r/dostoevsky • • Aug 26 '26

A sketch from Dostoevsky’s notebook for The Idiot

Post image
152 Upvotes

I recently read Dostoevsky’s notebooks for The Idiot, and they were super interesting. As we all know, Dostoevsky tended to write under deadline pressure, and The Idiot was no different. It was published in serial form in the Russian Messenger, and 23 days before the first five chapters were due, he threw out what he had written and started over.

What would eventually become The Idiot was Dostoevsky’s seventh version of the story and specifically the character of Prince Myshkin. Interestingly, earlier versions of Myshkin were closer to to Raskolnikov from Crime and Punishment, marked by “immeasurable pride” and a “burning need for love,” and capable of extreme manifestations of both good and evil.

It’s also interesting that the first five chapters were written before the idea of what Myshkin would be was fully developed. After submitting the first installment, he wrote to his niece, explaining that he was trying to portray “a perfectly beautiful human”.

“There is nothing more difficult than this in the world, especially now”, he wrote. “All writers, not only ours, but even all European writers, whoever has attempted to portray the positively beautiful,—has always given up. Because the task is immeasurable. The beautiful is an ideal, but the ideal—neither ours nor that of civilized Europe—is as yet very far from having been worked out.”

Anyway, I wrote an article that I’ll post here if anyone is curious. I also recommend reading the notebooks for fans of The Idiot. Very interesting. https://dostoevskyrr.substack.com/p/a-perfectly-beautiful-human-how-dostoevsky?r=1cx4ka&utm_medium=ios


r/dostoevsky • • Jul 06 '26

Notes From Underground Stage Production in GTA in Two Weeks

14 Upvotes

Hello, members of r/Dostoevsky... I have made this reddit account specifically to reach out to you (and any other subreddits that may be interested)

I am staging a production of Notes From Underground at the Hamilton Fringe Festival, opening on July 16 and running until July 25. I adapted it, am directing, and will also be playing the Underground Man. It is a 7-actor production, and the majority of the play consists of The Story Apropos of the Wet Snow.

If any of you happen to be in the GTA and would like to come out, that would be incredible. Please let me know if you do -- I would love to say hello after the show.

Not sure if I am allowed to post links -- feel free to just Google 'Notes From Underground Hamilton' if it gets removed-- but show details are here: https://hftco.ca/events/notes-from-underground/

Hope to see some of you there, because that would be awesome!!

- an Insect


r/dostoevsky • • 8h ago

An edition of Dostoevsky’s Works published for the centenary of his birth in 1921

Post image
46 Upvotes

I’ve always been fascinated by how the Soviet Union handled 19th century writers, and Dostoevsky is particularly interesting because so much of what he wrote was completely against what the Soviet Union stood for. I stumbled across a speech given by Lunacharskii, the Commissar of Enlightenment, during the 100-year anniversary of Dostoevsky’s birth (1921).  In that speech, if you can believe it, he claimed “Yes, Dostoevsky is a socialist. Dostoevsky is a revolutionary!”

As it turns out, there were tons of events held in 1921 for the centenary, and a lot of mental gymnastics to try to fit Dostoevsky into the Bolsheviks’ worldview. Of course, not everyone agreed (Lenin himself had famously said Demons was “reactionary filth”), but this was before there was a real hard and unforgiving cultural policy. That would change when Stalin consolidated power, and then again with the turn toward the Russian canon in the late 1930s and during the War.

Anyway, I wrote something about the 1921 centenary here if you’d like to know more. Surprisingly little about it is available in English. Dostoevsky and the Bolsheviks: The Centenary of 1921


r/dostoevsky • • 2d ago

"Love life more than the meaning of it." — Commemorating the master at his final resting place (Tikhvin Cemetery, St. Petersburg).

Post image
317 Upvotes

From Part II, Book V, Chapter 3 of The Brothers Karamazov, during the profound, soul-baring dialogue between Ivan and Alyosha.

Dostoevsky reminds us that we must love existence regardless of logic, for only then can we truly grasp its meaning. If we begin to love the 'meaning' of life—the cold logic, the rigid ideologies, or our own hidden agendas—more than life itself, wouldn't that be where the ultimate human tragedy begins?

Captured and shared with deep reverence for the great master who rests in Tikhvin Cemetery, St. Petersburg.


r/dostoevsky • • 2d ago

I hated reading The Idiot, but couldn't stop reading until I finished it.

56 Upvotes

I assume this is a common experience when reading The Idiot (I have seen previous posts about it). It took me several months to finish it. Sometimes I couldn't go beyond 5 pages without being sick of the characters' absurdity. I kept reading without really understanding the hidden meaning of such idiocy until I finished it and read the introduction, and this stuck in my mind:

When Max Brod complained to Kafka that there were too many mad protagonists in Dostoevsky's novels, Kafka disagreed vehemently. Their illness, Kafka argued, was a way to make visible their inner terror. Many of Dostoevsky's characters may well be either insane or diseased, but their 'dis-ease' must be understood as a consequence of their sensitivity to the absurdity and hopelessness of human existence.

