Yesterday I got a Kindle Paperwhite, 12th gen. In September I got a Kobo Libra Colour. I installed KOReader on the KLC and have been having an absolute blast. It was anti Amazon videos over their recent changes to send via usb that led me to get a Kobo. Also because I was told Overdrive only works on Kobo's in Canada.
One thing that gave me pause was how many Stans Kindle had despite all these anti consumer actions Amazon was making. It was enough to to where I had to buy a Kindle to find out.
Off the hop it was a bad experience. When I tried to sign up for Kindle Unlimited last night I was greeted with a message that said my account wasn't eligible for KU and to contact support. Everytime they tried to verify my account with an email or sms it would lead to a 404 page with a picture of a dog. Every rep I spoke to, over four calls, told me there was an outage and to try back in two hours.
I called again this morning and sure enough the rep sent a verify email and I got the 404 dog again. I told him I was getting frustrated and he told me those reps are just lazy and that the workaround is to click approve in the Amazon app instead of the website. Sure enough that worked and he immediately told me what the problem was: my account had a null value for its region. He fixed it and I got Kindle Unlimited.
Kobo Plus vs Kindle Unlimited, I have to give the point to Kobo. The books are absolute garbage on KU that I'm sure if I watched BookTok or Bookstagram I'd gobble up... But I don't and its all hot garbage. At least on Kobo Plus there were books I actually wanted to read.
Sideloading. I have to give the point here to Kindle and this is most surprising to me. Yes you can drag and drop via usb on Kobo but with the Kindle you can just email the book directly from your computer. Which means you don't have to bring your ereader to your computer. Which means if you forget it you don't have to do that walk of shame to collect your ereader.
Its not without fault though. I cannot seem to get table of contents working on any of my ereaders despite polishing and using the Kindle to epub fix. The ToC in book works and links to all the chapters but when I open the top drawer the ToC is greyed out. I bodged it by just setting a book mark to the ToC page.
Also pages don't work as seemlessly as they do on Kobos. On my KLC the pages left are dynamic and change based on font size and margin settings. Page turns on the device correspond 1 to 1 with the number of pages listed. On my Kindle it takes about 3 page turns until the page counter increases. A minor inconvenience but an inconvenience none the less.
The other shortcomings I don't mind. I don't use audiobooks so whisper sync is useless to me and I've been doing Goodreads manually since 2020 so the lack of integration into sideloaded books is lost on me.
However where the Paperwhite really shines, and why I think it will become my main ereader, is how it looks. The words look sharper where as on the KLC they feel softer around the edges. The lighting also feels smoother. Its astonishing how book like it looks.
My biggest personal complaint is the inability to turn off tap page turning and using swipe only. I have a habit of accidentally turning pages and I got around this on my Kobo by turning off tap and going swipe only. But I'll work around it.
I'm still going to use my Kobo for comics and manga as it has KOReader and its perfect for that but for every traditional book I am using my Kindle. The display really is great and you notice it immediately upon turning it on.
In closing, while I understand why people Stan for Kindle now, I do not get the love for the Bookerly font. Something about it looks synthetic to me compared to other fonts. I don't get how people can prefer it when Garamond exists.