Hey everyone, I recently tried using AI to create a product video for a moisturizer I’m selling. It’s my first time experimenting with AI video tools, and I was really curious to see how well it could capture the vibe and highlights of the product.
The video includes the key benefits, ingredient highlights, and a bit of a lifestyle feel—trying to make it engaging and appealing without a huge budget or professional shoot.
Would love to get your honest feedback on the video! Do you think AI-made content like this could work well for dropshipping product ads? Any tips on improving it or other tools you think I should check out? Appreciate any advice or thoughts!
About 6 weeks ago, a store owner reached out to us completely overwhelmed.
PayPal and Shopify Payments had both placed holds on his accounts
Refund requests were piling up
His supplier wasn't always answering him mid-scale
Support was chaos, spreadsheets, DMs, no tracking, angry customers
He had solid products and performing ads, but his backend was wrecking the business.
📸 Attached is the dashboard from his last 30 days: €62,182 in sales | 1,154 orders | 2.5% CVR (Sharing with permission, cropped to keep it clean.)
Here’s what changed 👇
📦 He stopped gambling on fulfillment He shifted to a centralized backend that allowed:
Order processing from one place
Quotations & sourcing within hours
Real-time ticketing for returns, reships, and after-sales issues
This removed 80% of his manual workload for him and his team, and disputes dropped fast.
🛠️ He fixed post-purchase, not just his ads Most sellers think fixing ROAS = growth. But backend chaos kills growth quietly. When his support process improved and customers got actual updates + quick reships, the chargebacks stopped too.
📊 He started thinking like a brand, not a product tester Better logistics → happier customers → fewer complaints → Payment processors calmed down → Ads kept scaling
💡 Lesson:
Scaling is easy. Sustaining it is backend.
If you’re doing 10+ orders/day and still managing fulfillment across WhatsApp, spreadsheets, and hope... it’s just a matter of time before something breaks.
Get your backend right. It’s the most important part of running a real business, especially in 2025.
Disclosure: I'm the founder of EcomSniper. This story came from a call I had with one of our users.
I had a call recently with a 27-year-old guy who had been doing eBay dropshipping for about two weeks.
He works in a factory.
He was literally getting ready to leave for his 9-5 after our call.
And he had a goal:
$30,000/month.
But what was interesting was the questions he was asking me.
He wanted to know about running multiple eBay accounts.
How do you set them up?
How do you prepare them?
How many should you have?
Should he create backups now?
He was basically trying to figure out the infrastructure he'd need once he became a big seller.
Eventually I stopped him.
I said:
You're asking the wrong questions.
You're two weeks into this.
Why are you worrying about account #10 when account #1 hasn't made you $1,000 yet?
And I understood exactly why he was doing it.
Because I've done the same thing.
About 10 years ago, I was working security.
I remember getting paid around $800 every two weeks.
Payday would come.
I'd pay my bills.
And then I'd basically be broke again waiting for the next cheque.
I also worked in a factory for a little while.
I was standing beside a conveyor belt putting things into boxes over and over again.
I remember looking at the people around me and wondering:
How do you do this for eight hours every day?
I started talking to the people beside me.
Manager came over.
"No talking."
Couldn't put headphones in either.
Just stand there and work.
So when this guy told me he was about to leave our call and go to his factory job, I understood why he was thinking about $30k/month.
When you're somewhere you desperately want to escape from, you don't dream about making an extra $500.
You dream about completely changing your life.
But I think that desperation can make you focus on the wrong things.
You start researching:
How to scale.
How to hire.
How to automate.
How to run 10 accounts.
How to build the company you'll supposedly need when you're making $30k/month.
Meanwhile, you haven't figured out how to make your first $1,000.
So I told him:
Forget $30k.
Forget 10 accounts.
Your entire goal right now should be:
Make one account work.
Get it to $1,000-$2,000/month.
Because if you can't make one work, having 10 doesn't solve anything.
10 x $0 is still $0.
Actually, it's worse than $0 because now you have 10 times the complexity.
But if you learn how to make one account consistently profitable, now you have something valuable.
You've built a machine once.
Then we can talk about building machine #2.
Then #3.
Then #5.
Then #10.
And I realized this applies to almost every business.
Beginners LOVE advanced problems.
Advanced problems are exciting.
"How do I manage 50 employees?"
"How do I scale Facebook ads to $100k/day?"
"How do I expand internationally?"
"How do I structure my company when I'm doing $10M/year?"
These questions make you feel like an entrepreneur.
But sometimes they're just sophisticated procrastination.
The problem actually sitting in front of you might be:
Get one customer.
Make one sale.
Get one store profitable.
Make your first $1,000.
Find one acquisition channel that works.
Hire one good employee.
And only after you've solved that problem do you earn the next one.
There was another thing I told him that I've started believing more and more:
The best business for you isn't necessarily the business with the biggest opportunity.
It might be the business where you have the best access to knowledge.
I gave him an example.
If your older brother is making millions on Amazon and he's willing to sit beside you every day and teach you exactly what he knows, I'd seriously consider learning Amazon.
Even if someone on YouTube tells you another business model has better margins.
Because the person beside you who has already solved your problems is an enormous advantage.
Everything is hard when you don't know what you're doing.
Then you learn.
Then what used to feel impossible becomes normal.
So maybe instead of asking:
"What's the easiest business?"
A better question is:
"Where do I have the biggest learning advantage?"
Who can I ask when I'm stuck?
Who has already made the mistakes I'm about to make?
Who can look at what I'm doing and tell me:
"You're worrying about the wrong thing."
By the end of our call, the guy completely changed the way he was thinking about it.
He basically said:
Okay.
I'll focus on getting the first account working.
Then when I'm making $1k-$3k/month, I'll come back and worry about the next step.
Exactly.
I think there's a simple lesson in that:
Don't build the infrastructure for the success you haven't achieved yet.
I was losing my mind watching this competitor absolutely dominate our niche for three months straight.
