I'm sure there's a billion and five complaining posts in this subreddit, but I gotta type this out somewhere. Wall of text incoming.
Big spoilers ahead
I just watched the rebuild series for the first time almost completely blind (was only spoiled of Kaworu's death), and honestly I was really loving it for what it was, seriously.
It felt like a cool new "take" on Evangelion, and I was more open since it was seemingly non-canon. I was even interested in Mari's character and was curious if there would be a reason why Asuka was named Shikinami now. The rebuilds introduced a lot of new concepts and plot points that had me at the edge of my seat.
My favorite aspect of the rebuilds was the whole Rei Ayanami "Find me" subplot, it was so interesting and always left me wanting more. I also loved the whole time skip thing, since it shows how humans could survive after such a cataclysmic event. I especially loved Shinji's character in the 3rd movie. They had all the ingredients for an amazing conclusion, something close to EoE level.
And they completely dropped the ball.
I'll start with saying that there were things I loved about the fourth movie. The entire farming sequence, though maybe a bit long, was quite interesting and kept my attention. Having it all be buildup to Rei 6's death made me jump in my seat, it was amazing. I would put it up with the rest of the rebuilds on their golden throne for me.
Once Shinji gets back on the Wunder, the movie progressively gets worse. Misato's crew, which I really liked in 3.33, begin to get more and more screentime while characters who need it (like Asuka and Mari) were sidelined unless the movie makers wanted to see more girls in latex. I don't even know why they tried to hard to make the pink haired one a prominent character... they hadn't even fleshed out their ACTUAL new character with a pink color scheme! Why would that background character get her own animated short in the DVD anyway... they should've animated that manga they had in the DVD instead.
The fan service was really unapologetic in the 2nd half, and I'm not just talking about the sexual junk. It felt like it kept trying to 1-up EoE, but all the flashiness just made it look like a bad Marvel movie. It was just reference, reference, reference. Explosion, explosion, explosion. Quip, quip, quip. There were times where I would actually predict what the characters would say before they say it. For example, the part where the lady with the short hair was like, "This is what I dislike about young men" with a happy face near the end was so predictable, so hashtag heckin wholesome that I just felt sick.
Speaking of Misato's crew, they somehow made me sick of looking at Misato. There were sooo many shots of just the side of her face and the front of her face either yelling or looking stern. That would be fine, if she actually needed that much screentime. Her quips and dialogue in general just became worse as the movie went on, too...
In all honesty, when she died, her character was so driven into the ground in this movie that I didn't really feel much. All the airship scenes in general just progressively became more mediocre.
The translation of dialogue and background character dubbing also left much to be desired at times.
Now, my biggest complaints. I do not like that Asuka was a clone. I do not like that real Rei got 2 minutes of screentime. I do not like that Mari's story was barely even shown in the movie. I do not like how Shinji ended up with Mari for. some. reason. beyond me. Finally, I do not like how the entire final third of the movie was near-completely incomprehensible. Sure, I could understand what was happening on the screen, but I could barely place anything in a timeline in my head before being shoved to the next lore drop like snap, snap, snap. It's like they realized that the movie was ending, so they made all these wonderful decisions like:
- Having Shinji suddenly have the whole "rounded out character" attitude and be nonchalant and divine-like to everything (also leading to him having No reaction to the real Rei, which was a very unsatisfying conclusion to the "Find me" subplot)
- Having Asuka's clone plot twist be shown in like 5 rapidly flashing images... and also having it be a plot twist at all. I almost feel like they did that so they could kill her off without rounding out her character at all since 3.33. They really, really sidelined Asuka and should've thought her through more. Having her be a clone now just kinda felt useless.
- Having Rei appear after a whole movie (and at this point two movies since you're at the end) of buildup and then she just disappears. I saw long haired Rei a lot before watching this, so I was waiting for her to have a prominent role.
- Gendo Ikari is the good guy now. Wow I have a son I should stop everything. Glad me, the supergenius, just realized this because of one talk. One. Talk. Also this movie needs to end so I'm good now yayyy
The CGI was so bad that I had originally thought that the movie came out in the early 2010s. Apparently it came out in 2021. That's embarrassing. Especially in the Ikari vs Ikari fight.
Finally, this just didn't feel like an Evangelion movie. The pacing, the environments, the dialogue, almost everything just felt like a Gundam X Star Trek fanfiction. This movie really did just take too long to make, I suppose.
I have more gripes with the movie, but those are the main points that come to mind. Overall, it was a very weak conclusion to a very, very promising movie series. With full honesty, I would have rather taken the cliffhanger ending of 3.33 as the ending to the rebuilds than this "happy ending yayyy!!" movie that felt like it was made for the creator to watch alone. Oh, and the credits song was coworker music. Beautiful World made my heart feel full, the piano at the end of 3.33 was purely amazing and sealed the movie for me... and 3.0+1.11 has coworker music. I'm just so unbelievably disappointed right now.
That's all, I'm saying this out of love for the rebuilds. I'll just consider them a trilogy, because if I do then I'll love them close to how much I love NGE. If there are any typos in this, it's your eyes playing tricks on you.