r/exjw • • 1d ago

Weekly Mini-Vent Megathread - November 15, 2026

7 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

This is a dedicated space for short-form venting posts that do not meet the character limit for standalone posts.

Angry at your family, the Watchtower or the congregation? Having a REALLY bad day? Experiencing some big feelings and but don't have enough steam to make a long post about it? Welcome to our weekly mini-vent thread, the place where you can let it all out- in little bites.

Note: Standard sub rules still apply here, so please report any content that breaks the rules.

-------------------

If You are Considering Harming Yourself:

Please stay with us. Know you are safe and among friends and we will do whatever we can to help.

If you are inside the U.S., text "CHAT" to 741741. You'll be connected to a trained Crisis Counselor from Crisis Text Line. Or call the National Suicide Hotline at 988.

If you're not in the U.S. please click here for a comprehensive list of hotlines organized by country and additional resources.

If you are LGBTIA+ and need to talk, please contact the LGBT National Hotline at 1-888-843-4564 or find them online here.


r/exjw • • 16h ago

News The Rumor Mill: News and Gossip - November 16, 2026

11 Upvotes

What is this Megathread?

We get quite a bit of speculation, questions on upcoming updates, and general JW gossip in our sub. As part of our community engagement poll you folks voted for a special home to house shorter posts devoted to this type of exchange, so here we are!

Got a juicy piece of gossip from your KH or your JW social circle?  Want to ask a quick question about an upcoming announcement, or change? Heard a rumor from the WT or about something going on in bethel? This is what the weekly rumor mill thread is for. Just remember not to share anyone's PII, and we're golden.

Please Remember:

All the sub's rules still apply, so remember not to use these threads for activist drama or rumors about the personal lives of activists.

Have a Lot to Say?

This megathread is intended for submissions that are too short to be stand alone posts. If you have a rather lengthy comment, we might prompt you to spin it off into its own post for more engagement :) 

Welcome to the Rumor Mill, everyone. Gossip away!


r/exjw • • 48m ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales Blood Change is Waking PIMIs Up

53 Upvotes

Background context:
Hubby and I left September 2024 and we’ve been vocal about it, of course earning the title “apostate” as a result. I’ve made public posts on my Facebook and pinned them so if any JW is snooping my page all they’ll see is apostate stuff 🤣😏 anyways the most recent one was a post about me almost dying in childbirth and blood saving my life thus how upsetting the blood change was to me. (See previous posts for the full story)

Well after the blood update, a PIMI JW I knew from childhood reached out to me regarding my post, we spoke over the phone, and she was spiraling from the blood update. I don’t want to share too many details but long story short just one year prior her toddler was dying from an infection and needed blood. They refused like the good JWs they were. Thankfully the courts got involved and forced the blood transfusion and he survived. That experience on its own was traumatic… but then a year later they update the blood policy and the illusion shattered. We talked about what life looks like after leaving, how to leave, what to expect, resources, etc. and left the door open for future conversations (we weren’t close and I know she was nervous since I am apostate so I didn’t want to push).

This week she texted me an update and it’s so beautiful I literally teared up. This is one of the best JW exits I’ve heard and additionally it makes me happy to know the org IS crumbling. Here is the text:

“Thank you again for talking to me the other day. Since then, I would like to say, my husband and I are 100% on the same page. Our plan is to fade for now, since we are trying to make it easier on the kids. I haven't been to a meeting in maybe a month and a half. We are closing our home for service and he will be stepping down as MS hopefully soon.
I have two close friends that I have talked to. And from talking to them, they also have other people they have talked to that feel the same way. I think a LOT of JW are waking up but too scared to admit it.
Also my parents .. my dad is stepping down as an elder and also planning on fading/doing bare minimum. They said whatever my husband and I decide, they wouldn't shun us.
Briefly talked to my siblings but not in depth. If we can get out with our family in tact I will consider it a huge win.
We have been studying multiple Bibles, I got new Bible story books for my kids, etc. I've felt a closeness to God and Jesus I have never had and it's only the beginning. And I'm meeting with my childhood best friend tomorrow that I haven't seen in 11 years (she was DF).
So even though I'm scared about a lot, I am hopeful and happy. So thank you again for giving me some courage. 😊 “

