you can hear a loud pop when she takes his cock out of her mouth, and he picks up an object from the dresser and asks her about it. She explains she had bought it for me as gift, they both laugh, and she quickly resumes sucking his cock. Then she interrupts the blowjob again and in a small, subservient voice offers to get him one too, but he laughs, and she sounds slightly embarrassed. She resumes the blowjob and I can eventually hear the sounds of her muffled gagging, which I now understand is from him grabbing her head and pulling her down on his large cock. She revealed to me recently that he does that at least once during every sexual encounter they have.
It lasts for about 12 minutes before she says, “please fuck me H. I want your cock so bad”.
Then, I hear the wet sounds of him penetrating her with his cock and her gasps and whimpers. She cries, “your cock feels so good, I love it. It's so big”. It sounds like he was teasing her with the tip of his cock for a while. Then, I hear him fucking her more deliberately and loudly. I hear her moan, “ohh my God…please give me your cum. Fuck, yes.”
Eventually, after she's whimpering particularly loudly, there’s a wet pop as he pulls his cock out of her pussy. Then, you can hear more of her submissive whimpers, this time muffled by his cock as she receives his load in her mouth. There’s a wet spurting sound as he fills her mouth with cum (she said his cum dribbled down her chin when he came, and I think that’s when it happened).
She continues kissing his cock and cleaning it up. Afterward, they talk for a bit, and she even resumes sucking his cock until he asks her to stop.
I've listened to it constantly. It feels masochistic but I also can't stop getting turned on by it. I masturbate to it more than anything else. She sounds so excited to be with him. There's something really intriguing and hot about hearing her having sex with someone and no part of it is a performance for me. She's even lied about a few things, like how she started sucking his cock more noisily after I said I liked it - the audio happened first.
Now, she tells me that my cock is too small for blowjobs, or that it's girly, or that H’s is twice the size. But it turns me on. And it feels playful. We have a very loving and open relationship for the most part, though I do sometimes wonder whether she would have left me if I hadn't allowed her to do this. Not including myself, she's had sex with six other people in the last year, and clearly has a strong motivation to continue seeking out other sexual partners. For context, I've only had sex with her for the duration of our relationship.
What do you all think of our relationship and her cheating? Honest thoughts are welcome