r/dsa • • Aug 21 '24

Electoral Politics AOC’s DNC Speech Was a Betrayal of the Gaza Movement

Thumbnail
thenation.com
17 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Dec 09 '23

Discussion "The Overton Window" and why we must vote for (unfortunately) Joe Biden.

0 Upvotes

After seeing so many Socialists on here claiming to support Democratic Socialism but refusing to vote I gotta say something. I don't think you have have understood the strategy of the DSA politicians or Democratic Socialists in a liberal democracy.

Joe Biden and Donald Trump = Bad right? Obviously one is much worse than the other, but that's not my point here.

The method of establishing Democratic Socialism in the US (or elsewhere) goes through "The Overton Window". It's a matter of politics.

The Overton window is an approach to identifying the ideas that define the spectrum of acceptability of governmental policies. It says politicians can act only within the acceptable range. Shifting the Overton window involves proponents of policies outside the window persuading the public to expand the window.

This is the main strategy and goal of our Democratic Socialists in office. If we are going to revolutionize democratically then we must play the game of politics.

Complaining and whining that the establishment gave us shit candidates does not further our agenda. We must use the Democrats as leverage to push our agenda until they become something other than traditional democrats (as a matter of winning elections), and instead become progressive, or Democratic Socialists.

This is what we've been doing since 2016 and we've made significant progress, we cannot shoot ourselves in the foot. Get out there and do your part so our kids can have a better country to live in one day, vote for the dems and push our agenda onto them until they cannot get elected unless they go through us.

This shit is chess, not checkers.

TLDR:

Capitalism> Social Democracy> Democratic Socialism.


r/dsa • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion Trump is going to win in 2024 and it ain't even gonna be close.

0 Upvotes

Biden has messed up so bad. His ironclad stand for genocide is too much for me. Next year will be the first year I won't vote for one of the two major candidates in my life. I have always believed in voting for the lesser of two evils, but genocide is a step too far. I will no longer be complicit.

The Arab and Muslim communities are not going to vote for Biden. The younger generation is also turning against Biden because of his stance on Israel/Palestine.

Yes, I believe that Trump might actually win the presidency while sitting in jail.

Looks like Cornel West will probably get my vote, but I definitely won't be voting for Biden(or Trump).


r/dsa • • Sep 25 '26

Discussion DSA’s leadership is ideologically unrepresentative

Thumbnail
jonhochschartner.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/dsa • • May 10 '26

Discussion The Three Arrows Symbol is NOT an Issue

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is something I just need to get off of my chest. I keep seeing everybody yapping about how we shouldn't be using the three arrows symbol because it was created as anti-communist. Listen, I understand the idea behind your critique, I really do, but just think about this for a second:

This symbol is relatively old and has been out of popular use for a while. Hardly any Americans know what it means unless they're tapped into historical politics. The only people who you risk offending with it are yourselves, and clearly that's what's happening. But if we can just get over that for a moment and think about the symbol itself, what is it. It's powerful, it's legible, it's useful, and it's versatile, which are all things that we need to be as well.

This symbol was invented to put us down, that's true, but what else was invented to put people down? Slurs, for instance, were invented to be derogatory and hurt other people, and since then, a number of slurs have become mainstay in the English lexicon. They've been reclaimed, and this isn't something that is just applied to words. The fasces is a symbol stemming from Antiquity, and Mussolini adopted it. He even named his ideology, fascism, after it. However, the symbol didn't fade away into obscurity after he fell, it returned to its place as a standard symbol throughout the western world.

My point is this: we don't need to be up in arms over our comrades using this symbol because

  1. Nobody but us will care

  2. It's incredibly useful and a strong banner for progress

  3. We can reclaim the symbol and give it a new life separate from its past

Agree or disagree, I don't really care, I just needed to get this off my chest. Thank you for hearing me out, at least <3.


r/dsa • • Oct 06 '26

Discussion Update on NYC-YDSA 10/7 Protest

0 Upvotes

So the YDSA chapters of The New School, Hunter College, Lehman, and The City College of NY have all reposted an updated call to protest against Mamdani on October 7th outside city hall.

