r/exmennonite • • May 17 '25

Mennonite Story Time the menno history we were never told

Thumbnail
gerhardsjourney.wordpress.com
1 Upvotes

heyo! ex-menno witch and former manitoban here. i recently read a blog that helped me figure out why my parents have skewed so far into white supremacy and eugenics-based antivaxx ideology. 'ethnically mennonite' people in germany/russia/canada/mexico/south america... were NAZIS. maybe this will help you understand the hypocrisy of our parents/ancestors' victim mentality.


r/exmennonite • • Dec 01 '25

Ex Mennonite born again?

2 Upvotes

I left a horse & buggy Mennonite community at the age of 29. I basically became an atheist. 8 years later I became a born again Christian. I had no idea! Just curious if this has happened to any of you?

I had a personal experience with God. So yes, he is indeed real.

Lack of understanding, and control, I think is the main issue of these communities:(.


r/exmennonite • • Apr 30 '22

Finding Community Come join the Southern California Interfaithless Beach Party on Saturday, May 21! ● /r/Exittors

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Dec 08 '25

Being asked to leave

2 Upvotes

I will try to make this short… I have been a member of a BMA affiliated Mennonite church for several years. We were drawn to the church for theological reasons particularly related to plain interpretation, full acceptance of the sermon on the mount, etc. I am 99.9% aligned with church theology.

My wife and I have had our share of issues over our 18 years of marriage and were divorced about 15 years ago but reconciled fairly quickly and were remarried. The marriage started to really go down hill about 8 months ago primarily due to my wife’s mental health issues that perhaps in some ways I didn’t make any better. She left me several months ago and quickly left the church, started wearing jeans/spandex stopped head covering etc. the church wanted to engage us in a restorative separation program overseen by the church but she refused. She also refused to work toward a separation agreement nor allow the church to assist mediating an agreement. Instead she filed for custody of our kids and child support and her answer to everything was to “talk to my lawyer”. I ultimately needed to hire a lawyer since she filed against me but she refused to move the case forward or attend legal mediation. I ended up filing for divorce as my lawyer advised that was the only option to establish basic finances and custody and that not doing so placed me at extreme financial risk and custody risk. I did so and was immediately confronted by the church (she filed for divorces as well).

Long story short, after a failed mediation attempt where she refused to agree to anything at all, and having to proceed for divorce, church leadership ga e me the talk that I am not supported by the church, the church can’t condone me being a party to divorce action, and that there “are lots of other churches out there I should consider joining”.

Looking for feedback from others that have been in a similar position. First, the “church” was the only support and “family” I had to still connect me to other humans. It feels like grieving another loss. Also, I find it hard to connect with other churches around for theological reasons. Finally, I’m really torn up because I believe in the stance the church is taking with me, I don’t believe in divorce, and feel luck I’m stuck in this no-win situation with my own theology. The church posture was that I should take no participation in legal processes at all, let her have what she wants, and simply trust God with my future and my children.

Just curious if anyone has experience of what it looks like coming out the other side of this kind of thing.


r/exmennonite • • Nov 24 '21

Education, Wisconsin v. Yoder & The Amish Heritage Foundation w/ Torah Bontrager | The Recovering From Religion Podcast

Thumbnail
podcasts.apple.com
3 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Feb 06 '23

Humanist Global Charity helps ex-religious people

7 Upvotes

Humanist Global Charity is a non-profit that provides assistance to people who have left religion. We work internationally - our website is https://humanistglobal.charity

We offer small grant funding to people who are impoverished due to leaving religion; we have a Safe House in and a hotline in Nigeria

We are interested in helping ex-Mennonites and we have a free book called Why We Left Religion


r/exmennonite • • Sep 07 '25

Are mennonites racist?

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone, first off I realize this is a space for those of you who relate on being ex Mennonite to talk. I am not Mennonite, but I’m here because I have shopped with my family at Mennonite run stores and such because there is a decent sized community where we live and typically the staff is kind and hardworking. I want to know if some mennonites are racist or discriminatory to those with Down’s Syndrome or who are not white? I ask because on multiple occasions my sibling who is biracial and has DS has gotten stared at when we shop at these places. I don’t mean just a bit of a prolonged look.. I mean several minutes of intense staring at which point I say to them it’s rude to stare! On all of these occasions the person who is staring doesn’t answer me let alone even glance my direction but continues to stare at my sibling.. at which point I usually get really creeped out and just stand inbetween them and my sibling. Is this just a random thing? If so why has this intense, creepy glaring only happened in Mennonite establishments? This has happened enough times that it’s REALLY creeping me out, can anyone provide me some insider info on this behavior?


r/exmennonite • • Sep 18 '20

Welcome!

11 Upvotes

I noticed this sub was dead and the mod had turned off submissions for the past 3 years so I requested control on r/requestreddit and it worked!

So whats up? What's your story with leaving the Mennonite faith?

Mines pretty boring to be honest. Born in a small all-mennonite community in the southern part of a Canadian province. Stopped going to church as a teenager and the fights with parents have been going ever since but we do still talk and get together often so its not all bad.

I don't really have ideas for the sub so let me know if you wanna see anything.