​The trivialities, superficiality and hysterical behavior in each character must be hiding their weakness and vulnerability - noise as armor - but it's so hard not to be engulfed by the overwhelming absurdity throughout the entire novel.


r/dostoevsky • • 2d ago

Where is Sonya?voice over

22 Upvotes

Mods , delete if this doesn’t suit the sub.

Hello folks ,

I know it’s frowned upon but I stumbled upon a voiceover of the letter Dostoevsky wrote to this friend after the untimely demise of sonya.i thought you might appreciate it .
Thanks.


r/dostoevsky • • 4d ago

I am so excited to read this

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Crime & Punishment was my first Dostoevsky novel, followed by Notes from the Underground and White Nights. Is there anything I should know going into it? No spoilers obviously 😅

Side note: I am beyond disappointed in myself for not reading Dostoevsky’s work sooner. To think that I have spent the past 33 years of my life not reading these masterpieces pains me to my core. I read them slowly, take notes as I go, and write down words I am unfamiliar with along with their definitions. I intend to read every single one of his books.

Thank you fellow readers 🤍


r/dostoevsky • • 3d ago

Do we know if this is releasing in hardback yet?

Post image
133 Upvotes

Only seeing paperback and Kindle edition on Amazon. I thought we might get a hardback edition to go with Katz’s Brothers Karamazov and The Idiot, but looks as though it’ll be a paperback to go with Crime & Punishment instead….

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Notes-Underground-Translation-Fyodor-Dostoevsky/dp/1324146915


r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

Rodions dream analysis

Post image
174 Upvotes

The dream state refers to Rodion's inner mind, glimpses of his morality buried under his consciousness. The unconscious can be understood using Lacanian psychoanalysis to refer to symbolism displayed during Rodion’s dreams. But the poor boy, beside himself, made his way, screaming, through the crowd to the sorrel nag, put his arms round her bleeding dead head and kissed it, kissed the eyes and kissed the lips. . . . Then he jumped up and flew in a frenzy with his little fists out at Mikolka. At that instant his father, who had been running after him, snatched him up and carried him out of the crowd."Come along, come! Let us go home," he said to him."Father! Why did they . . . kill . . . the poor horse!" he sobbed, but his voice broke and the words came in shrieks from his panting” . Using Lacanian psychoanalysis, we observe that the dream symbolizes Rodion’s internalized emotions regarding his planned murder. The horse symbolises Lizaveta Ivanovna and their innocence within their inexcusable deaths resulted from deluded individuals. Marmeladov symbolises the real within Rodion, a raw existence driven by physical desires. As both kill the innocent in a fever, symbolising their rebirth, free from morality. However the child’s conflict with Marmeladov's actions, symbolises Rodion's inner guilt and morality. His conscience has purposely displayed the duality of his nature, and the conflict to come due to opposition between the Child(Morality) and Marmeladov(desire).

- not my artwork


r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

Ivan Karamazov - Poem by R.S. Thomas

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 6d ago

Are there any good film or mini series adaptations of TBK?

8 Upvotes

I know it’s such a sacred and deep work so it might be blasphemous… but some of the scenes, particularly the dialogue gave me head movies while reading and I’d really love to see what visual artists do with the story.

I also think my gf would really enjoy the story and all the philosophy, but a 900+ page novel that’s light on plot for 400+ pages isn’t her vibe.

The Japanese adaptation from 2010 looks the most promising. Did it do the book justice?


r/dostoevsky • • 7d ago

Sonya version of my analysis

Post image
146 Upvotes

The Super Ego within Rodion is symbolised by Sonya. Sonya is the child of a drunken man, who’s married into a new family. Her father, stepmother and her children all live in extreme poverty and depend on Sonya for cash, forcing her to sell her body. This lifestyle forced upon Sonya clashes with her morality as she is a devout Christian. Now despite having the ability to step above her morality through her actions, she clings to her faith and morals. Acting as the lead figure within leading Rodion towards redemption.The symbolism between Sonya and Rodion's superego comes from her actions, rather then confronting Rodion with the truth or pressuring him through psychological torture, she forces Rodion to confront his morality(superego) through her words. “What have you done—what have you done to yourself”. The quote itself, displays Sonya’s symbolising Rodion's superego’s and its function as an internal moral compass suppressed under the ego. Rather than mechanical condemnation, the question challenges Rodion’s justification and reasoning for committing murder and the practicality of the extraordinary man theory. The result is that Rodion superego confronts his ego and ID, rather than hiding within his philosophical rants in an attempt to suppress self loathing. Therefore the duplication of Sonya’s question, suggests that morality and moral judgement can’t be suppressed by ego/rational thinking but only through spiritual redemption/judgment can an individual truly escape guilt.  

-not my art in the post


r/dostoevsky • • 8d ago

IT’S PEAK 🏔️ (Father Sergius - Tolystoy)

Post image
82 Upvotes

Although this does say more about the ethics and virtuous of Christianity, rather than pure faith which we often see in doestotevetsky — there faith leads to human communion.

Here, Tolstoy said the opposite: that human communion leads to faith.