If you are NYC-DSA & NYC-YDSA…I hope to see you there. I’m more than definitely attending.

One thing that’s interesting to note is that this updated post now has dropped the NYC-YDSA tag from it.

This is making me definitely feel like my suspicions in my previous post were spot on.

Someone at NYC-DSA or even national (basically NYC-DSA) told them to take it down.


r/dsa • • Aug 24 '25

🌹 DSA news The Real Reason American Socialists Don’t Win

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Nov 20 '22

Twitter What happened to student loan forgiveness?

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Aug 03 '26

Discussion I feel like some of the DSA's foreign policy flirts with the "Noble Savage" trope.

19 Upvotes

This was inspired by me seeing some posters/bots on this sub saying that Hamas was "the natural outcome of Zionist imperialism" or something like that. They aren't, they're a genocidal terrorist group that's been propped up by Iran and the Israeli right to keep Palestinian people angry/divided (the PLO's right there if you want an actual Palestinian government to support). However, it did make me think that some of the DSA's proposed ideas to end "American Imperialism" go a little too far and deny the agency of the non-American countries involved; or even the ability of the Western world to be a positive influence (whereas the East can do no wrong, hence the title.)

Specifically the calls to end NATO, American military bases abroad, and especially Ukraine assistance (Russian imperialism is still imperialism, it isn't better just because it isn't Western). NATO and US military bases abroad have been used to advance US interests in the past, but they're also largely defensive in nature. Countries invite the US military in as a bulwark against terrorists, to prevent other nations like Russia from gaining a foothold, or as part of a larger diplomatic deal; we (usually) aren't just forcibly involving ourselves, we're partnering with the local governments. The USA is not uniquely evil, countries are perfectly capable of seeing us as an ally and making mutually beneficial agreements even if they're weaker.

By unilaterally cancelling these agreements and retreating from the world stage, we'd be betraying the trust of our allies and leaving them vulnerable after outsourcing their defense to us. Instead of just isolating ourselves, we should plan on renegotiating our alliances to be more equal. Defensive alliances are a powerful tool for coalition building, we shouldn't toss them away because we're too busy self-flagellating to realize that American influence can be the lesser of two evils.

Edit: Changed the word interference to influence.

Edit 2: all the people defending Hamas and their methods are just proving my point. Groups aren't absolved of morality just because they're weaker and not as Western. Indiscriminate murder and repression is bad when Israel does it, ergo it's bad when Hamas does it. Frankly, it's infantalizing to say that the Palestinian people are incapable of doing any better.


r/dsa • • Sep 12 '20

Democratic Socialists should recognize that a vote for the Hawkins/Walker Left Unity Campaign is a vote against Trump. It's a vote FOR real COVID relief. FOR an EcoSocialist Green New Deal. FOR Medicare For All. A vote for Biden doesn't get us any of those things, because he doesn't support them.

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Oct 11 '24

Discussion No Votes for Genocide

0 Upvotes

Sharing this in case folks haven’t seen this yet and want to sign the pledge: https://actionnetwork.org/petitions/no-votes-for-genocide

There’s lots of coalition cross-chapter organizing happening around this campaign and we’d love for folks to sign and get involved. Pulling all levers to try and stop the war machine.


r/dsa • • 26d ago

Discussion Here's why I agree with the DSA International Committee on the war in Ukraine.

13 Upvotes

Greetings all,

I've noticed that lately many people (or bots) seem to be very confused about the DSA's stance on Ukraine. This is what the DSA International Committee has to say on the matter:

The war in Ukraine is a disaster for working class people in Ukraine, the region, and a terrible threat to us all, including increasing the danger of nuclear war and exacerbating global economic crises. We oppose the Russian invasion and call for the withdrawal of Russian troops through a settled ceasefire agreement. We recognize that the expansion of NATO and the aggressive approach of Western nations have helped cause the crisis and we demand an end to NATO expansion. We also oppose US and NATO military interventionism and the tens of billions in military aid and weapons shipments which only further exacerbates the war and undermine a negotiated settlement, as well as sanctions that will harm ordinary Russians. We call on the US and other countries to welcome refugees fleeing the war and provide needed humanitarian aid.

