r/dresdenfiles • u/Dogmovedmyshoes • Dec 07 '25
Fan Casting Modern Ebeneezer Casting Spoiler
Because I want someone who can play the character for a while. Somebody with the range for violence, crafty politics, and father figure vibes.
r/dresdenfiles • u/Dogmovedmyshoes • Dec 07 '25
Because I want someone who can play the character for a while. Somebody with the range for violence, crafty politics, and father figure vibes.
r/dresdenfiles • u/Empty_Act5759 • Jun 25 '25
I cannot let go of these two playing Harry and Thomas.
r/dresdenfiles • u/HorribleAce • Jan 18 '24
This isn't me trying to be negative or throwing shade on the books or anything.
I get why Butcher repeats some of the explanations in books one through three, but right now I'm reading Death Masks and I got to say I want to rip out my eyeballs everytime I read 'The Blue Beetle wasn't really blue' or 'Evocation was quick and dirty magic and I wasn't very good at it', or the fabled 'My apartment is an arrangement of mismatching furniture'.
I get you want to make sure new readers get these things, but who the hell picks up the series at Book 5? And I find it hard to believe people who read 1 - 4 would pick up five and go 'What did his blue volkswagen look like again?'
Eh. Just wanted to get that out there, it was irritating me.
r/dresdenfiles • u/[deleted] • Jan 22 '24
So I'm reading (listening, actually) through the dresden files for the first time, and I got to proven guilty. I'm maybe half way through the book, but I keep feeling grossed out almost any time Molly comes on screen. When she's first introduced, Harry talks for what felt like way too long about how hot Molly is. Then later, she shows up to his hotel room to take a shower, and bob goes on a long rant about how Harry should sleep with the teenager. Then Lasciel tells him the same thing too. Then Charity shows up to get Molly and she walks out of the bathroom in a towel so Charity assumes Harry was trying to seduce Molly. And it all feels like it was played for laughs, but it felt so gross to me.
Does this sort of thing keep happening? Because every time, I cringe so hard I have to stop what I'm doing.
r/dresdenfiles • u/3Dring • Jan 04 '24
Over new years me and the GF had a long drive to visit friends so I decided to throw on SF since she's been wanting to read/listen the series since I told her about it. However after only a few hours she said that while she's enjoying the story she can't get over how badly the women in the series are written and it's distracting her too much to want to keep listening.
I thought this was odd since she's not normally one to make that kind of criticism but I changed it anyway even after I told her it gets better. Has anyone else ran into this. Is there anything I can say to maybe convince her to give it another go?
r/dresdenfiles • u/Cheshire_Kiwi • Oct 27 '23
I was just wondering, the white court are generally open to anything, and there's Butter's thing with the werewolves, but have there been any characters in the main books or side stories that are gay?
r/dresdenfiles • u/BertnErnie32 • Dec 06 '25
All of you know you would cast him for Ebenezer too, and Harry, and Thomas, and Murphy and...
r/dresdenfiles • u/ohihadsomething4this • Feb 12 '25
r/dresdenfiles • u/Emrak • Aug 04 '24
It's been over a decade since I last read the series, I think, so I haven't gotten around to the more recent ones yet but man I hope Harry finally gets over Murphy. Younger me didn't notice it quite so much, but older me sees how verbally abusive she is towards Harry. There are also examples of egotism, self-centeredness, and just being obnoxious in general. More than once she hinders Harry based on false assumptions. And the one time she's apologized so far, it was treated with unnecessary importance--she struggled to force the words out and Harry practically genuflected, praising her and her character for doing this common thing. Harry meanwhile, is expected to (and does) apologize regularly, even when things aren't his fault.
I know JB wrote the tales when he was younger and all that so it is what it is. That said, I'd love to see an edited director's cut version down the line where the characters and interactions were written from a more mature perspective.
EDIT:
As I'm reading on, Harry's behavior towards women in general is one of deference even in the face of physical abuse. It's not emasculation because he didn't grow up with an overbearing mother (obviously) so it has to be mental illness--probably autism due to his relative intelligence but also his Forrest Gumpian attitude towards women. I grew up in a conserviative, religous household and was taught the same traditional principles towards women that Harry believes in: don't hit girls, hold the door for them, if they need help try to give it, etc. That said, your principles should never take a backseat to your self-respect, and he's a glaring example of someone suffering from incredibly low self-respect. (I wish I didn't know so much about psychology now.)
Almost every woman in Harry's life is disrespectful towards him in some way. The only two women (err, beings) who treat Harry with basic respect--let alone kindness--are Molly and Lasciel's shadow, and I'm not sure the latter counts lol
Lastly, there's weird double standards at play too. One of many examples: In Summer Knight, one of the changelings--Ace--tries to have Harry killed. Initially he does this to protect his friends, but then is coerced to continue lest the Red Court kill him. Merrill (a massive woman with "hands the size of dinner plates") who can pick up a tall man like Harry with one hand, physically attacks a downed, helpless, much smaller Ace for what he's done even though he intended no harm to her and would've been killed himself if he'd tried to back out.
