1 Star — November 21, 2026
I'm increasingly tired of watching the retail and food-service industries shift more and more costs directly onto consumers while simultaneously framing their offerings as discounts, benefits, and supposed savings.
If these companies are really struggling so much that they need to keep nickel-and-diming their customers in the shadows, maybe their business models need to change.
Except here's the thing: DoorDash is making more money than ever.
DoorDash reported $13.7 billion in revenue and $935 million in net income attributable to common shareholders in 2025.
In the third quarter of 2026 alone, it reported $4.6 billion in revenue, $466 million in net income, and $1.06 billion in adjusted EBITDA. Revenue increased 34% year over year, while net income increased 91%.
These are DoorDash's own publicly reported financial results. Keep those figures in mind.
I have DashPass through my Sapphire Reserve card that comes with a substantial annual fee. I'm already participating in a paid financial ecosystem that advertises delivery benefits as part of the value proposition.
So I decided to compare my DoorDash grocery checkout against the prices at the exact same Giant grocery store in Arlington, Virginia.
On November 21, 2026, DoorDash quoted me $184.45 for 24 items, including its preselected 7% shopper tip.
The app prominently congratulated me for saving $16.10 through DashPass and deals, while also displaying $6.60 in savings from my linked Giant membership.
Rather than simply accept those numbers, I went to Giant and checked the shelf prices myself.
The results were absurd.
Here are the prices for the same products I compared:
| Product | Giant in-store | DoorDash | Markup |
|---|
| Sargento Balanced Breaks | $7.49 | $8.79 | +17.4% |
| NY strip steak | $15.49 | $18.19 | +17.4% |
| Klondike Reese's bars | $5.59 | $6.59 | +17.9% |
| Blueberries | $3.99 | $4.49 | +12.5% |
| Eggs | $2.39 | $3.99 | +66.9% |
| Campbell's Chunky soup | $3.69 | $3.99 | +8.1% |
| Boar's Head turkey | $2.00 cheaper | $18.79 | +11.9% |
One Gatorade variety was cheaper on DoorDash, but that was the exception among the products I compared above.
Using matching quantities, I calculated approximately $16.40 in additional merchandise charges across just these groceries.
These were products I personally price-checked. I later made a few economical substitutions, but that doesn't change what the identical products cost on DoorDash versus inside the store.
Now let's examine what this transaction actually cost before DoorDash started congratulating itself for all the money it supposedly saved me.
The real checkout breakdown:
Merchandise subtotal: $172.47
Bag fee: $0.15
Estimated tax: $1.72
Service fee before DashPass waiver: $10.61
Delivery fee before DashPass waiver: $2.49
Suggested 7% shopper tip: $13.11
Total without discounts or waived fees: $200.55.
DoorDash "special" membership then eliminates $13.10 in delivery and service fees and applies a $3 discount.
Final price with my premium-card DashPass benefits: $184.45.
So DoorDash begins with a $200.55 transaction, advertises $16.10 in savings against that total, and produces a $184.45 checkout.
Meanwhile, I had already identified approximately $16.40 in merchandise price premiums on a portion of the basket.
Across those compared items, the advertised $16.10 in savings was effectively wiped out before I even considered tipping.
Now consider all the additional costs.
The $16.40 merchandise premium, $13.10 in pre-waiver fees, and $13.11 suggested tip add up to $42.61 in identifiable price premiums, fees, and tipping on the comparison.
This is why I find the whole DashPass savings presentation so insulting.
It's a pricing structure that makes discounts look impressive because consumers aren't being given a straightforward comparison against what those groceries would cost in the store. They are given some made up number that they are discounted in the app.
A discount against an app-inflated pricing structure isn't a consumer saving.
But the most revealing part of the transaction was the tip.
DoorDash automatically selected a 7% tip of $13.11.
Seven percent of my actual $171.34 pretipping checkout total is $11.99.
So why $13.11?
I worked backward through the numbers.
Take the merchandise subtotal, add the estimated tax, then add the $10.61 service fee and $2.49 delivery fee that DashPass supposedly eliminated.
That produces $187.29.
Seven percent of $187.29 is $13.11. Exactly.