At first, I thought they got funding. New videos dropping every other day - Facebook ads, TikTok, Instagram Reels. Not just one version either. They had 4-5 different hooks for the SAME product. Different angles, different intros, testing everything simultaneously.
I'm sitting here scripting one video per week like an idiot while they're flooding every platform.
So I did what any obsessed founder would do. I started stalking them. Checked their LinkedIn team page (still just 3 people), looked at their funding history (bootstrapped), even joined their email list to see if they mentioned their process.
Nothing.
Then I got weirdly specific. Started analyzing their video metadata, looking at publishing patterns, trying to spot editing styles. That's when I noticed something: their spokesperson was TOO consistent. Same lighting, same background, same energy across 40+ videos that dropped over 6 weeks.
That's when it clicked this wasn't a real person.
Fell down a rabbit hole researching ai video tools. Found threads about people using n8n workflows to automate content. Someone casually mentioned connecting it to Argil for the video generation part, then Eleven Labs for voice.
Tested it last Tuesday.
Uploaded my product shots and wrote 5 different hooks. Picked an avatar that actually looks like it could be from our brand. Three hours later I had 15 finished videos. Variations I would've normally spent 2-3 weeks coordinating with freelancers, giving feedback, waiting for revisions.
Two of those videos are already outperforming everything I've posted in the last month...
I genuinely feel like I am onto something the industry knows but nobody's talking about publicly. Like everyone's quietly building these systems while the rest of us are stuck in 2019 workflows.
I have a coworker who's old with a horrible lifestyle and I was watching a kid called Juliano Masserali sell this life insurance thing and it sounded kinda cool. When I saw him coughing it sparked a brilliant idea and I sent him a proposal and got this horrible response.
hey guys i’ve been doing high ticket dropshipping since late 2021, and tbh I've found much more consistent results compared to aliexpress dropshipping.
US suppliers with fast shipping, quality products, and google ads
if anyone wants to know more, feel free to drop a follow on twitter @ ecomTrevor
Day 1 Opened my laptop. Told myself I had to stop guessing. No more random TikTok products. No more testing random crap. I needed to see where the money was actually flowing.
Day 2 Started checking ads in Germany. Big buying power. I filtered only the ones spending over 200€ per day, and doing it for 2+ weeks. Because if they’re spending like that, it’s working. Period.
Day 3 Found a product that looked promising. Then I checked if it was being tested in France.
I was looking for this:
Low ad spend (under 50€/day)
Campaigns less than a week old
Boring creatives
Generic-looking store
That’s when I knew I had a shot.
Day 4 Picked the product. Made my own offer: Sell at €29.99 Cost was $4.70 + $1.99 shipping from AliExpress Ran a “Buy 2, Get 1 Free” deal
That offer alone made the math crazy good. Margin was strong, AOV went up, and people love bundles that feel like they’re getting more than they pay for.
Day 5–6 Built a simple store. Nothing fancy. Used better images, tweaked the copy, added a free PDF bonus to increase perceived value. Launched edited versions of the competitor’s ads to test fast.
Day 7 Cha-ching. First sale. Then another.
Not a massive win, but mentally it changed everything. Once you get one sale, you stop doubting. You just want to push harder.
If you're stuck at zero, I get it. Been there. If you want me to share the tools I used to find the ads and check which products were scaling, happy to drop them in the comments.
My name is Matteo, and yes, believe it or not, I made this money.
I was once like some people I didn’t believe it either.
But I tried, and in 64 days, I earned exactly $12,367.
Now, I run 3 faceless Instagram pages with only 42k followers, and I’m aiming to make $17k in February.
I focus on the business & entrepreneurship, content creation, and personal development niches.
I’m also planning to hire someone to create and manage additional Instagram pages.
These products include e-books, video courses, audio courses, prompt packs, templates, Notion templates, checklists, tool stacks, workbooks and more.
And there are over 1,000 products across 67 different niches.
Recently, I launched a page with lifetime access to all the digital products I sell. I’ll be sharing tips on how to promote them and how to beat the Instagram algorithm.
I'm looking to have as much information as possible about marketing or business or dropshipping so I want to start AI dropshipping but I'm looking if there another option out their that might have more success or long term money so I'm delighted to know your opinions
Last month I hit $30K in sales. On the surface, it looked like my dream finally came true. I stared at my Shopify dashboard every day, watching the revenue number go up, thinking, “this is it.” I told my family, felt proud for once, even allowed myself to relax a little, even started planning a trip
Then I checked the real numbers. And it crushed me.
Ads ate thousands. Shipping was worse than I expected. Refunds kept coming in. Even tiny things like app fees and transaction charges stacked up until they swallowed everything. I thought I had a big win, but in the end, there was barely anything left.
I realized the Shopify dashboard isn’t enough. From reading stories of other dropshippers here on Reddit, I learned about using deeper tools to track what’s really under the iceberg. Some folks recommended TrueProfit, so I’m giving it a try. No outstanding outcomes yet, but at least I know the exact expenses I kept missing. Has anyone here used it, is it worth paying for, or are there other beginner-friendly tools I should know about?
At the end of the day, I’m left wondering if this is just how dropshipping works: big sales on the surface but nothing left at the bottom. And if it’s not, how do you guys here actually push through those low points without burning out? Pls help, I need your ideas!
Anybody telling you dropshipping is an easy way to make money these days is straight up lying.
I say that with 100% confidence after 3 years in the game.
To make it work, you have to pour in a ridiculous amount of effort into product research, store design, ad testing, and customer service. It’s just like any other business and there’s nothing easy about any of it.
And here’s the part most people don’t talk about: getting sales is one thing, but getting PROFIT is another. Between rising ad costs, shipping fees, refunds, and a hundred of other costs, a 35% margin is pretty much a dream. Most stores are barely breaking even or sitting around 10–15% at best.
That’s the reality check people need before quitting their job thinking they’re about to become the next dropshipping millionaire. Most of us are grinding hard just to stay profitable.
