Hello community,
Foreword: I have been an Elrond OG for a while now and a long time supporter of the Elrond project, even back in the days of the ERD ERC20 launch. I am composing this post to give an honest constructive feedback from the perspective of a community member in hopes to encourage healthy communication between all, including the Elrond team if they are listening. These are my personal reactions to the announcements of the Elrond project. Despite most people fearing change of old ways, I am usually an adopter and embracer of new concepts and changes where it sees fit. Here is my review.
After watching the announcements of this past few days of X-day, I am not sold and my confidence for the future of this project is uncertain. I am not too sure that the announcements of the changes of the Elrond network seems all that ground breaking. Here is my constructive review and feedback of it so far.
Lucian Todea's presentation and public speaking skills was lacking. He seems very uncertain, nervous with the announcements, and this immediately did not install any confidence in me for what new "features" they have on the horizon. Unfortunately, first appearnances goes a long way with the audience and this has to be heavily considered when making the type of announcements/changes that he did. You have a lot of eyes watching you (like Jerome Powell) and what you say can indeed sway markets.
The announcement of the projects reutilization of LKMEX. i.e. the non-transferability of LKMEX. I guess this will be the demise of lockedmex.exchange huh? It appears that what they decided to prioritize on the utility of LKMEX was in a totally different direction instead of focusing on getting other ways (like getting it listed on centralized exchanges). This would help get the public more involved and having access to the LKMEX/MEX. It appears that the team has decided to restrict it even more. Something about this doesn't sit well and I need more time to digest this concept. Maybe if they had more examples and maybe a prototype to showcase this concept for better conception would aid in this announcement. Maybe when they follow through and go live with this, we will see it in action and it is not as bad as I am feeling it to be. It is an area of concern about protecting the economics and energy of LKMEX and Maiar. But it is our LKMEX that we should choose what we would like to do with it. Maybe the new voting mechanism will allow the community to vote what we would like to do with our rightly earned LKMEX.
In another post as I mentioned, rebranding of the Elrond to meta/multiverseX seems like a waste of energy. you already have gained as much adoption and brand recognition thus far, why change it up again? This is just too soon.
Restrictions on EGLD holders. Taking away EGLD ability to interact in metastaking to make way to strengthen LKMEX functionality is again another restriction. I am not sure their visions on how to increase the utility of LKMEX is going in a good direction. Again, something about this doesn't sit well with me. Furthermore, they plan on doing some type of exponential curve formula to aid in decrease whale influence. I am in agreeance with figuring out ways to not allow whale centralization of projects, but we shall see if this is done right because implementing these types of configurations could have unforeseen consequences.
I really enjoyed the Cantina Royale teams presentation. I felt they did a great job explaining the efforts, struggles, and lessons learned on their journey. This is great for future projects who wish to onboard to the Elrond (MetaverseX???) network.
It is a challenge in developing a continuous, thriving, economy. For this, I salute Elrond and all sincere blockchain projects that are dealing with this. This was well explained in the Cantina Royale segment and they were just speaking on the economics of the game, but this is metaphor for an even larger concept that expands to the global arena. Civilizations and Governments of the world have always struggled with this, to this very day. It is hard to govern this as it is hard to take into account humans reproduction and growth coupled with currencies (a change of state, flux, or energy in motion/flow) since we are forever expanding, which is not taken into account, and has manifested in the form of inflation. This is a hard concept that even our current state of affairs are having a hard time accepting.
The Elrond team will continue to have my support and best of luck and well wishes for the team and the project.
Please provide your own feedback to the conference and this post. Please provide constructive feedback and maybe help me gain clarity on any concepts I may have not fully understood or grasped. It is greatly appreciated.