THIS is why I’m proud to be an apostate. If I can help others get out, it’s worth the pain of losing my family.


r/exjw • • 9h ago

News UK MP Sam Carling calls for new laws to protect people from abuse by cults and high-control religious groups MO

Thumbnail
politics.co.uk
214 Upvotes

Labour MP Sam Carling is calling on the government to change the law to better protect people who experience psychological abuse, coercive control and exploitation within cults and high-control religious organizations.
In an article published on 16 November 2026, Carling argues that existing UK coercive control legislation is inadequate because it primarily covers abuse within family and intimate relationships, leaving people controlled by religious leaders and organizations without equivalent protection.

He highlights several serious concerns, including:
-Psychological manipulation: Using fear, shame, isolation and threats to control members.
-Financial exploitation: Survivors of the Universal Church of the Kingdom of God have reported being pressured into handing over significant sums of money.
-Child safeguarding: Allegations involving minors, inappropriate practices and inadequate education within some organisations.
-Isolation and retaliation: Members who question leadership or report abuse can face expulsion and lose their entire support network.
-Lack of accountability: Existing regulatory and legal systems may not have sufficient powers to intervene.
Carling, who has spoken publicly about growing up as one of Jehovah’s Witnesses, argues that these behaviors can mirror domestic abuse and coercive relationships, yet fall outside the current legal definition of coercive control.
He wants the government to extend coercive control legislation or introduce new offences specifically addressing abuse of power and psychological subjugation within high-control groups.

He also points to France, Belgium and Luxembourg, which have introduced legislation addressing similar forms of exploitation.

The bigger question:
Should UK law recognise coercive control and psychological abuse within religious organisations in the same way it recognises domestic abuse?

And how can the law protect vulnerable people without infringing freedom of religion or legitimate religious practice?


r/exjw • • 5h ago

Venting i can't do this anymore. i'm done.

58 Upvotes

I can't anymore. i've scheduled the questions. there is no going back. My mom keeps crying to me, telling me she had been praying for me and asking what was stopping me from getting baptized. She talks often about the tribulation coming soon and how important it is that I take this step so she can see me in paradise. Another factor is my father. He has never been asked to perform a baptism before, and this year he was given that responsibility.

as an elder’s kid there is an expectation for me to move forward since me being a young teenager. All my friends are baptized. I also can't stop thinking about how it would look if I don't get baptized. The daughter of an elder choosing not to get baptized during the same year her father was given the privilege of baptizing others would raise a fuck ton of questions. 

for some context, I've done things that are considered sinful (not a crime don't worry), but I was never judicially dealt with. You can probably assume why. As a result, no one in the congregation knows what I've done. for the sake of keeping up appearances and reassuring my parents, I've pretended to have moved past those things and to have begged god for forgiveness, even though I haven't. (the truth is, I still engage in those same behaviors.)

flame me all you want, but I love jws as people. I was born and raised as one. So I think it's natural I really do. Maybe it's a Spanish cultural thing but most of them are sincere people who genuinely want to do what's right and help others. In fact, most of them (not to be biblical) but are like literal lambs looking for guidance in spite of their naivety. But I will acknowledge there wolves in sheep’s clothing.

in general, what i struggle with most are the contradictions in the teachings. some of them are genuinely helpful and lovely, like being encouraged to be a good person, show kindness, and treat others with love. but then there are other teachings that are just flat out restrictive or licenses for abuse. another thing is the way my gender is generally treated within the organization, and, honestly, the governing body as a whole.

i also acknowledge that some kind of higher power may exist. but i don't see god as a real presence in my life. yes, I invoke him sometimes. but I feel that he's just not there. he doesn't do shit. and the way the gb uses god is as a pawn to keep people under its thumb.

and even if I get baptized, i know can keep doing things I know are wrong. I've seen it. Most of my friends and their siblings aren't squeaky clean. And they hold privliges. If I ever get caught, I could just lie, put on a show, and say I've repented. the old fuckers can't read my mind. I can keep up the act. I've gotten pretty good at pretending and hiding these past years. and if things get bad enough, I could always just fade far in the future. 

