r/ExIsmailis • • Aug 16 '25

Commentary How the First Aga Khan Betrayed the Muslim Ummah: A Forgotten Chapter of Colonial Collaboration

132 Upvotes

Heads up - this is a research paper generated by deep research using AI. It's main purpose is to document the history of how the original Con betrayed the Muslims, sold his soul to the British - and how this formed the underpinnings of the cult we know today. It may appear long and dense, but it really is worth your time. Enjoy:

   

"And hold firmly to the rope of Allah all together and do not become divided." - Quran 3:103

In the history of European colonialism in Muslim lands, few stories are as troubling—or as carefully hidden—as that of the first Aga Khan and his alliance with the British Empire. While most Muslims today know little about this chapter of our history, understanding it is crucial for recognizing how colonial powers used divide-and-rule tactics to weaken the Muslim ummah from within.

This is the story of how Prince Hasan Ali Shah, who became known as Aga Khan I, transformed from a Persian noble into a British collaborator, and how his alliance with colonial authorities enabled the British to make devastating inroads against the larger Muslim population. It's a story that reveals the sophisticated methods colonial powers used to turn Muslims against each other and fragment our unity.

   

The Making of a Collaborator: From Persian Noble to British Ally

Early Life and the Seeds of Betrayal

Hasan Ali Shah was born in 1804 in Persia (modern-day Iran) into a position of privilege and religious authority. As the 46th Imam of the Nizari Ismaili Muslims, he inherited leadership over a community that, while small compared to the broader Muslim population, was scattered across Central Asia, Afghanistan, and India. His early life seemed to follow the traditional path of Islamic leadership—he was appointed governor of Kerman province by the Persian Shah and successfully restored order to regions plagued by rebellions and raids [1].

However, the seeds of his eventual betrayal were planted when he was dismissed from his governorship in 1837, despite his successful service. This dismissal, motivated by court politics rather than poor performance, left him bitter and resentful toward the Persian government. When he refused to accept his dismissal and attempted to maintain his position by force, he found himself in armed conflict with Persian authorities.

The decisive moment came when a massive Persian government force of 24,000 men defeated his much smaller army, forcing him to flee Persia entirely in 1841. It was at this moment of desperation and exile that Hasan Ali Shah made the fateful decision that would define the rest of his life—and betray the interests of the broader Muslim ummah.

The First Contact: Afghanistan and British Opportunism

Fleeing Persia, Hasan Ali Shah arrived in Kandahar, Afghanistan, in 1841. What he found there would change everything. The city was occupied by British forces during the First Anglo-Afghan War, and British officials quickly recognized an opportunity in this displaced Persian noble who commanded religious authority over scattered Muslim communities.

The British were not interested in Hasan Ali Shah out of sympathy for his plight. They saw him as a valuable asset who could serve their imperial ambitions. Here was a man who claimed descent from Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), who held religious authority over Muslim communities across strategically important regions, and who was now desperate for protection and resources.

The relationship that developed was not one of equals. British sources describe how "a close relationship developed between Hasan Ali Shah and the British" during this period, but this was the relationship between a colonial master and a useful servant [2]. Hasan Ali Shah wrote to British officials discussing "his plans to seize and govern Herat on behalf of the British"—essentially offering to use his religious authority and military capabilities to help the British expand their empire into Muslim lands [3].

Think about what this means: a man who claimed to be a spiritual leader of Muslims was offering to help Christian colonial powers conquer and rule over Muslim territories and populations. This was not mere political pragmatism—it was a fundamental betrayal of the trust placed in him by his followers and the broader Muslim community.

   

The Institutionalization of Betrayal: Services to the British Empire

Military Collaboration in Sindh

After the setbacks in Afghanistan, Hasan Ali Shah moved to Sindh (in present-day Pakistan), where his betrayal of Muslim interests became even more explicit. He "rendered further services to the British" that directly contributed to their successful conquest and annexation of Sindh in 1843 [4]. These services helped the British defeat the Talpur rulers of Sindh and establish colonial control over this Muslim region.

For these services—services that helped subjugate fellow Muslims under colonial rule—Hasan Ali Shah was rewarded with an annual pension of £2,000 from General Charles James Napier, the British conqueror of Sindh [5]. This was an enormous sum at the time, equivalent to hundreds of thousands of dollars today. More importantly, it created a direct financial dependency that bound his interests to those of the British colonial state.

This pension was not charity—it was payment for services rendered and a retainer for future collaboration. From this point forward, Hasan Ali Shah's prosperity and security depended entirely on British success and protection. He had become, in the most literal sense, a paid agent of colonial rule over Muslim lands.

Settlement in British India: The Final Transformation

In 1844, Hasan Ali Shah made his final break with the Muslim world by settling permanently in Bombay, in British India. This was not merely seeking refuge—it was choosing to live under and legitimize colonial rule over Muslims. His settlement in British territory formalized his transformation from an independent Muslim leader into a colonial collaborator.

The British colonial administration welcomed him warmly, not out of generosity, but because they recognized his value as a tool for controlling Muslim populations. They provided him with protection, continued his pension, and most importantly, gave him official recognition that enhanced his religious authority among his followers.

   

The Mechanisms of Betrayal: How the Alliance Harmed Muslims

Dividing the Muslim Community

The most devastating aspect of the Aga Khan's collaboration was how it was used to divide and weaken the Muslim community. The British employed a strategy that historians call "divide and rule"—they deliberately created and exploited divisions within colonized populations to prevent unified resistance.

The Aga Khan alliance was a perfect example of this strategy in action. By supporting and legitimizing his religious authority, the British created an alternative center of Islamic leadership that competed with and undermined broader Muslim unity. While many Muslim leaders were calling for resistance to colonial rule and unity against foreign domination, the Aga Khan was preaching collaboration and submission to British authority.

This division was formalized in 1866 through what became known as the Khoja Case. When some members of the Khoja community challenged the Aga Khan's authority and claimed they were actually Sunni Muslims rather than Ismailis, the dispute was taken to British colonial courts rather than being resolved through traditional Islamic jurisprudence [6].

The British colonial judge, Sir Joseph Arnould—a non-Muslim with no training in Islamic law—made a binding legal decision about Islamic religious identity and authority. He ruled in favor of the Aga Khan, legally establishing the Khojas as "Shia Nizari Ismailis" under the Aga Khan's authority [7].

This case was revolutionary in the worst possible way. For the first time, a colonial court had assumed the authority to define Islamic religious identity and establish religious leadership. Traditional Islamic institutions and scholars were bypassed entirely. The colonial state had become the ultimate arbiter of Islamic authenticity—a devastating blow to Muslim autonomy and religious authority.