And that’s also why I’m part of Profit Lab, a newsletter that doesn’t sell you fantasies. We talk about the real mistakes, real numbers, and what it actually takes to build a profitable dropshipping business today (from people who are still in the trenches).
If you’re tired of fake success stories and shallow advice, you’ll probably enjoy what we’re putting out in Profit Lab. Check it out.
Dropshipping isn't the place to make an account and get sales the first day.
Or the first month, or even the first year.
I turned $200 into 5K through sports betting, went into dropshipping and paid 2 mentors for 24/7 help on rotation, ads, store building AI, product finding and hours of youtube videos.
I gradually lost all my money with a pat on the back that "It's a hard journey not everyone will win first try".
Which is inherently true, but had i kept gambling I could've been up by another $20K looking at the protectory or back to 0$, which is impossible because i only spend 10% of my income sports betting.
Which is what I'm going to do right after this post back at 0$. So my advice, Dropshipping is only a tool once you already have an established business, not a get rich quick scheme which you're much better off gambling.
ive scaled stores to $100k/day the first week after launching, $30k days immediately after launching, up to $10,000 on the first day of testing products, $250k+ months, etc. Ive also taught thousands upon thousands of people dropshipping with tons of success storys and have a decent sized YT channel showing my entire process. AMA
I posted these results of Walmart accounts run by my team 2 days back, and everyone thought that I was going to teach or here to sell some course. That is not what i posted for. I just wanted to share my experience working on Walmart dropshipping with various clients around the world, and want anyone else to get started with, where our team can help them grow on Walmart dropshipping by assisting them in developing their account, getting rapid sales on and eventually making profits. Let me know if anyone is interested in getting started on Walmart.
Last month our Meta ads were absolutely crushing it. CTR up 40%, CPC down, engagement through the roof. I'm literally texting screenshots to my co-founder like "we finally figured it out."
Then he sends me a Slack message at 11pm: "dude why are 3,000 people clicking our ad from Vietnam at 3am?"
They weren't people. They were bots. And Meta charged us for every single one.
How we figured out something was wrong
Our Shopify analytics told a completely different story than our Meta dashboard. We had 14,000+ clicks that:
Bounced in under 2 seconds
Never scrolled even 1%
Never moved their mouse
Obviously never bought anything
But Meta's dashboard? Everything looked perfect. Their fraud detection saw nothing wrong.
The patterns that exposed the bots
The timing was too perfect Real people are messy. They click at random times. We noticed 2,847 clicks happening at EXACTLY :00, :15, :30, and :45 of every hour. Down to the second. Humans don't work like that.
The geography was impossible 380 clicks from Ashburn, Virginia in 4 minutes. That's where AWS has their main data center. When we checked the IPs, they were literally data center addresses, not residential internet.
We also found clicks from the same "person" in Singapore at 2:34pm, then London at 2:34pm (4 seconds later). Unless someone invented teleportation to click ads, that's fraud.
Zero actual engagement GA4 showed these "engaged" visitors had:
0% scroll depth
No mouse movement (we use Hotjar)
Session duration under 2 seconds
Even if someone hates your page, they take 4-6 seconds to realize it and leave. Bots just check if the page loads and bounce instantly.
Same browser fingerprint 6,200 clicks from the EXACT same browser setup. Chrome 91, Windows 10, 1920x1080 screen, no plugins, English-US. All identical.
The odds of 6,200 different people having byte-for-byte identical browser configurations? Basically impossible.
Getting Meta to actually refund us
First dispute? Rejected. Meta said the traffic "appeared legitimate."
So we built a 37-page document with irrefutable proof:
Server timestamps didn't match Meta reported clicks that happened BEFORE our server saw the traffic. We documented 3,400+ instances where their timestamp was 2-8 seconds before ours. Time doesn't flow backwards.
Data center IPs everywhere We ran every IP through AbuseIPDB and found 11,200+ clicks from DigitalOcean, AWS, OVH, Hetzner. These are server hosting companies, not home internet providers.
Physics-defying behavior
Same device clicked 147 different ads in 24 hours
Switched from mobile Safari to desktop Chrome in 6 seconds
Clicked ads 6,700 miles apart within 4 seconds
We literally wrote "Unless this user invented teleportation, this is fraud."
Zero revenue correlation Meta claimed these clicks improved our ROAS. Our Shopify data showed zero conversions, zero add-to-carts, zero checkouts from ANY of this traffic.
They refunded $8,367. Came as ad credits (not cash, because of course), but we'll take it.
The system we built to prevent this
Getting refunds is exhausting. Prevention is way better.
What actually works:
Set up a Google Sheet that pulls your GA4 data daily and compares it to your Meta clicks. If there's more than 15% difference, you've got fraud. Takes 10 minutes to set up with GA4's API.
Run your ad traffic IPs through AbuseIPDB or IPQualityScore once a week. Both have free versions. Data center IPs should be basically zero for normal consumer brands.
Check for impossible patterns in your click timestamps. More than 30 clicks from one IP in a day? Clicks happening in perfect intervals? Red flags.
We also added a simple interaction requirement on our landing page. The "add to cart" button only activates after someone scrolls 25% or moves their mouse. Bots can't do this. Humans do it without thinking.
This dropped our "click with zero engagement" rate from 34% to 4%.
The uncomfortable reality
Meta has zero financial incentive to aggressively stop fraud. They get paid either way.
Their detection is good enough to avoid lawsuits but bad enough that billions in bot traffic gets through. The second we showed them undeniable proof, they folded immediately. They KNOW it exists they just bet most advertisers won't do the work to prove it.
What you should do right now
Go check your GA4 sessions vs your Meta clicks for last month. If the gap is over 15%, you probably have fraud.
Export your click IPs and run them through AbuseIPDB (it's free). Look for data center IPs.
Check your bounce rate by source. Bot traffic bounces 80%+. Real Meta traffic should be 40-60%.
The resource
I put together a spreadsheet that includes:
Click pattern analyzer (paste your data, it flags suspicious patterns automatically)
IP checker template with formulas built in
The dispute template we used (simplified to 8 pages that actually matter)
GA4 vs ad platform comparison tracker
If you want the Bot Click Detection Kit, comment below and I'll send you the link.
