r/exmuslim has lost its way.
Ive been a silent member of this subreddit for almost a decade now.
I mostly lurk and don't comment because I know what this sub-reddit is for.
I've seen a marked difference between the posts from many years ago, and the posts of today.
The posts many years ago were more like women asking for help in running away from abusive homes and trying to free themselves from tyranical families and oppersive siblings. The posts today are like people complaining about inconveniences and the obvious downsides of living in a religious society. Like, bro we know; this is our life on a daily basis. You are complaining and making rash actions that could get yourself and others killed. People have been secret apostates for CENTURIES in the Arab world, you are not the first.
In my opinion, there are certain things that shouldn't happen in this subreddit.
This is not the place for ex-muslims to come and find people to help finish your debates for you.
If you you start a debate with a muslim person, and that person says something you cannot refute in the moment, you cannot run to r/exmuslim and ask the people here to help you formulate a response. That means that person won fair and square and beat you in the moment. Take your 'L' and go home. You lost.
This is not a place for practising or doubting Muslims to come and ask questions about religion either. The people here have already gone through the horrors of growing up with religious families and live within religious communities that they cannot escape. This is the only space they can confide comfortably in. Practing-muslims can always go to other sub-reddits to ask questions and find answers. Ex-muslims are literally renegades who live in fear of their lives for leaving their parent's religion, it is wrong for the community here to permit people who would be open to harming them to come here and hold a 'civil discussion'. It is not your job to change the mind of muslim-religious people and there is absolutely no need to even try on this fourm. Just ruins the Fung-shui of the space imo.
This is not the place to debate religion or the validity of spiritual claims or their veracity. This is r/exmuslim and not r/DebateReligion or r/DebateAnAtheist or r/DebateIslam. IMO, there should be absolutely no entertainment of the debate of religion here or the worth of its claims. Hindus, Chritians, Sikhs, e.t.c. need to go to other subreddits in order to scratch their debate itch and not come here to r/exmuslim and bother people. I can't tell you how many times i've logged on to reddit over the last 10 years and I see some one with no right being here talking reckless about the people here who have been through a lot and are still going through it. It should be a given that religious DEBATE is not allowed on this sub. It gets us nowhere and just ruins the mood of the sub. We already debate religious people in real-life no need to come here and do it again.
ANOTHER POINT:
Yes, religion is evil, wrong, bad, grotesque and inhumane; it is still classless and immature to spite the religious by doing things that are openly hostile and provocative for the purpose of expressing your disdain. I don't know, but
imo don't deliberately trash holybooks, its tacky.
Imo, don't make a show of a expanding your diet to include banned foods and beverages, its needless.
Imo, don't disrespect the rules of your household WHILE STILL LIVING THERE.
You owe it to your family to obey the rules you disagree with (or atleast go along with it until you escape, lol. These are not well adjusted, fair, rational and balanced people, why are you surprised they are angry?). If I go to a state in America that it is illegal to pump my own gas, then it doesn't matter what state i'm coming from or what I am accustomed to doing, I have to follow their laws or risk endangering myself. Like my goodness, I know you don't like it but this is just reckless endangerment of your body and future for very little gain in the present.
These are just my thoughts, you are free to state yours below.
FINAL POINTS TO EX-MUSLIMS (lol):
Don't start a debate in real-life that you can't finish, only to run here and ask others to fight your battles.
Its lame, tacky and cowardly. You weren't good enough to beat them now you're running to your older brother to help fight your battles. Be prepared or don't show up at all. Plus you look bad when you lose.
Don't announce to your family your doubts and concerns about the religion they raised you in. This is Stupid. I see someone panicing here every week: "I told my friend/relative about my doubts and now they went to go tell someone else, I think my life might be over." Yea okay, you're probably right. THEY WILL LITERALLY KILL YOU FOR NOT BELIEVING and you are out here playing with your life. Anyone remember that news article from several years ago about that guy from India who got murdered and ripped apart in public for announcing his apostasy to others? Umm, please don't be that guy. He was good, but they killed him. You are not special, they will kill you too, go through your phone, find other ex-muslisms and track them down. You are not only endangering yourself, you are endangering me and others, lol.
Don't tell your brother, sister, cousin, aunt, parents, relatives that you don't agree with Islam. They will not accept you with open arms, they will throw you to the wolves. You look stupid when you believe otherwise.
Don't take of your veil while still living at your parents house. UNLESS you are actually ready to fight and possibly get kicked out do not take this action. If you do take of your VEIL while living at your parents house, please accept and understand that you have committed an act of impiety and dishonour in their eyes and they will understandably be shocked. You will have to live a life of secrecy or a life of regret, you don't get both.
Don't expect to keep your family if you marry someone outside the religion that they do not approve of. You cannot keep both your secular lover and your spiritual family. This is one thing that sucks about life, but you cannot have both the approval of your family and the choice of life you want to live. They will disown you, they will abandon you, they will never forgive you. In order to live the life YOU want, you will have the abandon the life THEY want. You want to have both the approval of your family and the affection of your lover, but the cost of one is sacrificing the other. Your family is who you were born with, your lover is who you send the rest of your life with. Imo, accept that you can't have both and then make a strong choice.
If you live a lie, you will have your family: parents, siblings, cousins, aunties.
If you live the truth you will be all alone: no parents, no siblings no cousins.
They will abandon you for 5-10 years before they even think of coming back around (and of course they would. I know they are wrong, but they literally believe you are sealing your fate and sending yourself to hell for all eternity. They are watching someone they know and love make what they believe to be a bad and reckless choice for what they deem to be youthful indiscretions and passions. They are wrong, but I get where they are coming from.) You will need to pick one or the other and live with it forever.
These are just my general thoughts as a silent observing member of this subreddit.
Ive been here since this sub-reddit was just a secret on the internet and watched it grow in fame and notoriety over the years. We have a lot of new people here who are naieve, optimistic, gullible and idealistic imo, but the real OGs from dayOne know the truth! You are all alone and no-one is coming to save you. sry.
I have more thoughts but maybe I will keep them for now.
Let me know what you think below. Maybe i'm right, maybe i'm wrong.