In the original movie she's played off as a ugly character who's supposed to be annoying because she's interested in Peter. however she's the only person who notices him enough to know when he's struggling mentally, she makes food for him and consistently stands up for him, she even gives him a pep talk and encourages him to go back out there and pursue his goals (which includes another woman). She's girlfriend material by any realistic standard and the actress is in fact pretty, but she's portrayed as unthinkably unattractive comic relief
Spider Man 1: Peter awkwardly interacted with MJ throughout the first movie and never actually tells her he's interested. Then she kisses him at the end and he walks away.
Spider Man 2: He is there in a friend capacity as she's already with Harry (who is the only shitty one in this situation since he knew about his best friends feelings for her...MJ didn't). Ursula is fawning over Peter despite him only being interested in MJ, who he up to this point still hasn't actively pursued. He also fails to actually show up to her play. Granted it's because he's busy being Spider Man, but she doesn't actually know that yet for sure until the end of the movie.
Spider Man 3: He constantly fails to be there for her, gets a big fucking ego and kisses another woman in front of her.
MJ doesn't actually do anything particularly shitty in the 3 movies. Peter does, regularly. The movie is very clear about it. If you're identifying with Peter when he does shitty things, it's time to reevaluate your own personality.
Edit: I have been informed that I got some plot points wrong. I don't think any of them get in the way of my overall point so I'll leave them.
Anyone can watch those movies and know MJ is the worst, and the one who ACTIVELY CHEATS on all 3 men. Don't tell me she didn't cause she did, she just didn't care. Her problem is she wants to be the center of attention and the second she's not getting it she huffing and puffing. "Oh I was late for your play I'm sorry I was busy saving the city" "OH I kissed the host that gave me the key to the city as a publicity stunt. Didn't you kiss spider man in a dark alley while with harry. Kissed harry while you were with peter And kissed Peter while at Harry's father funeral Broke up Peter for someone else played games with that man's heart then left him at the altar. Mj is just as selfish and egotistical. Ursula (Peter's landlord daughter) actually cared and showed it, she would have been a better partner.
Im gonna go on a rant here that MJ takes way too much flak. First of all they all look 30 but we gotta remember they are 18-20 years old for the duration of the trilogy. Being a little flighty and emotionally immature is absolutely normal.
MJ liked Peter, she just wasn't the outgoing/confident person her comic counterpart is. (In both comics and show she has the abusive dad and the over confident MJ comics is her coping. She is working on developing that in the movies I think. Again she's 18 in this movie).
I saw it as she's the girl who gave hints (obvious to her, and arguably Peter but he is just scared) and is waiting for Peter to make a move. She won't ask him out even though she does like him (til the end of the movie when she does ask him out). But she defends him, standing up to a bus full of jeering peers AND an adult bus driver. That's immense social pressure and instead of laughing along or just putting her head down she goes against the grain to stop the bus for him because she cares about him. Then she also (unprompted) compliments his eyes and his reflexes.
They've been friends for a while, in the 1st movie I saw it as MJ slowly seeing Peter as a man vs the boy next door, it just seems "worse" comparatively because Peter's been in love with her literally since he was a toddler.
In the 1st movie Peter thinks she'll only date if him he has a car based on her being excited to ride in Flash's car (who i dont think shes actually dating - i think he "claimed" her and wants to, but as far as the movies show they just hang out in the same friend group). She gave zero indication to be shallow (her family is poor; she lives next door to the Parkers after all). Peter is just a high school dingus who goes "girl like car. Me get car. Girl like me?"
The 2nd and 3rd movie is really where people cant seem to look at things from MJ's view.
She confessed her love to Peter at the end of the 1st movie and got rejected. She's sure hes into her but he's keeping her at a distance for some reason. MJ also has the first good thing happen to her since graduation, where she gets a role as an actress. And Peter can't be bothered to show up once in spite of her saving him tickets/a seat? (And she doesnt know hes Spider-Man so his obvious lies about why he can'tmake it just piss her off)
So she moves on. at that point is he even her friend, let alone a romantic partner? So she goes and dates Jameson Jr. (Also I think shes one of those people who struggle being alone because of her dad and so a male who actually loves and supports her is something she clings to)
MJ still thinks she and Peter are better/soulmates, and she's still 19 years old. So before she goes all in on Jameson JR she decides to give Peter one more chance and confess to him her feelings. And he rejects her. Then shes kidnapped by a supervillain lol.
MJ finally learns Peter is Spider-Man and why he's being so distant, and that he does love her so she dumps Jameson and goes all in on her true love.