i'm not posting this because I'm trying to attack anyone or start an argument. I just really need someone to talk to. I need someone to tell me something, anything, because right now I'm just so exhausted. I'm so sorry you guys. downvote me if you want. I already feel like a failure for this sub.

please, I'm asking you to refrain from leaving rude, judgmental, or condemning comments about my decision. normally, I'd be able to handle them, but right now I'm in a really fragile mental state.


r/exjw • • 3h ago

Meme Helpful Flowchart, copy and paste

Post image
28 Upvotes

Someone recommended a helpful video here, which suggested this line of reasoning. I used ChatGPT and added a little, including the BITE model part.


r/exjw • • 4h ago

Ask ExJW When Your Beliefs No Longer Align With Your Spouse

33 Upvotes

Has anyone been in this situation? I was born and raised in this religion, and my entire family is part of it. I’m now married with two young children, but over the years I’ve come to realize I no longer believe in any of it. I dread going to meetings and in service and honestly just want to be as inactive as possible.

My husband who’s an elder 🙄 doesn’t seem to understand that this isn’t about needing a better spiritual routine. Every time I try explaining how I feel, he goes back to saying we need to start having regular Bible readings, even though we’ve stopped doing that for over five years. I think he’s refusing to accept that my feelings go much deeper than that.

Part of me wonders if I can just remain married, accept that we have different beliefs, and focus on raising our kids. Between having children and the financial reality of life, divorce feels like such a huge decision.

I’m curious: Has anyone gone through this? Did you stay married or eventually divorce? Especially those with young children, how did it work out? I would really appreciate hearing your experiences.


r/exjw • • 18h ago

Venting Some of yall are still just as nasty as you were as a jw.

314 Upvotes

Not just on my post. A young kid asked for advice and some of yall jumped down his throat blaming him for getting baptized at all. Like do you even remember being in the cult??? The pressure??? The bad choices??

Maybe instead of channeling your inner witness and judge, jury, and executioner, you should try some humanity.

And a shout out to all of you wonderful people who have moved on from the snarky judgements of your past.

Yes, we all made mistakes and stupid decisions. Instead of pointing it out and being gross, maybe we should all just give the grace we never got before and LISTEN AND COMFORT!!!!!

Jesus.

Edit to say: some of you made the good point that this is actually not just a jw problem, it’s an issue that the world in general has. I agree to some extent.

I should probably have said that in a community (any community) with shared trauma and common circumstances that it is sad that we can’t be more compassionate and validating instead of tearing each other down.

I appreciate constructive criticism. I would hope we could all provide that. But sometimes it is obvious that the poster just wants a listening ear and validation. And most of us lived without our feelings being validated for a long time and we know what it feels like. Talk to people the way you want people to talk to you.


r/exjw • • 4h ago

PIMO Life NWT is the most accurate!!

20 Upvotes

It always makes me sad to see that even a simple google search can dismantle the NWT, but people are brainwashed and will die by it. Google will answer you with what is the most accurate Bible translation. Then put ‘in’ in front of accurate Bible translation and what pops up? NWT. But WT and their publications claim that scholars regularly comment that the NWT is the best translation. JWs will gaslight and learn everything from that Bible.


r/exjw • • 1h ago

Humor New Light: We now pray to the Governing Body in the name of the Governing Body

9 Upvotes

I'm a bit stressed.. let's pray.

Dear Governing Body,

We humbly come before the Governing Body to thank the Governing Body for providing us with spiritual food from the Governing Body.

Please help us never question the Governing Body, even when the Governing Body changes what the Governing Body previously told us to believe.

We ask all of this through the Governing Body, in the name of the Governing Body.