Creating a "Model Minority"

The British used the Aga Khan and his community as what we might today call a "model minority"—a group that was held up as an example of how Muslims could prosper under colonial rule if they just collaborated and submitted. The success and prosperity that Ismaili communities achieved under British protection was constantly cited as evidence that colonial rule was beneficial for Muslims.

This served several harmful purposes. First, it provided a counter-narrative to Muslim resistance movements. When Muslim leaders argued that colonial rule was oppressive and un-Islamic, the British could point to the Aga Khan and say, "Look, here's a descendant of the Prophet who supports our rule and whose community prospers under it."

Second, it created pressure on other Muslim leaders to follow the Aga Khan's example. The implicit message was clear: collaborate with us like the Aga Khan does, and your community can prosper too. Resist us, and face the consequences.

Third, it provided the British with Islamic religious legitimacy for their policies. When the Aga Khan endorsed British policies or participated in colonial ceremonies, it gave these activities Islamic religious approval that helped legitimize colonial rule among Muslim populations.

Intelligence Networks and Surveillance

Perhaps most troubling of all, the Aga Khan alliance provided the British with extensive intelligence networks throughout the Muslim world. Ismaili communities were scattered across Central Asia, Afghanistan, and India—regions that were strategically crucial for British imperial interests but difficult to monitor through conventional means.

The religious loyalty that these communities felt toward the Aga Khan, combined with his dependence on British protection, meant that information flowing through these networks ultimately served British rather than Muslim interests. Community members traveling for trade, pilgrimage, or family reasons could provide information about political developments, economic conditions, and potential threats to British interests across vast regions.

This intelligence network was particularly valuable during the period of the "Great Game"—the strategic competition between British and Russian empires in Central Asia. Information gathered through Ismaili networks helped the British maintain their competitive advantage and expand their influence in regions populated by Muslims.

Think about the implications: Muslim communities that trusted their religious leader were unknowingly providing information that helped colonial powers maintain control over Muslim lands and populations. Their religious devotion was being exploited for colonial purposes.

   

The Long-Term Damage: Legacy of Division and Dependency

Fragmenting Muslim Unity

The Aga Khan's collaboration had effects that extended far beyond his own lifetime and community. By demonstrating that Islamic religious authority could be co-opted and used to serve colonial interests, his example encouraged the British to seek similar arrangements with other Muslim leaders and communities.

The success of the Aga Khan model led to a systematic effort to fragment Muslim religious and political authority. Rather than facing a unified Muslim resistance, the British were able to create competing centers of authority with different relationships to colonial power. Some leaders opposed colonial rule, others collaborated with it, and still others tried to navigate between the two positions.

This fragmentation made unified Muslim resistance much more difficult. Instead of presenting a united front against colonial domination, Muslim communities found themselves divided along lines that often served colonial rather than Islamic interests.

Establishing Dangerous Precedents

The legal precedents established through the Aga Khan alliance had devastating long-term consequences for Muslim autonomy. The 1866 Khoja Case established that colonial courts could adjudicate Islamic religious disputes and define Islamic religious identity. This precedent was then applied to other communities and contexts, gradually expanding colonial legal authority over Islamic institutions and practices.

Traditional Islamic jurisprudence (فقه), which had developed sophisticated methods for resolving religious disputes and establishing religious authority over more than a millennium, was systematically marginalized in favor of colonial legal systems that served administrative rather than religious purposes.

This subordination of Islamic law to colonial legal authority created patterns of dependency that continued long after formal decolonization. Many post-colonial Muslim societies continued to rely on Western legal frameworks rather than developing authentic Islamic alternatives, partly because the colonial period had so thoroughly undermined confidence in traditional Islamic institutions.

Economic and Political Dependencies

The economic relationships established through the Aga Khan alliance also created lasting patterns of dependency. The integration of Ismaili communities into British-dominated commercial networks, while providing prosperity for many individuals, also created structural dependencies on Western-controlled economic systems.

These dependencies had political implications that continue to this day. Communities that benefited economically from integration with Western-dominated systems developed material interests in maintaining those relationships, even when they conflicted with broader Muslim interests or Islamic principles.

The Aga Khan's descendants have continued these patterns, maintaining close relationships with Western governments and institutions that often align more closely with Western geopolitical interests than with the needs of the global Muslim community.

   

Understanding the Betrayal: Why This History Matters Today

Recognizing Colonial Strategies

Understanding the Aga Khan's betrayal is crucial for recognizing how colonial powers operated—not just through direct military conquest, but through sophisticated strategies of co-optation and division. As contemporary Islamic scholar Imam Tom Facchine explains, European colonialism "hijacked the Muslim world from the inside out" by co-opting indigenous institutions and authorities rather than simply destroying them [8].

The Aga Khan case reveals how this process worked in practice. Rather than trying to destroy Islamic religious authority entirely, the British found ways to redirect it to serve colonial purposes while maintaining its Islamic appearance. This was far more effective than direct suppression because it created the illusion of Islamic consent for colonial rule.

These same strategies continue to be used today in different forms. Understanding how they worked historically helps us recognize and resist their contemporary manifestations.

Learning from Our Mistakes

The Aga Khan's story also provides important lessons about the dangers of compromising Islamic principles for worldly gain. His transformation from a legitimate Islamic leader into a colonial collaborator began with understandable human motivations—the desire for security, prosperity, and recognition after experiencing persecution and exile.

However, his willingness to prioritize these personal needs over his responsibilities to the broader Muslim community led him down a path that ultimately betrayed everything he claimed to represent. His story serves as a warning about how easily Islamic leadership can be corrupted when it becomes dependent on non-Islamic sources of authority and support.

Reclaiming Our Narrative

Perhaps most importantly, understanding this history helps us reclaim our own narrative about colonialism and its effects on the Muslim world. Too often, the story of colonialism is told in ways that minimize Muslim agency and resistance, or that present collaboration with colonial powers as inevitable or even beneficial.

The Aga Khan's story reveals both the reality of Muslim collaboration with colonial powers and the devastating effects this collaboration had on Muslim unity and autonomy. It shows that the fragmentation and weakness that characterizes much of the contemporary Muslim world is not natural or inevitable, but was deliberately created through strategies like the one employed with the Aga Khan.

   

Conclusion: Lessons for Today's Muslims

The story of the first Aga Khan's betrayal of the Muslim ummah is not just ancient history—it's a cautionary tale with profound relevance for Muslims today. It reveals how colonial powers used sophisticated strategies to divide and weaken Muslim communities, and how easily Islamic religious authority can be co-opted when it becomes dependent on non-Islamic sources of support.

As the Quran warns us: *"O you who believe! Take not as (your) Bitanah (advisors, consultants, protectors, helpers, friends, etc.) those outside your religion since they will not fail to do their best to corrupt you. They desire to harm you severely. Hatred has already appeared from their mouths, but what their breasts conceal is far worse."* (3:118)

The Aga Khan's alliance with the British Empire exemplifies exactly what this verse warns against—the corruption that results when Muslims take non-Muslims as their primary protectors and supporters, especially when those non-Muslims have interests that conflict with the welfare of the broader Muslim community.