I get that its not cool for Jameson Jr but its also fully understandable. MJ is smitten with a guy who's smitten with her but is refusing for some reason. So she settles and then when her soul mate finally reciprocated she dumped rhe settlee.
The 3rd movie is really not at all MJs fault.
I totally get Peter trying to empathize by saying her situation (public not liking her performance) is something hes familiar with (JJJ's smear campaign). But also, she very clearly just wants to vent and have Peter support her. Its the classic "listen to me, dont fix my problem"
Peter also reveals he's apparently been secretly close with a literal model who is into him (she jumped at the chance to date him at that jazz club) and compliments him a ton. He then kisses her as Spider-Man less than a minute after MJ is talking about how miserable she feels about her career.
She hangs out with their mutual friend Harry, they get drunk on wine, eggs, and she falls for his weird twist dance and briefly kiss with her immediately pulling back. Not great but she was drunk and emotionally vulnerable. Peter was just high on his own ego.
Peter is the problem in all of these.
1st movie : he has no sack hence no relationship
2nd movie: he has no sack hence no relationship. He either needed to tell MJ who he was, or completely cut her out. His weird 1 foot in the door thing was really fucked up to do.
3rd movie: he has too much sack and thinks purely with his dick/ego.
GIF is my face as I type this rant, totallt fighting back tears
I saw this in theaters with my buddies and all the guys I knew thought she was cute and awesome. We all wanted to date someone like her. I disagree she was portrayed as ugly.
I think they’re misreading it. Peter is a dork and uncomfortable around women. Her character is a potential love triangle and comic relief as Peter was not used to girls hitting on him. It wasn’t that she was ugly, the comedy was Peter being uncomfortable with female attention. Plus also her coming over all the time was not what a guy trying to hide a secret identity needed in a girlfriend who lives in the building. At no point did anyone I know irl ever refer to her as ugly.
She wasn't supposed to be "ugly", she was meant to be "homely". Like, "yeah, she's not on MJ's level but she likes Peter". Turns out she's a genuine smokeshow who, honestly, would have been the best fit for Petey.
"What do you look so shocked for? Fat Bastard does this all the time. Thinks just cause he doesn't say anything, it'll have some huge impact when he does...
She absolutely was not meant to be ugly or annoying. She was just plain. And we as the audience were supposed to see that Peter could easily settle for a nice plain girl who could love him, but he was hung up on MJ. I really don’t understand this weird inversion of what 2000s society was like.
THIS. The scene always landed to me that she was nice, kinda pretty, somewhat plain compared to MJ, and thus the fantasy of a "simpler life" which would be nice if he didn't have to be a superhero. Never that she was supposed to be super ugly, I think that's a weird read of the character
Not a movie, and not recent. She had a full frontal scene in Hung... not seeing anything else since then. Pretty sure the connection was just discovered and went viral on Reddit.
Peter's ice cream clone here. We used to take here as just a character when we were kids. But the we realized that she was actually the perfect gal for him since she actually cared about him, but peter kept chasing Mary Jane.
I wouldn’t say she’s the perfect girl for him, we barely know anything about her. Yes, she showed she cared for Peter, but it’s still fairly surface level, they didn’t know each other deep enough to say she’s perfect for him
And since Peter brushed her off, and especially when he gave her any enthusiasm back while being high on Venom she would do anything for him, including more cookies.
She was clearly starved for attention in a backwater home, so someone as decent as Peter in her daily routine is like an ideal.
it’s from ‘Not Another Teen Movie’, in which an incredibly attractive nerd is treated like a hideous pariah because she’s shy, likes to paint and wears frumpy clothes. That itself is a parody of the movie ‘She’s All That’, in which exactly the same thing happens.
How many times must this meme be explained? As a child you’re like “ha ha, she not as pretty as MJ” but as an adult you’re like “damn, she has genuine interest in him. That’s attractive.” Damn, this ain’t rocket science.
You remember when you were in college and a fairly attractive girl in your class once invited you over to her place for coffee but you weren't thirsty so you turned her down? And then later you had that OH SHIT moment when you realized she was coming on to you but you were so fucking stupid that you blew it? The girl from Spiderman is the living embodiment of that moment in your life.
I was struck by her on my last rewatch as well. She knew Peter wasn't interested and her support comes across as incredibly kind and tender in his darkest moments. We'd be so lucky to have someone like her in our lives.
I recently rewatched the movies, and I was taken aback on how kind she is. Didn’t expect anything in return, and just wanted to be his friend. We all need that someone in ours lives.
Mate, I'm having a stressful day and your comment has made me laugh so much just when I needed it, thank you. And I'm definitely stealing that first sentence off you, it's brilliant.