Amen. 🙏


r/exjw • • 21h ago

WT Can't Stop Me Oh dear! CLUELESS Jehovah Witness elder says “I have to end the conversation”

343 Upvotes

Went to London at the weekend.

saw some Jehovah Witnesses on the carts.

felt the urge to engage with them.

one of the men was an elder - I asked if he was qualified to answer some questions about their religion.

he was eager to!

me: “you guys are mormans right?”

cultist: “oh no we are Jehovah’s Witnesses, but people make that mistake all the time“.

me: “oh I am so sorry, so you guys believe in the trinity right?”

cultist: “we believe Jesus is the son of God”.

me: “ah cool so you believe Jesus is real?”

cultist: “yes, and he died for our sins”.

me: “do you believe you have a relationship with Jesus?“

cuntist: “yes”

me: ”to clarify, you have a personal, one to one relationship with Jesus Christ?”

cunt: ”yes”.

me: “Jesus is your personal mediator?“

cunt: “of course he is”.

me: “are you one of the 144,000 anointed?”

cunt: “no”

me: “are you aware of what the watchtower says about your relationship with Jesus?”

cunt: ….

me: ”read what the watchtower says about that, it claims you do not have a personal relationship with Jesus.“

cunt: …..

me: “here, let’s take a look on the JW website right now shall we?”

cunt: “I’m sorry, I have to end this conversation right now”

he, in front of his family, was completely humiliated.

Maybe one of them will start asking awkward questions too. maybe not.

fucking cults gonna cult.


r/exjw • • 10h ago

Ask ExJW What comment made from someone outside the organisation knocked you down a peg?

42 Upvotes

I remember being a really proud JW as a kid, I felt it was my duty to defend the faith at any opportunity. I remember one incident that changed my perspective and after that I stopped being so defensive and chose to keep my mouth shut.

Me: “there are over 8 million of us around the world!”
Trying to big up the organisation like a chad!

Other Kid at school: “so? There are 8 million that aren’t…”

It wasn’t the fact they said OVER 8 million, just 8 million that aren’t…

Idk why, but it shut me up.

Would be interested to hear anything similar you guys have experienced


r/exjw • • 12h ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales If Jehovah’s Witnesses Count Everyone Who Joins, Why Don’t They Count Everyone Who Leaves?

49 Upvotes

Every year, Jehovah’s Witnesses proudly publish statistics about their worldwide activities.

We are told how many people were baptized, how many publishers are active, how many Bible studies are conducted, and how many pioneers participate in the preaching work.

These numbers are presented as evidence of progress and spiritual growth.

But there is another side to the story that deserves just as much attention.

Where are the numbers of those who are no longer there?

How many Jehovah’s Witnesses were:

Disfellowshipped or removed from the congregation?

No longer willing to identify as Jehovah’s Witnesses?

Inactive because they stopped believing?

Inactive because of personal circumstances?

Lost through death?

These figures are not separately disclosed in the published worldwide annual reports.

And that raises an important question:

If the organization can carefully count those who enter, why does it not publicly account for those who leave?

I am not suggesting that every person who becomes inactive has lost their faith. Nor am I claiming that every departure is caused by organizational wrongdoing.

But without these figures, how can members or the public properly understand the organization's actual membership trends?

Imagine a business reporting every new customer while never disclosing how many customers it lost.

Would we call that a complete picture of growth?

Religious organizations should not be treated as businesses. But when an organization uses statistics to demonstrate its success, transparency matters.

Truth should not require selective reporting.

If Jehovah’s Witnesses genuinely value truth, wouldn't publishing both the gains and the losses provide a more honest picture?

I would love to hear from current and former Jehovah’s Witnesses:

Do you think the organization should publish annual figures for removals, resignations, inactivity, and deaths? And if not, why not?

This is not about attacking anyone’s faith.

It is about asking whether transparency should apply equally to the numbers that celebrate an organization and the numbers that challenge it.

Because truth should never be afraid of the full picture.


r/exjw • • 8h ago

Ask ExJW How can I cope with being scared I’m wrong

21 Upvotes

Hey guys, I’ve posted on here before asking for help but In genuinely really scared I’m wrong about everything. What if jw is right what if the world is ending. All I can think about is that I’m wrong and need to go back. The hard part is I can’t even tell for my self what to trust these days. I really want to know how you guys deal with anxiety of jw and how you over come it all.


r/exjw • • 3h ago

JW / Ex-JW Tales My Father, the Elder, doesn't have any friends!

