r/dredge • • Dec 22 '23

The WORST minigame

0 Upvotes

No, it's not that one fishing minigame where it becomes impossible to catch trophies once your fishing speed is too high. Good call, though.

The worst minigame in Dredge is the radial menu, because it doesn't pause the game, is imprecise in its selection, shows the menu on the left side of the screen while being controlled by the right stick, and intermixes emergency abilities with those you only need when everything's safe.

Let's be a bit less snarky, talk about it more seriously. Dredge is a pretty slow-paced, relaxed game, apart from being out at night at high panic. But at those times, selecting abilities quickly is important. You may need to turn off your lights before the Night Angler notices you, scare off crows that are about to steal your fish with the Foghorn, or use Haste or Banish, etc. to avoid damage from monsters.

Opening the radial menu only slows down time, and while it may be due to my butterfingers (playing on Switch), on numerous occasions it's taken me two or three times to select the ability I want and not the one to the top or bottom of it.

Clearly, it's a design choice that the menu doesn't pause the game, in order to increase the stressfulness of hostile encounters. However, getting frustrated by unresponsive and unnecessarily complicated controls (the intermixing, etc. I mention earlier) is something entirely different from being stressed out by having to react under time pressure.

Hence, I strongly suggest that BSG adds an "radial menu pauses the game" toggle in the options. It would be a meaningful compromise between the normal and passive game modes, for those of us who don't have twitch reflexes, or may have other reasons why they struggle with the control scheme.

A more lenient radial menu would also open up the design space for different interactions between abilities and dangerous creatures, and encourage the player to experiment with them. Lights and Foghorn could attract and repel different creatures, and different upgrades to these abilities could be introduced. You could try throwing bait or crab cages overboard to distract pursuers, or let the player use explosive charges to scare them off (or even for dynamite fishing). With a radial menu that doesn't pause the game, introducing new abilities in DLC would make it more cumbersome to use with each new one. By making it pause the game, you can neatly avoid this problem.


r/dredge • • Jan 18 '25

Did I miss something, or is the story/ending never actually explained?

0 Upvotes

I did both the good and bad ending. I did the good one first, delivering all relics but taking the book because the collector and the spells were creepy, then listening the the lighthouse keeper. I had no idea who "she/her" was, or why I got swallowed by a fish. It was probably one of the most anti-climatic and "huh" endings of a game I've played in recent memory.

Then I reloaded for the bad ending, did the ritual, and it still never really tells you what happened. You can infer her/she is a significant other, I guess, though it could just as easily be a daughter.

Are the vague mentions of "something terrible" and "blood" really all it ever conveys about the actual story? Or did I miss something?

EDIT: a lot of assumptions and judgment in the replies.

  1. I don't play a lot of games.

  2. I played a little bit at a time over a long time. I'm sure it's easy to remember all the little details and put it together if you play over a shorter time or maybe have a better memory I guess

  3. the bottles, being easy to never find in the first place, function differently than every other item you acquire in the entire game. They don't go to cargo or storage, just disappear into messages. if you had to open the bottle from one of those places, it would be consistent with the game mechanic and you wouldn't miss reading them.


r/dredge • • Apr 20 '25

Should I keep playing or is the game just not meant for me?

2 Upvotes

I started my first ~80 minutes of Dredge last night and couldn't get into it? I know the game is "Overwhelmingly Positive" so what am I missing? So far, Dredge just feels like:

  • The core mechanics (tap on green) feel like a dumpy mobile idle game I could get for free

  • The fog + sleeping just incentivizes you to stay near a dock

  • Your boat filling up with fish within 2 minutes of leaving incentivizes you to stay near a dock

  • The further you go out the harder it is to turn around and sell which incentivizes you to stay near a dock

Like, is this game just 15 hours of sitting near a dock, loading up on the same 4 fish spawns, and returning to sell till your boat is upgraded? I don't see any underlying story or mystery or reason to explore this world other than "ohh, you found a spooky handkerchief! Maybe there will be more spooky household goods!" or "ohh, a spooky mutated fish! Maybe you'll pull up more fish with weird blobs drawn on their face!"

