I was recently reminded that the bullies on this sub don't speak for everyone and that I should not let them shape my behaviour. So, I want to raise the question of what kind of sub this will be. The sidebar doesn't help much.
I participate here as someone who has been repeatedly traumatized by Adventists and various parts of the organization at large. I see some really bad things in Adventism and I'm not happy about them. I see this as one place to talk about those things and connect with (and support) others who may be wrestling with similar trauma.
I believe that one of the most abusive, toxic, cultish elements of Adventism (and this seems to be repeated by almost everyone who posts here) is the way it often distorts the world into very simple black-and-white terms, where everyone inside the church is good and everyone outside is bad. Thus, a lot of toxic behaviour hinges on policing those boundaries by whatever means necessary. Certainly, most Adventists are "polite" about it, but it remains a pretty damaging distortion nonetheless. For myself, growing beyond that includes recognizing the diversity and complexity in the world--that there are good Catholics and bad Catholics, good atheists and bad atheists, and good Adventists and bad Adventists. I want nothing to do with that kind of thinking which distorts the world and represents all outsiders as depraved, untrustworthy liars and abusers. Most importantly, that is a standard way of ignoring the abusive and toxic behaviour within a particular community.
Unfortunately, it seems there is a certain portion of this sub which wants nothing more than to abusively police the boundaries of the community and pretend that all Adventists are depraved, untrustworthy liars and abusers. Of course, (and I'm sure I will be attacked for saying this) it conveniently allows them to justify their own abusive behaviour towards people they disagree with. I suppose that if the community as a whole decides that it desires to be just that kind of community and reproduce just that kind of toxic behaviour which has hurt so many people in Adventism, that's an option. I won't stick around for it. However, I don't think a handful of bullies should be allowed to decide this for the rest of the sub.
I am here because I believe that kind of thinking and acting is profoundly hurtful and destructive and I want to connect with and support people who are struggling with the fallout from that kind of behaviour in the Adventist church. It's good to have people to talk to about those things. I want to participate in communities which have higher goals than just mocking and attacking those they mark as "others" or "outsiders" or "the world" or "the lost" or whatever. I hope this can be a healthier kind of community, but as I have been reminded, that isn't my choice to make. However, it is also not the choice of a small handful of bullies.
(Just to head off a potential sidetrack, I will be the first to admit I have occasionally misspoken and hurt people here. I am sorry for that. I have done my best to apologize and make amends to the specific people involved. I appreciate the patience and understanding of those I have hurt. But I have also been hurt by people here who operate from their own self-righteousness and double down rather than apologizing. In any community, people get hurt. That's just part of living together. But we have a choice about whether we will continue (or continue to allow) that behaviour, or whether we try to change.)
What say you?
Edit: I don't think it will hurt anything at this point to offer a detailed account of events, and I hope that it might shed some light on what has transpired here.
This current drama began about a week ago when someone made a post talking about their anger at being raised Adventist, how isolated and lonely they felt and how angry they were at themselves for the choices they had previously made. I responded with a brief post making two points:
That they be kind to their younger self, who was doing the best they could in a bad situation. (This is well-supported by trauma research and best practices).
That they would find other people with similar experiences outside of Adventism. (This is well supported by my personal experience and reading on toxic communities and cults). It is worth adding that this comment reflected a recent discussion with a good friend about our shared childhood traumas. She talked about her father's absolute resistance to anything Christian at all. I was surprised at such a familiar expression of toxic in-group/out-group behaviour. It was familiar to me from growing up Adventist. I found it reassuring to find someone else who understood some of my own childhood trauma. Thus I offered that observation with the intent of encouraging someone who expressed feeling isolated and lonely because of their childhood trauma.
Unfortunately, I didn't stop to think how this might sound to someone sensitive to gaslighting and emotional abuse. Point 2 was interpreted as a defense of Adventism by suggesting people suck everywhere. I understand how that could be hurtful. However, that was not my intent and I promptly apologized, both publicly and privately, as well as adding clarification to address the misinterpretation.
If it had been allowed to end there, I think things would have been fine. Unfortunately, by this point a collection of people had gathered to attack me, assuming that my intentions were purely hurtful and manipulative--regardless of my apology and clarification. As a result, I deleted the initial post to avoid hurting anyone else. I believe my second post was more clear than the original.
This group has continued to escalate the aggression since. One person was banned from Reddit for a PM they sent that wasn't too different from some of what has been posted publicly in this thread. (That seems a pretty fair measure of its acceptability). That same group has apparently organized in another thread and continued to downvote every post I have made in this community since, regardless of content. I have been subject to a lengthy and escalating campaign of aggression based on disagreements which happened many months ago as well as the worst possible reading of that single post (which I had apologized for). An increasing variety of false claims about my intent and things I have said have been brought forth without any evidence. My responses and denials have been met with increasing aggression.
I posted a lengthy, and admittedly angry post addressing this, which lead to a renewed wave of bullying and aggression. I deleted that and was ready to leave the sub when I was reminded that I should not simply let the bullies have their way.
Thus, this post. I do not believe I have been treated fairly. I can understand why people might be angry at things I have said. I can understand why people might have questions about who I am. But I have sought to explain myself. I have apologized and sought to make amends. Yet the brigade continues. This is hurtful and it is wrong--particularly in a sub which regularly fields complaints about how Adventists have attacked and alienated them for real and imagined slights and disagreements. My post is being read in the worst possible light (without regard for my apology and clarification) and presented as exemplary of my supposed intent to gaslight, abuse and otherwise harm others on this sub.
Thus, the initial miscommunication has snowballed to include seemingly every disagreement I have ever had with anyone on this sub--with the assertion that my disagreement with them is the same as their outright abuse of me. I understand fear and pain. I understand trauma and being sensitive to certain behaviour. But I do not believe that justifies the ongoing harassment and abuse this has turned into because I do not agree about every point of faith in this sub. Never mind the fact that nobody has been able to produce such a list of qualifications to post here, I have continually been told I have no right to post here because I am suspected of being an "Adventist" spy. (This reminds me of a certain group of people who continually accuse others of being "Jesuit" spies.)
I can admit I have entered into unnecessary debates with people, but I have not done that in months because I see it is not helpful. I do not agree with many statements here, but I have learned and adapted. However, I have consistently tried to provide support to people who express their pain and need for support in dealing with trauma from Adventism and their families. I happen to know a lot about that from both experience and years of study. But I am still being attacked based on what started as an unfortunate miscommunication.
What began as a simple miscommunication, which I did my best to resolve (what else could I have done?) has turned into a concerted campaign of bullying and harassment based upon the false and ungrounded claim of some that I am an Adventist employee sent here to manipulate, gaslight, deceive and convert people back. (Spoiler alert: I'm not. My old dreams of working for the church were brutally demolished some years ago, and I haven't been to church since. The years since have been painful but also led to huge growth.)
Two questions come from this, one regarding the initial incident and one regarding the subsequent attacks on my right to speak:
First, recognizing that people make mistakes and sometimes cause harm, is it then justifiable to harass and attack them even after they have apologized and done their best to make amends?
Second, given that we have diverse relationships to Adventism, what qualifies a person to speak here?