8 Upvotes

When I was a PIMI, I did not overthink making friends. We're all JWs, of course we'll get along! So I just befriended anybody because the religion taught me to talk to anyone, to love everyone and to always get along with my brothers and sisters. I had such a tremendous faith in the brotherhood and in the love among JWs.

My father, who's an elder, told me a secret that I kept up till now. He was jealous of me! He told me that he envied how many friends I had in the truth, how he was jealous that I would speak to anyone and how he envied the amount of love I was getting. No father should ever envy the love their son gets, that's just unhealthy!

My father was raised in the truth, he was born in 1972, got married in the 90s, became an MS in 2010(?) then got made an elder in 2016. He followed the standard career path for a JW man. He always obeyed the organisation, he always trusted Jehovah and sure enough, the brothers put him to good use. But he was alone. All of his friends got disfellowshipped in the mid-late 80s. He was the last young man of his social circle left inside the religion. He told me missed his pals and who can blame him?

He told me he wished he could make friends like I could. He told me he wished he wasn't so alone. I didn't know how to respond. What was I meant to say to my poor dad who's telling me he's lonely? As I got older, I noticed what my dad meant. We would be at social events as a family and I'd be surrounded by people, I would always be talking to someone and I was never alone at these events. But sure enough, I'd look in the corner and see my poor dad on his own. It just broke my heart to see my dad like that. I can't believe that I get my freedom and he's trapped forever. That's a shame.

But hey...That's cults for ya!

It's sad that he's the one shunning me now because if he could see this, all I want to say to my dad is:
"Wish You Were Here"


r/exjw • • 9h ago Regret

HELP Does it get better if you change Kingdom Halls?

24 Upvotes

I’ve (F19)been at the same Kingdom Hall my entire life and I’ve dealt with cliques. Most of the sisters have never included me in much only out of pity or only if someone from their events cancels. Now that we’re young adults I’m not invited to anything at all. I’ve gotten used to not being invited to stuff that they blatantly post on social media to brag about but I’ve recently started feeling very lonely and I realized I never had any real deep friendships with any of the people I’ve known my entire life.

I’m PIMO but I have to stay in for now. I was debating if I switched over to a different meeting for the time being if I could have better friends. Or maybe just feel like I belong somewhere with people being genuine.

I’m not saying the older ones aren’t cliquey either but they seem to be more inviting than people in my age range.

Does it get better if I were to a switch to a different Kingdom Hall? How should I deal with my peer group moving forward?


r/exjw • • 21m ago

Venting Extremism in plain sight…

4 Upvotes

One of the most dangerous aspects of religious belief is the idea that something terrible should happen to people simply because they believe differently. Invariably suggesting that disagreement is a moral failing, and moral failings deserves punishment. Many religions have variations of this, but some take it to disturbing extremes.

A case in point is Jehovah’s Witnesses. I was watching a non jw Bible-based drama with a pimi jw,(he had judged me for watching this documentary months ago, only for me to catch him watching it by himself, but that’s a topic for another day) anyways, he kept criticizing the production, insisting that they were getting the whole story of Moses wrong simply because it didn’t align exactly with jw religious views. Now, I agree that the acting wasn’t top notch, but it wasn’t even a proper movie, it was just an ordinary documentary.

At one point, he remarked, “In Armageddon, they will see.” I asked, “For getting some things wrong?” Suddenly, he had nothing to say.
That exchange revealed something troubling. Are people now deserving of destruction for producing a Bible-based movie without portraying things exactly how Watchtower would?
I simply reminded him that Jehovah, not us, determines what happens to people at Armageddon, and the conversation ended.

This is the type of talk you hear when you are around these people. They’ll casually judge and condemn other people to death/destruction, without any push back from fellow jws around, they’d all agree and kinda relish the idea, as if it’s a good thing for millions of people to die, not because the people they are condemning killed anyone. They are condemning these people for believing differently and/or reaching the wrong conclusion(according to them).

When people become so convinced of their religious position that they casually imagine destruction for those who differ, what you get is extremism in plain sight.


r/exjw • • 4h ago

Ask ExJW Going to an occasional meeting is a reversal of progress!!!