We were supposed to think she's somehow less attractive than mary jane in that movie? Kirstin isn't really a sexy woman, she's pretty mid. THis girl was way cuter and her character was actually sweet and not psycho toxic drama girl. He'd have done a lot better to drop MJ and her bullshit and just shackup with this babe.
Little on the skinny side, asymmetrical features, not so up-kept hair... all that makes her seem SO much more genuine, cute, and down-to-earth. Not just compared to MJ, but in general! And her way of flirting with him? 👌
Her smile was my favorite part of the whole movie.
shes supposed to be goofy and awkward but people who grew up with it and rewatched realuzed tha urula was the only woman that unconditionally cared for peter, and she would have been literally perfect for him. when mary jane was off being selfish and breaking his heart, URSULA BAKED HIM A CAKE AND BROUGHT HIM MILK
What’s crazy I saw the movie as a kid, and thought the same. Cringe and all that, than experienced the same exact thing in high school in a even worse way
Middle school had a crush on a girl that was almost to the tee like the landlords daughter in terms of being nice and real life girl was actually even prettier but was a little on the nerdy side. Going into high school I got with this super lustful attribute girl, around the exact time middle school girl tells me she liked me and what not, I pushed her away so bad I still feel bad to this day. Flash forward tho saw the movie again a few years back and the whole scenes hit me harder like the ops post 🥴
I was always confused by this, even as a kid. I thought she was really pretty and nice. I thought it was stupid that Peter went for mj when Ursula was right there.
I find the actress who played MJ in these movies somewhat repulsive, physically. She did not age well at all. This girl, however, was pure hotness. Just chalked it up to me being different, as I generally find famous supposedly hot women meh.
Even as a kid I liked her better than MJ. She's caring, beautiful, and unlike MJ, she doesn't constantly look like she's about to throw up or burst into tears.
No, Jesus how many times is the same thing going to be posted on here. Google it and you will be linked to a post on this sub. Use 1 brain cell and you could figure it out yourself.
She’s not comically unattractive, she’s gangly and awkward. She always had charm, but even if we grant that the actress is beautiful (she is) compared to other actresses she isn’t conventionally attractive.
In the movie she's the nerdy girl who's fawning over Peter despite him only being interested in MJ.
Now dudes look back and are mad at MJ because she had the audacity to have her own life, not read Peter's mind, and not take being disrespected lying down, where as this girl was dismissed by him and still fawned over him and cooked for him and the lamest dudes think that a woman you can walk all over and she'll still want you is the most desirable woman there is.
This just reminds me how little I understand the spiderman fandom as his backstory in what 4 remakes 'so far' never gets interesting its boring as hell.
Redditors circlejerking about how mad they are that Peter Parker didn't fall madly in love with the attractive quirk chungus girl because they self insert as someone desperate for any girl that shows them a crumb of attention.
The sinister six was right from the very beginning. Peter is an annoying asshole. Bad things keep happening to him because he sets himself up to fail constantly due to his assholeness. Just because he’s a smart nerd doesn’t automatically earn him the nice guy pass.
As the silent bard said, "You know, there's a million fine looking women in the world, dude. But they don't all bring you lasagna at work. Most of 'em just cheat on you."
Gotta be honest here. I actually thought pigtails was prettier. I didn't think that Peter should have gone for her, but I definitely didn't feel like MJ was the better choice. Then again I have a thing for redheads.
The woman in the photo, Ursula, is cute and was obviously interested in Peter. She was kind to him and cooked him food.
But she was presented as comic relief.
Peter was still in love with MJ, his childhood crush, who is presented as being more conventionally attractive but is cool with dating the popular jock/bully Flash Thompson... And is still cool flirting with Peter while she has a boyfriend. Then later, she dates Peter's best friend, but still ends up lusting after Spiderman. And she leaves her fiancee at the alter...and then later kisses a married guy.
She's a lot of drama and Peter chases after her and goes through these emotional ups and downs...but the whole time there was this perfectly nice, kinda cute, girl who just wanted to be with Peter.
I thought she was hot when I saw the movie for the first time and also that he should've went for her bcuz she was obviously into him. I was confused even at the time why he didn't
I remember even as a kid thinking if she changed up the fit a little Peter would have a less stressful, solid 7 over undecided, status chasing narcissistic MJ. The Raimi MJ was just not worth it atleast to me.
•
u/qualityvote2 Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 18 '26
u/AutomaticAd8377, there weren't enough votes to determine the quality of your post...it's time for the mods to do their jobs!