Hi, I’m the ex-seminarian who joined this subreddit about a week ago. My short stay here has been an eye-opener!
I think I’ve determined that I’m here because of a loss of faith; I’m no longer sure that I believe in God. Or at least, God as presented by the Catholic Faith.
I’m not here because I’m angry at the hierarchy, the rules, the pig-headed clergy, exclusionary social circles, anti-minority or anti-LGBTQ sentiment – or anything like that. Of course, I’m angry about the clerical abuse scandal – but I’m also angry about the Little League coaches who did the same (and I didn’t reject baseball because of those problems; I can separate bad actors from the overarching institutions).
I thought I was going to be happy to be here.
The problem is that I see far too many posts and comments, here, expressing anger at rules and clerical small-mindedness and repression inside the Church. I’ve read subredditors’ descriptions of odd beliefs that are better attributed to, say, a Southern Baptist belief system. Or a fundamentalist Christian system. I’ve seen memes and comments that completely misrepresent Catholic doctrine – and then say those doctrines are why they left.
I’m seriously wondering how many people here who claim to have been Catholic – I’m wondering how many of us aren’t making a distinction between Catholicism and a ‘Generic Christian’ church. I wonder how many people don’t know what separates Catholics from Mainstream Christianity. I’ve encountered it in spots wherever I’ve traveled – there are always ‘Catholics’ who don’t understand that Transubstantiation isn't ‘symbolic’. I've encountered a belief that Priests must be virgins (um, no). A belief hat the Pope is infallible in all things, having never heard the phrase ex cathedra. I’ve met members of apostate Mel Gibson-esque sects. I’ve even encountered ‘Catholics’ who believe in The Rapture.
The problem is when I encounter these people here on this r/excatholic subreddit; I wonder if it’s actually the Catholic church they’re angry at, or if it’s an anger better directed towards Mainstream Protestantism, or perhaps organized religion in general.
I’m not defending the Catholic Church; I’ve left it. I no longer have faith in God. At least not the one I was taught about.
But I don’t hold any animosity toward the church; it has its faults – some terrible – to be sure. But it also does a lot of good; it provides spiritual guidance to the floundering, it offers comfort to the suffering, it has fantastic higher educational institutions. Its network of charities, especially in underdeveloped nations, is outstanding.
But I have removed myself from all that.
I’ve never had a problem with the Catholic church, per se. I’ve had problems with individuals – including clergy. I’ve had problems with bureaucracy. I’ve had problems with many aspects of parish and seminary life. But I’ve not had a problem with the overarching Mystical Body of Christ.
I’ve encountered a lot of anger in this subreddit, especially over ‘doctrine’ – and the justification for it rarely jibes with what actual doctrine holds. I’m troubled by this. I suspect some people here have had one or two bad experiences in a parish, and never looked to another parish. Some, I think, were taught by parents or CCD teachers who didn’t know, themselves, what actual doctrine teaches. I think some have never understood what sets Catholicism apart from other Christian denominations.
I’m dismayed.
I’m here looking for support and encouragement now that I’ve made the decision to leave. I’m finding a short supply of those qualities. It’s hard to find encouragement from people who rail only against scandals. Or rail against certain aspects of the Catholic church – when what they describe has everything to do with a Fundamentalist Protestant, rather than Catholic, theology
Anyways. I’ll stick around a bit longer. I might stay; I might leave.
Thanks for letting me vent.