r/drums • • Sep 16 '24 Heart of Silver

META Please no more "Is this a good deal??" Posts

26 Upvotes

This subreddit is nothing but pricing posts lately and not trying to be a dick but how hard is it to Google comps?? People know this and post here instead. Okay you know the make so just search on eBay or reverb and there's your answer. "Is this a good deal??? Derrr" should not allow these posts any more here imo.


r/drums • • Sep 06 '24

Discussion LPT: When ordering multiple items from Sweetwater, always break up the items into separate orders

5 Upvotes

This way you get more candy. If it meets free shipping, I don’t order multiple items together, I always break them up cause I love Bit O Honeys


r/drums • • Mar 07 '24

Discussion don't reinforce the drummer stereotype

0 Upvotes

For the love of god, proofread your posts on r/drums. No subreddit has the volume of silly typos, grammar failures and indecipherable posts and replies as this one. We are not illiterate goons, do better! Break the stereotype!

edit: truly taken back by the volume of Oxford comma snobs here!

2nd edit: OK OK I might be missing a comma! but you're still snobs LOL. I'm harping on the folks posting pure gibberish/autocorrect nightmares with zero care.

3rd edit: Jesus H Christ people....this isn't contract law, the missing comma doesn't make my point ambiguous LOL....rest easy knowing I've earned zero karma here! happy drumming everyone!


r/drums • • Nov 23 '25

Unpopular opinion: Stop giving advice you don’t have and actively critiquing drummers in a universe of ability you aren’t anywhere close to yet

25 Upvotes

Did I read that other post correctly? Did somebody here actually critique Yoni’s playing and technique?? That is a new low, even for this sub.

Here’s the most priceless piece of advice that I already know some of you will hate hearing but I assure will make you a far better drummer otherwise. Focus on yourself. Build the tools, technique, etc you need to acquire to be the drummer you want to be. We’re not doing this for others. We’re doing this for ourselves. There are so many different arenas one can take this relationship and so many gradations of ability along the way. Wherever you land is fine, as long as that’s where you want to be.

Edit for clarification/TL;DR:

NO, YONI IS NOT ABOVE CRITICISM, ADVICE, or CRITIQUE. NEITHER IS ANYONE ELSE.

IT’S THAT YOUR PARTICULAR CRITIQUE/ADVICE IS LIKELY IRRELEVANT AND COULD BE KEPT TO YOURSELF WHEN IT HAS NOT BEEN REQUESTED. (no, not actually all of you but you get my point…some of you here offer advice sparingly and are skillful in re: to presenting it but the vast majority aren’t)

Like Yoni and anyone else within a variation of “elite-level” is just gonna go to Elitch or someone who’s not a part-time edgelord when he needs some pointers. Sorry if that hurts your feelings!!

Love the drumming community and I love the drums 🥁


r/drums • • Jan 09 '24

Discussion As a jazz drummer, it's difficult for me to appreciate Mike Portnoy. I dislike his lack of ghost notes, rudiments, grooves, and dynamics. What am I missing?

5 Upvotes

I'm a jazz drummer with a background in marching band. I love all of kinds of jazz, but especially bebop. I'm a fan of jazz fusion, and also love funk. I'm a huge fan of classic rock - Bill Ward and Mitch Mitchell are amazing. Outside of that stuff, I actually quite a bit of 90s alt rock like Smashing Pumpkins and punk - Travis & Chad Sexton incorporating their marching band background with rudiments is cool to me. I also like plenty of prog metal like Animals as Leaders, Meshuggah, Opeth, Tool, Jinjer, Porcupine Tree, and Between the Buried and Me. I'm a fan of Virgil Donati, Thomas Lang, and Marco Minnemann,

Joe Morello, Sonny Payne, Steve Gadd, Jeff Porcaro, Simon Philips, Chris Coleman, Vinnie Colaiuta, etc., are my favorites. I also enjoy watching and playing a good linear drum shed, a la gospel chops. Latin drumming is insane to me with the limb independence and dynamics.

However, Mike Portnoy is back in the news because he rejoined Dream Theater, and he's now got a Drumeo special. No matter what I do, I can't get into his style. It seems "easy" and juvenile to me. Portnoy in my view, never places ghost notes, never can lay down a nice consistent groove, lacks proper dynamics, and almost never employee any cool rudimental flair on the kit.

This is contrast to Mike Mangini whose technique was far more finesse and he was a master of his rudiments and dynamics, and often used ghost notes. I really liked Mangini's live performances as part of Dream Theater. Neil Peart may have been stiff, but he studied his rudiments even to the point of learning traditional grip quite well, and at least tried to swing.

Portnoy can also be sloppy live, not as bad as Lars, but directionally there. And his technique is really unrefined and he's a hard hitter without much nuance. And his drum parts seem busy in a bad way, sounding like the audio version of a word salad. In contrast, Animals as Leaders has very busy drumming but not in an obnoxious sounding way.

