r/eulalia • • Apr 14 '21

Redwall and the Damaging Tropes of Epic Fantasy

Thumbnail
bookriot.com
1 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Sep 21 '23

Martin the Warrior and Rose of Noonvale - Generated using AI

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Dec 28 '21

Abbey Archives Episode 12 Warning It's Racism

6 Upvotes

We're finally back woodlanders! Sorry for the long wait, here's part 5 of Redwall, Warning It's Racism

Content warnings for racism and indigenous stereotypes! We breeze through the Sparra specifically because we don't want to spend time in that section of the book. It's not pleasant to read or talk about and we are not quiet or shy about calling the kettle a kettle with this.

If you are BIPOC, we're interested in hearing your thoughts about the Sparra.

If you're not comfortable listening to that, please skip to about 50 minutes in.

We love y'all! Starting next month we'll be reading Mattimeo, so please send us any questions you want us to answer about the book, any discussion points, any comments, et cetera! You can DM us here, on Twitter, or join our Discord!

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AbbeyArchives/status/1475857372707016705?t=WHel6_PYbh_MA1vKg0TWpw&s=19 Pinecast: https://pnc.st/s/abbey-archives/538affa3/warning-it-s-racism

Discord: https://discord.gg/Bj7VR4K


r/eulalia • • Oct 22 '23

If Brian were still alive?

0 Upvotes

If Brian Jacques were still alive what would the present state of Redwall be? Would he still be writing them or trying other material?

He would only be slightly north of 80 if he were still alive, not very old at all.

One thing I noticed about the Redwall books is with fits and starts slowly declined in quality after Taggerung. His last few books ( Eulalia, Doomwyte, and Sable Queen) barely resemble even his more mediocre books from the 90s and 2000s.

I read recently the first few chapters of SQ and had to put it down because of how much I didn’t like it. In terms of story but also language it barley resembled the author of Redwall and Mossflower.

Part of it was because all the characters I read about I’d encountered before: captive badgers, kidnapped dibbuns, vermin who strike like ninjas I’ve all encountered before. With SQ especially the lanaguage was very basic and functional, nothing like the lush descriptions of the summer harvest found in redwall nor characters who were that complicates.

I wonder if perhaps even before his death BJ was slowing down a little or perhaps he had someone help organize his thoughts. It almost felt like a different writer.

I think redwall would have ended, because sad to say it seems as if it sort of calcified and didn’t change in that big of a way.

Given Brian’s Catholic roots ( not sure if he still practices) I think he would have resisted the push to make the series “ woke” in any way at all. I think what’s happened to JK Rowling may well have happened to him too, but he would have taken it with less grace.

He wrote the Redwall book for blind children originally because he was unhappy with the sort of “ unwholesome” fiction they were being offered. What would he have thought of modern kids literature in the era of Twitter, the internet and games played on one’s phone?

Thoughts please!


r/eulalia • • Jun 08 '19

Introducing The Red Wall Podcast, a leftist critique of the Redwall series (plus food)! Episode 1: Martin the Watchmaker

18 Upvotes

Hey, fellow woodlanders!

We've just released the first episode of The Red Wall Podcast, a leftist critique of themes of politics, race, gender and religion in each of the books in the Redwall series.

The Red Wall Podcast Episode 1 - Martin the Watchmaker

Every month we're reading one book from the series and talking about their various themes and events through a leftist lens, plus talking about and cooking food from the books. Subscribers to our Patreon can even get a custom recipe inspired by the books every month from our very talented chef cohost!

We hope you enjoy the episode and let us know what you think, both here and over at The Red Wall Pod subreddit!


r/eulalia • • Oct 23 '24

Which Actor Should Play Riggu Felis

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Oct 11 '26

Salamandastron: a very disappointing reread

13 Upvotes

Salamandastron used to be one of my favorite Redwall books when I was a kid; I loved that it had two mischievous youngsters, Mara and Samkim, as protagonists. As an adult, though, I tried rereading it and had to drop it shortly after the point where Thura and Dingeye flee the Abbey. Just thinking about this book gives me a headache.

Looking at Mara and Samkim’s storylines, I think the backdrop of their stories was meant to be the subject of parenting and growing up, and I think their situations were meant to mirror eachother - while Mara’s guardian, Lord Urthstripe, was too strict, Samkim’s guardians, the Abbey elders, were too lenient, and parenting choices on both sides created situations that led to the young protagonists’ leaving home. But I dislike the way it was written overall.