Because ad platforms make billions from this stuff and won't fix it themselves. But we can stop paying for fake traffic if we actually check for it.
Turns out when you only pay for real humans, your CPA drops 30%. Who knew.
Look, I'm not here to tell you agencies are dead or whatever. But I just need to share what I found because it's kind of ridiculous.
My Background?
I run a small DTC brand (skincare, if that matters). We were spending about $4K/month on a creative agency for product ads. The work was good, but turnaround was 2-3 weeks per batch, and every revision added another week.
Last month I stumbled on Flora's node-based system for generating product ads. Figured I'd test it since we needed to scale our Meta creative anyway.
Here's what actually happened:
I uploaded one product photo. Added a few parameters (actor style, outfit, background). Hit generate.
Four minutes later, I had 12 variations of product ads that... honestly looked better than some of our agency work. Not all of them, but enough that I kept testing.
The workflow is basically: product image → add actor → choose outfit/location → generate base ad → create variations → upscale to 4K → swap products or outfits for different angles.
Then you can push it to video using Wan 2.5 or Veo if you need motion ads.
The part that surprised me: It's not just about speed. It's that you can test way more angles than you could ever afford with traditional creative.
We went from testing 8-10 ad variations per month to testing 50+. Our hit rate didn't change much (still about 15% of ads become winners), but now we're finding 7-8 winning ads per month instead of 1-2.
The ROI is kind of insane. We cut our creative costs from $4K/month to maybe $200 in API costs. That alone paid for itself, but the real win was testing velocity.
One thing I learned the hard way though: More creative doesn't automatically mean better ROAS if your landing page sucks.
We had this problem where we'd generate all these ads, drive tons of traffic, and our CPA was still garbage. Turns out our site was loading in 3+ seconds and we were losing half our clicks before people even saw the page.
We rebuilt on Shopify Hydrogen (which I didn't even know existed until our developer suggested it) and our landing pages went from 3.2s to 0.9s load time. Same ads, same targeting, CPA dropped 40%.
So yeah, the AI creative thing is legit, but it only works if people actually stick around long enough to see your offer.
If you want to try this yourself...
The Flora system is node-based, which sounds complicated but it's actually pretty intuitive once you mess with it for an hour. There are a few quirks with prompt formatting and you need to pick the right models for product shots vs lifestyle shots.
I put together a workflow doc with the exact setup I use, model recommendations, and the prompts that actually work. Not trying to sell anything, just figured if this saved me $40K this year, maybe it helps someone else.
Also happy to answer questions if anyone's tried similar AI creative tools.
I tested a few others (Midjourney, DALL-E variations) but Flora's product-specific nodes just worked better for e-comm.
If you need the flow let me know in the comments & I'll D'M it.
I’ve been helping a small store recently that was super frustrated with Meta Ads. They were boosting posts, spending money… but getting zero real sales tracked. Meta had no idea who their buyers were.
So I helped them set up:
• The right conversion event • A simple retargeting setup • Better audiences based on real data
Once tracking was fixed, Meta finally understood who to show the ads to — and the results were kind of wild:
407 website purchases
$0.08 per purchase
$31.15 total spend
Honestly, nothing crazy. Just tracking done right + a bit of structure.
If you’re running ads and can’t tell what’s happening or why sales don’t show… it’s probably not your product. It’s the setup.
I don’t mind taking a quick look at someone’s ads/pixel if they want — happy to share what’s broken or what could help.
And if anyone wants full help with campaigns, I’ll drop my Fiverr link in the first comment
What’s the biggest issue you’re facing with your Meta Ads right now?
In early October 2024, I hit the highest single-day GMV I’ve ever had — about $15,000 in one day from one store.
My phone wasn’t on silent back then, and I didn’t even need to check the dashboard — Shopify’s notification sound would just go off on its own, one “Kaching” after another. It sounded like farming gold in a video game, except this was real money landing in the account. I’d pull up the live view and see 46 people in cart, 25 at checkout, 20 who’d already paid — all within ten minutes. Two orders a minute.
At the same time, I was single-handedly running more than a dozen Meta ad accounts. Because each account has a spend cap, the only way to scale was to open accounts horizontally. My execution was decent — I kept the cost-per-conversion roughly the same across every account. That month I spent $102,482, got back 4,668 orders at an average of $21.95 each, for $184,882 in sales — a 1.8 ROAS.
That was my ninth year running independent stores, and it was also the last time I ever had a day like that.
I remember it clearly — it was past 3am, and I was adjusting budgets while thinking about whether I could break $20,000 and set a new record.
Not long after, I got an email from Shopify.
The sender was [email protected]. Subject line: DMCA Takedown Notice. The gist was simple — someone had filed an infringement complaint against my store, the flagged content had been taken down permanently, and my backend had been suspended in the meantime.
Almost simultaneously, the store was shut down, the backend was inaccessible, and the payment processor account was frozen too.
I was a little stunned. Maybe it was the long-term sleep deprivation catching up with me, because I felt kind of detached from my own body. What stunned me wasn’t the loss — it was the sudden silence. The day before, the notification sound wouldn’t stop. The next day, nothing. No orders, no backend, no page that would even load — like someone had pulled the plug. The whole thing didn’t even need a process. It just stopped, and then it was like nothing had ever happened.
The only proof that any of it had really happened was the money sitting frozen in the payment account.
Fortunately, that money got paid out to me after 180 days. After refunds and disputes were deducted, I still came out slightly ahead.
So this isn’t a story about getting wiped out. I didn’t blow up my inventory, I didn’t go into debt — every order was paid for before it shipped, so the math still ended up positive.
But from that point on, I understood something. Every dollar I’d made over the previous few years wasn’t because I was especially skilled — it was because I kept chasing trends. Sometimes I caught one and made money, sometimes I missed it and got shut out. And the door was closing faster and faster.