This seems straightforward and accurate to me, and I totally agree with it: I oppose the war in Ukraine, I oppose the Russian invasion, and I oppose NATO expansion. For some reason that I'm not entirely clear on, having this position seems to upset people. If I say "I'd like the war to end," people tell me that I must want Ukraine to "lose," or that I'm pro-Russia, or that I'm repeating "Kremlin talking points." Someone in this subreddit even called me a homophobic slur for making this point yesterday.

There are a number of ways to approach this issue, but I think it comes down to this: even in DSA, people still want to believe that America is, or can be, some sort of force for good in the world. Sure, maybe America gets things wrong sometimes, but occasionally they'll do something truly heroic, like "help" Ukraine in their war against Russia. I'm here to tell you that you need to let go of this fantasy immediately.

America is not "the good guys." They CAN'T be, in fact, by definition, even occasionally. It is the Anglo-American empire which is primarily responsible for the state of the world post-World War 2. If you think the earth is in bad shape and getting worse, then you primarily have America to blame, along with capitalism/imperialism more broadly.

I'd like to leave you with a few thoughts from Nate Bear now, as this article does a better job of explaining the situation than me:

You don’t have to think that Russia was right to invade Ukraine to try and understand why it invaded Ukraine, a consideration we are never prompted to investigate in a discourse dominated by normative moral judgements viewed exclusively through the lens of western imperialism. The shape of post-2014 Ukraine made Russia fearful that the country could once again be the launchpad for an invasion. And it wasn’t as if Putin hid this fact. He repeatedly warned, into late 2021 and early 2022, that the further militarisation of Ukraine was a red line and if Ukraine and the west refused diplomacy, Russia would act. He hadn’t been that bothered about Ukraine before 2014, there was no war talk, because it wasn’t the threat then that he perceived it became.

Again, this is not a defence of Putin, it is a question of cause and effect, and of the western arrogance and hubris that believes only its red lines on geostrategic issues are valid. Would the US have allowed a military alliance led by China to be built up through South America, reaching Mexico without a response? Would western media have dismissed American concerns about Chinese militarism as paranoid nonsense if Chinese military bases were dotted throughout South America? Of course not! The media would have demanded war and sold us war. But when the roles are reversed, American militarism becomes mere Russian paranoia.

And now the war that NATO expansionism threatened is not just here but is in danger of become a permanent fixture of our lives, with European economies embracing the bloodshed and building war economies. And to build these war economies, the liberal class is demanding more cuts to a welfare state already decimated, in many places, by two decades of austerity.


r/dsa • • Sep 10 '24

DemocRATS 🐀 The DSA must condemn Harris' promise to continue the genocide and pull the US into a war with Iran to protect the genocidaires. No member of the DSA should vote for Harris or any democrat that supports her.

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion DSA has a tankie problem

0 Upvotes

There are way, way too many people in this movement who feel comfortable with historical revisionism vis-a-vis the Soviet Union, China, and other such regimes. And there are way too many people who feel comfortable essentially advocating for an end to democracy.


