r/doctorsUK • • Mar 22 '26 Wholesome Seal Bravo

⚠️ Unverified/Potential Misinformation ⚠️ G.P. to kindly end fascism

5 Upvotes

Next week the BMA is doing what it does best, wasting your money, and mine, going on a march in London against fascism, virtue signalling instead of working for you.

Who could be against hope? Who is in favour of hate? Which doctor is in favour of fascism? 

No one. And that’s the point. 

For decades the BMA has busied itself fighting strawmen. Going on marches in favour of the NHS (don’t believe me, go to update your BMA details, you’ll be met by a picture from a demo with a big NHS banner). 

My point here is, yes fascism is bad, I think that pretty universally we can agree that it’s bad. But the work the BMA can do is limited, and every minute we spend arguing about things that are outside the scope of our pay and conditions, or issues that other organisations are fighting against (quite frankly a lot better than the BMA), is a minute less spent on fixing issues affecting our pay and contracts.

It costs nothing for your reps to condemn fascism, funnily enough it doesn't defeat it either; not only are they taking away from time where they could be advocating for the profession, they aren’t ever going to achieve their stated goal with this performative waste of time.

BMA council elections are underway and people need to recognise just how important this vote is. Five minutes of your time this weekend will probably shape the next decade of the profession.

The basic work of a union is optimising pay, terms and conditions for its members. The BMA, I think we can all agree, failed in this basic duty with regard to resident doctors over the period 2008-2022. 

Pay fell in real terms. Rotas arrived late, pay went wrong, leave was denied, induction structures were labyrinthine and disorganised. We got used to being treated as unimportant 'baby doctors' whose personal lives could be upended on a whim, who were required to constantly 'be kind' under the watchful eye of big brother, sending TAB after TAB to colleagues for whom there was no reciprocal feedback mechanism. A member of the #OneTeam has been rude to you? Too bad. Suck it up. 

If you make an issue of it, you are the problem.

For some time this held, doctors on the whole just want to be doctors. We have a fundamentally great job and most of us just want to get on with it, in a system that respects us and works. Eventually though, individually and then collectively, we started to think, is this it? Is this really the best we can do?

For some it was being denied leave or training. For some it was meeting friends who had never sat on a bin in their professional life. For some it was the paper-thin Potemkin safety culture, more interested in being seen to do something than doing the thing. For many it was the insane realisation that physician associates would be paid more than physicians, not as some anomalous quirk, but by deliberate policy.

Eventually on Reddit enough doctors found each other and started to ask: could we collectively do something about our pay and conditions? Is there an organisation whose job it is to do this?

Ah yes, the BMA.

One of these reddit renegades formed Doctors Vote and the rest, as they say, is history. Since memories are short, please remember that they are the people who, through extraordinary hard work and strategising, managed to take enough control of the BMA to carry through the changes we have seen since 2022.

This post is not about what Doctors Vote achieved. It is about who wasn't there, who didn't help, and what failed to happen in the long years before.

Many of those now asking for your vote have been BMA representatives for years. Sure they aren't the reps who have been there for 30 years, but they were there for the past 10 years when nothing got done. 

You deserve to know what they were doing and what they achieved during that time. Success has many fathers but if someone asks for your vote you have the right to know if they really were a sperm donor, or if they were just some guy sitting in the room.

So what was the BMA doing from 2008 to 2022?

It was accepting real-terms pay cuts rather than pissing off the government. It was doing nothing significant to protect individuals from rota, holiday and pay errors, with no strategy to support doctors or penalise trusts who made them routine. 

It was opening UK training posts to overseas doctors while making BMA membership free for new arrivals, without anyone at the BMA pausing to consider the very basic and obvious point that this would inevitably increase competition for existing members. 

It was campaigning for more medical school places without thinking through the long-term consequences. 

It was supporting medical apprenticeships, essentially two-tier medical degrees, without considering the effect on the value of a British medical degree or the risks to the students themselves.

Most egregiously, it offered no real opposition to the substitution of doctors with ACPs and physician assistants. Some of those now asking for your council vote actually lobbied to invite PAs to join the BMA, a move that would have permanently obliged the union to support the people whose role is to undermine the profession.

To be fair, the representatives of this era were not entirely idle. 

Some were enjoying a welcome break from the undoubted strains of clinical medicine. Some were collecting tickboxes and training courses for their ever-expanding LinkedIn profiles. 

Some kind people (probably wonderful colleagues) genuinely believed it was a bit uncouth for privileged doctors to demand more pay than an HCA and had somehow ended up in a union representative role for which they were fundamentally unsuited and possibly ethically opposed.

The most invidious of these people were not the lazy, the careerists or the well meaning bystanders they were the self-styled trade union activists.

While Doctors Vote were forming a movement and making union staff and government uncomfortable with the scale of their demands, these people were saying be careful, be realistic, 15% is the maximum. 

While Doctors Vote brought thousands of doctors into strike groups, these people were arranging training courses for BMA representatives in London to learn theories of activism and organising. 