1. The high was real. So was the cost.
There’s no real trick to the winning-product game — it’s honestly just about who’s faster. Whoever finds the video that’s about to blow up first, whoever gets the store live first, whoever scales spend first, wins. Sometimes the product itself is an afterthought — the creative blows up first, and you start running ads before you’ve even sourced the product. A brand-new store can go from zero to $10K/day in a matter of days when things move fast.
It’s a hard feeling to describe — like buying lottery tickets nonstop. Every product is a ticket. Hit one and it’s hundreds of thousands, even millions; miss and you just buy another. Extremely addictive.
But there’s a cost, and it comes in layers.
The first thing you feel is physical. There are only ever a handful of winning creatives, so scaling means opening dozens, sometimes over a hundred, ad sets off a single creative, then manually managing them — doubling budget on what’s working, killing what isn’t, immediately. You can’t sleep through this. The data is continuous — look away for two hours and you’ve burned money. During that stretch I was basically nocturnal: sleep during the day, watch the dashboard all night, completely inverted schedule. And none of that monitoring compounds — no matter how well you watched today, tomorrow you start from zero again. The worst part is that even grinding like that doesn’t guarantee profit. Lose control even slightly and a product run ends in the red.
Below that is risk. With winning products, quality is out of your control — you don’t own the supply chain, there’s no QC, sometimes you’ve never even seen the physical item. Once it sells, the complaints start: item doesn’t match the listing, high return rates, and disputes climbing right behind them. Dispute rate is the hard line for every payment processor — Stripe, Shopify Payments, PayPal, all the same. Cross that line and you get shut off instantly. The money isn’t gone, but it’s frozen for 180 days. Worse: even if you do everything “right,” a brand-new store suddenly taking in a lot of money is inherently high-risk behavior on its own. Risk systems don’t know you — all they see is a freshly opened merchant account with revenue spiking, tens of thousands of dollars a day, every day. You’re permanently sitting on a watch list. IP is the same story — most of the products and creative in this game carry real trademark and copyright exposure. The moment a brand notices, the complaint, takedown, and fund freeze move fast, and you have basically no defense. That DMCA notice I got is exactly how this plays out.
None of these risks are really about probability — they’re about time. The longer you do this and the bigger you get, the closer that probability drifts toward 100%.
But the thing I thought about longest was the last layer.
I don’t have the ability to produce original creative — I only know how to copy. I’d see whatever video was performing and run it too, and everyone else was doing the exact same thing. Dozens of competitors running the same creative at the same time means the same audience gets hit over and over until they’re burned out, and then that creative just stops converting for anyone. So the only way to make money is to move earlier and spend bigger than everyone else — slow down even slightly and the window’s gone. Then you have to go find the next one.
At the end of the day, what I was running wasn’t a business — it was a series of sprints, back to back. Every single one started from zero: find a product, open a store, set up accounts, scale spend. The money you win in each sprint is real, but once it’s over you’re left holding nothing — no brand, no repeat customers, no creative library, nothing you can carry into the next one.
Nine years in, and I’m still restarting from the starting line every time.
2. And then the platform stepped in itself
If it had only been what I just described, I probably would have kept going for a few more years — I was making money, and I’d accepted the cost. What actually ended this path for me was the platform itself cutting it off.
Meta’s algorithm went through a fundamental shift over the last two years — codenamed Andromeda. After that change, all the old tricks that exploited the mechanics of the system stopped working, across the board.
Here’s how that failure showed up in my account, specifically.
First, duplication stopped working. Take one creative, duplicate it into ten ad sets — the old structure was: roughly six lose money, three break even, one wins. You’d double down on the winner repeatedly until it more than covered every losing test. We used to call that “skill.” Later, the same exact move would produce eight losers out of ten, two break-even, and not a single one that scaled.
Then doubling budget stopped working too. Occasionally a winner would show up, but pushing more budget into it wouldn’t pull more volume — doubling used to be an amplifier, now it was just a faster way to lose money. I tried switching to manual bidding, tried Cost Cap — none of it worked.
Finally, the creative side collapsed entirely. Used to be you could rip someone else’s creative and it would still convert reasonably. Later, the same move would send CPMs to over $100 and CPC to levels you simply couldn’t sustain. Dozens of competitors running the exact same creative, all racing each other on price — I saw someone selling for $9.99 and knew right then that product was already dead.
For a while I assumed it was just me — that my execution wasn’t good enough. I spent my days watching how other top sellers were running things — the “258” scaling method, timing your scale-up around the best hours, some using CBO, some ABO, some raising bid caps. I copied all of it. Same result.
It eventually clicked: all of those tactics were really just exploiting loopholes in how spend got distributed. Opening a hundred ad sets to “horse race” them wasn’t about understanding customers — it worked because the system’s allocation logic let you get away with it. Once the platform tightened that structure, the loophole simply stopped existing.
And this wasn’t collateral damage — it was exactly the outcome the platform wanted. From Meta’s perspective it’s obvious: if a hundred sellers are all running the same video, every user just keeps seeing the same ad over and over, and that’s actively bad for the platform’s ecosystem. What the platform needs is enough diverse creative that the machine can gather real signal — who responds to what content, what kind of message lands with what kind of person. Duplicate one creative a hundred times, and to the machine, the information content is exactly one.
There’s one more thing I understood way too late: creative has a lifecycle.
There’s an old saying in this industry — “creative is king.” I used to agree with that, but I understood it shallowly — I thought it just meant “go find good creative.” What I eventually realized is that once a piece of creative has been used and reused by everyone, no technique, no bidding strategy, no account structure can save it. It’s just dead. And what I’d been doing for years was repeatedly trying different techniques on creative that was already dead.
Technique is craft. Creative is the actual foundation. Every technique only works on top of creative — and a product can only keep selling if the creative behind it is genuinely evolving.
So Meta, Google, TikTok — they’re all moving in the same direction. The requirement is shifting from “can you run ads well” to “can you keep supplying different creative.” This isn’t just an algorithm update — it’s a shift in what the barrier to entry actually is. The era of tricks is over. What’s left is whether you can consistently produce content.
