r/dredge • u/Queen_Six • Dec 22 '23
The WORST minigame
No, it's not that one fishing minigame where it becomes impossible to catch trophies once your fishing speed is too high. Good call, though.
The worst minigame in Dredge is the radial menu, because it doesn't pause the game, is imprecise in its selection, shows the menu on the left side of the screen while being controlled by the right stick, and intermixes emergency abilities with those you only need when everything's safe.
Let's be a bit less snarky, talk about it more seriously. Dredge is a pretty slow-paced, relaxed game, apart from being out at night at high panic. But at those times, selecting abilities quickly is important. You may need to turn off your lights before the Night Angler notices you, scare off crows that are about to steal your fish with the Foghorn, or use Haste or Banish, etc. to avoid damage from monsters.
Opening the radial menu only slows down time, and while it may be due to my butterfingers (playing on Switch), on numerous occasions it's taken me two or three times to select the ability I want and not the one to the top or bottom of it.
Clearly, it's a design choice that the menu doesn't pause the game, in order to increase the stressfulness of hostile encounters. However, getting frustrated by unresponsive and unnecessarily complicated controls (the intermixing, etc. I mention earlier) is something entirely different from being stressed out by having to react under time pressure.
Hence, I strongly suggest that BSG adds an "radial menu pauses the game" toggle in the options. It would be a meaningful compromise between the normal and passive game modes, for those of us who don't have twitch reflexes, or may have other reasons why they struggle with the control scheme.
A more lenient radial menu would also open up the design space for different interactions between abilities and dangerous creatures, and encourage the player to experiment with them. Lights and Foghorn could attract and repel different creatures, and different upgrades to these abilities could be introduced. You could try throwing bait or crab cages overboard to distract pursuers, or let the player use explosive charges to scare them off (or even for dynamite fishing). With a radial menu that doesn't pause the game, introducing new abilities in DLC would make it more cumbersome to use with each new one. By making it pause the game, you can neatly avoid this problem.