While Doctors Vote talked to thousands of doctors by every means available these people attended miners galas and ran Ella Barker training courses on “organising” (named after Ella Barker, an African American civil rights activist in the 1930s, a strikingly analogous scenario to UK doctors in 2026 trying to increase their pay).

And while this was happening, while the government was changing the fundamental status of our profession, these activists were developing policies on Uyghurs, Ukraine, Gaza, sanitary products in toilets, and having endless discussions about every kind of -ism anywhere. They patted themselves on the back for all of it.

To be clear: developing a policy on sanitary products has not helped one girl attend school who otherwise could not. Not one Gazan has been saved by the British doctors' union passing a resolution. The Uyghurs continue to be oppressed despite the effort expended by the union. 

It surely must be a matter of time before Xi Jinping chokes on his Cheerios when he reads the withering BMA position statement.

Many people, me included, have historically considered this kind of activist politicking to be trivial or at least well-meaning. It is not. It is not cost-free. It does real harm.

The clearest example: these people voted to publicly censure the Cass Report on the basis of a critical paper by a group of American lawyers. 

Never mind the outrageousness of a union publicly censuring a report by a member of its own profession, let alone on such spurious grounds. Everyone knows this is a contentious topic and that the relevant royal colleges welcomed the report. 

Doctors' real opinions on this issue are, to say the least, divided. And yet a small group of SHO dilettante activists took this extreme step on the basis of their own ideological beliefs. 

How would any of us feel if a group of twenty pro-life religious doctors voted that the BMA considers life to begin at conception? No religious doctors' group would consider doing such a thing, because they rightly recognise their views are not universal and that as elected union members they do not have the right to pass personal beliefs as union policy. 

These activists knew their views weren't universal either, which is why they didn't consult the membership on it, or hold a public vote. They have redacted their votes from the record, and they have not publicly defended the fact that they subverted the democratic policy making processes of the BMA. But because they believe they are on the right side of history, they believe these underhand methods are justified.

People like this are probably a normal occupational hazard for any union. The reason the RMT isn't writing letters of solidarity to railway workers in Bolivia is that it has normal railway workers leading it. 

If you are a shelf stacker or working long warehouse shifts, being a trade union rep offers you something valuable: time away from difficult work. The problem with doctors is that our job is, on the whole, pretty great. The doctor who gravitates toward union politics tends to be someone who loves politics more than their job, who believes in trade unionism as a quasi-religious calling rather than a practical strategy. Our profession seems almost designed to self-select the worst possible representatives for our union.

So at these council elections you have a choice: Broad Left, Doctors Vote, Doctors Together, IntMedGradVoice, various quiet slates and the unaffiliated, and some guy who didn’t bother to submit a photo or an election statement.

I believe a union's job is to maintain and improve the pay and conditions of its members. Not to grow a movement of activists. Not to support political causes or fix the ills of the world. 

When something goes wrong at work I want accurate, timely advice. I want excellent pay and conditions negotiated on my behalf. I want the leadership scanning the horizon for the next PA or training crisis and pushing back on it robustly. 

Anon accounts now criticise Doctors Vote, but it was Doctors Vote reps that made the BMA address the PA scandal (I don't see Stephen Nash cursing the Broad Left for the current BMA policy on PAs). They were effective in finally getting something done, how? Relentless social media awareness-raising (twitter anons you know who you are), 20,000 survey responses thanks to intense campaigning from Doctors Vote reps, and Mel taking the initiative to write an alternative scope of practice, more or less singlehandedly, in her own time. She forced the entire medical establishment to either accept it, or publicly acknowledge they wanted to implement a weaker scope which would harm patients. 

Am I saying that everything the Doctors Vote did was perfect? No. They never pretended to be activists, they never pretended to be perfect, they were just normal doctors, carving out time from their 48 hour weeks to do something, anything for the profession.

What did the Broad Left do? They advocated for physician assistants to join the BMA and ran training sessions encouraging doctors to spend more time as activists. 

It is almost beyond parody. To paraphrase Logan Roy: these are not serious people.

They get elected because most people have better things to do than think about union politics, and because most people agree that genocide and racism are bad, so it seems fine to vote for people who say so. 

But what these people do when they get your vote is interpret it to mean: 'I have authorised you to use the apparatus of the union, however clumsily and incompetently, to further your personal esoteric belief system. Which paradoxically includes the primacy of union activism qua union activism but absolutely absolves you from any concrete actions to  improve the pay or conditions of union members'.

And the consequences are real. We now have hundreds of physician associates who trained in good faith and have no jobs, because a group of people who couldn't say no gave them false hope. We have international colleagues who moved to the UK expecting access to training programmes, now having to wait years to apply, because a group of out-of-touch doctors decided to turn UK training posts into a form of imperial reparations.

These unserious people made much of the cost of moving to the UK, ignoring the cost that UK graduates have to bear to get through university, especially those whose families are unable to support them.For these activists supporting people like you is not trendy, you can’t praise yourself in a kumbaya circle for helping ordinary UK graduates.