And that’s exactly the one thing I had the least of.
3. Nine years, and nothing I built ever compounded
Around that time I did a pretty blunt self-assessment: what had I actually been making money from for the past nine years?
My first answer was “good luck” and “being fast.” Neither felt quite right. The more accurate answer is: for nine years, I was running tests.
2016 to 2019, Amazon — bulk-listing products, testing SKUs, testing keywords. 2019, I moved to Shopify stores and winning-product dropshipping — testing products, testing creative, testing audiences. By the peak of the winning-product era I’d taken testing to its extreme, opening a hundred ad sets a day — which, at its core, is just paying money to ask the market a single question: will this work or not.
There’s nothing wrong with testing itself — it’s necessary in this business. The problem is I spent nine years testing and never once turned the results of a test into something that actually stuck around. Every time something worked, what I got out of it was one payout. Once that product’s run was over, nothing was left but that money — the next product had to be tested completely from scratch. I never built a brand, never built a base of repeat customers, never built a creative library, never even built a real understanding of any one type of person.
Nine years in, my skills had probably gone up. My assets were zero.
That’s the actual problem. It was never about not being fast enough, or not lucky enough — it’s that I kept doing one-off things. No matter how well you execute a one-off, it doesn’t grow on its own.
I don’t want to still be adjusting ad budgets at 3am when I’m forty.
So I changed direction. It really comes down to two things.
First: stop hunting for new products, and instead go deeper on products that are already proven. The winning-product logic is finding something nobody else is doing yet and grabbing a bite before anyone else notices. My logic now is the opposite — I specifically look for products that competitors are already actively spending money on. If other sellers are running sustained ad spend on something, that’s proof the demand is real and the market is accessible. Then I ask myself: what makes me able to do this better than they can? The answer isn’t sourcing, and it isn’t price — it’s understanding the person, and the ability to turn that understanding into creative.
Second: stop taking one wave and leaving, and instead stay on a single product continuously. Different people buy the same product for different reasons — some to save money, some to save effort, some because a specific scenario hit home for them. If the reasons differ, the creative shouldn’t be one-size-fits-all either. What I do now is continuously build creative around one product, covering different audience segments and different stages of awareness, so that no matter which angle someone comes in from, there’s a path that leads to a purchase.
That’s the real difference between chasing winning products and building a small brand. A winning product is one product sold to everyone. A small brand is one product sold separately to several distinct kinds of people.
It sounds slower, but it has one property a winning product never has: it compounds. The creative is mine, the audience understanding is mine, the store is mine — what I build this month is still there next month.
Here’s a concrete example. Last November 27th, at 4:18pm, this current store got its first order. It’s now September, and it’s still getting orders. Ten months, one product, and the lifecycle still hasn’t ended.
The payout freeze + DMCA part is what jumps out. Gross revenue is a fun screenshot, but processor risk, refunds and cash runway decide whether the business survives. The shift from chasing the next loophole to compounding around one product makes way more sense.
btw I’m building Orderain — a full ecommerce platform, not just an AI page builder. I’m pretty biased toward owning the store layer, but durability matters more than another big month.
In the old winning-product world, the rhythm I knew was: a product scales, burns out its audience, and it’s over — a couple weeks, maybe a few good weeks if you were lucky. Something lasting ten months simply didn’t exist in that model.
One more thing, and it might matter more than the money: I now work about two hours a day. No monitoring dashboards, no all-nighters, no adjusting budgets at 3am — because I’m no longer relying on reflexes to exploit a mechanic, so there’s no such thing anymore as “look away for two hours and burn money.” What’s left to do is really just two things: studying the audience and iterating on creative. Both can be done during the day, and once they’re done, I close the laptop.
I’ll walk through exactly how I do this below.
4. What the platform wants isn’t more creative — it’s more information
Before getting into the specifics, I need to clear up one concept first, otherwise everything after this is wasted effort.
“You need more creative” has been said to death the last two years, so a lot of people’s solution is to take one image, swap the background, swap the copy, swap the aspect ratio, swap the colors, and mass-produce ten thousand variants — AI has made this essentially free. But that entire direction is wrong from the foundation, because what the platform is short on isn’t creative volume — it’s information.
What the algorithm is actually doing is matching — putting the right content in front of the right person. To do that, it needs genuinely different content to probe genuinely different people: this person responds to saving money, that person responds to fear of doing something wrong, another person is only drawn in by one specific visual. Every creative that expresses something different is one real probe. Take one image and remix it ten thousand times, and you’ve only run one probe — the information content is exactly one.
So the real question isn’t “how do I produce more creative.” It’s “how many genuinely different ways do I need to reach how many genuinely different kinds of people.” Once you ask the right question, every step after this just falls out of it.
I’ll walk through the full process using a specific product: pet dental powder.
Start with product selection. For this step I only use the Meta Ad Library — free, no tools needed.
I’m not looking for whether people are running it — I’m looking for whether people are seriously spending money on it. The bar is simple: at least 20 active ads on that product, more is better, and the more recently the creative was uploaded, the better — that tells you they’re still actively running it, not just something left over from before. Ideally more than one seller is doing it.
Most people’s instinct runs the opposite direction — see a competitor doing it and back off, assuming it’s already saturated. That’s leftover thinking from the winning-product era, where you were racing against a closing time window, so competition was scary. What I’m doing now isn’t racing a time window — it’s racing for a better understanding of the customer. A competitor running sustained spend and continually refreshing creative actually proves three things at once: the demand is real, the price point works, and the traffic is buyable. The market has already validated it for me — what I save is the cost of my own trial and error.
So what makes me able to beat them? Not product sourcing, and not price — I already fought that price war in my earlier career. It’s because they’re most likely only speaking to one kind of person, while I plan to speak to four.
5. Start by listening to what real people actually say
Once I’ve committed to a product, I don’t write copy or make images yet — I go collect what real users have actually said, first.