He says in another page; Communion with Humans doesn’t come from Communion with God, rather Communion with God comes from Communion with Humans.

Do you guys agree? Or do think that faith in God (here Christ) does lead to communion with humans? We’ve seen it with prince myshkin (the idiot) and also I’m Alyshoa (near the end; TBK).

Or…


r/dostoevsky • • 8d ago

quick Sviddrigailov analysis

Post image
92 Upvotes

Sviddrigailov is a gross manifestation of the extraordinary man from Rodion’s theory, characterising a complete rejection of religion, morality and law. Both have attempted to rise above morality in order to satisfy their ID, however Rodion’s superego/unconscience causes mental torment and prevents him from becoming extraordinary. However Sviddrigailov isn’t shackled by his superego/conscience like Rodion and therefore leads a life of self-pleasure with complete disregard for inner and universal morality. Defined by his spiritual void and nihility, rather devoted to fulfilling his ID. In this vice at least there is something permanent, founded indeed upon nature and not dependent on fantasy Within the quote, the juxtaposition between nature and fantasy refers to the conflict between the ID and Superego. To Sviddrigailov nature represents his desires based on reality while fantasy refers to the internal morality, an illusion only existing within the mind. The juxtaposition reveals two hidden meanings within Sviddrigailov character, one displays his total indifference towards morality and moral judgement. The second refers to humans inability to escape moral judgement, despite claiming morality is a fantasy, he seeks this very same fantasy. Shown through his sudden acts of charity, and his death. Which are derived for his attempt washing away his sins, due to a blinding desire to escape his existential vacuum and when forced to confront his internal void, he kills himself. This urge for moral judgement displays horrifying consequences derived from the complete rejection of morality.


r/dostoevsky • • 8d ago

First time reading through C&P and this provoked some thoughts

Post image
62 Upvotes

Does every individual have the capacity to become "extraordinary"? In this context, to take charge of their destiny and be willing to step over the line or rather redraw it on the sands of morality to fit their version of justice? And if they do, do they get a pass on account of their self proclaimed superiority ? ( Ofc not ) Or as an extraordinary person, should you go as far as to make it apparent that you are above the reproach of the law? does your extraordinary nature only become apparent once the dust settles and in retrospect? It kinda reminds me of Johan Liebert from Monster.


r/dostoevsky • • 10d ago Bravo Heartwarming

Happy birthday to Fyodor! :3

Post image
2.1k Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 10d ago

Happy 205th birthday to Dostoevsky!

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Born 11 November 1821. Died 9 February 1881.

Beauty will save the world!


r/dostoevsky • • 10d ago

Raskolnikov & Porfiry Petrovich. Dialogues

44 Upvotes

I’m rereading every dialogue between Rodion Raskolnikov and the examining magistrate Porfiry Petrovich, and I want to write about them later. These two, especially Porfiry, who does most of the talking, are truly terrifying in their own way... Is there anything in particular that stands out to you in these exchanges? I’ll read your observations


r/dostoevsky • • 11d ago

What did ppl prefer writing wise, stavrogin's confession or Rodions rebirth

Thumbnail
gallery
138 Upvotes

For me, stavrogin's confession was better


r/dostoevsky • • 11d ago

Just got “Devils” Oxford University Press edition paperback.

10 Upvotes

My read for next month.

This is my first Oxford Press book, it’s a bit smaller format than the Penquin Classics I’ve usually bought.

The paperback cover feels like very thick card stock.

The back indicates Michael R Katz translation and a restored chapter “Stavrogin’s Confession”, too shocking to print back in the day, yet it does not show as a Chapter in the TOC. No Mayer.

Also, the footnotes are an intriguing method, indicated by an asterisk by the noted word/phrase and organized by Page Number in the Notes section.

I’m doing no other reading about this book before I dive in.

I found and saved a reading plan post in this sub for this book that I’ll review too.


r/dostoevsky • • 11d ago

Book buddy for crime and punishment

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/dostoevsky • • 15d ago

Raskolnikov’s eternal truth.

Post image
834 Upvotes

Dostoevsky didn’t just write books. He lived and breathed our deepest pain.

Missing Raskolnikov and Sonya tonight.


r/dostoevsky • • 15d ago

170 pages into Demons and four pages of notes.

Post image
322 Upvotes

Just Dostoevsky things… :D


r/dostoevsky • • 14d ago

Demons Introduction Wordsworth Classics

2 Upvotes

Before I read the introduction, does the Wordsworth Classics intro to Demons contain spoilers?


r/dostoevsky • • 15d ago

Anyone else feels this way- that Dostoevsky's work does not express great empathy and compassion to all of his characters?

Post image
41 Upvotes

Not trying to humiliate or ostracize the person who responded to me with this comment. Genuinely curious. I am no expert on Dostoevsky. Just a big fan. He has recently become my all time favorite author. I have read Crime & Punishment twice since last year and am working on a second read of Brothers and a first of House of the Dead. What I love about his work above all is the psychological and philosophical depths he plunges, and his incredible empathy and compassion for people of all walks.