Even the other suggested percentage options match this higher calculation base.
In other words, the platform appears to calculate its suggested tip using the very fees it has told customers they aren't paying.
I cannot inspect the underlying algorithm, but the arithmetic is remarkably clear.
And this illustrates a much larger problem with modern tipping culture.
Tipping has become an increasingly aggressive mechanism for transferring compensation costs onto consumers.
It used to be a relatively straightforward way to recognize good service. Now consumers are routinely presented with predetermined percentages, increasingly high suggested amounts, and checkout prompts that make tipping feel less like voluntary recognition and more like another expected transaction charge.
We're now asked to tip for everything, including some transactions where the service consists of little more than ladling food into a bowl.
And in this case, a multibillion-dollar technology platform appears to be recommending a tip using a calculation base that includes charges the customer doesn't even owe.
Meanwhile, worker compensation is increasingly negotiated through customer guilt and interface design rather than transparent pricing and compensation arrangements.
Just pay your freaking people.
This isn't a criticism of the shopper. The shopper deserves reasonable compensation. And I'm not claiming that DoorDash pockets the shopper's tip; though that's actually not clear.
It's a criticism of a business model that makes the consumer responsible for navigating a maze of merchandise premiums, labor compensation expectations, subscriptions, fees, promotions, and algorithmically generated recommendations.
Why should customers be left trying to reverse-engineer a percentage calculation at checkout?
And why is a company that reported $466 million in net income in a single quarter presenting something as basic as a suggested 7% tip in a manner that apparently incorporates waived fees?
The broader retail industry is increasingly comfortable with this approach.
Rather than simply telling consumers what something costs, companies fragment the total into multiple components, introduce loyalty programs and subscription tiers, and then present the removal of selected charges as evidence of extraordinary value.
It's becoming a game of making customers feel like they're winning while making it harder to determine what they're actually spending.
We're paying more, navigating increasingly complicated transactions, and being congratulated for the privilege.
After seeing the prices, I went into Giant and bought the groceries myself. I made a few minor economical substitutions and walked out with 29 products for $180.58.
DoorDash's proposed 24-item checkout was $184.45 with my membership benefits, or $200.55 before those benefits.
I bought more products for less money.
The baskets weren't perfectly identical, so I'm not pretending that the difference between their totals is a precise measure of markup. That's why I checked and documented the prices of the matching products separately. That being said, I purchased MORE products.
And before someone says, “You're paying for convenience,” I understand that perfectly.
I'm not objecting to paying for convenience. I'm objecting to disguising the price of convenience through inflated merchandise prices, complicated fee waivers, and opaque tip calculations.
If delivery is worth another $20, $30, or $40, show me that price clearly.
Let me decide whether the service is worth it.
Don't bury much of that cost in the grocery prices, display an enormous savings banner, and then apparently calculate the suggested tip using fees you've already removed.
DoorDash should disclose the aggregate merchandise premium, clearly explain its tip calculation base, and stop presenting internal fee waivers as though they establish savings relative to shopping at the store.
And Chase should pay attention to how these benefits are experienced by its premium cardholders. A subscription benefit is significantly less compelling when the underlying transaction contains merchandise premiums that can wipe out the advertised savings.
The fact that DoorDash is growing rapidly and reporting substantial profits makes this all the more frustrating.
There's nothing wrong with a company being profitable. But at this scale, expecting transparent pricing is hardly an unreasonable demand.
I can't establish that the individual grocery markups I observed caused DoorDash's corporate profits, and I recognize that merchants may also participate in setting in-app prices.
But DoorDash controls the checkout experience that presents those prices, fees, discounts, and suggested tips to the customer.
And that's where the transparency should exist.
I have the physical grocery receipt, DoorDash checkout screenshots, my firsthand shelf-price comparisons, and the company's published financial figures.
This is exactly the sort of retail practice that deserves far more public scrutiny.
The problem isn't that convenience costs money. It's that companies have become extraordinarily sophisticated at obscuring the real cost while convincing consumers they're getting a deal.
And when a company can generate billions in annual revenue while its customers need a calculator during a "not recession" to understand their alleged savings, something about that experience deserves to be challenged.