Hey guys,
I like digging through DTC brands’ ads for fun, and this one surprised me, so I’m sharing it.
The brand is Fabula Coffee. US, organic low-acid coffee, somewhere around 500k to 1M visits a month by estimate, and they claim 40,000+ five-star reviews. I pulled up their active ads in the Meta Ad Library.
They have 93 ads live from their own page. Sounds like a lot of testing, until you read them. There are only about 20 different opening lines.
One line shows up 33 times: “Did you know that a regular cup of coffee has more chemicals in it than any other product we eat or drink?” The oldest copy started in late June and they launched more of it this month. Throw in three other “Did you know” versions and that’s at least 50 of the 93. What’s left is discounts, review quotes and flavored coffee.
Here’s the part I can’t figure out. Their homepage opens with “drink coffee without the tummy burn”. But only 5 of the 93 ads mention acid or stomach in the first lines. Almost half talk about mold, toxins or chemicals.
Then I checked Lifeboost, which sells pretty much the same thing. I could load their 24 most-shown ads, so take this with a grain of salt. Those 24 have 15 different openings, and 22 of them have been running since July or August.
They’re all over the place in a good way. One is about taste (“Most healthy coffees sacrifice something, usually flavor”), one about chemicals, a 58% off bundle, a decaf one for people who can’t handle caffeine. And they go straight at the stomach thing: “Love coffee, but hate the way it makes your stomach feel?”
So Fabula bets a third of its ads on one scary fact, and Lifeboost keeps a bunch of angles alive for months, including the exact one Fabula’s homepage is built on. I can’t see spend or results, only the copy and the start dates, so I honestly don’t know who’s making more money.
A few things I took away for my own stuff.
I count ideas now, not ads. 93 ads with 20 openings is 20 tests at best. If two ads have the same hook and a different caption, that’s one test.
The angle your competitor keeps running and you don’t is the first one worth testing. If I were Fabula I’d try the stomach angle tomorrow, my own site already promises it.
And check for dead offers. One of their ads still says “last day of our biggest spring sale”. It’s November... BUT If it's still live there are a reason
One more thing I looked at: what’s moving in coffee right now that neither brand seems to use much.
Coffe prices are up about 10% in a year and surveys say people are brewing at home more. I didn’t see a single “cost per cup vs the coffee shop” ad from Fabula.
Black coffee is also up, from 18% to 24% of drinkers in one survey, and Fabula has customer reviews saying they stopped adding cream. That’s an angle sitting on their own site. And another low-acid brand, Puroast, is writing a lot for people on GLP-1 drugs who can’t handle regular coffee. I’d be careful with that one, it’s a health claim, but it shows where the stomach angle is heading.
So before testing a new angle, I’d check two things: is it moving in the market, and does the brand already have proof of it on its own site