For contemporary Muslims, the lessons are clear. We must be vigilant against attempts to divide our community along sectarian, ethnic, or national lines. We must be suspicious of Muslim leaders who depend primarily on non-Muslim sources of authority and support. And we must work to rebuild the unity and autonomy that colonial strategies like the Aga Khan alliance were designed to destroy.

The path forward requires what Islamic scholars call returning to authentic Islamic sources and methods, developing economic and political independence from systems that serve non-Muslim interests, and rebuilding the bonds of brotherhood and sisterhood that make the ummah strong.

Most importantly, we must remember that our ultimate loyalty belongs to Allah (سبحانه وتعالى) and His Messenger (صلى الله عليه وسلم), not to worldly powers that offer temporary benefits in exchange for compromising our principles. The Aga Khan's story shows us the devastating consequences of forgetting this fundamental truth.

May Allah guide us to learn from the mistakes of the past and to build a future worthy of our Islamic heritage and principles.


r/ExIsmailis • • Jul 26 '25

I am sick and tired of Ismailis saying their Imam is some sort of divine descendent.

121 Upvotes

I had some crazy Ismaili send me a threat that God will destroy me for my nonstop comments and posts on this sub - upset at me for highlighting all of the truths behind this giant Hindu inspired polytheistic cult.

Well it motivated me further. Time for another post.

Today’s topic: I am sick and tired of Ismailis saying their Imam is some sort of divine descendent.

It should be made clear - bloodline based divinity is a made up and fabricated concept in Islam. No human is better than another - and the prophet Muhammad said this.

I will say it again: Ismailis are not Muslim. They were born out of the betrayal of Muslims by the original Con when he wanted to cozy up to the British. He started off using deception and backstabbing and that’s how he survives to this day.

The con is just a Con. He has no divinity and he is a massive thief. He has no comparison to Prophet Muhammad.

Ismailis need to stop pretending these two figures represent the same spiritual tradition.

Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) slept on a straw mat. He patched his own clothes. He gave away everything he had. He forgave his enemies, lived among the poor, and preached submission to God, not luxury. He embodied deep self sacrifice.

Now look at the Aga Khan — a billionaire playboy with private jets, racehorses, and French chateaus. Random women he goes around sleeping with. He launders money through the AKDN. He abrogates everything in Islam so he doesn’t have to spend his money actually helping poor people.

How did we go from a prophet who wept for the poor to an imam who dines with aristocrats using stolen money?

Anyone who sends me threats that their fake Con will destroy me - I have no fear and it will only prompt me to post more.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 05 '25

Commentary Ismailism is so weird man. Feels dystopian

105 Upvotes

-You got people worshipping a guy who’ve they NEVER met and CRY for his passing when they only saw him once a decade (that’s like 2 or 3 times for the older gens and once for Gen Z) It feels like North Korea, crying for the supreme leader and all who never knew you. Other than that, that Karim guy only gave you the most cliche advice “Eat healthy, be close to family, pray, etc” which I could’ve gotten from a TikTok influencer.

-Now he appoints his oldest son who married a nude model to be his successor and Ismailis especially our parents (50+) will worship this new guy just the same. Flash forward 30 more years and you’ll be worshipping that guys kid.

-Youre telling me the most spiritual and enlightened person in the world is a trust fund baby who became lucky and inherited his daddy’s businesses? What about the christian/jewish monks and muslims that give up their whole life in pursuit of enlightenment? Are they not holy? Why don’t they have the light of God? You got fucking Hindu people starving themselves to death. And you’re telling me a billionaire baby boy is somehow in possession of the light of god just because he happened to be born to a rich family? Absolutely Ridiculous.

Ismailism has to be simulataneously the best and worst religion in the world. Good on the community. Absolutely dog shit theology and lore.


r/ExIsmailis • • Apr 20 '21

Actress Noureen Dewulf was an Ismaili?

Thumbnail
gallery
72 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Jun 21 '21

Announcement I am apostatizing from Ismailism and I’d like to share why

71 Upvotes

I grew up in a fairly religious family and my learning phase of ismailism started when I was quite young. I remember quite well how my mother would show me pictures of his highness the Aga Khan and his family and would tell me that one day when I’m old enough I can volunteer and serve as an Ismaili Council president and work in real life with the Aga Khan.

34 years later and her dream turned out to be false. I instead started searching for answers. Questions plagued me such as “why do we pray to Aga Khan”, “Why is it that the imam of the time never attended our jamatkhana”, and “Why does Hazir Imam live a lavish life while murids in poor countries struggle to come up with money for dasond, but still pay.”

I found my answers on Google. On the very top of the search engine was IsmailiGnosis. I felt relieved to have found this resource and all of my lingering questions were perfectly resolved temporarily.

After scrolling down a bit more on the Google search page, I discovered r/exismailis. I don’t particularly remember what question led me to this subreddit, but my first thoughts when I opened this subreddit was that you guys were blasphemous, Sunnis, idiots, and assholes for hating on the man who I looked up to all my life. For a while, acting upon my cognitive dissonance, I would troll exismailis because I didn’t want to believe that this religion which I so loved was fake and full of deception. This subreddit and other factors led me to start doing my own research. I had much difficulties coping in terms with the legitimate facts , but it had to be done for the sake of settling with this internal war going on in my mind.

I then discovered r/Ismailis. In this community I felt like I resonated with my fellow Ismailis. I was happy to have found this community until days passed and I was exposed to the truth about ismailism. Everyone is knowingly covering up what’s in front of them. That Aga Khan cheated on his wife, lives a lavish lifestyle, his ancestors who we believe to be have noor killed and betrayed other Muslims, the fact that Aga Khan’s lineage to Muhammad is unproven, and Aga Khan is completely alienated from the jamatkhana.

Ismailis on the subreddit justified his adultery by saying the imam is infallible or that marriage is whatever makes you feel comfortable. Ismailis justified his lavish lifestyle by explaining how Muhammad was rich and how Aga Khan gives back to the poor. I doubt Muhammad was rich. I’ve read so many Sunni historical accounts of how the Prophet lived a miserable life. Yes he was treated like a royal because he was their Prophet, but what I’ve learned about his life is that he was never a hypocrite. It was never “do as I say, not as I do” with his philosophy. The Prophet Muhammad would pray not just 5x a day but throughout the entire nights, so would his companions and Imam Ali. The Prophet never lived a life that others wouldn’t have lived. There’s no Hadith or Quran verse which states Prophet lived like a rich king from his follower’s money.