Maybe I'm holding Portnoy to too high a standard, but he's often praised as one of the world's best drummers and is in a band known for their technical prowess. Yes, he can weave in and out of complex time signature changes and has a mean single stroke roll with the hands and double bass, but mechanically he is lacking in my eyes.

What am I missing?


r/drums • • Oct 11 '25

Playing for my students at the end of the class.

13 Upvotes

r/drums • • Mar 11 '23

Discussion I got told there is no way i play drums cuz I'm a girl. what's your opinion ?

0 Upvotes

r/drums • • Oct 20 '23

Question Anyone else find Neil Peart overrated?

0 Upvotes

Obviously a great drummer, but also often rated as one of the best ever.... I just don't see why he's considered by many to be the greatest drummer ever.


r/drums • • Sep 23 '21

Discussion My experience with Matt Garstka

0 Upvotes

As some of you already know, Matt switched from Tama to DW recently. And personally, I thought that was pretty cool, as DW is one of my favorite drum companies. I started scrolling through the comments on his Instagram post, and saw a plethora of other famous drummers congratulating him, and angry Tama fans mad about his new endorsement, and etcetera. One comment was by Matt Greiner, congratulating him, and Thomas Pridgen replied saying "now it's time to switch to Zildjian". And there were about 10 other people saying things like "Meinl > Zildjian" and pointing out that Matt Garstka had like 3 signature models with Meinl. I decided to reply and said "Meinl is the way to go bro" in a friendly tone, and Thomas Pridgen replied to me something along the lines of "and who the hell are you? Quit acting like you're Dave Weckl" so I replied to him "I have to be famous to talk to you? Your blue checkmark means nothing, get off your high horse" and Matt Garstka replied to me "the only one on their high horse is you, and the blue checkmark might not make him important, but the fact that he's Thomas Fucking Pridgen does, show him some fucking respect" I tried responding to the both of them, along the lines of "how about instead of ganging up on me, we talk this out level headed like men". I got no responses. A while later, I checked back, and saw that my replies were deleted. I replied to Matt "you just lost a fan" and now I'm blocked by both of them. I honestly have no idea what I could have possibly said that got them so irritated, but I won't be listening to Animals As Leaders possibly ever again, and I sure as hell am not supporting Thomas Pridgen. I'm posting this, to let you guys know how these guys think it's ok to treat their fans.


r/drums • • Oct 20 '23

Discussion Hot take: these "are they worth it" posts are lame

0 Upvotes

Just do your own research and figure out if they're worth it.

Edit: ok, I just realized there's a "drumming" subreddit in addition to the "drums" one. I'm thinking I've just been in the wrong place. I guess if there's both it makes sense to post gear questions here and I should just stfu about it.


r/drums • • Jun 05 '26

Question Where does Fishman rank in the pantheon of drummers?

11 Upvotes

I have a friend who is crazy into Phish that tells me Fishman is one of the greatest drummers of all time. While I haven’t dug incredibly deep into Phish’s catalog, what I have heard makes me wonder why he’d say that. I can think of 100 drummers I’d put ahead of him.

Who is the crazy one here?


r/drums • • Feb 18 '23

Question Does this need replacing if I don’t hit this side?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/drums • • Jun 29 '26

Question What's a controversial opinion you have about drumming or drum education?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/drums • • Mar 31 '24

Kit Pic Getting the kit right for Trans Day of Visibility 🏳️‍⚧️

Thumbnail
gallery
856 Upvotes

After a lot of back and forth, this is going to be my main setup for most of my lower-dynamic/jazzier gigs.

15” Agop signature hats 22” Murat Diril golden jazz ride 24” Bosphorus K old stamp tribute ride 14x5.5 sugar percussion aluminum guy Sonor aqx jungle kit (16” bass drum one?)


r/drums • • Aug 01 '25

Am I the only one who doesn't really understand the Everlong hype? I've seen the 8 millionth Facebook Musicians Wanted ad, where a guy was playing this, either with a previous band or alone in his basement

0 Upvotes

Remove if this falls under toxicity. but I'm puzzled. are we really that impressed over a 150-160ish barrage of 16th notes with a chorus that rests your hands somewhat? why is it apparently the apex of what so many people can do? I don't mean to knock people earlier in their music journey than me. it's just that lots of these ads say 10+ years of experience. it indicates a lack of curiosity and unwillingness to improve. I'm not advocating everyone play a 270 BPM blast beat with diarrhea bass drum nonsense. but I want to see people reaching for the stars more than this

If I see one more ad like this, I'm going to scream. I'd be embarrassed if that's the best I could do 10 years in


r/drums • • Jul 08 '26

Discussion Can I play your drums?

0 Upvotes

The other night at a bar, a friend introduced me to a someone and when they found out I was in a band they got all excited and wanted to know when our next gig is. They then mentioned they always wanted to play drums and asked if they could play my kit “for fun” at the show. They got a very abrupt, “No, you should sign up for lessons or buy a kit if you want to do that…” which left a very confused look on their face. I then quickly excused myself and left (I was heading out anyways). I’ve also had this convo at gigs and unless it’s a young earnest-looking kid, it’s a hard no. Anyone else have to deal with clueless folks and drums.


r/drums • • Aug 05 '26

Cam/Video Trakian Cymbals are really great! Loving them so far.

