Hey Reddit,
wanted to quickly share my experiences with a complete Noctua Fan replacement (PSU, MOBO, Hotend) for my Ender 3 v2 as me and my neighbours were really annoyed by fan noise and vibrations.
Ender3V2_AllNoctua
Yes, there already are a couple of these reviews but I ran into some things maybe others are interested in.
First up: Results are amazing. The printer is dead silent and barely noticeable at max fan speed. Now you can hear the actual printing sound of the drivers very subtle and I really like those as they are still very very silent.
Here is a quick comparison between the stock fans VS all Noctua fans:
Ender 3 V2 All Noctua Comparison Video https://imgur.com/a/n6bpI5X
I bought these things from Amazon (DE):
I printed the following things all in White PLA, 0.2mm, 200°, 25% infill:
The detailed descriptions from Jaymerx and BRISSMOTO covered almost all necessary things for me. Additionally I found the (or better all) videos of Bryan (BV3D) about the V2, buck converters and fan replacements very helpful. He once saved my ass putting the printer together, so why not listen to him now?
My only issue was the buck converter placement. The motherboard cover has one nice cutout with holding pins (see picture D) but you need to securely place two other homeless converters for the hotend fans somewhere. Nearly all buck converters come without cooling and have explicit warnings in their product descriptions that additional cooling is needed for ‘longterm use’. Most people here on reddit or youtube suggest to just wrap them in a shrink tube, glueing it directly to a flat surface or don’t cover the topic of converter placement at all. These ways don’t sound like sufficient cooling and a safe solution for me and just didn’t feel right. Additionally there is not much space near the motherboard for the converters.
D_Buck-converter-cutout_in_MOBO-cover
So me and a friend looked for an approach to
A) have all three converters near the motherboard B) ensure good ventilation around them with our new 92mm fan C) use some spacers to not glue it completely on a flat surface
So we sawed four yellow angles from an old toolbox and cut them in shape. We hot glued one on each inner side of the motherboard cover so they have enough spacing around them. You can see them in the pictures C1, C2 and C3. If I had known this from the beginning I could have printed a holder attachment for these beforehand, but with the printer disassembled we improvised here. Maybe someone wants to build something for this (like the mini case from Bryan here).
C1_Buck-converter_spacer
C2_Buck-converter_spacer
C3_Buck-converter_placement_MOBO-Cover
A few other small side notes probably obvious to skilled people but note-worthy for noobs like me:
All fans (PSU, MOBO, Hotend) should blow the air into the device, so logo (= direction of airflow) should point inwards on all fans.
The larger 92mm Noctua fans have a yellow instead of red cable. Yellow equals positive, black is negative/ground.
If you don’t have or want screws in the right size to tighten the hotend fans, you should print (at least) 8 holding pins for the hotend fans which are included in the ZIP on cults3d. Just in case the rubber things coming with the Noctua fans drive you nuts as you try to put them in (they will). And yes, if the rubber things did work you should cut off the long brown nipples on the hotend fans. But I kinda like them now in a very weird way. So they stay.
This took way more time than expected, don't get fooled by these 10 minute videos :D Me and a friend (both motivated in building and soldering but not talented at all) were busy for about 5-6 hours from disassembly to first print test. Was very fun though and the results exceeded our expectations on the low noise level by a whole lot.
Looking forward to some feedback on the buck converter placement, would like to know if this was necessary at all / if this approach was valid and read your opinions on love/hate relationships with long brown nipples.
Happy printing ✌️