r/dsa • • Sep 14 '26

Discussion In 2028 AOC should run for the Senate, not for President

0 Upvotes

Not because she isn't a good candidate, but because we would be wasting a good candidate too early. The DSA has only just started to get national momentum, and I get that this is very exciting. But we have only barely shifted the overton window, and even if all of our candidates win in 2026, we will be in the minority in congress. This means that if she won, an AOC presidency would be faced with a lot of promises she would be completely unable to deliver. The general milieu of centrist dems would fuck her over. And if she loses then she doesn't have a seat in congress for at least two years, the DSA will be blamed for whatever the republicans do for the next four years, and we've lost one of our most well known candidates. Instead, I think she should run for the Senate. Few like Chuck Schumer, so I think she has a very strong chance in the primary, and NY is an extremely safe Dem state, so we don't run the risk of her losing the general and no longer being in congress. Additionally, we would have someone in the Senate to take over when Bernie retires, which to be honest he really needs to do. He's almost 90, I'm a fan of his but at a certain point you've gotta retire. This would allow her to represent the DSA on a much more visible scale, push for our policies, and give her a much stronger jumping off point for an eventual presidential run. But that run should happen after we've successfully reshaped the democratic party, not when we've only just gotten in. Right now any kind of pay off to such a bid would be unlikely, and the likelihood and risks of failure would be incredibly high.

Who should we hope for in 2028 then? I'm not sure yet. The midterms aren't over, so we don't even really know who's on the table yet. I'm keeping my eye out for a center-left progressive, but one who is not DSA affiliated and is able to couch their progressivism in normie language. Someone who will vigorously prosecute the present administration, who will dismantle ICE, who will push for strong AI regulation, and who is willing to deal with climate change, and the issues of LGBT people and people of color. That is to say, someone significantly to the left of Kamala Harris, but still slightly to the right of AOC, and without the baggage of being a self-labeled socialist. I am not yet sure who will fill that role, but I suspect more than one person will try.

If AOC runs, I will support her. But I'd much rather back her Senate run than her Presidential run for all the reasons above.

One last slight side track: Some people might ask, can't AOC run and just moderate her positions? My answer is, who wants that? That would be a huge waste of what an AOC presidency could look like at a time when she won't have to do that, and would mostly just piss off the left without winning over the moderates.


r/dsa • • Sep 03 '26

Discussion Struggling to understand why “abolish police” is on the party platform.

3 Upvotes

I’ve been reading through the DSA platform docs, and while I strongly agree with the vast majority of platform positions, I just do not understand why full 100% abolishment of the police is the long term stated goal of the platform with no real discussion of alternatives. To my knowledge, there is no country in the world that has done this, even countries with dramatically lower crime than the US. What happens if there is an active shooter, or a hostage situation? Who arrests executives that broke the law? Who enforces the law in general?

Dramatically decrease police budgets? Sure! Fully reform and replace with new police units? Also makes sense. Demilitarize, civilian oversight, reduced power of police unions - all great. But outright abolishment with no police, I just don’t even understand what this looks like in reality and based off the complete lack of details it seems like the party doesn’t have a real vision either. It makes me seriously worried because this is such an extremely easy attack point on DSA candidates, it’s a massive albatross to tie around our neck. Can anyone offer some insight here?


r/dsa • • Dec 01 '25

RAISING HELL Why is Mamdani backing Jeffries for house speaker?

2 Upvotes

Not only is it that mamdani didn’t support the primary challenge but he also backing Jeffries becoming speaker of the House. This is problematic as Jeffries is against everything mamdani stands for: Jeffries voted to condemn socialism and he is a hardcore israel stooge who takes massive aipac donations.

Source:

“On NBC’s “Meet the Press" a day later, Mamdani said if Democrats take control of the House in the 2026 midterm elections, he would support Jeffries remaining the party leader, which would make Jeffries speaker of the House.”

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2025/11/29/zohran-mamdani-mainstream-jeffries-transition/87489060007/

List of Democrats who voted to condemn socialism as Mamdani came to dc (includes Jeffries): https://www.newsweek.com/full-list-of-democrats-voting-to-condemn-socialism-as-mamdani-comes-to-town-11088383


r/dsa • • Mar 20 '26

Shitpost Social Democracy fans when they can't exploit the Global South

Thumbnail gallery
21 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Aug 27 '25

Discussion Refusing to criticize non-western imperialism just starts the cycle again.

4 Upvotes

A certain sect of leftists (DSA Left typically) have engaged with this inane "campist" ideology to define their geo-political worldview. This has led to a large number of us unable to see a non-western country actively doing terrible shit. I'll be focusing on China for this post.