9 Upvotes

r/drums • • Mar 17 '24

Discussion DW is overrated

0 Upvotes

There, i have said it. Don't get me wrong, they Sound amazing. They sound so amazing, that i find it somehow boring. Edit: boring doesn't mean that its tremendously bad. I like them. Because they sound so good, they mostly sound the same which leads to them lacking in uniquness if that makes sense.


r/drums • • Jul 07 '25

So I made the old people on Facebook even more mad this time

11 Upvotes

r/drums • • Jun 17 '26

Discussion I think Thomas Haake (Meshuggah) is a VERY underrated drummer.

19 Upvotes

When going on reddit posts and instagram coments about the greatest drummers of all time, i never see Tomas Haake and it genuinelly blow my mind.
The guy is a machine i think he is the greatest drummer of all time. I dont give much credit for drummers with influence, if your an ok drummer but are in a very famous band your going to influence people for playing drums and its not connected to skill or anything, more like luck. so skill is i think the only way to compare drummers and Tomas is the best undeniably. What do you think?

NOTE: Im not saying that Tomas is bad or anything. from my experience i dont see many people talking about him on the more " mainstream" side of drumming, only the metal circles. On the metal scene he is a god no doubt, but im talking about the more popular side.


r/drums • • Jul 11 '24

Discussion People shit on Lars. But is it justified to say the studio recording drum tracks on AJFA are nothing short of incredible, legendary, and iconic?

0 Upvotes

People shit on Lars all the time for his sloppy live playing the past few decades, refusal to practice, fills in weird places, and inability to keep tempo while playing live. Lars-isms is a real thing.

But I feel this is more about Lars' live playing and St. Anger snare than about his actual studio recording on his first few albums?

If you didn't tell me the drummer was Lars and I heard AJFA blind, I'd think the drummer was incredible. Blackened, Dyer's Eve, Harvester of Sorrow, The Shortest Straw, The Frayed Ends of Sanity, And Justice for All, and One all have incredible drum tracks. In that they complement and serve the songs super well, are creative and unique, and super fun to play. And they can be technical at parts - such as fun 16th note bass triplets in One or Harvester of Sorrow. The fills seem well placed and complement the music and song drumming such as The Frayed Ends of Sanity is actually SUPER GROOVY and tasty?? I didn't expect from Lars. And the over the bar line fills actually aren't gratuitous and make sense. And he's using DYNAMICS?

The double bass sextuplets in One are absolutely iconic and legendary. And I love the dynamic 7/4 tom groove in And Justice For All. There are people who do drum covers on YouTube, and when they cover Dyer's Eve or Blackened well, I give them huge applause as they've clearly demonstrated skill.

Am I wrong to hold Lars in such high esteem for the AJFA studio drum recordings? Maybe there was studio magic, but the output is great? I also like his drumming in Master of Puppets, Right the Lightning, and Kill Em' All. Also even the Black Album has some banger tracks like Ender Sandman is iconic for the toms, and Sad But True has iconic great sounding snare hits and fills.

Even on newer studio recording songs like Cyanide or Moth into Flame, I like the drumming on it. Not AFJA level, but it's cool sounding.

Am I correct to feel this way? Blackened is also quite technical with time signature changes including what sounds like 7/4 or even 7/8 depending how you count it. A second rate drummer couldn't execute those correctly, even on a recording. At the very least, he's a great composer for drum arrangements.


r/drums • • Sep 29 '25

Expensive snare drums are overrated - debate!

4 Upvotes

The most expensive snare drum I own is a 13x7 Tama SLP G-Force maple. It retails for about $500 USD, routinely sells used for $250-350. I own it because it was local for $89. I don’t think I would’ve paid the going used price for it, to be honest. It’s my most expensive snare but not my favorite. I think my 70s Supraphonic holds that honor presently.

So, like most of you, I will drool over fancy snares on Reverb / marketplace / etc… however, I’m convinced everyone could have their favorite snare sound for no more than $300 on the used market. I’ll go further to suggest that 80-90% of all drummers could probably satisfy their ear for less than $200.

I’m wondering where other players are on this spectrum. Are you cruising around with a $100 Acrolite and totally satisfied or did you need to spend $800+ to get your dream snare? If so- was it worth it?

EDIT: I’m surprised at how many replies misinterpreted the post as “cheap snares are better than expensive snares”. That was never the debate. The central thesis is that spending a fortune on a snare drum is a fantastic way to support the craftsmen who make them, but that you probably won’t get any more utility out of your drum than you would from a used snare in the sub-$300 range. I’m not hating on anyone, just genuinely curious what others’ experiences have been on their own tone quests!


r/drums • • Jun 19 '25

Y'all like my hi hat

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/drums • • Nov 10 '23

Question PSA: Stop asking health related questions here, go see a Doctor instead!

0 Upvotes

This is a drums sub, we are not doctors.