For context: Subnautica, SOMA, Outer Wilds are some of my favorite games. I love story driven indie games combined with some psych horror. I'm itching for another great game so if there's more to Dredge than "tap green till you find all the hidden household goods" and I need to keep pushing through the intro please let me know.


r/dredge • • Apr 07 '26

Discussion Wheres the fucking sequel?

0 Upvotes

Seriously this is a game that NEEDS a sequel!!!

The studio made this game years ago and hasn't made anything since!

WHat the fuck!!!

We need a new dredge with new mechanics, new map, new characters, new lore etc


r/dredge • • Aug 15 '23

Ruined the ending for myself accidentally

5 Upvotes

Finished the game the other day but so frustrated because I misread the dialogue that you're prompted with at the end when confronting Mr. Memento.

The dialogue prompts you with "do you know who I am" or something similar and for some dumb reason I selected "I know".

As a result, you get nothing, you just are left with having to go to the spot with the book.

So frustrating. I feel like most games that have a dialogue that prompts users over whether they figured it out or not still do some further exposition afterwards (I mean afterall how would you even confirm what you know?). There's also no option to go back and change your answer.

So I had to watch YouTube videos explaining the ending and the big twist. Complete let down.

I know it's my fault, but seems like poor design to not at least still provide the reveal. Literally it goes:

"Do you know who I am?" " I know" "Then you know what to do"

That's it. Not even hinting at the twist. Hell even if it wasn't a mistake, wouldn't you still as a matter of good writing confirm the person's knowledge? I honestly don't remember why I selected "I know", but what if I thought the guy was the lost mayor or something?? How would I actually confirm this?

Amazing game, loved every minute but so disappointed how easy it was to mess up the dialogue ending.


r/dredge • • Aug 21 '26

Finished First Playthrough

5 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion, maybe: Dredge is a good idea that never quite becomes a great game. The atmosphere is genuinely special, and that first foggy night run is unforgettable, but the core loop is shallow. The fishing minigames repeat fast, the horror stops being scary once your boat is upgraded, and the panic mechanic becomes trivial to manage. By the back half I was mostly running errands in a spooky skin, and the story hints at more than it ever delivers. None of that makes it bad. It's a pleasant ten hours and I get why people love it. I just think it gets by on vibes more than substance. Did anyone else feel the tension drain out midway, or did the endgame land better for you?


r/dredge • • Oct 08 '23

Discussion Do i get the DLC if i’ve already bought the deluxe edition?

3 Upvotes

I bought the deluxe edition a while ago since it was on sale and cheaper than the standard edition, but do i get the upcoming DLC for free since i bought the deluxe edition, or do i have to pay for it?

I just think that in the future the DLC will be added to the deluxe ixe edition so it would make sense that the ones who have already bought the deluxe edition just get the DLC.


r/dredge • • Jul 10 '25

Haven't seen these birds before, I guess they are DLC addition

2 Upvotes

r/dredge • • Oct 15 '23

Can I transfer my pirated save if the game to the real steam one

2 Upvotes

This game is just so good so I wanted to buy it for the devs. So can I transfer my save from the pirated version to the real version?


r/dredge • • Apr 24 '24

Discussion Defeating all monsters

4 Upvotes

You know what would be cool?
If in the next dlc we get a way to permanently defeat all monsters, like we did with the Mind Suckers.
What if a military fleet come to the archipelago?
Would cannons and bombs be enough to kill every monster? (exept the leviathan of course)
What do you think about it?
Thank you in advance!

EDIT:

I've read your responses, and i must add:

What if, this mechanic happens only AFTER you collect all the artifacts/the ending?
Also, this would be a questline where you need to do the right things in order to help the Navy, or the monsters would just eat them too (maybe getting more powers if you do so?). Thing that would happen anyway if they go against the leviathans.
I know this is a horror game, and i love it for what it is, but i feel this would "complete it", see the humans fight back against the darkness, and inevitably fail when dealing the really big stuff.