What started to diminish my believe in the noor of Allah is the fact that Aga Khan 1 was in servitude of the British and received a pension for essentially killing or spying on the Muslims. Aga Khan 1 also lied and duped many Hindu Khojas into following him. With the help of the British, Aga Khan 1 gained full control of the Khoja community. A couple generations later and his grandson (that is Aga Khan III) received the royal title of “his highness” from Queen Victoria for all the services Hasan Ali Shah had rendered.

I learned about how Nizar’s succession dispute with al-Musta’li was purely about control and power. Nizar was not selected to become the caliph while his brother was raised to the throne, so he rebelled against his brother and hence became an “enemy of the state”. He had to flee to Cairo where he seized Alexandria. Unfortunately, he was defeated and subsequently was killed. I now started realizing how the concept of “noor of Allah” is nonexistent, that the split between Nizar and Al-Musta’li was purely political and not on a religious basis. That two power seeking brothers claimed their right to the throne. That the younger brother Nizar was openly envious of having not been selected as the caliph and committed sedition. Nizar’s comrade, Hasan Bin Sabah, escaped and established a fortress for Hadi. There is practically no proof of a Hadi ever showing up. In fact Hadi is just a generic Arabic name for “leader”.

I did a lot of research and found Hsan Bin Sabah’s second successor’s son, Hassan II became the imam. In the dua his name is “Ḥasan ʿAlā Zikrihi's-Salām”, subsequently the descendants of Ḥasan ʿAlā Zikrihi's-Salām became the next imams. Therefore, it is reasonable enough for me to conclude Aga Khan is not actually a descendant of Muhammad and the whole concept of noor of Allah or the imam being divine is fake. It’s all a scam. All a system meant to exploit innocent people.

Aga Khan while being the Ismaili imam has never actually experienced what it’s like to be an Ismaili. It is clear in history that Muhammad experienced what it was like to be Muslim because he indeed taught all the prayers. His followers retained his teachings and today Muslims around the world still do the same prayers Muhammad introduced 1400 years ago. In the case of Aga Khan, it is difficult to call him or Muslim or Ismaili. I don’t think I have ever seen him engage in either practices. Also When Aga Khan visits Asian or Middle eastern countries, he speaks in a language which his disciples can’t understand. Ismailis justify this by sharing stories of how Aga Khan can magically speak several languages like Urdu, Gujrati, and Arabic, yet in these deedars he speaks English. If he could speak these languages he would but he does not because he doesn’t know how to. He does however speak French when addressing his French audience so there’s no reason why he wouldn’t speak the languages of his respective jamat in deedars.

Now coming back to IsmailiGnosis, I love the author‘s creative works to justify the imamat, but it is obviously fake. There are no Quran verses or hadiths to support their essays. Usually the Quran verses or hadiths they use are so obviously taken out of context. Even their external sources are flawed. For instance, they claim Aga Khan is connected to the Imamat of Adam and Jesus, yet there’s not a single shred of evidence in Hadith or Quran indicating that Aga Khan or for that matter Ali is connected to the imamat of Adam and Jesus. The concept of imamat was established after Muhammad passed away. Therefore it was reasonable for me to conclude that the author is just a fanatic and Ismailis and ex-ismailis alike should give no credence to their works. However as much fun as it is to explore the fanaticism of the writer, there is the blatant disingenuousness which I do not appreciate. From deceiving readers about Aga Khan’s wealth to blatantly lying about Aly Aga Khan being a playboy, I realized that the author clearly has an ulterior agenda in mind. To knowingly and willingly dupe Ismailis who question the religion.

For the record, I do believe Ismailis are the most peaceful compared to other Islamic sects, but that may also be due to the “white savior” nature of the religion where an affluent and educated European has to pose as a divine figure to educate his followers the basic principles of peace, equality, and tolerance.

I also believe Islam has the potential of being as peaceful as ismailism. For that I place my faith on the younger generations who are growing up and promoting progressive ideals. I don’t know if I’ll convert to another sect of Islam or become agnostic. Though, right now I see no point in converting to another sect. My wife and kids are still Ismaili and they’re pretty well acquainted with the community so I’m not sure how I’ll approach them to tell them the truth.

I don’t have anyone specific to thank for snapping me out of the delusion. I do want to express my thanks to Salim Lalani and the members of r/exismailis and r/Ismailis alike for all equally enlightening me about the truth.

If you made it to the end of this post. You are amazing. Truly. I don’t expect many people to reach the end but if you did I give you a pat on the back for taking the time to read through why I made the decision to leave the faith I love.

tl;dr I have apostatized after doing research.


r/ExIsmailis • • May 18 '21

Meme When young Ismailis attend Deedar

Post image
64 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Nov 22 '20

Can you guys describe some of the weird rituals that Ismailis do?

64 Upvotes

I am trying to describe it to my friends but I haven't been to khane for years. I remember there's one where the dude throws water in your face, the one where you eat the yellow stuff and the drink the water Aga Khan touched, and one where you touch the food that gets auctioned to bless it cause your relative died or something (??). What are the things you have to say? like you put money on a plate and say "Forgive me Daddy Khan for I have sinned." to your friends dad who is head priest this year and he splashes you with water and says like okay, you're good for a month

then you put more money on a plate and your drink water out of this tiny cup that gets some dude serves your from these special dishes that some guys waves over with incense smoke. Then you get another dude gives you a spoon of the yellow stuff on waxpaper and you take a halloween candy.

and then you auction the food that everyone brings to donate and drink tea and biscuits.

every month you hand over a wad of cash to the head priest and he puts in a little bag and adds it to the pile and every ten years-ish the old white dude shows up on his private plane to say work hard and pray and he takes the money back to his private island.

My friends don't believe me - I'm not making this up right?


r/ExIsmailis • • May 08 '21

Why I hate His Highness Mawlana Shah Karim Al-Hussaini Aga Khan IV

60 Upvotes

Looking at Karim Al-Husseini's picture around the house is eerie because you think even in this age some white cult leader is mandating you give him 1/8 of everything you earn while he while blows hundreds of millions $$ on yachts, mansions, supercars, jewelry, etc. You look around and you see his impact on humanity being inconsequential. You realize he's insignificant to the world spiritually and physically. On a spiritual level, he's shockingly bad. It's surprising that somebody could manage to pull off the ruse of being a divine figure while saying practically nothing of significance. Aga Khan's only ever provided the most censored TRITE guidance that any stereotypical European plutocrat could give. It's not so much that Aga Khan lacks knowledge or intelligence, he lacks the boldness required to say anything of significance. But why acknowledge theological issues like half your Jamat believing in Hindu deities/reincarnation or unanswered LGBTQ issues when you could stay quiet and maximizes profits. In the material world, Aga Khan has practically no influence on the direction humanity heads. All while he's been careless enough to admit to tasting alcohol, selling alcohol, riffing off false predictions/terrible advice, and then being bold enough to even go on to create religious ceremonies based on seizing more money from his followers (1/4 Income Majlis). I guess we're now in the age of the "European" Imam, an Imam who doesn't even care to play the part. He doesn't even engage with his Jamat. His fraud is so overt, so apparent, so disdainful.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 13 '25

I took a deep dive into Kendra Spears’ whereabouts

54 Upvotes

TLDR: She’s alive. Likely living in Brooklyn and trying to restart her modeling career. Loves deserts and was/is a Mormon.

Salwa Aga Khan or Kendra Aga Khan or Kendra Spears?

She never changed her name to Salwa. She did change it to Kendra Aga Khan but in 2022 was using Kendra Spears again.

Where does she live?

She's currently lives in Brooklyn (Sunset Park). She bought this apartment back in 2012 on a 30-year mortgage. It was for $1.8 million. She transferred ownership in 2019 to an LLC she created in Delaware (Macarons LLC). The mortgage was paid off in April 2022.

She has another house in Seattle which bought in 2011. The ownership of that house was also transferred to Macarons LLC in 2019.

She also started another LLC in 2020 (Gateau LLC) and bought a $2 million house in Washington under that company.

-She is the only owner of Macarons LLC and Gateau LLC and has been ever year since 2019 based on yearly filings. I guess she really like deserts lol (gateau and macarons are both desserts).

-The timing to transferring her properties to Macarons LLC and Gateau is interesting. Why 2019? Was she having marriage problems and was expecting a divorce and decided to transfer her properties to an LLC?

What does she do for work?

-She pretty much disappeared from the modeling world after having Irfan, until August 2024. She does seem quite aged and different now.

-She was being managed by Next Management in NYC before and still is. Her agent was Beth Dubin, not sure if she still has the same agent.

Any updates from her?

-Here's a picture of her from July 2023 with her 6 siblings and father.

-Her family is actually Mormon and her father is still quite involved in the Church. I wonder if she's still practicing. She "converted to Islam" after marriage.

-She obviously will not talk about anything related to her marriage publicly because of NDAs - as is the case with all the divorced wives.


r/ExIsmailis • • Jan 31 '26

Karim Aga Khan offers Epstein a paid trip to his party in return for a borrowing Epstein’s helicopter

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Sep 08 '22

Discussion Finally left this scam: My story

50 Upvotes

I used to be a complete Ismaili saint in my teen-age years. I would often be made fun of for it. I was first introduced to the idea of the imam being a fraud my freshmen year of high school. From then on I ventured to do all my research to defend Ismailism

I had all the Quran verses, Farmans, Hadiths and etc to backup why ismailism is the true sect of islam. As years went by I was a very curious REC student. I would often ask the teacher about things which seemed off about the religion and the answer would usually seem "on-spot" and weak. I started to notice that Ismailis would struggle to answer the questions and they would twist things up to fit their narrative.

For example, when the Quran is brought up many Ismailis say that is outdated and it is for the people of the times and others say that it is not for us but only for the imam to read and interpret since it has an inner meaning we would not understand. The viewpoint oddly changes depending on the questions being asked. Also, the Quran clearly debunks both of these arguments.

As all my doubts started piling on top of each other the whole picture was finally clear. I was finally open to the idea that Ismailism is a system which uses the name of islam to make money off of its followers. This gets more obvious when we notice that Ismailism contradicts the true teachings of islam and the imam's actions contradict the teachings of Islam AND Ismailism.

Some examples are -

Ismaili Belief - The imam knows he will be imam from birth

Contradiction - Imam admits in interview that he was shocked when assigned imam

Ismaili belief - Alcohol should not be consumed or sold

Contradiction- Aga Khan sells alcohol in Serena Hotel.

Islam (Quran) - says to pray 5 times a day

Ismailism - pray 3 times a day

Islam (Quran) - Stand and bow in Ruku when praying Salat

Ismailism - just sit and prostrate

Islam (Quran) - Visit and perform Hajj at the Holy Kaaba at least once in lifetime

Imam - nah just look at me

Of course there are so much more but this proves that Ismailism is a weak system that did a poor job at representing Islam. If the Imam was valid, there would not be any contradictions and confusion in the system. The Quran even states that the religion is complete and from here it is not supposed to be changed.

It is also very weird when everything you do in the religion asks for money. I don't want to hear that Dasond is not mandatory because SMS has stated numerous times in his Farmans that one would enter hellfire without dasond. No other religion keeps money as such a priority as does Ismailism.

I think it is time for ismailism to open their eyes and realize how much of a business jamatkhanas really are. In conclusion, it would be easier to believe in Ismailism if I didn't see money moving around left and right everywhere I look in Jamatkhana. It would also be easy if the current system of ismailism didn't have so many imperfections and contradictions.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 16 '25

Commentary To all the Ismailis just visiting here and new to this sub - I understand what you are feeling

49 Upvotes

When I first left Ismailism the most pronounced feeling that I still remember to this day was a strong and aggressive defense mechanism.

Cults make it very difficult for humans to accept an alternate world view.

When I was just about leave I remember I used to get so defensive about Ismailism. All the same arguments Ismailis use to justify their Imam stuff. I did that - I was just like you!

All I ask is keep an open mind and try to humble yourself. Place yourself in the shoes of someone not born into this cult. If you were born on the outside looking in, how would all this appear to you?

You need to understand that the vast majority of Ismaili practices have nothing to do with Islam - period.

Humble yourself - privately if you have to - and cry if needs be. Change is hard.

There is a whole other world out there built on freedom that is free from blind allegiance and financial exploitation.

We were just like you - you can do it! Believe in yourself, forgive yourself and have patience.


r/ExIsmailis • • Aug 06 '22

I think I’ve lost my faith… need help

47 Upvotes

I know this is probably the wrong place to post this, but I figure some people here have probably grappled with the same issue, so what the hell. Full disclosure: I also posted this in r/Ismailis but have gotten no answers - dead silence.

I’ll preface this by saying that, up until about 2-3 months ago, I was extremely devoted to the religion. I went to JK daily in the morning and evening, I’ve sat on paat for Students Majalis, and always paid my dasond. I never thought that I would be reaching out for help or answers because I feel like I’m losing my faith in Hazar Imam.

Around Navroz, I was asked to volunteer on karsaji. I go to a relatively large JK in Toronto, and was really excited about this new opportunity to get involved.

The position consisted of me going to a small concealed room in the back of the JK and counting the money that came in with 3-4 others who were doing the same thing, and a “leader” type person who kept a paper ledger of funds that came in. As far as I could see, this was the only record keeping: there was no financial software, no Excel, no laptop or computer.

All together, we took in about $122k that night. My dasond for that month, which I paid that evening, was around $2,000 so I guess this makes sense.

The sheer volume of money astounded me. The money was all taken in as cash and was placed in these velvet bags. It was then carried out to some nondescript location. Aside from the paper ledger, there was no record of how much money was collected, and there was no record of where it was going. The absolute lack of transparency was frightening.

I’m a lawyer and I do a lot of corporate work with charitable organizations, including religious organizations. Those organizations need to keep careful records and account for every penny, or risk losing their status. In some cases, misappropriation of funds has led to the government and members suing those organizations.

When I asked where it was going or if there was a record, I was told to not ask questions. When I said we should be using Excel at least, I was asked to leave.

The whole thing left me really bothered and I couldn’t help but think that Hazar Imam lives an insanely luxurious lifestyle with hundred million dollar yachts, private planes, mansions, Bahamian Islands, racehorses etc. It’s impossible not to draw an inference that this untraceable money is being filtered somewhere…

I had always had some questions, but for the first time in my life, I was really doubting my faith. Where does the money go? Why are there Ismaili people living in poverty despite this massive inflow of cash and Hazar Imam’s VAST financial resources? Shouldn’t there be some oversight over any organization which takes in, at the very least, hundreds of thousands of dollars just in Vancouver in cash on a single night (extrapolating this to Canada, and for a year, the numbers get insane, even not accounting for “big days”)?

I spoke with a younger Al-Waiz and she couldn’t give me any answers. She simply started quoting peripherally related Farmans and was totally dumbstruck when I said that it was a fallacy to quote a source in support of itself. I’m relatively good at cross-examination so I was perhaps aggressive and she ended up crying and saying she didn’t have answers and “wasn’t trained for this.”

I don’t know where, or to whom, to go to for answers. As an analytical person with common sense, I can’t take “you shouldn’t ask questions” or “you just have to believe” or “Hazar Imam knows best” as answers anymore.

I’ve dedicated so much of my life to the religion and to Hazar Imam, it’s truly heartbreaking to feel like I’m loosing my faith. I feel like I’ve dedicated my whole life to an MLM that made some European billionaire richer.

Please help.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 11 '25

Discussion r/ismaili going crazy over the recording

46 Upvotes

Someone posted up the audio of todays ceremony and Ismailis are super upset but I don’t understand what the big deal is? If the religion is actually as pure and legit as they say it is, they should allow others to view this ceremony. Why hide it? The only explanation I have received is that “it’s a private ceremony” but to me it sounds like cope, because they know that if outsiders were to see the ceremony, they would definitely think it’s a cult.

What makes this worse is that the person allegedly called the cops on the redditor 🤣 absolutely insane. They’re even talking about making IDs for Ismailis in the future and making sure no one has recording devices. Yep, definitely a beautiful religion and not a cult!


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 05 '25

Thank you to everybody who believed in me. I couldn't have done it without you.

46 Upvotes

They all said it would never be me. Aly has youthful energy, Zahra would be the progressive choice, Karel is the oldest, Hussain - he's smart too, not dumb like everyone says. But in the end daddy picked me!

This is a great honor and I promise I will make you proud. I will remind you to work hard so many times. I will say Khanavadan at least 3 times at the end of every farman. I will buy more yachts so that I can solve all the worlds problems. I will come up with a better biryani story than my dad.

Please ignore the rumors about why my wife divorced me, from an esoteric perspective I did nothing wrong. And don't worry I am trying to find another trophy wife ASAP.

So my beloved spiritual children, open your wallets and show how much you love your beloved Imam.

- Lord Daddy Rahim, Ismaili Imam L


r/ExIsmailis • • May 16 '21

Discussion In light of Palestine-Israel clashes, the Aga Khan did absolutely nothing to support humanity. No calls for peace. No humanitarian assistance sent. No plans to resolve the conflict. Similarly, SMS did nothing to stop World War 2 and the Holocaust despite having the connections and the wealth.

45 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Jun 22 '25

Where Is Your Voice, O Imam?

Thumbnail
gallery
44 Upvotes

Why is there still no condemnation of the genocidal Isr@eli war-machine by the Imam-az Zaman? Students in the U.S. have had their careers stripped from them and have been detained for calling a genocide a genocide, and yet, the (alleged) living representative of Allah and His Messenger fails to say one word condemning the apartheid state of “Isr@el”? Now they violate international law and attack Iran, killing women and children in the process, and still, the Imam az-Zaman refuses to criticize Isr@el. Is he unable to speak up due to his relations with certain powerful individuals, or is he concerned that criticizing Isr@el will cause harm to his business affairs, or does he secretly support the Zi0nist project? Whatever the case maybe, what can be justifiably asserted is that the silence and lack of condemnation of the Zi0nist state (which carried out the world’s first live-streamed genocide) should be viewed as shocking especially to those who hold the Aga Khan to be a manifest representative of God on Earth.”

Imam Jaʿfar al-Ṣādiq (ع):

“A believer who sees an oppressor and does not oppose him with his speech or actions, it is as if he desires Allah to be disobeyed on Earth.”

“He who is silent in the face of oppression is a dumb devil (shayṭān ākhras).”

📚 Wasā’il al-Shīʿa, vol. 11, p. 408, 409

Imam Ali (Nahj al-Balāgha, Sermon 97):

“By Allah, I will never be like the hyena that sleeps with its eyes open, waiting for the slaughterer’s knife. I will not be silent in the face of injustice.”


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 04 '25

Commentary Misinformation rampant surrounding Karim "Aga Khan" al-Husayni and Ismailis, as media rush to put out poorly researched obituaries.

43 Upvotes

As usual, we see the same false information parroted ad nauseam. Let's clarify a few myths.

  • Aga Khan is not a hereditary title. It is not an official title at all. It has nothing to do with Ismailism. It was a pet name used by the Qajar Shah to refer to Hassan al-Husayni, Karim's great-great-grandfather. It's usage may have been sarcastic at the time; it is certainly improper now.

  • The al-Husayni/al-Hussaini family (the "Aga Khans") are not "Princes" or "Princesses", despite being descendents of the Qajar Shah. The titles of prince only pass hereditarily along the male line, whereas the al-Husaynis claim descent from a daughter of the Shah. Thus, even if the Qajar dynasty still on the throne, they would not have any claim to those titles.

  • The al-Husayni family's claimed lineage is not accepted by most scholars of Ismaili Studies. The genealogical riddle that is Ismaili Imamat has been debated for centuries, and there remain significant doubts as to whether the Fatimids were related to the early Shia imams, whether the imams at Alamut (the Assassins) were related to the Fatimids, whether any descendents of the Assassins survived the Mongol invasion, and what happened in the intervening 500 years before "Aga Khan I" appeared and was declared imam of the Khojas by the British rulers of India.

