I made a prior thread discussing the idealism verus realism of environmental policy, and to the naysayers here's an "ideal" (haha) example of this: banning the sale of new gas lawn equipment in MN starting in 2025 (!)
"https://wjon.com/mn-house-bill-would-ban-gas-powered-lawn-equipment/"
"https://nypost.com/2023/02/18/minnesota-dem-lawmakers-push-ban-on-gas-powered-lawn-mowers/"
For many of you who probably have never mowed a lawn and hire this out (let alone know how an engine works) let me explain:
-small engines consist of two different types: 2 strokes and 4 strokes. The 2's don't have a separate oil system, ie they're the type you mix gasoline and oil with, and as such they burn dirtier. 4 Strokes have their own oil, and work not too different than a car engine on a much smaller scale - and burn cleaner than 2's.
-2 strokes used to be popular, now most don't sell them outside of chainsaws and some really small cutting stuff - almost all gas lawnmowers are 4 strokes, in fact the only 2 stroke I've ever operated was an antique snapper from the 80's, even the last gas mower I purchased from the 1990's was 4 stroke, which burns cleaner;
-the overall emissions from lawn equipment overall is marginal;
-the technology isn't there yet frankly, let alone for chainsaws, god forbid snowblowers, though blowers don't seem to be explicitly listed;
-Minnesota is largely a rural state, minneapolis/st paul aren't real cities (small downtown area) and frankly it's mostly overgrown suburbs surrounded by crappy chain restaurants, so the particulate issues that other larger more metropolitan cities deal with aren't a real issue here because the "city" really is just a big suburb mostly;
And lastly, given the small reduction in emissions this will be terrible PR for getting electrification to happen. IE, you'll be pissing off a lot of people if this law is passed.
I have a worx 48v lawnmower that I use, and it's okay, it takes two sets of 2 x 24v 4.0 amp hour batteries to cut a pretty small lawn, about the size of a basketball court. However if the grass is wet or I let it go for too long, I tend to use my older gas lawnmower, because it frankly doesn't cut the lawn well, leaves some uncut grass (yes i sharpen the blades so it's not that) and won't cut the entire lawn on two sets of batteries.
Yes there are better electric mowers out there, but compared to gas you won't have the performance - with batteries you'll easily spend over 1k for a comparable performance from even a bargain 4 stroke mower.
IE, the technology isn't there yet, and the inconvenience to people is far greater than the net benefit frankly.
Now I'm sure if you've never mowed your own lawn you won't understand this, but to everyone who does you'll know what I'm talking about here, and especially the bigger lawns, and god forbid if you own a landscaping company.
And here's the kicker - it bans everything under 25hp, which is many many smaller tractors, the type that hobby farmers use etc. Lots of people have dual-use john deere's they use for everything explicitly this size, around 20hp. And if you think electric tractors work well then frankly you live in another world. (when they have power they work, however power / batteries are the issue here)
IE, electric lawnmowers "work" for smaller lawns, and some cases - but def. not them all, and this will piss off a lot of people for no real reason.
Please also note that minnesota did do a good thing, (in my book) by requiring that all power plants produce all their power from carbon free sources starting in 2040, and 80% by 2030 - so cool off wankers, I'm on your side here, it's the crazy shit like the aforementioned banning of freakin' gas lawnmowers that has me rolling my eyes, and many in this state.
It's this vary idealism that's the problem here, wait until battery technology advances enough that people just buy electric lawnmowers, this is already happening for many suburban types with small lawns, since they do have advantages, like not having to change oil, being quieter, etc. The transition has already started, I don't know why they are shoving it down our throat frankly, or at least attempting to.
But banning everything? ban new sales of 2 strokes, fine - but everything? In 2 years?
Well, there you go. An example of idealism gone wrong.