Contrast this with Elaine in the same book. Betrayed Harry and almost got him killed back in the day, then fled and never tried to reach out to explain herself despite "loving him". Uh huh. She claims that she had no choice but to do what Justin wanted. K.
In Summer Knight, she meets up with him again--but not by choice--and then once again tries to flee (at the airport) without even telling him goodbye despite "still caring for him". After Harry fills her in, she could still simply LEAVE as she intended without betraying Harry. Her debt to Summer was repayed and in any event, no one was forcing her to not leave on her trip.
Instead, she plots with Aurora to ambush Harry in the NeverNever. She actively lies to him in order to hide the identity of the killer, she sends in the mind fog at the store (almost killing him again) and finally, she openly betrays him at the end. Yes, she left him a slim chance to survive the magical quicksand, but what if he didn't make it out in time? (He almost didn't, actually.) Since she's only giving him a very small opportunity to survive, why not just let him die and hit Aurora with his death curse? Probably for the same reason she didn't just fly away earlier. She wants to curry favor with Aurora more than she cares if Harry lives or dies.
Finally, at the end, she helps him reach Aurora with a short-range portal but what was her only other choice? Not help and potentially have him or the Winter forces kill her? God forbid. She explains that all these betrayals once again weren't her fault, FOR REALZ. She suffers no consequences for her actions. Compare that to Ace.
It's like this throughout. If they're a woman, Harry lets them do whatever and just takes it, claiming high-minded principles. Um, no, that's not principle, that's mental.
r/dresdenfiles • u/Lord_Purifier • Jul 18 '25
So I decided to give the series a try this year and I am really liking it. Has some weaknesses and some stuff that really bothers me but overall I am really enjoying my time.
I spoilered myself completely before going in (don't mind being spoilered honestly) and I am currently reading Peace Talks.
I was aware of the Butters discourse but holy hell reading it myself I have to agree. I really liked Butters in Ghost Story. Him stepping up in the void Harry left and being a ressourceful tinkerer was really cool. But in Skin Game and now in Peace Talks his character just becomes obnoxious and unbelievable in a way that doesn't fit with the vibe of the series.
Also the lightsaber...
r/dresdenfiles • u/uncreativevision • Feb 24 '26
I want to preface this with a couple of things. I'm a die-hard Dresden Files fan, and I'm generally quite happy with the books. (with some exceptions, e.g, Bonea getting sidelined, and the deeply horny descriptions). The books certainly do have flaws, but that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about what's not there in the first place.
Chicago is a really, really diverse city. 58.5 percent of the population is Black or Hispanic (2020 U.S. Census). Chicago has a huge LGBT+ population, and Boystown (now Northalsted) was the first ever recognized gay neighbourhood in all the U.S.
On the other hand, the Dresden Files aren't very diverse. THAT IS NOT A PROBLEM IN AND OF ITSELF!!! I AM NOT MAKING A MORAL JUDGEMENT! But as it stands, I can't name more than a few secondary and tertiary characters who aren't white (Susan & Maggie, Listens to Wind, Ancient Mai, Lt. Rawlins, Fitz, to name a few) and AFAIK the only textually queer character (who isn't a Whamp and therefore more of a predator than a sexual being with agency) is Freydis Gard.
You might be asking, why do I care? Well, it's not because Jim Butcher's a big mean racist and homophobe, I'll tell you that much. From what I can tell, he seems to be a chill dude, and the Dresden Files have genuinely inspired me to become a better person.
Mostly, I think it's an accuracy thing. Obviously Butcher's Chicago is geographically out of step with real Chicago, and it's literally a different world, but it do think it bears saying that like, at least half the Chicago cast should be like, Black or Latino. In my head I've always read Molly as queer at least but again, nothing is ever said on page. I don't think we need to go back and meticulously assign everyone in the cast a different ethnic or racial group, but I do wonder what this series would look like if Butcher were truer to Chicago's real population.
Sidebar: I'm not trying to start anything, and I remember back when this sub got really really mad about transphobia accusations. I'm not gonna weigh in on that cold case but I want to preempt anything similar. I don't think Butcher or the Dresden Files are racist, sexist, or homophobic. I do think Butcher has blind spots that show through in his writing, but that's observation, not condemnation. I really do just wonder how the Dresden Files would feel if we had a wider view of Dresden's city.
Sidebar the 2st: I realize that there are more non-White characters in the Dresden Files than I mentioned, but that's kind of besides the point in the face of IRL Chicago's population being way broader than what we see in the books.
r/dresdenfiles • u/[deleted] • Dec 28 '23
I've seen a couple threads lately talkign about how we need a new Dresden TV series. But if we're going to have Dresden TV, it needs to be done right. Of course, a few changes need to be made.
So what if instead of Harry's continued issues with women, we make him happily married? Harry would be married to, say, Susan Rodriguez. Their kids would include Bonea and Maggie Jr., of course. And maybe they could have a third child.
Harry should have a regular magic show that he does, aimed at teaching people about magic they could do at home. Harry's reasonably competent, but his sidekick Bob (who possesses a human with an affection for flannel) could show himself to be truly competent and help the show along.