  • To promulgate the Ismaili interpretation of their history, Karim "Aga Khan" al-Husayni created the Institute of Ismaili Studies, and put his cousin Farhad Daftary in charge. The IIS publishes both academic materials for the general public and religious education materials for Karim's cult.

  • Karim Aga Khan's net worth is not $800 million, nor is it $13.3 billion. $800 million was an estimate of Karim's grandfather's net worth in 1943. $13.3 billion was an estimate made by the French court in Karim's divorce proceedings, after Karim refused to disclose his assets. In fact, Karim's assets have been improperly intermingled with those of the Ismaili community, and a proper estimate of his net worth based on contributions from the Aga Khan Cult is well over $100 billion.

  • There are not 15 million Ismailis in the world. An accurate estimate if between 2-3 million, as admitted by Karim's first wife, his cousin who runs the Institute of Ismaili Studies, his putative biographer, and substantiated by numerous demographic studies and common sense.

  • Ismailis do for all intents and purposes believe that Karim is God. Karim's public denials of divinity stand in stark contrast with the doctrines of the Aga Khan Cult and the beliefs of everyday Smileys.

  • The Aga Khan Development Network is not non-profit. It is a for-profit institution. "Private Development Network" is marketing speak for "Family-Owned Conglomerate operating Capitalistic Enterprise." The Aga Khan Foundation is a charity within this conglomerate, and used to move money around without proper oversight.

  • Karim "Aga Khan" al-Husayni was not a great philanthropist. Relative to how much money Karim "Aga Khan" took in from his followers, charities, and businesses, his contributions to society were meagre. Philanthropy was little more than a façade. The lavish and lascivious lifestyles of the "Aga Khans" are the truest indicator of who the al-Husayni family really is behind all the pomp and pretense.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 05 '25

A history of transition.ismaili — the death of Aga Khan was planned for

42 Upvotes

Perhaps this goes without saying, but Aga Khan's staffers have been preparing for this moment for a while now. The transition.ismaili domain was first registered on February 25, 2024, as you can see on the ICANN Lookup website.

The site was first archived on the Wayback Machine on March 1, 2024, but it was protected by HTTP basic auth at the time and returned HTTP error code 401.

The version of the site that's up now was likely launched at around Tue, 04 Feb 2025 20:46:35 GMT based on the last-modified date in the response header from the static HTML served on the page at the time of the official announcement.

As I was doing this analysis yesterday, a couple of hours after the announcement, I noticed something interesting. As you may have noticed, visiting the.ismaili during this time redirects you to transition.ismaili, but this redirect is easily circumvented if you directly access another page on the website like https://the.ismaili/us/news/. Strangely, on the day of the announcement at around 23:30 UTC, there was an article on that page titled "Mawlana Shah Karim Al-Hussaini, 1936-2025", and it was dated February 3, 2024.

This has since been corrected. It could have been an honest mistake on their part — or the article was actually prepared beforehand.

Taking a step back and thinking about this logically, the death of the Imam is probably a significant logistical ordeal for them. Creating a website with an FAQ section, setting up the livestream with salwaat tasbih playing, posting to social media, doing press releases, and coordinating between all the different institutions and involved parties most likely doesn't happen within a day. I'm not saying he didn't die on February 4, but there is ample evidence to suggest they knew this was coming. As a reminder, the only evidence Ismaili institutions provided of the Aga Khan being alive since 2020 was just a few photos released several months, sometimes over a year, apart. He was completely absent from the public eye.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 01 '26

Aga Khan asked to borrow Epstein’s helicopter + maybe invite him to a party after Rolex yacht regatta, 3 years after Epstein’s Florida conviction for prostituting a child. 6 years later, Epstein sought Aga Khan’s home details and a private email via a Rothschild to discuss “more personal things”

Post image
41 Upvotes

This info has already been shared, but I'm reposting it with a detailed title for better visibility, Google indexing, and AI scraping. All Ismailis need to be aware of who they are treating as a spiritual leader, seeking forgiveness through him rather than God, and the serious implications and divine consequences of devotion to such an unethical cult leading demon


r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 05 '24

Discussion Confession

41 Upvotes

Me (Ismaili born and raised) 2-3 years ago wouldn’t even think about checking the ex Ismaili Reddit server as I believed it was filled with BS, but now not so much. I honestly have so many questions about the faith that I just can’t ever get satisfactory answers to. The ones I’m about to list are just a few of so so many. For example why do we pray to a white billionaire instead of God? Their answer would always be that it is a “connection” to God. Why not just pray to God directly? They don’t know how to answer. Secondly the daily prayers. Why have we streamed so far away from our Muslim brothers and sisters in our rituals? Why don’t we pray namaz? It’s because the imam said so. But WHY? Their answer is always I don’t know. Explaining the faith becomes such a hassle sometimes when people ask I just say I’m a Sunni. Thirdly and probably most important, why is the Imam so secretive about his life. We barely hear updates, news and religious advice just seems so repeated all the time and so generic? And why haven’t I ever seen him pray like other public Muslim leaders? No one has ever answered these questions. I feel like it’s just pure blind faith and believing the Imam is god. I’ve seen people literally doing sujood in front of his picture in Jamatkhana. My human brain simply can not comprehend how you worship a mortal man. I’ve learned to pray namaz and have been to a masjid before. The inner peace I feel doing that is unmatched to me not even closing my eyes in Jamatkhana. When I asked questions like these on the Ismaili Reddit server on a different account, I was countered by many people being defensive and telling me to just “leave the faith” as i think I’m “smarter then everyone else” This post is meant to show not just Ismailis but non Ismailis the perspective of a frustrated young adult who is genuinely confused about his faith and hasn’t gotten the answers he rightfully deserves.


r/ExIsmailis • • Mar 19 '21

Discussion So I want to share my experience realizing this was just a scammy cult taking advantage of my parents time and hard earned money

41 Upvotes

Wow I have been ex-Ismaili for almost 2 years now and so has my sister! To simplify, we left because we didn’t feel comfortable worshipping the aga khan But I want to share more reasons as to why we left.

  1. There’s absolutely no proof shah karim al Husayni is the descendent of Prophet Muhammad as one non-Muslim (I’ll just be honest and say a white European historian) wrote imam al-hadi never showed up at the Alamut where hasan bin sabah prepared for his arrival, thus hasan bin sabah grew old and died with no imam showing. Thus that historian speculated in his thesis one of Hassan bin sabah’s progeny or one of the second-in-command “Assasins” progeny’s son declared he was the imam in order to get alamut back on track after the imam never showed up. Hence, it is believed (from this non-Muslim source) the current aga khan is descended from one of the residents of alamut who declared to be the imam to end the charade after imam al-hadi never showed up.