This step is called VOC — voice of customer. It’s not market research in the formal sense. It’s basically just copying down people’s real words.
Reddit is the most valuable source. In pet- and dog-related help subreddits, people talk without a filter, because they’re not talking to a brand — they’re asking their peers for help. I also read Amazon reviews for comparable products, focusing on the 3- and 4-star ones specifically — 5-star reviews are too vague, and 1-star is usually a shipping complaint; the middle two star levels are where the real usage detail lives. TikTok comment sections work the same way — find a top-performing video in the same category and read through what people are arguing about and asking in the comments.
When filtering, I only look at high-engagement content. This part matters a lot — if a comment or post got pushed up and got hundreds of replies, that means the person who said it wasn’t a one-off case. They spoke for a group, and the engagement is the weight behind that statement.
For pet dental powder, the recurring things I kept seeing across these sources were things like: people saying the vet quoted $800 for anesthesia dental cleaning, and their dog is eleven, and they’re scared to put it under anesthesia. People saying they tried brushing and the dog won’t let them near its mouth, and it takes two people to hold it down. People saying every time the dog opens its mouth they want to look away, and then feeling like a terrible pet owner for thinking that. People saying the gums are already red and the vet warned that extraction might be next.
None of these statements are actually about the product. They’re about money, fear, guilt, relationships. That’s the real raw material for creative.
After collecting this, the next step is defining audience segments from these statements.
This approach comes from Breakthrough Advertising. Its core insight is that people never buy the object itself — they buy the desire that object satisfies. Someone buying a gym membership isn’t buying equipment access, they’re buying looking better. Someone buying an investment course isn’t buying knowledge, they’re buying becoming wealthy. Someone ordering a new iPhone on release day is buying not falling behind.
Desire also breaks into long-term and short-term. Long-term desires are always present — health, wealth, being loved, security — and products built on them have long lifecycles. Short-term desires are event-driven — a new product launch, a holiday, something suddenly trending — they arrive fast and disappear just as fast.
There’s something I used to misunderstand here. The window on a winning product is usually only a couple of weeks, and the reason usually isn’t that the underlying desire is short-term — a lot of winning products actually satisfy very long-term desires. What actually dies fast is the creative — once one piece of creative has burned through the audience it can move, there’s no new audience left, and nobody iterates a new angle on it, so it just dies. So the desire’s timeframe determines how long a product could theoretically run — but your ability to keep iterating creative determines how long it actually does run.
Back to the dental powder. On the surface, it satisfies “remove tartar, reduce bad breath.” But looking at the VOC, underneath that are several genuinely different desires. I collapsed them into four segments.
The first is the old-dog owner — what they actually want is more years with their dog, without putting it under anesthesia. The second is the failed-brusher — what they want is to escape the guilt of “I haven’t been taking good enough care of them.” The third is the bill-avoider — they just don’t want to spend $800 solving this. The fourth is the bad-breath-tolerator — they want to be able to hug and kiss their dog the way they used to.
These four sentences are the entire foundation of the creative matrix. Note that the audience label and the desire are two different things — “old-dog owner” is just a label; what actually becomes creative is the second half of that sentence.
I usually build three to five segments per product. Fewer than three and you’re not covering enough ground; more than five and your effort gets too spread out.
6. A creative matrix across five awareness stages
Once the segments are set, the question becomes: what creative do you make for each one?
The answer isn’t “one ad per segment,” because within a single segment, people are at different distances from actually buying. Eugene Schwartz breaks that distance into five stages: Unaware, Problem Aware, Solution Aware, Product Aware, Most Aware.
Most sellers pile all their creative into the last two stages — talking about ingredients, results, discounts — which means they can only reach people who are already ready to buy, and that group is both the smallest in the market and the one every competitor is fighting hardest over. The first three stages contain far more people, and almost nobody is reaching them.
Here’s what five pieces of creative look like for the old-dog-owner segment.
① Unaware — they don’t even know this is a problem yet
• Visual: an old dog with graying fur, the owner’s hand gently lifting its lip, gums showing red
• Headline: They won’t tell you it hurts
• Subhead: Past age three, most dogs have some degree of gum disease. They just tolerate it. They don’t say anything.
• Job of the ad: don’t mention the product at all — not once. Its only job is to get someone to look, just once, at their own dog’s mouth.
② Problem Aware — they know the teeth aren’t great, but think it’s just a dental issue
• Visual: a simple diagram — tartar → gum inflammation → loose teeth → bacteria entering the bloodstream
• Headline: Tartar isn’t just a teeth problem
• Subhead: Eventually it affects the heart and kidneys
• Job of the ad: upgrade a “minor issue” into something that needs addressing
③ Solution Aware — they’ve decided to deal with it and are comparing options
• Visual: a three-column comparison table — anesthesia cleaning / manual brushing / dental powder, rows for cost, risk, and whether the dog will cooperate
• Headline: Three options — see them clearly before you choose
• Job of the ad: this is the ad that looks least like an ad, but often drives the highest conversion, because you’re helping them decide, not pushing them to buy. The anesthesia-risk row — the thing the old-dog owner cares about most — speaks for itself.
④ Product Aware — they know dental powder exists, and are comparing brands
• Visual: real usage documentation — day 1 / day 14 / day 30 condition of the teeth, ideally shot with genuine user-generated texture
• Headline: No holding them down — just sprinkle it on their food
• Subhead: ingredients, time to see results, how it differs from other brands
• Job of the ad: answer “why you, specifically”
⑤ Most Aware — they’re ready to buy
• Visual: product + price + bundle
• Headline: Three-pack — lasts a season
• Subhead: money-back guarantee if it doesn’t work
• Job of the ad: don’t overexplain, just give them a reason to check out
Four segments times five stages equals twenty pieces of creative — that’s a full matrix. The point of it is: no matter which angle or which stage someone enters from, there’s a path that carries them forward — something remixing one image ten thousand times could never do.
One more sequencing note worth making: write the brief before you generate the image. That’s the line between deliberate production and just generating things at random.
