r/excatholic • • Jul 05 '21

Personal You need to stop supporting arson and vandalism

40 Upvotes

This is probably gonna rattle some walls and shake some windows for some people. But this subreddit needs to stop openly, vocally, and enthusiastically supporting the burning and vandalism of churches in Canada.

I'm not going to go on a long rant here but in the West we are nations of laws. There are provisions within those laws to appropriately protest without doing harm to others.

Arson is a crime and in many places, a violent crime - a felony. Burning churches puts innocent people at risk - parishioners, religious workers, church employees, and yes, even people threatened by fire due to dry conditions this summer.

Arson and vandalism only does one thing: it makes the church out to be a victim and it makes its critics look like mouthbreathers who advocate violence.

I realize that many on this subreddit have been hurt. They've been pained by years of religious indoctrination not to mention several have been abused sexually. Many have even endured living hells because of sexual orientations not aligning with Catholic practice.

My heart goes out to you all. Like many former Catholics, I too am on the brink of despair. The best thing that we can do is look at each other, maybe joke a little, and regard each other with sympathy.

Find someone to talk to. If you have the means, get therapy. There are healthier avenues.

But reveling in arson and vandalism isn't the answer. It isn't just innocent schadenfreude. It's supporting and encouraging felonious activities.


r/excatholic • • Feb 28 '23

Personal Recently joined r/excatholic; some observations.

7 Upvotes

Hi, I’m the ex-seminarian who joined this subreddit about a week ago. My short stay here has been an eye-opener!

I think I’ve determined that I’m here because of a loss of faith; I’m no longer sure that I believe in God. Or at least, God as presented by the Catholic Faith.

I’m not here because I’m angry at the hierarchy, the rules, the pig-headed clergy, exclusionary social circles, anti-minority or anti-LGBTQ sentiment – or anything like that. Of course, I’m angry about the clerical abuse scandal – but I’m also angry about the Little League coaches who did the same (and I didn’t reject baseball because of those problems; I can separate bad actors from the overarching institutions).

I thought I was going to be happy to be here.

The problem is that I see far too many posts and comments, here, expressing anger at rules and clerical small-mindedness and repression inside the Church. I’ve read subredditors’ descriptions of odd beliefs that are better attributed to, say, a Southern Baptist belief system. Or a fundamentalist Christian system. I’ve seen memes and comments that completely misrepresent Catholic doctrine – and then say those doctrines are why they left.

I’m seriously wondering how many people here who claim to have been Catholic – I’m wondering how many of us aren’t making a distinction between Catholicism and a ‘Generic Christian’ church. I wonder how many people don’t know what separates Catholics from Mainstream Christianity. I’ve encountered it in spots wherever I’ve traveled – there are always ‘Catholics’ who don’t understand that Transubstantiation isn't ‘symbolic’. I've encountered a belief that Priests must be virgins (um, no). A belief hat the Pope is infallible in all things, having never heard the phrase ex cathedra. I’ve met members of apostate Mel Gibson-esque sects. I’ve even encountered ‘Catholics’ who believe in The Rapture.

The problem is when I encounter these people here on this r/excatholic subreddit; I wonder if it’s actually the Catholic church they’re angry at, or if it’s an anger better directed towards Mainstream Protestantism, or perhaps organized religion in general.

I’m not defending the Catholic Church; I’ve left it. I no longer have faith in God. At least not the one I was taught about.

But I don’t hold any animosity toward the church; it has its faults – some terrible – to be sure. But it also does a lot of good; it provides spiritual guidance to the floundering, it offers comfort to the suffering, it has fantastic higher educational institutions. Its network of charities, especially in underdeveloped nations, is outstanding.

But I have removed myself from all that.

I’ve never had a problem with the Catholic church, per se. I’ve had problems with individuals – including clergy. I’ve had problems with bureaucracy. I’ve had problems with many aspects of parish and seminary life. But I’ve not had a problem with the overarching Mystical Body of Christ.

I’ve encountered a lot of anger in this subreddit, especially over ‘doctrine’ – and the justification for it rarely jibes with what actual doctrine holds. I’m troubled by this. I suspect some people here have had one or two bad experiences in a parish, and never looked to another parish. Some, I think, were taught by parents or CCD teachers who didn’t know, themselves, what actual doctrine teaches. I think some have never understood what sets Catholicism apart from other Christian denominations.

I’m dismayed.

I’m here looking for support and encouragement now that I’ve made the decision to leave. I’m finding a short supply of those qualities. It’s hard to find encouragement from people who rail only against scandals. Or rail against certain aspects of the Catholic church – when what they describe has everything to do with a Fundamentalist Protestant, rather than Catholic, theology

Anyways. I’ll stick around a bit longer. I might stay; I might leave.

Thanks for letting me vent.


r/excatholic • • Feb 15 '24

If you're no longer Catholic, what kind of moral framework do you teach your kids for them to be good people?

0 Upvotes

Wondering how you would teach your children. Do you use mythology, philosophy, ethics, the law, cinema as a framework?


r/excatholic • • Jul 24 '19

Stupid Bullshit How do you leave the Church when the miracles seem credible?