7 Upvotes

Spouse asked me to go to an occasional meeting to be with the family- but knows I am not coming back and not a JW any longer & i do not back track - but wants the family togetherness in "worship". To me there's so many more ways & opportunities for us to be together. To me this is so multi layed especially since my fading/removing myself took YEARS & going for even one meeting would so much reverse progress & take a piece of me that I am not willing to give. It would give an illusion to these ppl that I want to be even a little small part of them. It would give my kids hope of me returning. It would be me living a lie. And I'm not okay w any of that.

Anyone else go just for sake of family because they want you to every now and then? I am at a firm no with this but curious to see how others that are out and have spouses in land on this. I know everyone's situation is different and I'm not judging either way, just curious if how strongly yall feel on this one.


r/exjw • • 3h ago

Meetup Any fellow Belgians here? 🇧🇪

6 Upvotes

Just curious to know if there are any other people in Belgium going through a similar situation. It would be nice to know I’m not alone in this!
Right now, I feel like I’m fighting against the whole world on my own. I’m realizing just how difficult it is to be in this situation without having anyone close to you to talk to, especially when everyone around you is PIMI and simply can’t understand what you’re going through.
Thanks in advance for your replies. It really means a lot.


r/exjw • • 25m ago

Ask ExJW Does anyone still notice PIMIs and POMIs on here?

3 Upvotes

I would regularly have JWs comment on my posts and comments several times per month. It seems like since the last blood update, or even before that, I haven’t seen a single one. Has anyone else noticed this?

Could it be that they are slightly embarrassed about their religion since they have no confidence in any of the doctrines being permanent anymore and don’t want to be made a fool of?


r/exjw • • 15h ago

Venting PIMIs deny evidence; watching wildlife documentary with PIMIs

49 Upvotes

There were three of us (Me a POMO, 2 PIMI brothers) watching Discovery Channel about animal ecosystem and the narrator said that the crocodiles have remainined unchanged for 225 million years.

When the PIMI brothers heard it:

PIMI #1 said: "The Earth is only 6,000 years old, how did that happen?"

PIMI #2 said: "They are only estimates by scientists."

PIMI #1 replied: "Perhaps they're wrong."

Me rolled my eyes. Me a POMO, I'm about away from them by 20 feet because I'm doing chores, when I heard it, In my mind it's like: "This is how I woke up. The math doesn't add up in Science. The Earth is 4.5 billion years old, and the 6,000 years doesn't add up because the Bible is not true"

Also in my mind: "it's sad that PIMIs like them are denying Science's timeline. They're clearly deceived by Watchtower."

When I woke up, that's how everything clicked. The humanoid fossils (Neanderthals, denisovans, erectus), the dinosaurs, the age of the Earth. Take the Bible out of the equation, and the Scientific timeline fits.


r/exjw • • 23h ago

News I can bring you great news from the UK on the 16th November Sam Carling MP will lead a debate in lower house of Parliament exposing the Borg.

187 Upvotes

On the 16th November Sam is leading an adjournment debate entitled 'Support for victims leaving high control religious groups ' it will cover Practical and emotional support for people leaving controlling religious communities, Social isolation and loss of family relationships, Access to specialist support services and whether existing public services understand the particular difficulties of leaving a high-control group.

He is calling it high-control group to increase support but will be talking about his personal experience of the Borg. This will hopefully be reported around the world. I hope it will inspire more people to lobby they local or national deputies. This could be the start of something bigger than Japan. What do you think and what is happening in your country?


r/exjw • • 7h ago

Academic Why Many Will Never "Wake Up": The "Humane" vs. the "Merely Human"

9 Upvotes

These two concepts — the "humane" and the "merely human" — stand at opposite poles.

In the theology of Jehovah’s Witnesses, the "merely human" is viewed as petty, fallible, and rooted in limited understanding.

The "humane," on the other hand, in its broader sense, pertains to the very essence of being human; it reflects the light within people — a reflection of God's spirit, since we were created in His image and likeness.

Those who reject such human virtue are deemed "inhumane" — or, in a more stark sense, "non-human" (nelyud): someone who has crossed over to the side of darkness, a fallen being, an abomination to the light.

From this, an interesting phenomenon emerges:

The common adage "To err is human" is used to imply that a person's ways are inferior to the ways of God — or, more specifically, the ways of His representatives: the Governing Body!

Meanwhile, the call to mercy — "In any situation, remain humane" — is frequently ignored, as it is often considered more "effective" to point out sin, framed here as an inherent flaw — a defect in the "mould" from which we are cast.

The Governing Body, for its part, avoids such clichés. Though they claim to be "neither inspired by God nor infallible," they are nevertheless described as "fostering unity" and "always proving themselves to be good shepherds." They are presented as chosen by Christ, guiding us in alignment with the movements of God's heavenly chariot.

They serve as the benchmark — a standard from which any deviation is unacceptable, whether backward (by humbly trusting the "brothers" to reveal "new light" and adjusting one's own limited, human understanding accordingly) or forward (by refusing to run ahead of the chariot and remembering what matters most: unity).

The same applies to the boundary between left-wing and right-wing views: one cannot remain rigidly conservative, yet neither should one become excessively enthusiastic about change — anticipating further reforms, extrapolating a trend towards liberalization, and speculating about what might eventually emerge at the end of this "rebranding."

Any acknowledgment of "new light" must itself fall within the bounds of an appropriate response. Even a nod in response to "new light" must be the right kind of nod. A weak one betrays a lack of faith and trust, intellectual rigidity, an unwillingness to open one's mind to God; a strong one conveys triumphant agreement, perhaps accompanied by a silent reproach that the revelation came so late. Perhaps it is best not to react at all — or rather, to offer nothing more than a perfunctory "Noted." After all, genuine praise is constructive and specific. It is not the kind of perfunctory "thank you" that one can casually get away with giving an ordinary elder, without anyone asking, "What exactly did you appreciate?"

To go further and offer praise to the "faithful slave" is risky. Genuine praise, when it goes into detail, can instantly be interpreted as pretence — or, worse still, as calculated deceit disguised as naivety, intended to cast the Governing Body in a poor light by innocently drawing attention to a particular fact.

A particularly telling example is a friend's reaction to the major policy shift concerning blood.

"I don't feel anything in particular, whether resentment or joy. Everything just feels... neutral."

Bravo, Winston! O'Brien would be proud of you.

Crimestop is working at full capacity.

Will anything ever be able to break through it?

Modified: added original message in Russian:

В теологии Свидетелей Иеговы человеческое – мелочное, людское, зачастую ошибочное, основанное на ограниченном понимании. В то же время человечное в общем смысле это – быть человеком, «человечиться», даже в некотором смысле использующееся как выражение того света, что есть в людях, духа Бога, по чьему образу и подобию мы были созданы.

А те, кто отвергают человеческую добродетель – бесчеловечные. Сразу в голове всплывают следущие ассоциации: перешедший на сторону тьмы, падший, омерзительный для света – нелюдь.

Отсюда можно наблюдать интересный феномен: Крылатая фраза «Человеку свойственно ошибаться» выводит: его пути (человека) ниже, чем пути Бога, или... Его Представителей – Руководящий Совет!

А фраза-призыв к милосердию «В любой ситуации оставайся человеком» – зачастую игнорируется, так как эффективнее указывать на грех – переданный через форму для хлеба изъян.

Совет же избегает такого клише. Он – хоть и « не вдохновлённый Богом и способный ошибаться», «содействует единству», «всегда проявляет себя как хороший пастырь», избран Христом и ведёт нас в согласии с путями Небесной колесницы Бога. Эталон, отклонение от которого ни назад (смиренно доверяем братьям открывать нам Новый свет и корректируем своё человеческое понимание), ни вперед (не бежим быстрее колесницы; помним о главном – единстве) недопустимо; то же можно сказать и о границе между левыми и правыми взглядами – нельзя оставаться консервативными, как и в стремлении к реформациям нельзя чрезмерно радоваться изменениям и строить прогнозы на последующие, выстраивая тенденцию либерализации и гадая, что же будет в конце этого ребрединга. Кивок как реакция на Новый свет должен быть в рамках правильной реакции. Слабый – недостаток веры и доверия, закостенелость разума, нежелание открыть его для Бога; сильный – торжествующее согласие и молчаливый упрёк в запоздании откровения.

