I first discovered Duelyst around January time, and since then I've been playing fairly regularly. Normally, I never buy anything from free to play games. This is because most F2P games are openly exploitative, trying to hook you on a treadmill where you keep spending money to keep up.
Hearthstone is pretty bad about this. They charge you a dollar or 2 for five random cards, and these five cards are almost always trash. A legendary shows up something like once in every 20 packs, and some of the legendaries are absurdly powerful. You need these cards to play at even a remotely competitive level, because they're just so obviously unbalanced (Dr Boom was the worst offender here). And some other legendaries are awful, making the random packs even more of a crapshoot. You can craft legendaries, but only for 1600 dust and you get 5 dust back from each common you disenchant. You only get 400 dust back if you (eventually) pull a crappy legendary. The whole system is set up to frustrate players and then captialise on the ones with either low self control, or stacks of disposable cash. These are the 'whales'.
And many other games, especially (but not exclusively) on mobile, are far worse than Hearthstone. I don't want to contribute to any of this. It's fundamentally an exploitative business model that shares a lot in common with how casino's operate.
But I have bought the 40 spirit orb bundle twice now. This is because CP games genuinely seemed to care about minimizing exploitation of the user base. Legendaries come in every five packs or so, and they aren't so absurdly powerful that they warp the whole meta. Cards disenchant for a reasonable amount of dust, and the crafting costs are also very realistic amounts. Fundamentally, the game still runs on a casino model. But its a casino that pays out on a regular basis in fairly predictable ways, so I don't mind too much. The long and short of it is that CP seems to care about providing a good experience over total profit maximisation.
Duelyst is still a very expensive game. Here are some things I could buy with 50 dollars:
A complete game in another genre.
A very nice restaurant meal
Five decent takeaway meals (one for each work-day)
A tank of petrol for my car
But I chose to buy 40 packs of duelyst cards, and I did it twice. I'm pretty happy with the purchases, because I've had a lot of fun playing Duelyst. But this is still a high price. Remember that new expansions are going to release every year or so, which means 50 dollars is a recurring fee if I want to play with a wide variety of cool decks.
I was fully intending to buy 40 more packs at the release of Shim'zar. But now I'm feeling very concerned about investing any more money into this game. It appears, from my perspective, that CP might not care about the playerbase as much as I initally assumed.
Question: What are emotes for? What is their purpose? I think most people would agree on something like this: They let you communicate with your opponent while you play.
Who decided on the prices for the emotes? Seriously, who decided them? Give that guy a smack up the head, because he's clearly lost touch with reality. A full emote set for a single Hero (12 icons) costs 25 dollars. As a bundle, you get 50 percent off, at 13 dollars. There's little point in buying just a few emoticons, since you'll have huge gaps in the emotions you can communicate to your opponent, so the most sensible option is clearly these half-price bundles. This is clearly the option CP are trying to influence you into buying. These emoticons are locked in to a single Hero, so If you want to emote at your opponent you'll need them for each hero you play. 13 dollars here, 13 dollars there, it's going to add up fast.
If I don't want to pay for the bundles, I could craft the emotes individually (no option to craft the bundles themselves, as far as I see). The price then comes to 7,500 dust per hero. Thats about 8 legendary cards worth of dust for each hero. Let me tell you, if had 8 legendaries worth of dust I'd build an artifact Vetruvian deck, not craft 12 little pictures of Saji's face.
These emotes are simply not production-quality. In many emotes, it's hard to tell what emotion is even meant to be shown. There are so many small details, so many colors, and very little space on each emote is actually dedicated to showing the emotions. I can't even tell the difference between many of Scioness Saji's emotes. There's like 4 of her just staring blankly. All the emotes look like they were thrown together in a day or two, just so you'd have something to flog on your store. I certainly don't believe you went through any iteration on these designs. Their quality is not terrible, but let's put it this way: I honestly believe Blizzard would be ashamed of charging 13 dollars for 12 small images of a hearthstone hero that look like they were pulled off a random DeviantArt account. And I think many people playing Duelyst would say Blizzard are money-grubbers.
Other people have talked about card backs, and how they're completely unnecessary and were obviously added just so you'd have more things to sell us. The obvious solution here is card fronts, as many have said. I'm not so annoyed about the pricing of card backs, because you only need one (rather than 12) and they aren't locked to heroes.
Overall, I'm really getting the impression that the head honcho's of CP gathered around one day and had a big brainstorm on how many different ways they could sell us things while we play your game. Part of me believes you called in a consultant from the mobile space and he told you to disregard any kind of respect for your playerbase and just focus on milking your whales. Another part of me believes you came up with this strategy on your own.
Whether I continue to invest money in Duelyst depends hugely on whether I feel this is a 2-way, respectful relationship. And the latest patch makes me doubt that. If you honestly thought I'd pay $13 for each secondary hero I play just to emote at people, on top of paying $4 dollars a pop for card backs and player icons, on top of actually buying the cards I need to even play the game in the first place, then I'll honestly say I feel disrespected. If instead you thought you could simply price average players out the market and just rinse your whales for all they have, then I feel doubly disrespected.