1 Upvotes

Eucharistic miracles: Scientific studies saying the Host has turned into actual flesh and blood with blood type and everything and it’s still intact after thousands of years. Lanciano, etc.

Miracle of the Sun: 100,000 saw it at Fatima, can’t be a mass hallucination when it was also seen hundreds of miles away. There’s video footage from Medjugorje, Conyers, etc.

Our Lady of Zeitoun appearance

(Original) Guadalupe image supposedly has no brushstrokes

Shroud of Turin: They say the image was formed by ultraviolet rays or something?

The Resurrection

Other Biblical miracles: Virgin birth, the magi, multiplication of the fishes and loaves, turning water into wine, etc.

Holy House of Loreto transported by angels?

Incorrupt saints: Though, this one is pretty easy to disprove since they did put a wax mask on St. Bernadette, who was the most convincing.


r/excatholic • • Dec 15 '12

You may be former catholics but: Here is a link to the Catholic Church down the street from the shootings. They can put you in touch with charities or ways you can help.

Thumbnail
strosechurch.com
3 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Mar 14 '21

Stupid Bullshit Nice, got banned from r/Catholicism for judging their views

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Jul 08 '18

I saw this and was worried for the kids. Father Joe sounds terrifying.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • May 10 '22

Personal Did any of you stay pro-life after leaving?

11 Upvotes

Okay, so honestly I can't 100%choose which side I'm on, but mostly I feel like I'm leaning towards being pro-life. When I left Christianity, and religion in itself, this was one of the things that I didn't stop believing. Later I switched sides but now I'm kind of in the middle doubting myself a lot. I won't go into detail about why I'm this way unless I'm asked to because I didn't make this post to persuade/ argue with anyone. I'm just curious if anyone has a similar experience because I feel very alone in this.


r/excatholic • • Apr 21 '25

Ding dong the witch is dead

Thumbnail
apnews.com
0 Upvotes

Rest in nothingness like the rest of us will


r/excatholic • • Jul 31 '20

Fun Women like Jesus

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Apr 12 '20

I saw extensive coverage of the Pope this morning. It’s akin to Harvey Weinstein holding a press conference and no one asking about the lives he ruined.

0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Aug 14 '24

Personal My experience as a Catholic and considering Pentecostalism

0 Upvotes

I (F18) grew up in a Catholic family in a Catholic dominant country. As I turned 18 two months ago, I finally can express my honest feelings of me being a Catholic.

I am considering Pentecostalism after my boyfriend (M19) told me about it (he is one). I've attended a Pentecostal church with him several times and he and his family one time invited me over to their house to explain about their religion. After that episode, I believed that I would find the truth in Pentecostalism and considered converting into one. If it wasn't for them coming into my life, I might have considered atheism. (I struggled with my catholic faith ever since before I met my current bf)

My main concern about Catholicism is confession. I didn't realize what was wrong with it until my late teen years (16-18). I didn't feel comfortable going to confess my sins to a priest (most sins were lustful so I understand why it bothers me so much) as I'm afraid he could take advantage of me, plus it's no one's business except God's. I also believe that priests are sinners just as every other human being so they aren't any better and I believe it's an insult that they are "representing" God. He sent his son Jesus and he died on the cross for us for a reason.

Apart from confession, an issue I have with Catholicism is believing that contraception is a sin. In this modern day, where children are a luxury (where I live), it's expensive to have like 10 children per family. What about women with irregular periods (I have PCOS)? I don't want surprise pregnancies. And for abortion, I am against it in general but what if the mother's life is at risk? If the mother dies, so will the fetus. Just save the mother and she can try her luck getting pregnant again.

I also heard that the Catholic Church also removed one of the original 10 commandments and split the last commandment into two to still make 10 commandments (correct me if I'm wrong btw).

Also, what are the point in sacraments? I believe that they are meaningless if you don't have a good personal relationship with God. A personal relationship with God is what I believe could grant us salvation. As a soon ex catholic, I used to receive communion anyway without confession because I hate confession. It's an example of why I think they're meaningless in the first place.

I had more points to mention why I don't wanna remain catholic but this post is already long as it is so I'll stop here. Feel free to comment or share your experiences. I would like to know if you can relate to me somehow. Good night/day!


r/excatholic • • 5d ago

Trent Horn is a begging. Talks about health insurance in video.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

This is pathetic.

There is another thread about this, but I did this so people can specifically talk about the political-economy of this.

His wife has cancer and needs expensive cancer drugs.

Ben Shapiro's new movie, Confession, talks about how the communists don't value anything but bread and ignore the soul. (I don't watch it, but a sympathetic reviewer said that.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jtr6K-gD6zU

I pray for as much suffering to be inflicted on Trent Horn that the scales can fall from his eyes so he can advocate for progressive policies.

And we know that in all things God works for the good of those who love him, who have been called according to his purpose. - Romans 8:28

P.S. Was playing that sympathetic review of Confession before pressing "enter."

Maybe MAGA is like that pro-Soviet person in prison. They have to destroy themselves for the betterment of America.

