I'm a jazz drummer with a background in marching band. I love all of kinds of jazz, but especially bebop. I'm a fan of jazz fusion, and also love funk. I'm a huge fan of classic rock - Bill Ward and Mitch Mitchell are amazing. Outside of that stuff, I actually quite a bit of 90s alt rock like Smashing Pumpkins and punk - Travis & Chad Sexton incorporating their marching band background with rudiments is cool to me. I also like plenty of prog metal like Animals as Leaders, Meshuggah, Opeth, Tool, Jinjer, Porcupine Tree, and Between the Buried and Me. I'm a fan of Virgil Donati, Thomas Lang, and Marco Minnemann,
Joe Morello, Sonny Payne, Steve Gadd, Jeff Porcaro, Simon Philips, Chris Coleman, Vinnie Colaiuta, etc., are my favorites. I also enjoy watching and playing a good linear drum shed, a la gospel chops. Latin drumming is insane to me with the limb independence and dynamics.
However, Mike Portnoy is back in the news because he rejoined Dream Theater, and he's now got a Drumeo special. No matter what I do, I can't get into his style. It seems "easy" and juvenile to me. Portnoy in my view, never places ghost notes, never can lay down a nice consistent groove, lacks proper dynamics, and almost never employee any cool rudimental flair on the kit.
This is contrast to Mike Mangini whose technique was far more finesse and he was a master of his rudiments and dynamics, and often used ghost notes. I really liked Mangini's live performances as part of Dream Theater. Neil Peart may have been stiff, but he studied his rudiments even to the point of learning traditional grip quite well, and at least tried to swing.
Portnoy can also be sloppy live, not as bad as Lars, but directionally there. And his technique is really unrefined and he's a hard hitter without much nuance. And his drum parts seem busy in a bad way, sounding like the audio version of a word salad. In contrast, Animals as Leaders has very busy drumming but not in an obnoxious sounding way.
Maybe I'm holding Portnoy to too high a standard, but he's often praised as one of the world's best drummers and is in a band known for their technical prowess. Yes, he can weave in and out of complex time signature changes and has a mean single stroke roll with the hands and double bass, but mechanically he is lacking in my eyes.
What am I missing?