They now claim to be in favour of UK graduate prioritisation, they claim to be in favour of ending PA scope creep, they claim to have been against medical apprenticeships. Where were they when these arguments were first being made? 

They are charging through the green fields of the Somme in 2026 long after the guns have gone silent, congratulating themselves on their bravery.

The people who say 'rights are not a pie' are really saying: I feel uncomfortable confronting the fact that my interests do not always coincide with everyone else's, and rather than face that and try to cut the pie fairly, accepting not everyone will be happy with me, I will pretend everyone can have as much as they want and blame others when some people get none. 

It is moral cowardice. It is antithetical to real organising, to real confrontation with power, to real effort for change.

These people are not monsters- they truly do care, they may be excellent colleagues, kind friends, and considerate neighbours but: they are deeply wrong about their role as union representatives and totally unfit for office.

So when you vote this month, decide whether you want people willing to do the work, say the unpopular thing and make the tough call, or people who believe words are actions and that their role is a platform for the fight against fascism.

Vote Broad Left and you will get lovely resolutions condemning crimes against humanity, declaring a climate emergency, acknowledging the biopsychosocial impact of war, recognising the importance of sanitary products, a pay 15 campaign that goes nowhere and a great deal of collective back-patting. You will get no hard thinking about real decisions, no rational debate about genuinely difficult issues, and no serious advocacy for the profession.

If there is no strong pro-doctor voice from the doctors' union, the government and its associated quangos make all the decisions.

If you do nothing, these people will let you down again and again. 

The choice is yours.


r/doctorsUK • • Aug 29 '26

Clinical "Anaesthetists have a lot more free time"

5 Upvotes

So we're sitting around drinking coffee and talking.

So?

Seriously, and what?

Our jobs are different. I could go on about how the intensity and focus needed means I actually need that coffee time to do my job safely without burning out or harming a patient.

Instead, I'll reframe the issue: My free time does not make your cannula my responsibility. It's your patient.

If any doctor finds that they have unexpected down time, are they obligated to go to ED/AMU/SAU to see and clerk patients?

I am also expected to see, assess, talk to patient and family, talk to my consultants, all to make an escalation plan about your patients, when you don't want to do it. Or call your consultant to make that decision. And I do it.

See the difference: When it's genuinely important to patient care, I go out of my way even if it means I don't get to sit down or have a break.

The reason we get butthurt is explained well by /u/suitable_ad279 here: 90% of the time it's a waste of our time and skills and what the patient needs is not deception about another person trying, it's a holistic assessment of vascular access needs.

So that's why we're grumpy. And I won't apologize for it.

edit: Just so it's clear, when I said grumpy before, I meant grumpy among each other or on social media, as in reference to the recent cannulation thread. I don't mean being uncivil when receiving a call, I'm always polite. Ironically I offer far more politeness to the people demanding cannulas from me.


r/doctorsUK • • Aug 15 '25

Quick Question CMV: Non-surgical/procedure resident doctors/Cons/GPs wearing scrubs is peak laziness.

7 Upvotes

In a time of striking and seeking pay in line with other professional colleagues, i.e. solicitors, have we lost our way in terms of daily attire? After years of school, exams and study, surely should we not dress like professionals with shirts, ties, etc rather than scrubs & trainers? Scrubs are made for theatre and wearing them on wards or in GP land diminishes patients’ perception of us.


r/doctorsUK • • Jun 18 '26

Pay and Conditions A caution to those voting no

17 Upvotes

As a Tonic to the near constant flow of vote no propaganda on here. Let me propose some practical thinking about the matter. 

 

1.     Many of the arguments by which we are advised to reject the deal are weak 

a.     That we should reject the deal because consultants ’might’ go on strike and will strengthen our case – this is a ludicrous reason to reject a deal, for a hypothetical scenario 

b.     50% turnout expected to be removed – again another hypothetical scenario with which we are gambling this deal away. We cannot know this for sure. If the 50% turnout rule is NOT removed, the whole movement is scuppered. There was only 55% turnout at last strike ballot. Only 5% less and the whole strike movement is over. Clearly a lot of doctors are losing will power and financial ability to keep striking

c.     Hyperbolic language used on all fronts for example ‘token’ exam fees: in what way are these token? most of us spend 1000s of pounds a year on exmas portfolio and membership fees. That’s over 600 pounds a year in real terms 

2.     Voting no to this deal represents a real risk of putting an end to strike action for the forseeable future with the risk of absolute ZERO gain from any of the last 2 year’s strike action

a.     There is a VERY strong possibility that 50% voter turnout will not be reached at the next ballot

b.     We gain nothing from all of our days of lost pay

  

3.     The deal does represent an average of 6.6% pay rise for 26/27 financial year when you factor in DDRB + nodal point reform, which is 3.5% ABOVE RPI inflation. 

a.     NOTIWTHSTANDING the fact they’ve guaranteed us nodal point pay rise for the following year (again on top of DDRB recommendation) 

Essentially it is a risk benefit calculation: Yes we may stand to benefit a very small amount if we reject this deal, perhaps another 1% pay rise for this year? Who knows – certainly not full pay restoration. But we risk so much by rejecting it. 