Thank you again in advance!!


r/dredge • • Sep 10 '24

Dredge A new player's first experience with Dredge- Part 4

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/dredge • • Jan 12 '26

Discussion Dreadmoor

Thumbnail
store.steampowered.com
1 Upvotes

Saw this new game (currently in play test) in Steam, looks very familiar …

Hope to be able to test it soon !


r/dredge • • May 26 '24

This game needs an increase in fishing difficulty

12 Upvotes

The game is wonderful, the story, the gameplay, the songs, everything. But one thing I missed is the progression of difficulty in the fishing part. I think that as you go through and progress through the game, the fish should get harder to catch, but that doesn't happen or it's very slight. for people who like a more chill game, there could be a hardmode that would be unlocked by finishing the game once, so you can choose what you prefer.


r/dredge • • Jun 12 '26

Dredge I made dredge into a fictional TV show

Post image
0 Upvotes

Go check out all the details(Episode names & Descriptions)—> https://seriesgraph.com/fictional-charts/8544a4c7-234c-4002-bd50-706d613b3517


r/dredge • • Mar 03 '24

I like this game! Hope you like my commentary 😉

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/dredge • • May 11 '26

Discussion What If Dredge was in first person, honestly, I LOVED THIS

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

(Made by AI)


r/dredge • • Oct 11 '25

Dredge Which place in game / which version this picture.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I just got this picture from my friend asking me to help identify "meaning" of this picture.. I asked chatGPT and it said from Dredge. But when I playing it (currently at devil's spine), I can't seem to find the area in this picture at all. The aesthetic seem to be similar to Dredge, even that floaty box, so... must be from this game.

Can anyone help me identify this picture?
Is it from Dredge (current version or earlier version), if so, where in game this picture is?


r/dredge • • Oct 08 '24

Anybody else hoping for a patch that allows selective enabling of the DLC'S?

1 Upvotes

Much as I love Iron Rig, I'd like to play the game without it again, there's a way to get to both endings without buying equipment at the pontoons if you have Dredge+Blackstone Key+Pale Reach and I'd like to play it that way again sometime in the future


r/dredge • • Jun 27 '26

Seems that u guys liked the idea of a dredge roleplay

1 Upvotes

Well good news, its ready to start now!

r/DREDGE_RP


r/dredge • • Jun 19 '25

New Dredge movie trailer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

First trailer for the dredge movie posted by A24DredgeFilm youtube account


r/dredge • • Dec 23 '24

Does Anyone Else Feel The Collector's Edition is a Bit Much for what they're asking?

2 Upvotes

I'm currently sitting at 200 hours in game, so not a small amount invested. I just got Iron Rig admittedly so I just completed my DLC but - either way..... $100 bucks for a map, coin, the sigil, an art book, etc. IDK - maybe it's just me but that just seems under whelming.

If it had like a glowing element, something with red or blue LED I'd have been so down. I had my brother offer to buy it for me for Christmas and I asked him not to because I genuinely didn't want it. Am I alone in this?


r/dredge • • Feb 26 '25

Why cant you play after the game is done ?

0 Upvotes

Idk when i finished the game i felt like there was more to do like side quests n making my bigger n upgrading it you know but it just throws me back in the menu n when i press continue its before i finished the game …


r/dredge • • Oct 10 '26

Switch 2 and 60fps without dev kit possibility

0 Upvotes

I seen posts talking about the devs not having a SW2 dev-kit to make an upgrade version. As some people said "it play nice on switch 1 version" and its not, 30 fps on this game feels terrible. I seen that the game runs on 60 fps at base switch using a homebrew called fpslocker and a patch inside that, the game runs without any issues on a much lower powerful hardware. So if some random people can make the game run unofficial with few tweaks, why not the devs release a patch atleast to uncap the framerate to 60. Then they can do a proper switch 2 version with 4k res and all the rest when the dev kit arrives, but i'm always looking to buy the game and never complete the purchase because the demo running at 30 its TERRIBLE, feels like a power point when doing mini games and the input lag its insane. Graphics looks ok on handheld mode with boost but fps and input lag are blocking me to buy this game on switch 2


r/dredge • • Aug 21 '23

I caught my first "nightme fish" and recorded it! Come swing by :D

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes