r/econometrics • • May 02 '25

SCREW IT, WE ARE REGRESSING EVERYTHING

763 Upvotes

What the hell is going on in this department? We used to be the rockstars of applied statistics. We were the ones who looked into a chaotic mess of numbers and said, “Yeah, I see the invisible hand jerking around GDP.” Remember that? Remember when two variables in a model was baller? When a little OLS action and a confident p-value could land you a keynote at the World Bank?

Well, those days are gone. Because the other guys started adding covariates. Oh yeah—suddenly it’s all, “Look at my fancy fixed effects” and “I clustered the standard errors by zip code and zodiac sign.” And where were we? Sitting on our laurels, still trying to explain housing prices with just income and proximity to Whole Foods. Not anymore.

Screw parsimony. We’re going full multicollinearity now.

You heard me. From now on, if it moves, we’re regressing on it. If it doesn’t move, we’re throwing in a lag and regressing that too. We’re talking interaction terms stacked on polynomial splines like a statistical lasagna. No theory? No problem. We’ll just say it’s “data-driven.” You think “overfitting” scares me? I sleep on a mattress stuffed with overfit models.

You want instrument variables? Boom—here’s three. Don’t ask what they’re instrumenting. Don’t even ask if they’re valid. We’re going rogue. Every endogenous variable’s getting its own hype man. You think we need a theoretical justification for that? How about this: it feels right.

What part of this don’t you get? If one regression is good, and two regressions are better, then running 87 simultaneous regressions across nested subsamples is obviously how we reach econometric nirvana. We didn’t get tenure by playing it safe. We got here by running a difference-in-difference on a natural experiment that was basically two guys slipping on ice in opposite directions.

I don’t want to hear another word about “model parsimony” or “robustness checks.” Do you think Columbus checked robustness when he sailed off the map? Hell no. And he discovered a continent. That’s the kind of exploratory spirit I want in my regressions.

Here’s the reviewer comments from Journal of Econometrics. You know where I put them? In a bootstrap loop and threw them off a cliff. “Try a log transform”? Try sucking my adjusted R-squared. We’re transforming the data so hard the original units don’t even exist anymore. Nominal? Real? Who gives a shit. We’re working in hyper-theoretical units of optimized regret now.

Our next paper? It’s gonna be a 14-dimensional panel regression with time-varying coefficients estimated via machine learning and blind faith. We’ll fit the model using gradient descent, neural nets, and a Ouija board. We’ll include interaction terms for race, income, humidity, and astrological compatibility. Our residuals won’t even be homoskedastic, they’ll be fucking defiant.

The editors will scream, the referees will weep, and the audience will walk out halfway through the talk. But the one guy left in the room? He’ll nod. Because he gets it. He sees the vision. He sees the future. And the future is this: regress everything.

Want me to tame the model? Drop variables? Prune the tree? You might as well ask Da Vinci to do a stick figure. We’re painting frescoes here, baby. Messy, confusing, statistically questionable frescoes. But frescoes nonetheless.

So buckle up, buttercup. The heteroskedasticity is strong, the endogeneity is lurking, and the confidence intervals are wide open. This is it. This is the edge of the frontier.

And God help me—I’m about to throw in a third-stage least squares. Let’s make some goddamn magic.


r/econometrics • • Mar 21 '24

Economists be like:

Post image
456 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • May 19 '21

economists irl

413 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Dec 09 '25

[Meme/Shitpost] Heteroscedasticity

Post image
281 Upvotes

This is an accidental graph that represents the places where a belt was punctured. As you can see the variance is not equal 🙃 since my father is right-handed.


r/econometrics • • Feb 25 '24

Is 33 years too old for starting a phd?

228 Upvotes

I'm applying to a phd in Economics program in Spain, nonetheless I'm now 31 (half way to 32) and by the time the university give the acceptance check, plus the answer of my home country scholarship, I would likely be 33 years of old.

I am also father of a 4 years old girl and husband.

My motivation for doing the phd is, actually, to research the topic I like the most, which would be my "dream job" (is not job if you enjoy it enough).

Currently I have a Master in Economics, but the things I do in my job are not even closer to the research I'm aiming for.

On the other hand, it is somewhat risky since I did my master degree about 5 years ago, so returning to the game will be a challenge for me. Also, there is the economical factor. The scholarship gives me a stipend of about 2,000 usd monthly, which is not enough to sustain a family of 3. So it will be a real challenge...

Thank you all!!!!


r/econometrics • • Dec 10 '21

Thought this b

Post image
208 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • May 17 '18

Data Science

Post image
204 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • May 18 '25

Econometrics Cheat Sheet Project updated with Panel Data Section and Theil's U stat!

Post image
201 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am the creator of the The Econometrics Cheat Sheet Project, I have updated the Additional Cheat Sheet with a Panel Data section as asked. Also, I added a little summary of Theil's U in the Time Series Cheat Sheet.

I am currently focused on my PhD and with the work of correcting exams, but in the future I plan to create a small guide (< 10 pages) for econometrics with R that covers most of the contents of the cheat sheets.

Suggestions, feedback and bug reports are welcome!


r/econometrics • • Nov 04 '24

There are some confounders here

Post image
175 Upvotes

Sorry I just wanted to bring the fun discourse here. Link to original post: https://x.com/natesilver538/status/1852915210845073445?s=46&t=QZNf3lcB_9bqrUbW2D833A XS


r/econometrics • • Jan 19 '22

I created a complete econometrics cheatsheet!

Thumbnail
github.com
174 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Apr 05 '26

My opinion: to really understand econometrics you need a math heavy course in probability and stochastic processes as a prerequisite

163 Upvotes

People struggle with econometrics because it is teached in a bad way, they Just throw you this course without any or very little preparation on the foundation of this topic, like you at least need to know what is a sigma algebra and what is theoretically the sample space from which your random variables X,Y comes from. It s like they re teaching you calculus 2 before calculus 1, you will struggle because you dont have the basics


r/econometrics • • Feb 16 '24

Econometrics/Statistics

Post image
144 Upvotes

Which answer is correct and why?


r/econometrics • • Oct 14 '20

Working paper states that strong IVs need to have an F of at least 104.7 (paper in the comments)

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Apr 21 '25

New edition of The Effect coming out soon

116 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm thrilled to have seen my book, The Effect, recommended so many times in this sub. The Effect is an approachable book about how to perform causal inference, covering the theory, intuition, and plenty of applied methods and coding examples. You may be interested to know that there is a second edition coming out soon, which features considerable updates and improvements all through the book, including more on updated difference-in-differences methods, as well as a whole new chapter on partial identification (what you can do when you don't quite believe your identifying assumptions all the way!).

Preorders are available here: https://www.routledge.com/The-Effect-An-Introduction-to-Research-Design-and-Causality/Huntington-Klein/p/book/9781032580227

and the website theeffectbook.net, where you can already read the first edition for free, will update to the second edition once the new version officially launches. New videos for the new chapter coming soon as well, in early May. (this post cleared with the mods)

Hope you enjoy!


r/econometrics • • Apr 09 '24

Python or R

116 Upvotes

Ok so I’ll bring up this age old question, someone most definitely answered it somewhere some time but you can never be too sure am I right?

Python or R for econometrics? For workplace (public and private, think economists and financial analysts) and academia (econ research)

My honours prof (econ background) keeps emphasising the superiority of python with its packages. So we pretty much use python for all of the contents in class. However in my undergrad, we were taught purely based on R for metrics 1 and 2, and was told that it was the holy grail for econometrics. Then of course we also have Eviews for simple plug and play that industry also likes.

Bruh I have limited time and energy so idk where I should put more focus on


r/econometrics • • May 15 '25

Why aren’t Bayesian methods more popular in econometrics?

112 Upvotes

From what I know, Bayesian methods are pretty niche in econometrics as a whole. I know they’re popular with empirical macroeconomists and time series econometricians, but why are they not becoming more popular in other subfields of econometrics? It seems like statistics is being taken over by the war cries of Bayesian statisticians, but why are econometricians not following this trend?


r/econometrics • • Nov 10 '20

No, prof, the solution is not trivial at all

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Mar 28 '19

Ah, trusty old regression~

Thumbnail
imgur.com
108 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Feb 13 '26

Me learning Econometrics for the first time

Post image
107 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Oct 15 '26

Graduate Econometrics is hard

105 Upvotes

I just took my midterm and I feel like I got a 0 on it. I studied for hours over a week, so I studied topics once and came back to them multiple times. I completed the textbook problems and problems from the slides.

I felt like I had a good grasp of the content. I really don’t know what I could have done differently.

I’m currently in a master’s that requires the first two classes of the PhD Econometrics sequence. I want to do a PhD and my grade in this class will be a good signal to the programs I’m applying to.

Any tips?


r/econometrics • • Mar 03 '20

Here's a stupid meme that I made on my study break from my Econometrics take home exam

Post image
101 Upvotes

r/econometrics • • Oct 04 '26

What books are the holy grail in econometrics?

100 Upvotes

I rather read a physical book than a digital book, but money doesn´t let buy all book i would want. Which books would you consider so good and important to have it in physic? In all fiel of econometrics, not just econometrics overall. Could be about time series and macroeconometrics, causal impact, etc..-


r/econometrics • • Apr 22 '26

Ummm why are profs still teaching F > 10 (for 1st stage relevancy in 2SLS) when Lee et al. (2022) basically buried it?

92 Upvotes

Genuinely asking, not trying to be that guy. I'm in an undergrad metrics class at a pretty serious program and we're still being taught the Stock–Yogo (2005) "rule of 10" for first-stage F-stats as if it's the final word on weak instruments. No mention of tF, no mention of effective F, no mention that the threshold controls bias under homoskedasticity and not the size of the t-test.

Quick recap of what I actually think the state of the literature is (full disclaimer, my read of the literature could be entirely wrong):

  • Staiger & Stock (1997) and Stock & Yogo (2005) give us the ~10 threshold. But it's derived under iid errors and targets a bias criterion (2SLS bias ≤ 10% of OLS bias), not t-test size.

  • Montiel Olea & Pflueger (2013) show the Stock–Yogo critical values don't hold under heteroskedasticity/clustering/autocorrelation. They propose an "effective F" that does. Virtually no real-world applied paper has iid errors, so this alone should retire the naive F > 10 check.

  • Andrews, Stock & Sun (2019, ARE) synthesize this and are pretty explicit that F > 10 ≠ valid inference.

  • Lee, McCrary, Moreira & Porter (2022, AER) is the one that actually kills it. In the just-identified single-IV case, a true 5% t-test requires F > 104.7. If you want to keep F > 10, you need to swap 1.96 for 3.43. They re-examine 57 AER papers and roughly half of the significant results become insignificant under valid inference. They also propose the tF procedure, which gives a smooth F-dependent SE adjustment so you don't actually need F > 104.7 — you just need to use the right critical value.

  • Keane & Neal (2023, JoE) and Angrist & Kolesár (2021) basically pile on.

This seems pretty important upon first glance. Why is this not standard in undergrad/first-year grad teaching yet? Is there a defense of the old threshold I'm missing? Inertia in textbooks? Worry about scaring students off of IV entirely? Genuine disagreement with Lee et al.? I'm trying to figure out whether to bring it up with my professor or whether there's some pedagogical reason I'm not seeing.

References


r/econometrics • • Nov 30 '24

Have any of you taken the IMF's course on macroeconometric forecasting?

91 Upvotes

Just curious if the course is worthwhile/insightful. My modeling skills are a bit rusty -- is this course worth taking? It seems to focus on classical models (ARMA, VAR, VECM), which I suppose could make sense in a small n/macro context, but I question to what extent this stuff is cutting edge in 2024.

https://www.imf.org/en/Capacity-Development/Training/ICDTC/Courses/MFx