LONG ASS WALL OF TEXT INCOMING
I've seen people comparing Shield VS Orbital to Lance VS Duplicator, but personally? I didn't really feel all that much with SvO. Part of the reason that made LvD so amazing was that it was a fight against an underdog with a subpar performance VS a ball with a clean winstreak of five. During discussions on which ball can possibly beat Dupe, Lance only ever really came up when the match was announced. Even so, the fight felt equally matched, Dupe can easily overwhelm Lance if she dodges all her lunges; meanwhile, Lance can do some heavy damage to Dupe if she hits.
This did not feel like the case with SvO. Shield has always been regarded as the closest counter to Orbital, so when they finally end up fighting, it doesn't feel like a triumphant win against the main villain despite people believing the odd is in the villain's favour, but instead it felt like a predictable fight with one obvious winner (though it was closer than I expected) that went by too quickly.
It'd be like if Dupe fought Scepter first before Lance. She was already considered a potential hard counter meanwhile Lance was basically never really considered. It wouldn't have the same impact because it stops being a climactic fight against all odds, but instead simply a fight with a clear winner where the other fighter is essentially just a victim.
Really, a more fitting fight would've been if Scimmy won against Orbital. It had the same conditions of and underdog and the main villain who due to certain circumstances, are equally matched, where Scimmy's mirages have insane DPS potential against any ball that can't parry and Orbital has insane DPS by simply being near their opponent. But alas, we aren't in that timeline, but I hope we're in the timeline where Crossbow can win against Orbital in the next match.
TL: DR, I found Shield VS Orbital comparatively underwhelming to Lance VS Duplicator. One is a fight between the underdog and the main villain of the season, while the other is a match with a much clearer winner, and a better substitute would've been Scimmy winning against Orbital, and maybe the upcoming Crossbow VS Orbital.