Лучше никак не реагировать – в том смысле, что достаточно «принято», даже не вдаваясь, казалось бы, в похвалу верного раба, ведь хорошая похвала конструктивна, это не дежурное, спускаемое с рук «спасибо» рядовому старейшине, следовательно, она вдаётся в подробности – и лестное замечание в мгновение ока может обернуться притворством, хуже – замаскированным под наивность лукавством с целью невинным подчеркиванием определённого факта выставить Совет в дурном свете.

Весьма образцовым служит пример реакции моего друга на грандиозное обновление в отношении политики крови:

«Каких-то чувств, будь это обида или радость я не испытываю, все ровно как-то»

Браво, Уинстон! О’Брайен бы тобой гордился.

Самостоп работает на полную мощность. Сможет ли что-нибудь их сломить?


r/exjw • • 1h ago

PIMO Life How to stop submitting my field service report?

3 Upvotes

I’m currently in the process of becoming inactive. I haven’t been out in field service for almost two years, and I only attend meetings about once a month.
I think the elders have probably figured out what’s going on, but surprisingly, they’ve never really tried to arrange a shepherding visit with me. Only one particularly annoying elder has tried to make plans to go out in service with me a few times, but I’ve always canceled on the day.
The thing is, I’m still submitting my monthly field service reports. I just tick the box in the app saying that I participated in the ministry that month, even though I haven’t. I’m honestly scared that if I stop, the elders will start contacting me and trying to arrange shepherding visits, and I really don’t need that stress.
What’s even more annoying is that whenever I forget to submit my report, that same elder texts me to remind me.
So now I’m wondering: what would happen if I just started ignoring his messages and stopped submitting my reports altogether? Would I become inactive after three months, or does it take longer? And would the elders start trying to contact me more often?
I really just want to fade quietly without having to explain myself or have any uncomfortable conversations with them.
Another thing I’m worried about is that I still live with my PIMI parents. I’m over 18, but I’m scared the elders might contact my parents if I stop responding. My parents also know that I haven’t been to service but we don’t talk about it anymore. They just ask me to come to meetings sometimes. But I don’t know how they will react if that elder contacts them. Has anyone experienced something similar?


r/exjw • • 15m ago

Ask ExJW Advice on raising a child: Mom non-JW, dad studying.

2 Upvotes

Hello!

I would like to start this post by saying that I do not have anything against JWs as a whole, and advising that I did not grow up a Witness.

My husband was raised JW, but was never baptized. His parents had a lapse of about 5 years around the time he was ten, and by the time they were all the way back in, he was too old to force to meetings or out in service.

When we started dating, he expressed that he wanted to return to studying with a brother that he is close with. I was not aware of what that entailed, and because we were just starting out, I was very supportive because I was largely ignorant to the ins-and-outs.

Fast forward, we are married five years, and we have a two year old that is the joy of our lives. I have no complaints about my husband, and honestly, I have no complaints about the arrangement right now. My fear comes from the fact that my husband has just suffered a major loss, which has led to deeper conversation about being baptized.

My husband has been extremely lax thus far, and I haven’t experienced any trouble on his side as far as celebrating holidays or birthdays with our child. He usually attends Christmas light walk-throughs, but he’s never been a Halloween enjoyer, so I spend that time with my child and best friend while he hangs out at home.

My questions are to those who were raised in our situation, or perhaps somebody that is in it with an older child. What were some things that your family implemented/implements that made you feel your religion was your own choice? Did you find that setting boundaries early on or talking with your JW partner or parent helped you in the long run?

I realize this post might merit a litany of “GTFO OF THERE,” or “TAKE YOUR CHILD AND RUN,” which is very fair based on many of the experiences I’ve read, and heard about first hand. I am overjoyed to report that my husband (nor his congregation, for that matter) have never made me or my child feel that we have no choice but to become “evenly yolked,” and I am choosing to believe the best of him because that is what he has shown me our entire relationship.