Also the subreddit wiki is open to everyone so if you feel like contributing any links or other resources, please feel free to do so.


r/exmennonite • • Jan 13 '26

Any other bi/gay ex mennos?

11 Upvotes

Hey all, just created an account today after having seen this sub awhile ago. Got me thinking, anyone else in this group bi/gay and find that a big part of your story in leaving the Mennonite church? I grew up in a conservative Mennonite church in Canada, in my teens realized I wasn’t “the same” as my peers regarding sexuality. Went through all the usual purity culture classes etc. I never felt I had anyone to talk to without being judged, definitely an area Mennonite churches can improve I think. Just wondering who else out there had this experience.


r/exmennonite • • Feb 26 '23

A Mennonite Health Nonprofit Saddled Thousands With Debt as It Built a Family Empire Including a Pot Farm, a Bank and an Airline

Thumbnail
propublica.org
8 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • May 14 '25

Hello

5 Upvotes

Ekj bin and ex-Menno un ekj bin schwul. Ekj suekje blush online Frenschauften, Minschen ut mien Welt, with wie ekj ehrlech kjnatsche kon.


r/exmennonite • • 4d ago

Holdeman Mennonite

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Apr 16 '25

Miscellaneous Ex-Mennonite Stuff Best paska recipe?

6 Upvotes

Hello!

I want to make paska for a friend who has his birthday on Sunday, and was wondering what the best recipe is. All my grandparents have passed away, and I didn't love my one grandma's paska anyway 😅 I remember hers always being super dry, but I've had others that were way better.

If you have a recipe for the cheesy sauce that you'd put on top, you get bonus points!


r/exmennonite • • Apr 01 '25

Ex-Mennonites, I’d Love to Hear Your Story for My College Ethnography

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m a college student currently working on an ethnography about ex-Mennonites and the process of leaving the faith. I want to understand the personal experiences of those who have transitioned out of Mennonite communities—what challenges you faced, what freedoms you gained, and how you navigated life after leaving.

If you’re open to sharing, I’d love to hear about:

  • What led you to leave the Mennonite faith?

  • How did your beliefs or lifestyle change after leaving?

  • What challenges (social, emotional, or practical) did you face during and after your transition?

  • Did you find a new faith community, or did you distance yourself from religion altogether?

I also have more in-depth questions if anyone is willing to do a one-on-one interview. Let me know if you're open to that!

Your experiences will help me present a more personal and authentic perspective in my project. You can share as much or as little as you’re comfortable with. If you prefer, you can also DM me to remain more anonymous.

Thanks in advance to anyone willing to share! I really appreciate your time and insights.


r/exmennonite • • Nov 07 '20

The unjust god paradox.

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Nov 09 '25

You May Be In a Cult (This is for a friend)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Feb 28 '26

Leaving A Mennonite Church 🪧You can put up a BILLBOARD about shunning too – Let's start a trend?❣️🚙

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Sep 14 '25

Looking for support, and friends.

4 Upvotes

Any ex mennonites here from either Washington Franklin. Conference, pilgrim,eastern or nationwide?


r/exmennonite • • Dec 15 '25

Miscellaneous Ex-Mennonite Stuff In a wild turn of events…

10 Upvotes

As a healthcare worker and a mother whose kids made my hair literally fall out, I have started wearing a dyuck/kapp again to control flyaway hair…

Feels like an uncanny return to my roots! But I’ll admit, the Mennonite Omas have the monopoly on solid black synthetic bandana-type head coverings that actually stay put on your head for an entire day. So I’ve conceded to them and purchased some from the colony store today. You win today Agatha…


r/exmennonite • • May 16 '26

Did you leave Christianity altogether?

6 Upvotes

Not ex mennonite, but have lots of mennonites in my area. Curious if most of you have stayed Christian or have left the religion entirely? If so, do you have any sort of faith or spirituality now?


r/exmennonite • • Mar 10 '26

amish interview

6 Upvotes

helloooo everyone!

i am currently in year 11 and doing society and culture as one of my classes. (australian syllabus)

my first assessment is an extended response essentially comparing the life of a male in amish society with a male in australian society.

a part of this assessment is having to conduct primary research, an interview / questionnaire that can provide findings for me to refer to.

i was wondering if there are any ex-amish or mennonites that could help me with this and possible be interviewed . thank you let me know !!


r/exmennonite • • Apr 21 '26

Pure Life Ministries Investigation

6 Upvotes

Hello,

I have a strong suspicion that Pure Life Ministries has been/is complicit in covering up the sexual abuse of minors.

In the past men have gone there for crimes that should have put them in jail, however their prospective faith leaders sent them to Pure Life as an "alternative." This is illegal. The first step these men should have faced is law enforcement, regardless of religious beliefs.

I ask that if you have any information, to PLEASE share below.

Thank you.


r/exmennonite • • Mar 10 '23

Improving Access to Education Would Improve Holdeman Church, Not Harm It: Opinion

Thumbnail
link.medium.com
4 Upvotes

r/exmennonite • • Feb 24 '23

Leaving A Mennonite Church What are some ways your life has improved after leaving your former church?

6 Upvotes