AI image generation is cheap now, so most people’s process is “generate a hundred images with AI and pick the best ones.” The problem is that approach has no intent behind it — you don’t know who any given image was meant to target or what it was meant to say, so once performance data comes back, you have no way to diagnose what actually went wrong.
My process is: every piece of creative starts with a brief document before any image gets made. The brief specifies the target segment and awareness stage, the core desire, the exact VOC quotes it’s drawing from, the visual description, headline/subhead/CTA, and the landing page it points to. I use an LLM to write the brief and an image model to generate the visual — but never in the reverse order.
The brief has a hidden benefit too: it’s a reusable asset. Audience segments and desires don’t change every quarter — images can be regenerated, but the brief stays valid.
As for tools — for VOC collection I use Claude or Codex to drive a browser and pull keyword-based results from Reddit, TikTok, and Amazon reviews, then compile the high-engagement content into a table. Briefs are generated with Claude or GPT. Images are generated with GPT image generation, or by calling an image model’s API directly — for example, Google’s “nano banana.” For uploading and launching campaigns I use an MCP tool I built myself called adscove, though the official Meta MCP or manual upload both work too.
7. Let the spend tell you who’s actually buying
Once the creative is built, the next step isn’t precise targeting — it’s letting the system figure out who’s buying on its own.
The setup is simple: one CBO campaign, starting at $50/day, one ad set per segment, with that segment’s creative loaded into it, and no targeting tricks.
Why not “horse race” a bunch of ad sets? Because it’s not necessary anymore. CBO automatically shifts budget toward whatever’s performing, and underperforming creative naturally stops getting funded. Manually racing ad sets against each other was a workaround for an older system structure — now you just need to separate the audience segments and let the budget find its own way.
After a few days, where the budget flows tells you which type of person is actually spending money. The answer is often not what you expected — you might assume the bill-avoider converts best, and it turns out almost all the spend is flowing to the failed-brushers instead. That’s information you paid to learn, and it’s more accurate than any survey.
Once you have that answer, there are two things to do. First, double down on that segment — build more creative for it, filling out all five awareness stages. Second, rebuild the landing page to match that segment — if most buyers are failed-brushers, the top of the page shouldn’t be talking about ingredients, it should say “no need to hold them down.”
There’s one more thing that eats more time in media buying than anything else: money spent with no conversions, and not knowing where the problem actually is. A lot of people guess at this point and change the creative and the page at the same time, and then have no idea afterward what actually fixed it. In reality, front-end metrics alone can tell you which of the two it is:
• High CTR, low CPC, but no conversions → the creative is fine, people are getting pulled in — the landing page isn’t closing them. Fix the page.
• Low CTR, high CPC → nobody’s getting pulled in at all. Go back and rework the creative.
Creative’s job is bringing the right people in. The page’s job is keeping them. Whether front-end metrics look good or not tells you exactly where the responsibility sits. Once that’s clear, most of the second-guessing in media buying just disappears.
8. Doing the actual math
Running this process, one product now does roughly $100K/month, at about a 2.0 ROAS, with all creative AI-generated. This store got its first order last November and is now ten months in, still running on that same single product.
I know what some people are going to say — you used to do $185K in a month, and now you’re only at $100K, isn’t that a step backward?
That deserves a straight answer. That $185,000 was gross revenue. What has to come out of that number includes high returns, high disputes, funds frozen for 180 days, a payment channel that could vanish at any moment, a store that got shut down by a DMCA notice, and a run of consecutive all-nighters. It was a number from a bet I happened to win — and after that one round, I had to start completely over.
The $100K is a number I can reasonably expect again next month. The creative is mine, the audience understanding is mine, the store is still standing, and I work two hours a day. Even if I didn’t touch the ads or iterate anything for a full month, GMV wouldn’t drop off a cliff. That’s what compounding actually looks like. That’s a real passive-income base.
I’d trade $85K a month for that shift — from gambling to compounding, without hesitation.
And there’s a more important difference between those two numbers than the dollar amount: that $185K playbook is basically impossible to run today. Not because I don’t want to — because it doesn’t exist anymore.
Looking back, for ten years I kept doing the same thing — find a door that hasn’t closed yet, run through it, grab what I can, and get out before it slams shut. Amazon was a door. Shopify stores were a door. Winning-product dropshipping was a door. I caught every single one, and made money every time. And I genuinely did walk away from each one with something — media buying skill, platform understanding, scar tissue from every mistake — that’s all real, and it’s still part of who I am today.
But all of it shared one thing in common: none of it grew on its own. Skill went up. Assets stayed at zero. Every time a door closed, I had to carry that accumulated skill to go find the next one.
The platforms have now made their requirement explicit: they want sellers who can keep producing genuinely different content, consistently. Meta, Google, TikTok — all the same direction. It sounds like a burden, but it’s actually the first time in ten years that the barrier to entry has shifted from “who’s fastest” to “who can keep making things.” Being fast is something you take. Making things is something you build up.
So I’m done looking for the next door. I’m planning to stay right here, around one product, and just keep going.
One last thing.
If you made it all the way down here, you actually walked through a real arc. You probably came in because of a big number and a suspension email, and at that point you probably didn’t think you had the same problem. By the time you got to “eight out of ten duplicated ad sets losing money,” you started to realize this wasn’t just about execution. After that you understood where the actual problem was, and that there’s a way out. Right now, you’re deciding whether this approach actually holds up.
Unaware → Problem Aware → Solution Aware → Product Aware. From not knowing there’s a problem, to knowing there’s a solution, to being aware of the product itself.
This post was written in that exact order, on purpose.
I’m still running this strategy, still refining it. I’ll break down each individual piece in future posts — exactly how to do VOC collection, how to write a brief, what the pitfalls are at each of the five awareness stages, how to build a landing page around a specific audience segment.
I’ve done this for ten years, made money and had stores shut down. None of what’s in my head turns into anything on its own — but writing it down means at least someone else might actually get some use out of it.