Please take the Vote no propaganda with a pinch of salt, I wonder what the agenda of some of their posters actually is – whether it is to benefit the profession as a whole, or to gain some leverage by which to enter into BMA leadership. Either way - This sub reddit is a bit of an echo chamber sometimes, The majority of my colleague and friends I have asked in person are voting yes to the deal. USE YOUR HEAD. 


r/doctorsUK • • Jul 31 '24

Pay and Conditions Trust the JDC leadership. We are the strongest union in the country, so let's stick together now and stay that way.

0 Upvotes

Trust the JDC. Trust Doctor's Vote. They are recommending this as the best offer we can get right now, so let's take it.

We are such a strong union, so let's end this round on a high note with a show of strength, by voting yes, by showing that we will always back our leadership.

Let's stick together now as an emboldened, empowered union. If we take this win now, we can absolutely come back for further negotiations in a year. We will have the confidence of knowing that we ALWAYS back our strong leadership, and that we will strike together as soon as we need to.

If our union takes this victory now, there's no stopping us. We can limit scope creep. We can improve our working conditions, like getting decent IT, mess facilities, proper food at night. We can do anything.

And we can sure as hell strike again together if progress towards FPR doesn't continue at the rate it's started.

Vote Yes


r/doctorsUK • • Jun 07 '24

Clinical How to deal with patronising upper middle class colleagues

7 Upvotes

Basically unless you’re actually working class (proper - free school meals the lot) you probably won’t understand what I’m talking about.

I’m now a senior registrar in anaesthetics, the majority of anaesthetic trainees (I don’t know why) tend to come from private/grammar school backgrounds and have family members who are doctors, nurses etc

I’ve always dealt with snide over confident trainees who were my peers, but I just ignored them to be honest and I don’t really tend to interact with these types if I can help it.

I know that I am a good trainee I get chosen to be with consultants who have difficult patients and consistently get good feedback - that’s good enough for me.

I now supervise more junior trainees and sometimes I find the gobshitey-ness, audacity and overconfidence grating, to the point I just want to tell them to fuck off and let me get on with it alone.

It’s just the total lack of understanding of their patients (usually from deprived backgrounds), lack of insight how they come across, the sneakiness - passing off other nurses/trainees management plans as their own, trying to land other trainees in trouble. And finally the expectation they get their way no matter what, and no openness to any real feedback or criticism.

I want to be a good senior/trainer, and I’m not saying all anaesthetic trainees are like this but I’m finding with the increased competition for CT we seem to be selecting more of these types who I would argue would be better off in surgery.


r/doctorsUK • • Oct 19 '24

Serious NHS workforce: diversity & inclusion. Homophobia/Transphobia.

6 Upvotes

Probably a controversial/polarizing post but idrc.
A little bit of my background. I am gay but a brown straight-passing doctor (born in the UK) who studied in Bulgaria (so I am a British-born IMG myself) and moved back home for Foundation Training Programme. Let me first preface by saying I do not support/condone racism or discrimination of any kind.

A lot of our doctors in the NHS are IMGs from diverse cultures and backgrounds, which I think is a good thing to celebrate. However one of the inevitable side-effects of this is ugly cultural clashes. The UK, in my opinion, is a very progressive nation when it comes to LGBT rights and lifestyle, women rights, etc. This is one of the major reasons why apparently a lot of oppressed/closeted LGBT doctors from Asia, Africa, and other countries come over and work in the UK in the first place, as per the IMG doctors group on Facebook. In the same group, there has been occasionally some vitriol and intolerance/mockery towards the LGBT community from certain members. To imagine that these close-minded people are also the same people who are looking for employment opportunities in the UK is frankly quite disturbing and scary.

Don't get me wrong, I have personally met many amazing IMG doctors who are very kind-hearted/tolerant/etc. However, the NHS importing and employing massive numbers of people from certain countries with cultures very incompatible to NHS workforce values/UK values at a huge rate at Training/non-training level – without prioritizing our own British graduates/citizens - was always going to be problematic for social cohesion (on top of worsening job saturation and competition at the Training level and trust-grade job market) and will do no good to patients and other colleagues who are LGBT/might appear to be LGBT/who lead a different lifestyle, etc... the list goes on.

I have personally seen multiple posts by those LGBT doctors who have fled persecution and mockery in their countries only to be trapped in the same hospital as their co-citizens who would be mocking LGBT people in their own language. Obviously they would not dare express these openly and publicly because of fear of repercussions. And apparently this sort of judgemental attitude goes rampant among more male IMG doctors.