While Urthstripe gets flack from some fans for being prejudiced against Klitch and Goffa, I personally think the Abbey elders were worse than he was in every respect. The parent figures in this book are all incompetent, and it feels like they’re just jerked around by the plot - no common sense, no emotional intelligence, no desire to gain some agency in their situations, just making whatever decisions need to be made in order to enable the existence of cheap drama that isn’t even remotely interesting or exciting. This isn’t what I remember and love Redwall for 😣

Urthstripe. We begin with him wondering whether it was a good idea for him to adopt a female badger, noting that he found Mara in the mountains as a helpless whimpering baby. First off, ouch. Questioning whether you should have adopted your child is bad enough, but the phrasing almost makes it sound like Urthstripe wonders whether he should have just abandoned the baby to die. BJ could have at least clarified it by having him think that maybe he should have found her a different family. Secondly, apparently female badgers aren’t fit to be rulers of Salamandastron. Hooray for Redwall sexism! Thirdly, Urthstripe, if you think maybe you shouldn’t have adopted a daughter because she’s being a rebellious teenager, boy, have I got news for you about what the typical relationship between a badger lord and his growing son is like. Anyway, Urthstripe’s angst with his daughter grates on me because he is shown as having the self-awareness to understand that his strict attitude towards Mara is hurting their relationship, but he’s not really doing anything to change his ways, and as a reader, I feel like I don’t really understand why.

Then comes the whole thing with Klitch and Goffa. I actually think Urthstripe was right to be suspicious of them and not want them in Salamandastron. Not only are they members of a species that is known for being hostile to creatures like him, their behavior is suspicious. Salamandastron is a well-known military fortress. It is not a hotel, nor is it Redwall, which is supposed to be open to all good creatures and anyone who is in need. Klitch and Goffa can clearly see that Urthstripe and the Long Patrol hares don’t want them there, and the vermin present themselves not as creatures who have a real need of hospitality, but as free and independent young travelers who take care of themselves. The very fact they don’t decline Urthstripe’s very-grudging offer of hospitality is cause for wariness. Mara also deserved to be reprimanded for inviting them into Salamandastron without permission.

Of course, Urthstripe’s rant about how vermin can’t be friends is BS. Not only is it a shitty sentiment to voice, even canon proves Urthstripe wrong, as there are several instances of vermin becoming friends with woodlanders in other books. But the main thing that kills me is that Urthstripe doesn’t want the vermin there, absolutely freaks out on Mara and Pikkle for inviting them. . .and then lets these suspicious characters stay the night at Salamandastron anyway, claiming that he feels “obligated” to offer them hospitality. WTF, Urthstripe? Again, this is the military fortress Salamandastron, not Redwall Abbey! Since when are you “obligated” to let someone you don’t trust spend the night there?

To Urthstripe’s credit, he does shut Klitch and Goffa up in a chamber and have them closely watched (all while fantasizing about being handed an excuse to kick their asses), but it also makes this whole scenario pointless, just an excuse to have Mara get angry and run away from home. Also, at this point, if Klitch and Goffa’s presence did end up putting Salamandastron in danger, it would be your fault, Urthstripe. You can’t put all the blame on Mara; she’s not the adult here!

Anyway, Mara cries when she gets yelled at. She points out that not all vermin are evil, and she explains that she feels lonely and over-restricted, as Urthstripe doesn’t even approve of her one good friend Pikkle. Urthstripe doesn’t address any of the points she’s made and just gives her a speech on how someday she will carry the responsibility of ruling Salamandastron. This causes Mara to get up and flee in despair. Urthstripe doesn’t go back to check on his daughter at any point, but spends the evening fantasizing about getting a chance to beat these vermin teenagers up.

Then morning comes, Urthstripe tells the vermin to hurry up and GTFO, and Mara jumps up and declares she’s so sick of his rules that she’s leaving Salamandastron. A few Long Patrol hares move to stop her, but Urthstripe tells them to just let Mara run off with these two suspicious characters she’s befriended because she isn’t happy there at Salamandastron. Fast-forward a couple of chapters, and we get Urthstripe freaking out at his hares because - surprise! - the young vermin he kept insisting were dangerous and evil are in fact, dangerous and evil and now Mara could be in serious peril. One wonders exactly what Urthstripe thought would happen when he allowed his teenaged daughter to leave home while blinded by emotion.

The Redwallers are real charmers, too. When we come to Redwall, Samkim is being taken to task by an old squirrel named Bremmun because he won’t stop treating his bow and arrows like toys, firing them where they could hurt creatures. This most recent incident involved him shooting into an orchard and scaring an old hogwife, but there have been previous offenses, including one where Samkim shaved some of the Recorder Brother Hal’s headfur off and narrowly missed killing him! I cannot understand why the elders didn’t do something about Samkim’s behavior earlier.

It’s noteworthy that neither of the youngsters show any remorse at all about what they’ve done, either. When Bremmun reprimands Samkim for it, Samkim only responds by shrugging and saying, “Sorry, I didn’t mean to hurt anyone.” Arula does bravely confess to her part in Samkim’s stunt, but it feels more like she wants to be loyal to her friend than like she cares about the harm they caused. Again, this is not the good, kind-hearted Redwall attitude that remember loving.

Bremmun sentences Samkim and Arula to confinement in the Infirmary and extra chores, and the other Abbey elders act like he gave him life in prison or something. The narrative whines that punishments are rare in the peaceful Abbey, which absolutely kills me. If you want to maintain a community based on peace and compassion, you have to be willing to hold members of the community accountable if they’re doing things that risk harming others!

Stupidly, one of the elders comments that if Redwall only had a badgermum, she would have really straightened Samkim and Arula out, and thus commences a recurring theme of us readers being beaten over the head with the fact that the Abbey doesn’t have a badgermum and reeeaaaally wants one, foreshadowing the ending, where Mara comes to live at Redwall, though I can’t imagine why the Redwallers even want a badger to discipline their youngsters if they can’t even respect a current resident’s efforts to do so. (God, I feel sorry for Mara - she wanted a life where she could feel relaxed, free and cheerful, and instead she’s going to end up in the role of resident hardass, stick-in-the-mud caretaker and disciplinarian to the lazy Redwallers’ Dibbuns.)

Moving on, the Herbalist Holbrook undermines and guilt-trips Bremmun to get Samkim and Arula out of their punishment. Then Dingeye and Thura arrive. They’re a couple of none-too-bright stoats who have abandoned Ferahgo’s army and now have to flee from his sadistic punishment for deserters. They come to the Redwallers in need of food and shelter. We then see that while Urthstripe, Lord of Salamandastron, is willing to extend hospitality to a couple of vermin who don’t actually need it and whom he has reason to be suspicious of because he feels “obligated,” ironically, the Abbess of Redwall, the place known for compassion, hospitality, and lending aid to others, looks down her nose at two hungry and desperate stoats because they’re bedraggled and rough-mannered and has to practically be begged to let them in. Even after she lets them in, her attitude towards poor Dingeye and Thura remains rather crappy. It’s also rich that prior to inviting them into the Abbey, the Abbess lectures them on how creatures of Redwall Abbey believe in not harming others. Lady, Samkim has almost killed creatures by treating a weapon like a plaything, and you complained when Bremmun tried to discipline him for it! You have no room to preach about good Redwall values!

Anyway, all goes well until the poor slow-witted stoats take a turn using a bow and arrow as a plaything and end up accidentally killing poor Brother Hal for cheap drama. (I think BJ should have killed off Brother Holbrook, the Herbalist who got Samkim and Arula out of their punishment, instead; it would have been sweet irony.) Dingeye and Thura steal the sword of Martin (which is not a nice thing to do, I will admit) and flee the Abbey. Samkim walks in on Brother Hal’s body, then another elder walks in on them both and assumes Samkim is responsible for Brother Hal’s death. The Abbey elders, being the intelligent creatures they are, isolate the traumatized youngster in the Infirmary while they confer about the mystery of Hal’s death.

The elders’ behavior continues to be laughable. Bremmun has become a caricature of the stern and unreasonable elder who has it out for the poor young protagonist. A creature has just been killed, and he’s talking about how if Samkim is the one responsible, he’ll punish him even more harshly than before, as if any sane person would believe discipline was necessary or helpful in this situation. Then the possibility that Thura and Dingeye are the culprits comes up, and Bremmun starts seething over the vermin, but the Abbess bangs on the table and yells at him, saying he’s always accusing other creatures without proof. Lady, you were the one who looked down your nose at Thura and Dingeye the moment you laid eyes on them. You’re hardly in any position to yell at Bremmun for being prejudiced. It feels like she just has it out for Bremmun because he’s strict with Samkim, of whom she’s fond.

The elders conclude that Samkim was, in fact, not the culprit, and the Abbess says she will go to the Infirmary to console him. That sounds like a good idea, and she should probably do it right away. But she doesn’t. They hold Brother Hal’s goddamn funeral, at which Samkim isn’t present (and apparently neither is Arula), and the Abbess just assumes Samkim didn’t attend the service because he was upset about the whole situation. This means that none of these buffoons bothered to go in and check on him between their concluding that Dingeye and Thura were the culprits and Hal’s funeral. This stupid behavior exists only to motivate and enable Samkim to run away from Redwall Abbey. I couldn’t read much farther. This book did not live up to the nostalgia.


r/eulalia • • Aug 16 '22

Surveys for the book readers

0 Upvotes

Hi, everyone,
I am Yash Patel. I work as a Product Designer. I am designing an app for avid readers, where readers can borrow & lend their books over the internet across the city/state level. For this, I am conducting the survey. I would appreciate it if you spare a few minutes and participate in this survey.
Here is the link: https://forms.gle/Hoai6D82vpCoi6ou6

Your opinions would really matter for my case study. I really appreciate it if you would fill up the surveys.


r/eulalia • • Dec 07 '14

Do you consider Redwall and the Redwall Online Community to be "furry"-or something else?

0 Upvotes

Since this has been a fair point of discussion between many members of the ROC, do you guys consider Redwall to be "furry"-or something else? What do you think about the label "furry" being applied to Redwall?


r/eulalia • • Mar 01 '24

Any good quotes about the Long Patrol?

0 Upvotes

Please include the quoted character if it's a character quote :)

Long story short, I'm making a magic the gathering deck with AI art and need a quote for a long patrol card. I read these books about 25 years ago so obviously I don't remember any and don't have any copies I can look through. I tried searching online but the best I could do was find a list of the quotes from the book The Long Patrol, and even though they were definitely good, they didn't have the character who spoke them so they're unusable.

Edit: Can also be quotes by Long Patrol members


r/eulalia • • Mar 28 '23

Redwall related images generated by Midjourney 5

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Jul 07 '26

How well do you think these two would get along in a hypothetical crossover as two antisocial, “Jerk With A Heart of Jerk” characters?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Apr 06 '23

Shipping?

2 Upvotes

Which Redwall characters are you shipping?

Personally, I’m low-key shipping Clogg and Badrang. But I’m totally shipping Orlando and Constance!

What about you?


r/eulalia • • Oct 23 '24

Which Actor Should Play Urgan Nagru

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Jun 11 '26

How well do you think these two characters would get along in a hypothetical crossover?

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

Considering they're both fantasy warriors with blades so heavy only they can lift them.


r/eulalia • • Apr 05 '22

Abbey Archives ep23 Polyamorous Jesus

5 Upvotes

Gooood morning! Thank you all for being so understanding about last week, the rest really did me some good. 💜 But now we're BACK ON TRACK with our next episode of Abbey Archives! Jeez, are we already in part 8? Man this is a long one! Anyway, we talk about classism and racism amongst British upper class, villain trauma, and AU tangents about a certain bird. All in all a very good episode in my opinion, Despite the fact that the night before this recording I had been bevved.

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AbbeyArchives/status/1511357802136096781?t=RW-arPJXNMbdL5EVtyrOHA&s=19 Pinecast: https://pnc.st/s/abbey-archives/97ef1820/polyamorous-jesus

Want to continue the discussion with us and other folks? Join our discord, where you can ask us questions, talk with other Redwall loving folks, and have a chill time. https://discord.gg/Bj7VR4K


r/eulalia • • Jul 04 '22

The Redwall series is basically the Book of Judges from the Bible.

24 Upvotes

An evil army invades and oppresses the "good" people.
A supernaturally-selected individual rises and does heroic deeds.
The hero rallies the good people and drives away the invaders.
Return to status quo.
New generation, rinse and repeat.


r/eulalia • • Sep 02 '26

Redwall Self-Insert!

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

I had a Redwall S/I before but it was a more western based one that I ended up not feeling wholly attached to in 2024. After finding out about the greater grison I knew that's what I'd want to be, so I got to work and spent a couple days creating my new Redwall sona.
As you can see her name is Pocket-It, quite fitting because she is a thief! I am planning on shipping her with Scumsnout not gonna lie!


r/eulalia • • Mar 27 '19

Does anyone else find the Hares incredibly obnoxious?

12 Upvotes

Maybe an unpopular opinion? And whilst I've read a few of the books, I've not read them all, so maybe there's something I'm missing, but so far every time a hare character shows up I really find myself tuning out. Their speech pattern really grates, but I think the biggest issue I have with a lot of the hare characters is how they don't seem to take anything seriously even when they're in these God awful situations. And yet they have this plot armour and always make it to the end of the story? Does anyone else find them annoying or is it just me?


r/eulalia • • Sep 11 '24

Redwall and it’s decline?

79 Upvotes

As others have noted I can’t help but feel that Redwall declined over the years of its existence.

Worse then declined, it calcified! The world started off intersting and open to expansion. It was possible to think human beings existed in this world and who knows what other mysteries might exist.

By book 15 or so, it all felt like “ dry, rinse repeat” pretty much the same for the next book too.

Starting in Redwall and even up until 10 or so books later the books had a very “ Olde England” feel.

I almost believed “ Redwall” was just about animals in 1500s England, including an abbey run by Catholic or Anglican mice.

There was a sense of “ olden times” about it, hearkening back to Robin Hood, the wind in the willows, Chaucer etc. That “ olden times” feel ran well into the series, and was even felt in Taggerung.

Everything after Taggerung ( except maybe Triss and Loamhedge) felt so copy and paste. There was no distinct sense of place or “ other world” and even the characters stopped being complicated or intersting. Even characters who are “ good” or “ evil” can have serious layers and depth to them.

The later Redwall books almost felt AI generated long before AI was a thing. Also, so many accents of the British isles ( Welsh, Cornish, Scottish, Northumbrian etc) made it hard to read and track what some of the characters were saying. I sort of lost interest.

What are your thoughts?


r/eulalia • • Feb 17 '26

Caption this image part 2

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Nov 11 '23

Top 20 heroes from Redwall according to ChatGPT

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/eulalia • • Nov 19 '23

Does Redwall have strong Libertarianism political principles?

0 Upvotes

Don't want this to turn into a political debate but couldn't help that Redwall implicates a strong support for Liberterian ideals.

  • There are no overarching governments in the Redwall universe. Even Salamandastron, the strongest form of moral authority, has a pretty weak hold on the rest of the world.

  • The heroic beasts are generally independent, work for themselves, and support each other, resorting to violence only in defense.

  • The good creatures have no issue defending themselves and having to fight and kill if necessary. Again, Salamandastron has a pretty weak hold on the rest of the world and only participates when it is needed.

  • Vermin are shown be generally authoritarian with despotic rulers, contrarian to individual autonomy.

  • Some other goodbeast societies are represented too. The GUOSIM shrews seem to have a hyper-democratic culture. Other societies have a stronger monarchy (like Southsward) or tribalist society (often shown in a more negative light however). It is important to note that these other societies are often shown to be inefficient at best and sometimes direct threats to the heroes such as the mountain hares in Lord Brocktree.

Though a fantasy world, Redwall has some interesting potential real-life allusions that, though the author seems to want to avoid, cannot be ignored.

What are your thoughts on the political structure of the Redwall world.


r/eulalia • • Jun 21 '22

Abbey Archives ep27 HAVEEDI KADEEBI

0 Upvotes

And we're back folks! Sorry for the long absence, burn out sucks a lot and I haven't had the energy to edit the audio we already had.

This audio is from March.

I am very tired lmao

ANYWAY dive into Mariel of Redwall with us as we mock Gabool's beard, question where ivory comes from in these books, and pile love on Mariel, who is Best Girl.

Pinecast: https://pnc.st/s/abbey-archives/c4b15942/haveedi-kadeebi

Twitter: https://twitter.com/AbbeyArchives/status/1539259946570862595?t=bmvuH-LRWu8hwfTR7-7KSw&s=19

Want to continue the discussion with us and other folks? Join our discord, where you can ask us questions, talk with other Redwall loving folks, and have a chill time. https://discord.gg/Bj7VR4K

Want to support us and what we do? Feel free to donate to our Ko-Fi to help us afford hosting, equipment, music, and guests! https://ko-fi.com/hsenclave

This podcast is part of Hearthside Enclave, which includes other productiona such as Hope's Heart, a solar hopepunk actual play, and Post Apocalyptic News Radio, a Fallout inspired audio drama.