A lot of episodes could focus on Harry's more outre magic inventions, and his continuing struggles as a father. Ebenezar McCoy (whoe face we never see) could provide Harry with crucial advice most episodes. Harry being Harry, he'll often garble the application of the advice, but he should usually be able to make it through.
And everything will be better with "grunt MORE MAGIC!!"
What do you guys think?
r/dresdenfiles • u/Ok_Bug9106 • Jul 23 '26
Nicolas Cage doing a British accent is genius. Christopher Lee is dead, so perfect casting will never happen again.
r/dresdenfiles • u/SniperFiction • Dec 09 '23
Listen, I don't care for Battle Ground much for a lot of reasons. But worst of all is how they killed off Murphy. From my perspective, she was FRIDGED. Fridging is a bad trope in which a character dies ONLY to make another character feel bad. Her death served no other purpose than to upset Dresden. And the audience, I guess, but it didn't upset me for the reason it should have.
Murphy was one of my favorite characters. And worse, Jim Butcher built up her and Dresden's romance for TWENTY YEARS, only to kill her off so quick into their relationship? Bullshit. Nonsense. And worst of all, WASTEFUL.
Let me be clear, this is just my opinion, and you are entitled to yours. If you have any counter points, I would be happy to discuss and consider them. I still love the Dresden Files. I apologize if I seem worked up over this, but I am. The character deserved better writing.
Now, I get sometimes death happens and there's nothing to be done about it. I can't say it's not realistic for someone to go with the worst possible timing. But it still wasn't satisfying. Her death served no other purpose than making Dresden feel bad. Thus, fridging. And Jim Butcher is better than that.
EDIT: Haven't listened to The Law yet.
r/dresdenfiles • u/CatsKnightTemplar • Dec 01 '16
r/dresdenfiles • u/TwoLetters • Jul 17 '15
r/dresdenfiles • u/bushidomonk • Dec 10 '25
r/dresdenfiles • u/Maximum_Violinist_53 • Aug 17 '23
First of all, I want to say that I really love the series but I loved it more when it was an urban fantasy than now that it's an epic fantasy. However, something that has made me increasingly disillusioned with the series is the fact that it seems that with each book that comes out, Jim leaves Harry in a worse place than the last, it's always misfortune after misfortune, after misfortune, and's already bored me
I understand what Jim says about the series being more exciting when there are conflicts, but at this point, it seems like a very repeated resource, it's not even that I feel sad, it's more that I find it frustrating and somewhat predictable, for example, Harry loses two very important people to him in the last book and even though this is supposed to be a heartbreaking moment, all I could think was "wow, Harry is miserable again, wow, how surprising."
I compare it to Spiderman because it is a complaint that many fans of the character have, even the new movie focuses on that, as Peter can never get out of his life full of tragedy and misery since it is a canon event.
This simply made him lose interest, also from what we are seeing of the deeper plot of the series, it seems that the vast majority of the tragedies that Harry goes through are planned by other characters, his father is murdered, someone he hides from Morgan, then Justin finds him, even "good" characters make him miserable, I'm 100% convinced that Uriel pulled the strings for Harry to become the winter knight. The apparent reason we're given in the books is that they're preparing it to be used as a weapon in the apocalypse to save the world and honestly, that makes me feel like I'm watching that episode of south park where everyone comes together to make Britney spears' life miserable and sacrifice her at the end or that book (forget the name) where in order for a whole town to have good fortune, its inhabitants unite to make a child's life a constant agony and keep him locked in a closet suffering forever.
To be honest and as a not-as-good person like Michael my favorite ending so far is Harry sending everything to hell, deciding to turn evil and let the world be destroyed.
Thanks for reading my personal rant.
r/dresdenfiles • u/Melenduwir • Mar 09 '24
Obviously trivial things would probably be different -- 'Harry' isn't a woman's name, and there aren't many women's names that can be nicknamed 'Harry' in common usage.
But, what if a girl child had been born in Harry's place, with the same magical potential and status and everything? Leaving all the other facts of the Dresdenverse the same, how would the story be different?
r/dresdenfiles • u/Jerry-And-Tom • Oct 27 '24
r/dresdenfiles • u/JohnGlaenzer • Jun 29 '24
Hello All.
My most recent forays into current fantasy have mostly been duds (though I am enjoying the Rook and Rose series by M.A. Carrill), so I decided to curl up with an old favorite the other night. Reading the fist few pages of Storm Front was like hanging out with a good friend who you haven't seen in a few months. You can finish each other's sentences, and you know all the jokes. But every once in a while you get a new insight.
Anyway, I'm about halfway through SF, and I am at THAT SCENE. You know, dripping suds, stuck in the sub-basement, lightning crashing around, and Susan in a little black dress.
And I thought, what is the MOST CRINGE scene in this series? Where you are the absolute most embarrassed for Harry? This has to be top five, right? Here are some that spring immediately to mind:
See above
When Charity enters the hotel room when Molly comes out of the shower (PG)
When he realizes every creature in Faerie has witnessed the *consummation* of his deal with Mab (C)
When he wakes up in the hotel room with Tara West, wearing incredibly crappy clothes and completely at her mercy. (FM)
When he and Morgan are almost on the verge of actually LIKING each other. (TC)