China

China, for many years, with very easy ways to search, even WITHIN it's own sources, is not socialist in any tangible way that benefits workers.

Taiwan is an obvious starting point. It has been decades since the war, and yet China still believes it has the right to an island that has clearly said it's not interested. Despite this, leftists blindly support China in this matter.

The Uhygyrs, an undeniable genocide and assimilation attempt by the CCP. Ex-prisoners have explained how fucking terrible it is right now, and despite this, I have five braindead Leninists come up to me every time I say this to show me a propaganda video made by the CCP. (Yes, the state owned media is making videos directed by the state, to benefit the state.)

The Great Firewall, sadly something that seems to be coming to the west soon. Which is also bad. China has had this wretched thing for a while though, it's the world's biggest censorship machine. This is not "western propoganda", this system exists, you can find the law about it passing, and how it restricts the freedoms of Chinese citizens. Any "socialist" country that fails to give their citizens freedom of information are failed states.

They are attempting to control the entire narrative of a religion. The CCP's attempts to select the next Dalai Lama are well-documented and terrible. This is a blatant attempt to secure control over Tibet, which I'll remind all of you, China forcefully Invaded in the 50's.

This is terrible. How are we "liberators of the downtrodden" if we ignore the plight of people under governments that vaugly have associations with socialism? I ask the PLAdocuhes of the crowd to PLEASE get their head out of their bloated self-serving asses for five seconds.

(Before some pedantic bag of horse excrement comments this, yes I know they sometimes go by the "CPC" instead.)


r/dsa • • Aug 12 '26

Discussion Caution

3 Upvotes

I am deeply sympathetic to the cause but Megan Romer is a terrible messenger and should be replaced. The New Yorker interview confirms every enemy’s worst assumptions.

Lack of specifics and command of the conversation + defensive posture is political malpractice


r/dsa • • Apr 23 '23

Class Struggle Russian soldiers beg for help as own army throws them into pit

Thumbnail
news.yahoo.com
0 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Dec 08 '23

Electoral Politics Done with voteing for the lesser evil? Vote against the 2 party oligarchy!

5 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Jul 26 '23

Electoral Politics AOC Is Just a Regular Old Democrat Now

Thumbnail
nymag.com
15 Upvotes

r/dsa • • Sep 09 '25

Discussion Zohran Mamdani capitulating on 'globalize the intifada" is a mistake

0 Upvotes

In a recent interview with Al Sharpton, Mamdani disavowed the phrase 'globalize the intifada' and said he'd discourage others from using it. (As a reminder, the 'intifada' in this context means Palestinian uprising against colonial / imperialist oppression by the Zionist state.)

By disavowing the phrase, he's essentially ceding rhetorical ground to Zionism, implying the illegitimacy of Palestinian resistance against violent imperial oppression. This move undermines American left-wing solidarity with Palestine. Furthermore, it has the effect of entrapping Mamdani within the rhetorical bind that entraps all milquetoast liberals - he's now going to try to defend Palestinian "rights" while implicitly delegitimizing their resistance, which essentially means to disavow their rights: This wishy-washy sort of equivocation has the effect of pissing everyone off.

Americans today want bold statements of belief, even if those statements ruffle feathers, because they are sick of stage-managed politicians who speak out of both sides of their mouths. We will win where we are able to offer our moral vision clearly and unapologetically. Prominent socialists like Mamdani should take occasions like this as an opportunity to educate the public on the meaning of the word 'intifada' and to reaffirm the rights of oppressed people to resist oppression.

Edit: Strangely a variety of people are interpreting this as an anti-Mamdani post. It's not. I like him a lot and would vote for him if I were in NYC. This is simply a discussion about rhetoric that I believe is relevant to our politics more broadly.


r/dsa • • Jan 03 '26

Shitpost This sub is a compromised garbage heap littered with Liberal wet napkins. Also, "Eco Libertarian Socialist" lol.

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

Let's not mention the throttling of the Venezuelan economy the past 2 decades. No no, we need to return to the paradise of the 4th republic.