Okay so I started watching Euphoria after seeing all the posts on insta etc.
The impression I had of Maddy was that she was a girls’ girl - someone who looked out for her friends and just did some questionable things because of the abuse she was enduring.
Upon watching it… that’s not what I’m seeing? At all. She is manipulative, violent, unpleasant, selfish, lazy??? She’s horrible to her friends, not a girls’ girl at all. She is controlling, bad mouths them, and they’re actually scared of her. Kat blindly agrees with her when she’s shouting at Nate in the hot tub due to fear (no sympathy for him, but it was bizarre).
As far as I can see, nothing has happened to her to inspire this unpleasantness towards the people around her. In her episode, she’s just described as being born with an acute confidence. She knows she doesn’t want to work. Her dad is a bum. She’s entitled and horrible about her own mum, seeing her as one of the little people because she works.
Nate… well, he also has daddy issues of course. He is also terrible. We don’t need a discourse about why he sucks.
Cassie is more confusing. She’s grown up with an absent parent, whom she idolised, who disappeared overnight and who became an addict. She can be a bit of a gobby madam to Lexi sometimes, but that’s literally what most sister relationships are like.
From the online discourse, I was under the impression that she seemed super fake & she had this ‘nice girl’ persona that dissolved behind closed doors. But you can SEE the anguish of her character. She way she’s calling Nate up, texting him all hours, sobbing over the phone, having an existential crisis about being a bad person.
Now don’t get me wrong - if I were Maddy, I would be FUMING. Cassie made a horrible, horrible decision when she slept with Nate. She has a lot to answer for. But I can’t hate her like a lot of the internet does. You can see in her eyes in the scene where she presents Maddy with a birthday cake & the scrapbook that she is dying inside because of the guilt. It just… dissolves when she sees Nate.
I think it would have been interesting if the show had portrayed it as more of a side-by-side with Rue’s struggle with addiction, we might have gotten more inside the mind of someone with chronically low self esteem.
The absolute worst part for me was when Rue revealed to the room what was going on between Cassie and Nate… and Maddy just abandoned the matter at hand to make everything about her, at a VERY inappropriate moment.
Everyone online is going ‘omg Maddy really cares about Rue 🥺’. What???? Where? It doesn’t take an adult to see that it was a very obvious ploy on Rue’s part to draw attention away from herself & Maddy just kinda goes with it.
Cassie’s actions are inexcusable. But you can see that she wants to be a good person. Maddy??? Not so much. Nate? Not at all.
Edit: after being reminded about the whole cheating on McKay thing (which I had forgotten about), I want to revise the last paragraph -
Cassie wants to be / wants to be perceived as a good person, but keeps falling short.
Also, I find the complete turn around from her desperation/her being completely consumed by guilt, sobbing on the phone at the start of the series to complete and utter denial at the end a very odd character development choice by the writers.