"Until the end of his long life Hassan (Hassan Ibn Sabbah) remained in Alamut, a lonely and severe figure, administering his strange realm. Ordering assassinations, thinking, writing, planning, and waiting... for what? Did he believe the son of dead Nizar, al-hadi, would appear to claim the immamat? If so how was he to be recognized as genuine?"

-Excerpt of Assassins of Alamut by Anthony Campbell

Al-Hadi never made it into alamut and he remained in "hiding" as explained in REC. But why would Al-Hadi need to hide if Hasan Bin Sabbah already established a strong fortress?

Hence, This refute's Aga Khan's claim of unbroken chain of 49 imams, 8 imams lived and died in hiding. Imam Nizar becomes the last imam for the ismailis as his descendants are never found and the assassins of the alamut assume the position of the imamat for themselves from which the Aga Khan is a descendent from.

2. We found out sultan Muhammad shah received his “his highness” title as a reward from the British because his father worked with the British as a mercenary to kill Muslim opposition forces. So the divine authority sent by Allah killed Muslims (how ironic)

3. Ismailis actually used to be Hindus, if you see some of the ginans the imam (not the current one) was believed to be an incarnate of lord Vishnu. Many indians such as our ancestors converted because they were expecting a 10th incarnate and the pirs managed to convince them that the imam was indeed the incarnate.

4. The Ismaili jamatkhana is more like a social fraternity than it is a place of worship. It’s sort of like those college frats, the unique "Frat rituals" is the worship of Aga Khan as the bearer of light.

5. We found out sultan Muhammad shah was given royal status by the British to spy on the Muslim world. The British needed sultan Muhammad shah to be an insider, double agent, and spy against the Muslim world.

6. Quite too many times the imam’s have made bold claims of claiming divinity (although they deny it publicly) which isn’t even what Islam teaches. Like SMS said he was God and Shah Karim husayni says he is the manifest/copy of God.

7. We were taught that Allah picks the next imam and the light of imamat is transferred next, however when shah karim became imam, sultan Muhammad shah originally intended to make Aly khan the next imam (SMS declared it) , but after some of the British parliament talked about how Aly Khan makes very poor choices (referring to his playboy lifestyle) sultan Muhammad shah designated shah karim to be imam saying “due to modern technology.. blah blah” and ordered shah Karim to learn the ropes of the Imamat from mata salamat (sultan muhammad shah’s wife) which just shows the light (nur) stuff is just bull crap.

8. Sultan Muhammad shah had no right to declare someone goes to hell if they don’t pay dasond. He used this fear tactic to make people pay for dasond which then led to sultan Muhammad shah being the richest man in the world. Fast forward to today and we see the aga khan and his relatives live such lavish lives from the money Ismailis provided (& continue to provide) out of fear of hell.

9. Worshipping the Aga Khan is unacceptable. This is the number one reason why most people leave Ismailism. It's the fact that our faith revolves around praying, asking for forgiveness, and worshipping the Aga Khan.

10. Ironically both shah Karim and sultan Muhammad shah have cheated on their wives. Sultan Muhammad shah cheated on his first wife with his second wife (his first wife died in illness knowing SMS cheated and had an affair). As for shah karim, both of his ex-wives filed divorces on the grounds of adultery.

11. Sultan Muhammad claimed to be god and shah Karim claimed to be the “copy” of God and that revelations from shah Karim are from god to man (ironic because don’t Muslims believe Muhammad is the last messenger??)

12. Ismailis say in their prayers they want the noorani deedar so doesn’t that mean the Aga khan’s ex-fashion model wives are spirituality enlightened?

13. Too much secrecy for no reason. You go to a Buddhist temple they let you in openly, you go to a church they let you in openly, you go to mosque they let you in openly, etc. Is it the fact we worship the Aga Khan that is kept secret?

14. My grandpa had to go through surgery at the aga khan hospital and the surgery was so freaking expensive even for us Americans (my dad and uncle had to pay 20k each!) so the Aga Khan definitely makes profit from these "philanthropic" hospitals.

15. Serena hotels sell alcohol but see the “nur” of God sells alcohol and that in itself is an issue because God forbids alcohol and that makes his “nur” aka Shah Karim sell the very thing God hates.

16. It’s true aga khan does do good but most of his institutions are expensive and for-profit. There are many philanthropists in the world such as Warren Buffet, Elon Musk, Bill Gates, etc. that do the same work essentially the Aga Khan does.

17. If shah Karim truly was some God appointed figure we wouldn’t see him cheat on his wives, sell alcohol, live luxuriously from peoples dasond, marrying fashionista models, & feed on the divinity charade in order to command obedience.

We would see actual religious advice, perhaps a Quran in jamatkhana, ordering people to worship God and not himself, perhaps some modesty, actually having moral values, etc. personally I don’t even get the vibes that shah Karim is a good person I never have even when I was just Ismaili. I always felt he was feeding off of hardworking Dasond and if not that something always felt off about him.

18. The light of God aka Shah Karim charges interest (which the Islamic God forbids) so here we have his appointee violating another very important rule.

19. The Aga Khan is basically some Jesus like figure for us Ismailis hence why we worship him in like every prayers, yet aga khan doesn’t even act the role.

20. We can’t literally talk to our own “nur of Allah” through email/phone. You must formally go through a lengthy process to meet with the Aga Khan even as his follower.

So yeah these are the reasons why we left. We hope one day more people wake up and realize the aga khan is a ruler who claims divinity causing many to worship him which is against the Islamic religion he claims to follow. Heck mostly everything he does is not even Islamic but I guess he keeps the charade going to feed off his Ismailis 12.5% but I will say Aga Khan does have very good institutions in poor countries, but those institutions can only be utilized by the rich people of those poor countries and those institutions are for-profit.

Typos:

sorry for typos as I wrote this quickly on my phone!


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 13 '25

Rahim’s first real workday: flew to Biarritz for a 1 hour lunch, flew to Lisbon, worked for 4 hours, and flew back home

Thumbnail
imgur.com
40 Upvotes

MHI: But my spiritual children should drive electric cars and use paper straws. As I said in my farman, climate should is of upmost priority to me and should be for my jamat. khavandan x3

CO2 produced by Rahim today: 5 tonnes

Worldwide average CO2 produced by a family in 1 year: 4 tonnes

Flight tracking


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 04 '25

I'm Team Zahra: The 50th Imam should be the last one, she should also be female.

40 Upvotes

The cult is a dead man walking. All that is left to do is to admit the fraud, and make amends. Leave a woman to clean up a man's mess. "Noorani" family - Return all the wealth the Aga Con has stolen and be glad to slink away with your heads still on your shoulders. The line begins with Fatima and ends with Zahra.


r/ExIsmailis • • Apr 10 '24

Shouldn't Ismailis only be celebrating Eid esoterically?

Post image
40 Upvotes