I am, not in anyway, saying that everyone needs to live the British way, start waving pride flags and drinking alcohol (because I am a non-alcoholic and not a very woke individual myself), but surely inviting people who might unbiasedly/subconsciously discriminate against others in the workplace (based on their fundamental beliefs) is not going to lead to a healthy workforce, imo? And this has nothing to do with the complexion of skin or ethnicity – it’s about the environment and culture people were brought up in, isn't it?

edit: So....I am not implying that IMG doctors should be deported or they should not recruited. But if you ever see any homophobic behaviour or belittling coming from any of your IMG/non-IMG colleagues at workplace, please call it out swiftly and escalate if necessary. And hopefully anyone who engages in this behaviour (whether IMG or non-IMG) can reflect on themselves. :) thanks y'all.


r/doctorsUK • • Dec 10 '25

Medical Politics Full pay restoration will never happen without UK grad priority

4 Upvotes

You simply cannot argue with any employer for more pay, let alone a 28.9% pay rise when there are IMGs ready to take your job for whatever pay they get and unemployed UK grads desperate for work.

This job market simply isn’t in the power of the employees like it once was. Doctors used to be a scarce commodity but with the IMG influx and partially also the expansion in med school places, it’s almost impossible to argue for FPR with such a crisis. Fixing unemployment at all levels should be the main goal at the moment.

The fact that Wes after three offers has not moved a bit on pay, tells you a lot, it’s simply not feasible but even more so with this job market.

Edit: can someone actually explain how FPR is feasible in this job market with an oversupply of cheap labour?


r/doctorsUK • • Apr 27 '25

Pay and Conditions UKMG prioritisation must mean proper prioritisation; No foreign medical graduate ‘grandfathering’!

Post image
65 Upvotes

The whole point of UK Medical Graduate prioritisation is to actually prioritise UKMGs. Not to introduce carve-outs and exceptions that completely undermine the whole thing.

Grandfathering IMGs who are already in the system would be a total betrayal of UKMGs. It legitimises IMGs as being on equal footing with UK graduates who studied medicine in UK medical schools, trained here and then committed years of their life here.

It also guarantees that the oversupply and bottlenecks will continue for years. There are already tens of thousands of IMGs stuck in non-training posts in the UK right now, all waiting to compete against UKMGs for a training number. Grandfathering them in just ensures that thousands of UK graduates will continue to be pushed aside year after year.

Prioritisation must mean proper prioritisation. No grandfathering. No half-measures. No betrayals. Otherwise, it is just lip service and the situation for UKMGs will get even worse.


r/doctorsUK • • Jul 12 '24

Serious Wes Streeting to uphold the ban on Puberty blockers

0 Upvotes

So I'm a transgender doctor and every time I see a news article about trans healthcare in this country my heart absolutely sinks.

How have we become this much of a political football to the point where we are being denied healthcare.

The Cass report, even in its transphobic nature, did not call for a full ban on puberty blockers, it called for more research.

Since puberty blockers were limited in 2020, at least 16 transgender children under GIDS have died to suicide, compared to 1 in the three years leading up to this

Thread on these numbers here, and how they were misrepresented. (https://x.com/JolyonMaugham/status/1803729360731406489?t=OLQicKc-4O6HI-Cz91Bhog&s=19)

Even when using this piece of political propaganda as a stick to beat trans children with, they make it even worse than it says. People are waiting upwards of half a decade just to have an initial consultation with an expert, let alone have any form of medication started.

To finish I'd like to add some of the academic criticisms of the Cass report.

https://law.yale.edu/yls-today/news/report-addresses-key-issues-legal-battles-over-gender-affirming-health-care

https://osf.io/preprints/osf/uhndk

I am so scared for the state of trans healthcare in this country.

Edit: loving all the transphobic replies being upvoted and the support being downvoted.

Way to go DoctorsUK


r/doctorsUK • • Feb 26 '26

Fun We Can Actually Breathe Now: The Hate Train Might Finally Be Over!!!!

0 Upvotes

I’m an IMG who’s been in the NHS a few years now, and honestly, seeing the prioritisation bill make it through Lords stages without changes feels like I can finally breathe. The endless online rhetorics has been killing me, some UK grads straight up saying we cheat on PLAB, or we can’t speak/write English even though we all smashed IELTS, which is brutal. Like, loads of regular Brits wouldn’t pass that exam, and we have to get stupid high scores on top. Then the absolute mad ones claiming we can’t even diagnose a simple UTI… come on lol.😅

It’s draining hearing we’re inferior or not good enough when a lot of us are single handedly holding departments together. Sincerely, I get why UK grads are taking the piss lol. I would probably be pissed if I were a local grad too, but would never direct it at my colleagues (that is a big difference). Hopefully, this bill fixes anything and everything concerning the heart desires of UK grads and they would dial down a lot of the hate aimed at us. Because, some of these false rhetorics from here have real life impact and consequences. The other day, the BAME F1 I was working with got racially profiled by some white bloke who genuinely thought he hadd come over here to steal jobs. It would almost be funny if it wasn’t so grim. The irony is, he is actually a local grad who came to the UK to study medicine and trained here.