And then there's the fourth prisoner who still believes in the state even while he's sitting in its prison. He says that there's only one truth and he holds up his fist power. But he was in Ukraine, too. But unlike the Jewish prisoner, he doesn't cry about [the repression of the Kulaks]. Says that the Kulaks had to be destroyed and their children with them. The iron wheels of history grind over the pebbles. When Alexi asks him what he believes in, he gives a one-word answer. [8:20]

Clip plays with the prisoners' scene:

"Bread. Bread."


r/excatholic • • Jun 18 '26

you are anti-cathodic don;t make you a communist

0 Upvotes

i feel pretty frustrated that so many people misunderstand me that i am an communist just because i anti catholic

i am anti communist and anti catholic too (my country is a communist country)


r/excatholic • • Jan 17 '19

Politics I don't know if anyone's thought of this before: A plea

0 Upvotes

So all you excatholics out there are all baptized, all confirmed and been to church, but when you left you couldn't because they banned voluntary excommunication and resignations from the church.

What can an organization do when they've outlawed firing people in the organization who create dissent? Nothing, right.

This isn't to bring you back into the fold of Catholicism by practicing their beliefs again, but this is a plea that you infiltrate Catholicism and defy the Vatican in any ways you can.

You can be a pro-choice catholic, you can be a transgender catholic, you can be an atheist catholic and you for sure can ordain women and LGBT as priests. All you have to do is collaborate with and create organizations that intentionally subvert the power of the Vatican.


r/excatholic • • Jun 17 '13

P.Z. Myers goes to a Catholic service

Thumbnail
freethoughtblogs.com
0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Aug 26 '21

Sexuality Even though I am not Roman Catholic anymore, this book is wonderful!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Aug 29 '19

Personal As a Converting Catholic, I Must ask you all Why did you leave the Church?

8 Upvotes

I am generally curious as to why you left the church. In converting (meaning getting baptized & chrismated) into the religion in a few months, and I personally believe the church's truth claims about it being the 1st church of our Lord to be true and grounded in Historical and Theological evidence. I figure in my process of conversion that I should see the religion from an apostates p.o.v.. This is the question that I'd like to ask every subscriber of this subreddit:

  1. Is this subreddit mostly made up of ex-catholic atheists or ex-catholic "Christians"? If atheist/other religion, what made you leave Christianity in general? If " Christian" what problems do you have with Catholic theology that made you leave the church?


r/excatholic • • Aug 12 '22

Sexuality I think Joan of Arc might be trans. Thoughts?

4 Upvotes

(Note that I aam not part of this community, just posting here.)

I've been reading a lot of history recently, and I've been thinking about what people in the deep past might have actually lived like, it's kind of hard to think about when the person in question is living in a very different time and situatuion, but we're all human, and the same thoughts and feelings exist in every era.

I'm an agender induvial, and I was born in a very accepting environment (I was born in the early 00s, and I've lived in Manhattan my entire life), but I've seen the experinces of people born in less good times and places, and for trans and enby people born in those enviorments it can be hard for even them to know themselves. I know there was at least was Transfem Roman Emperor, though she didn't seem like a very good person, though there have probably been many more people like that in history.

Looking at what we know about Joan of Arc it seems that they were almost certainly trans or enby. They faked visions from a religion that was taken very seriously at the time, just to justify masculine clothing, something basically unheard of for an afab person to wear in that era. They did things that were wildly outside of female gender roles at the time, even when it put them in danger. Just dressing that way should be enough for the era to make me think there's a good chance they didn't experince the feamle gender.

Though we can never know for sure, they probably felt deep dysphoria from being gendered as female. Their story seems to be one of a transmasc person who lied so that they could live as a man, and was eventually killed for expressing their gender. I certainly think they could be seen as a transmasc symbol one day, especially since it doesn't seem like the catholic church is long for this world (no offense, my gf is excatholic, and that faith doesn't really seem like it can survive in the modern world).

I'd like your thoughts on this. I'm trying to hear a lot of veiwpoints so I'm posting this is many places.


r/excatholic • • Dec 04 '24

Personal Three words…

4 Upvotes

I have only had three words for myself, FUCK the lord.


r/excatholic • • Sep 25 '18

I'm a Catholic, AMA.

5 Upvotes

I just came to say hello, I hope you guys don't mind.

In the light of recent scandals coming to light, it was just sort of disheartening to see how being a Catholic/ex - Catholic/Christian of other denomination/Atheist etc. was sometimes an obstacle to honestly talk about something so horrible, let alone lighter issues - these ones sometimes turn into plain throwing mud at someone.

I'm just hoping for my post to be a positive step towards a normal, peaceful discussion; not something done out of pride - Catholics and ex-Catholics have the same (or very similar) background, problematic topics, so I believe we should still talk about stuff, no matter how difficult it is.

A bit of my background: I'm a 26yo woman, born and living in Poland, I was raised Roman Catholic. I will try to answer as many questions as time and my level of English will let me.


r/excatholic • • Aug 09 '20

Cuddling

Thumbnail self.catholicdating
0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Apr 01 '26

I’m having Rabbit for Easter …

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/excatholic • • Feb 09 '18

Weekly Roundup: Catholic Abominations

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes