what it says on the tin. I really love this community and I will have to accept whatever the mods decide here because this is a very vital place for me. at the same time, I do want to be able to speak openly and critically about psychiatry. I had two comments immediately removed for talking shit about psychiatry with no explanation. EDIT: maybe the post was removed? I'm confused honestly. SECOND EDIT: I did not make the other post. I just commented on it. I am posting this in fear of being banned just for broaching the subject. why can't people speak against this?
psychiatry is a colonial tool of oppression. depression is not a chemical illness (source). this doesn't mean people don't experience suffering, this doesn't mean people don't find benefit in formulated chemical compounds. this means that it's important to build alternate structures and remain highly critical of the psychiatric industrial complex.
I will accept what the mods decide on this because I have to. I have no other community this large and important. I really enjoy the connections I make here as an autistic person on other subjects, and I am not willing to give that up. I will find other places to discuss this if I have to, but I wish I could also discuss it here.
edit
I haven't read the comments cause I came back to my phone and saw "36 notifications" and went ... oh hell no.
but here are more of my thoughts on psychiatry for context:
if you spend time in research circles, you'll hear people talk about how we cannot research outside the psychiatric paradigm because if we do, and we find something that might "delegitimize" or deconstruct a concept within it, this may impact people's access to support within the psychiatric industry.
for example, formally determining there's no credence to the serotonin theory of depression could prevent people from accessing SSRIs. despite not being a reliable treatment for depression, some people find benefit from SSRIs. and it can be VERY harmful to suddenly take someone off them, so it's important to protect folks from this.
at the same time, we have to recognize that there is no science in this. it's pure bureaucracy. often, if we're not researching alternative possibilities, it's because they can't get funding, because it will threaten access to care, and/or there is fear that it may destabilize the industry in power. (also re threatening access to care: drug companies would absolutely pivot and seek to re-legitimize their products in any way possible, but I digress.)
if you do want to critique the system, you must first legitimize yourself within it. getting a degree will most often mean accepting dominant ideas and lenses, and struggling to access funding, support and resources if you engage in research that contradicts someone with the power to suppress you. even if you legitimize yourself with a degree, if you speak against the interests of the system, you can be de-legitimized. people can have credentials, employment, and connections rescinded, all to preserve the connections that come with aligning with the psychiatric industry's interests.
this isn't some big conspiracy with one group of people pulling the reigns and telling everyone to do this. this is an adaptive, fear-based response that's occurring throughout the psychiatric system. those who benefit from the system, and especially those who are empowered by it, fear its dissolution and seek to protect it. those who see its harms seek to speak to those harms and create alternatives. conflict regularly arises between such groups, such as between psychiatrists and mad-pride advocates, or psychiatric survivors and folks under psychiatric "care".
bureaucracy aside, psychiatry cannot be extricated from its colonialist context. western psychiatry (which is the only psychiatry I can speak to) operates on control and subjugation. it was built from a system that stole, murdered, and brainwashed indigenous children, experimented on black people, women and indigenous people to the point of their deaths, and destroyed, demonized and pathologized all culture that could not be assimilated into a puritanical Christian rule. the concept of "disorder" cannot be extricated from the attempt to enforce a particular, colonialist "order".
remember who has the resources and the funding. as my old social work prof would say: follow the power and the money. psychiatry does not support people trying to explore decolonized, indigenous perspectives on being human, on the world, on connection and belonging and existence. it also does not support pre-existing indigenous practices and ways of life.
much of what western psychiatry describes as "pathology" is individualized, robbed of its context, and held uncritically against an ever-evolving colonialist norm. the people who reinforce the dominant narrative will get the most funding, support, and connections, so these are the perspectives (and propaganda) you're used to hearing.
if you do want to question it, it will mean listening to people who are not part of authority structures: mad pride advocates, psychiatry survivors, indigenous peoples who are still connected to their culture, and former "clinicians" who have left the psychiatric or mental health industrial complexes. you might even begin with folks who are still in these complexes and questioning them, if that feels more accessible.
I think this often feels like conspiracy to people because you have to leave one lens to explore another, which can feel unnerving, even terrifying. "conspiracy" is also a word that's often used to delegitimize something that makes a person uncomfortable or calls too many things into question to feel traversable. there's a lot of nuance to discuss here that I'd probably need to write a whole essay on to properly discuss, but I'll say the following.
many genuine conspiracy theorists, that is to say people who are basing their beliefs purely on disembodied, unfounded ideas, are touching on SOMETHING that's real. for example, in the US and Canada, extreme right wing libertarians are feeling the harm of government, and its attempt to control them. their ideas about what aspects of government are especially controlling and why and how they are being controlled may be unfounded, but they are not wrong that their government does not have their best interests at heart. it has businesses' best interests at heart.
challenging norms will feel destabilizing, but I still think it's vital to do so. taking a realistic, decolonized look at psychiatry doesn't have to mean never consuming chemical compounds that might help you or keep you alive. it is possible to access some aspects of psychiatry while rejecting its assumptions; accepting what "treatment" psychiatry has to offer doesn't have to mean accepting its beliefs about you and other human beings. and importantly, if the drugs "work" by helping you, that doesn't mean you were broken without them.
we can take the food, and still bite the damn hand that feeds.