254
u/Trevor_Nolan Imaginary Engineer Apr 08 '20
At least for me, the general correlation seems to be that the more in-depth knowledge of a subject that you have, the more difficult it becomes to explain it in layman's terms.
213
u/Kawi_moto96 Apr 08 '20
Please explain thermodynamics to someone who has no knowledge of it?
Me: “Haha ice melt now steam” or “boiler go psss”
107
u/McFlyParadox Apr 08 '20
"Hot things are hot. Cold things are not hot. Gases are just big, hot liquids. Liquids are just small, not-hot gases. If you multiply how hard your gas or liquid is, by how big it is, it is equal to: how much gas or liquid you have, multiplied by how hot it is, multiplied again by a magic number that is the same for all liquids and gases."
54
u/Hail_theButtonmasher Imaginary Engineer Apr 08 '20
how hard your gas is
Never thought about it like that.
13
u/McFlyParadox Apr 08 '20
I think 'hardness' of a gas may actually refer to its moisture content, but idk. It's been forever since I've done any real thermo.
11
u/MainRotorGearbox Apr 08 '20
You might be thinking of quality, x.
4
u/McFlyParadox Apr 08 '20
Yup. Quality. That's what I thinking of. Thermo 2 was eight years ago for me, and I haven't really touched thermo since.
2
30
u/memeticengineering Apr 08 '20
That's how you separate the geniuses, they can make difficult concepts understandable to almost anyone.
19
u/Trevor_Nolan Imaginary Engineer Apr 08 '20
True. I've found that most of the time if I have trouble explaining something it usually falls under one or more of the following categories:
-More abstract stuff (it'd probably be pretty difficult to explain special relativity to someone without mentioning the twin paradox)
-High level stuff that is difficult to explain without some knowledge of the basics (if I am trying to explain a computer algorithm to you it's helpful if you know the different types of primitive data structures)
-Things I've only recently learned (it's a pretty true statement that one demonstration of knowledge mastery is the ability to teach it to others)
-Things that I haven't had a lot of time to think about explaining (if there is some concept that will likely come up in conversation, I'll probably have some sort of example analogy ready. One example of this that I made and really like is comparing object oriented programming to a room filled with IKEA furniture)
5
Apr 09 '20
That's the most stupid thing I've heard. What makes a person a genius is his ability to solve complex problems and to think in certain areas, not his ability to explain things, that's what makes you a good teacher
Look at sports, for example, many great players that play in positions that require great game knowledge, break the game in ways you never thought were possible then try to transition to coach and just suck, makes them less intelligent about the game or just aren't good at explaining/organising?
3
4
3
15
22
u/Alpacac1no Apr 08 '20
Have you met some engineering professors?
34
Apr 08 '20
Especially during practical lessons.
"Hehe, and you add this to that, heh, *5 min of silence while he works* and then what you do is pretty simple do take this and do it like that. *end of lesson* And that class is how you make a fully functional gundam with an onboard quantum computer. Any questions? No, see you next time."
21
20
Apr 08 '20
One of my roommates and I tried to explain jerk, snap, crackle, and pop to our other not-engineer roommates. It was so difficult to do
13
6
u/NewoTemplar Apr 09 '20
All I can think of is the time I was in a multidisciplinary workshop at uni - me and the other engineer in the group spent 1 minute of back and fourth to understand and resolve whatever scenario had just been given to us. We then spent another 5 minutes trying to explain it to the science majors in our group who decided they needed to work through it themselves for 5 minutes before they reached the same conclusion as us.
The marketing guy in the group then piped in with "I have no idea what any of you said someone just write down what I need to say"
8
6
4
2
u/amatuerscienceman Apr 08 '20
There’s at least a season’s worth of x-files episodes where this is a subplot
2
1
u/second_to_fun Apr 08 '20
You wish to imply that engineers as a stereotype have poor social intelligence?
Why I never...
1
1
1
1
0
0
258
u/Drakeadrong Uncivil Engineer Apr 08 '20
This hurts so, so much