To IMGs like me: GP and IMT isn’t vanishing. So many local grads still skip it, especially the remote/rural ones, so spots will stay open. Might mean more of us head to those far off places with low diversity where yeah, you could run into racism or feeling out of place. It would happen, and it would suck. But that’s part of the deal and price we would have to pay for being born in and coming from countries where corrupt politicians wrecked everything and richer nations took the rest.

We’re just chasing a decent life for us and our families, you know?

Rant over lol. Feeling some actual relief for once. Hoping the smears chill out and we can all get back to just doing the job.

Big shout out to my lovely reg. She is a UK grad and she checks in often to know if I have flipped or still managing to keep my self sane 😁


r/doctorsUK • • Jun 13 '26

Serious I propose we continue our planned strike action

0 Upvotes

It is clear our BMA leadership has failed us and is prying for us to vote for an unacceptable offer. This wastes further time against our cause and put our organisation into disrepute. We are still a union and we should not let those who have let us down dictate our stance. Thoughts.


r/doctorsUK • • Feb 09 '26 All Seeing Upvote This Thanks Hooray

Medical Politics Sign up to RDConf to vote for UK grad prioritisation 12pm tommorrow (10/02/26)

Thumbnail bma.org.uk
2 Upvotes

Registration opens tomorrow (10/02/26) at 12:00 PM (Midday).

​Important: You can attend virtually or in person. Seats often go within minutes, so please click the link immediately at midday to secure your place. We need you there to vote for Motion RD26013.

​The Numbers Don't Add Up. ​We are facing an unsustainable trajectory for UK medical training. Here is the reality: ​This Year (2026): There are ~21,000 prioritised applicants for only ~10,000 training posts. Roughly 15.5k are UK graduates. The remaining 5.5k are prioritised IMGs ( those with ILR, citizens and other prio groups).

​In Just Two Years: The situation becomes catastrophic. ​UK Graduates: Expected to rise to ~20,000 (driven by the backlog of rejected applicants, graduates returning from Australia, and medical school expansion). ​IMGs: There are over 20,000 IMG Locally Employed Doctors (LEDs). We expect 15,000–20,000 eligible IMGs in the workforce.

​As LED jobs are cut and posts withdrawn across the NHS, these doctors will be forced into the training application pool. This is not a theoretical risk; it is already happening.

​The Result: Within two years, 35,000 to 40,000 prioritised doctors will be chasing just 10,000 posts with the current BMA ukgp policy.

​The Solution: Motion RD26013 ​We must stop fighting a losing battle against the reality of government workforce planning. Motion RD26013 aligns our stance with the actual landscape of NHS staffing.

​Why We Must Prioritise UK Graduates: ​Public Investment: The state invests roughly £4 billion in training these doctors. It is right that the country prioritises this investment.

​Economic Reality: UK graduates sacrifice years of potential consultant earnings if they are forced out of the pipeline.

​Future Viability: We must ensure there is a viable pathway for medical students, or the domestic pipeline will collapse.

​The Flaw in Current Policy: Current BMA policy is broken. It inadvertently locks out all IMG FY1s now and in the future, as well as new IMGs who started core training in August 2025 without prior NHS experience (e.g., Psych trainees) from ever progressing to Registrar training.

​RD26013 is the necessary, evidence-based update in policy.

Sign up tommorrow at midday!


r/doctorsUK • • Jul 31 '24 Polished Silver Turd

Pay and Conditions A worked example: Vote No, but only if you can afford to throw away a £2,286 cash lump sum

94 Upvotes

For context, I'm an ST4 registrar, with a Plan 2 Student Loan which is a smidge shy of £100,000, living in a top 10 highest cost of living city in England. I rent a small flat and would like to get on and make the single biggest step on the path to financial freedom (in my mind) - to buy a property. My landlord just put my rent up by almost 8%, to 37% of my monthly income. I've participated fully in every round of strikes thus far, in spite of some grumbling about the timing of the last one. I'm known amongst friends as 'militant' for my pro-strike stance, and for - in my view at least - fairly chastising friends who voted in favour of strikes for strikebreaking in the past.

Work schedule

I work a 47 hour average with 4% weekend allowance and a fairly light 4h30min night premium, for a total of just over £69,000. My monthly payslip deductions include: £1,040 PAYE, £283 National Insurance, £493 pension at 10.7%, and £316 in Student Loan (and £30 parking).

The 4% increase

I find the discussions around percentages slightly nebulous, so have punched in the numbers and worked out what the 4% pay rise would mean for those at my nodal point. The hourly rate would have risen from £26.52 to £27.59, resulting in my gross pay per month rising from £5,793 to £6,012 (a rise of £219 per month). However, deductions would of course creep up to - including £20 more pension contribution, £4 more NI, £80 more income tax and £20 more Student Loan, resulting in a net gain of £127 per calendar month.

Given that last year's backpay was paid out in September 2023, and that it's unlikely that we would receive it sooner than that this year due to the time it'll take to organise the vote, we're looking at 18 months of backpay coming in September (12 months for the 23/24 financial year, plus April to September of this one). 18 x 127 = £2,286 in net, after tax cash making its way into our bank accounts from the 4% rise alone.

The 24/25 DDRB pay rise

When you then factor in the 7.7% rise for ST3-5 for this financial year, if the 4% is accepted we're now looking at a new hourly rate of £29.65 per hour. I'm happy to post a breakdown if people would find that interesting, but plugging those numbers into my work schedule increases my net monthly salary from £3,660 today to £3,960 from September - a £300 per month increase. Not forgetting that six months of backpay will have also been accrued from the DDRB payrise, that would result in an extra £1,800 post tax lump sum, which when added to the 4% lump, comes to a total of over £4,000 in cash from the combined uplifts. The gross salary for an ST3-5 doctor will be around £78-80k all in. As an aside, ST6-8s will be at £90-92k.

The likely post-'Reject' scenario

I've been chatting with colleagues, as I'm sure everyone has, over the last 48 hours. I completely agree with our current F1s that it is completely inappropriate that, for example, they still will not be out-earning a PA on Band 7. I've also spoken to registrar colleagues, though, often with small children, who have had to swap to interest only mortgages to ride out the interest rate hike that would've doubled their monthly mortgage repayments. If we vote to turn down four grand in cash and a £127 a month pay rise, there is no scenario in which colleagues like these will continue to strike and sacrifice roughly £300 per strike on the slim chance of an extra 1-2%, which will take months to earn back.

tl;dr

We all know that we're not worth less than a doctor was in 2008. The bottom line for those similar to me is that accepting this deal will bring me significantly closer to the goal of escape from the nightmare that is renting in a high cost of living city. To vote No would be to risk £2,286 in cash in the hope of securing a few quid more - not worth the risk, in my opinion. There is absolutely no guarantee that voting No will result in the government offering an inflation-linked guarantee moving forward, and the boss himself Robby L seems to think going on will result in serious grind for very little reward. I'd implore you to lock in these gains and be ready to go again in the next year or two, if any subsequent DDRB recommendation falls short of an inflation-beating uplift.


r/doctorsUK • • Jul 31 '24

Pay and Conditions Vote accept: this is a fantastic deal

20 Upvotes

I think we are all just tired and it’s time to go home. Let’s all look forward to our extra £150 quid a month. Let’s regroup and see how our peers in the private sector fare and review things in another 5-10 years. After all, the DDRB in its latest report said that our salary lags behind other sectors including law, accounting and finance, pharmaceutical industry and I’m sure they will take concrete action to address that.

This is a fantastic deal from Rob and Vivek. They even said the best deal they can get and after all FPR was always a pipedream.

While we are at it, you know PAs aren’t that bad either. They don’t strike and more numbers will surely only enhance doctors’ working lives.

We should stand ready to deliver another golden age of the NHS and that might mean some belt tightening. Now who’s with me?


r/doctorsUK • • Mar 18 '26 Helpful Bravo

Speciality / Core Training Oriel offers today have been a huge mess I feel so bad for all those exceptional candidates who are now stuck in limbo

0 Upvotes

As above. I am looking through the threads of offers from IMT, histopathology and a few others.

One IMG ranked at 46 in IMT with 3 years of nhs experience and is stuck in limbo , someone else with a score >2600 has an offer.

I really do feel bad for any IMg trying to get into training now. I say this as someone who is less than 2 months away from cct as an IMG I have colleagues who are on their 3rd exam attempt who are UKGs , I have scaled through all exams and portfolio requirements without skipping a beat medical exams are very variable and a lot can happen but in reality this kind of selection process just breeds some level of mediocrity in the system.

As an IMG I really hope others who have had their futures delayed and stuck in limbo use this elections to show their disdain and vote for people who will not use you as pawns and actually fight for your interests.


r/doctorsUK • • Aug 11 '26

Medical Politics Medfluencer’s social media post on “how men named women’s bodies”

Thumbnail instagram.com
0 Upvotes

Faye Bate, resident doctor turned full-time influencer posted on instagram 6 hours ago about how men named women’s bodies in a derogatory way. Seems a perfect way of stirring up drama for social fame.

Points raised by her:

  1. vagina named after the Latin for ‘scabbard’ aka something a sword goes into

  2. hysteria named after the Greek word for uterus

  3. geriatric pregnancy

  4. cervical incompetence - when the cervix opens early in pregnancy, imagine experiencing pregnancy loss and hearing that

  5. hostile uterus - when there is an issue preventing embryo implantation

  6. primary ovarian insufficiency - when a persons ovaries stop working before age 40

She goes on to suggest in the comments that we “start describing men’s hair follicles / penis as incompetent when they can’t grow”.

Am I missing the point here or what?

Outdated terms being insensitive ≠ misogyny.

“Incompetence” is used widespread in medicine to describe dysfunction. It’s not a denigratory term. “Hostile uterus” isn’t a diagnosis. Hostile in this context meaning not conducive to implantation, sure.

Claims like this which imply men are a detriment to women’s health are ridiculous, and I feel posts like this correlate with women declining to be seen by a male physician for intimate problems. The post stinks of inflammatory nonsense written to stir people up.


r/doctorsUK • • May 25 '25 Bless Up

Medical Politics On the state of the Union, and membership sentiment

7 Upvotes

I'm going to say what is echoed in current UK-practicing IMG spaces, but what they are too afraid or disenfranchised to voice — and that, in itself, reflects a failure of the BMA. A union meant to represent all UK doctors has allowed a significant portion of its membership to feel sidelined at best, and scapegoated at worst.

After reading The Sunday Times article this morning, I wasn’t surprised to see no mention of protection or grandfathering for current IMGs. That was to be expected. Ross's tweet at least acknowledged the issue, but let's be honest — it’s just talk. No one is fooled, or reassured. Especially considering the BMA’s own reluctance to include any sort of grandfathering clause until backlash forced them to seemingly begrudgingly add it earlier this year.

Since then, this so-called "grandfathering" safeguard has been mentioned once or twice, but when a proposal was made to formally attach it to the UK prioritisation motion at the RDC conference, it was struck down. And before anyone says, “That’s democracy — the membership voted,” let’s be clear: Nothing about how RDC conference delegates are selected is truly democratic or representative. At best, it’s a first-come, first-served process. At worst, the selection lacks transparency altogether. Unsurprisingly, historically marginalised groups like IMGs — who are less engaged for very real structural reasons — remain underrepresented.

And where was the BMA when the government announced sweeping immigration changes directly impacting thousands of IMG doctors? Silent. Yet we’ve seen the BMA weigh in on political matters before — most recently, in a statement on the Supreme Court’s gender ruling. So why the silence on immigration policy that will directly harm a large segment of their own members? It’s not just disappointing — it’s telling.

It’s no wonder that resentment is growing. Many IMGs no longer feel represented by the BMA.

Yes, countries will always prioritise their own medical graduates — rightly so, absolutely behind it 100%. But many IMGs came to the UK following the 2020 policy changes that actively encouraged them. They came believing they could build a future here. That’s what makes this different from going to Canada, Australia, or the US, where such promises were never made.

To uproot your life, invest years into service provision or training, contribute to the NHS during crises — only to be told you’ve essentially wasted your life and made the wrong move, no one wants you here, you’re not welcome to training, you’re not welcome to stay — and have the so called representative body pile it on as well, is why so many feel betrayed.

How all of this will affect the upcoming vote remains to be seen. The government may be trying to divide the union, but the BMA isn’t doing itself any favours either.

Not here to argue, won’t be responding to comments. This will probably be down voted to all hell anyway, the demographic on here being what it is. This just needed to be said out loud. BMA - prove this sentiment wrong.


r/doctorsUK • • Sep 07 '25

Speciality / Core Training Guys at some point we gotta be accountable for our own training.

0 Upvotes

In a very serious note, doctors are some of the most high achieving people through A-levels to get into medicine in the UK. I've not got any skin in the game but.

How is it this difficult that in 5 years of medical school and 1.5 of foundation that people can't get a publication out and decide to blame IMGs for it. Get a publication, present in some vague conference, do a QI over the course of 6 years and you've reached the IMT cutoff

Don't get an oral just present a poster - 4 Don't be a first author just be anywhere on a paper - 6 Do a QI - 4 And make a teaching program with feedback for three months (3/72) - 3 marks

That's 17 points right there.

Now if it's an oral presentation+2, first or co first author +2, organize and teach the sessions under an official group + 2. This way you bypass needing a publication even.

I'm not tryna come at anyone, but I'm surrounded by very capable people who act like they're not able to function without more advantages. You have every advantage you need. You're too busy focused on the fact that you were sold this idea of job security but now it's gotten (much) harder.

Secondly, There are jobs available, sure it's not the London job you want or the Ortho SHO you hoped to land it's probably the geriatric job in the middle of Ayrshire. It's not easy to leave your home, it's not easy to work in a department you don't like. But 70% of people can have a job, you're choosing not to take the job. Which is fine cause you deserve to be happy. But the n stands for national and so it means there are jobs nationally. So if you don't take it, and an IMG takes it instead, why are you getting worked up over it.


r/doctorsUK • • Apr 04 '26 This Hooray Bravo

Pay and Conditions Speaking up for the silent majority: Why I’m not striking this week.

0 Upvotes

I’m posting this because this sub has become such an extreme echo chamber that anyone who isn't 100% "FPR or Death" is treated like the devil. Speaking to colleagues at work, I know I’m not alone in my thinking, but many are too afraid of the pile-on to say it.

Our pay is now competitive. BMA demands are harming us in the long run. These strikes are a mistake.

Salary:

The narrative that we are underpaid is becoming laughable.

With this offer, for an F1, you would start on around 40K. With a standard 48-hour rota, that hits over £50,000 straight out of med school. If you think a 23-year-old earning £50k is ‘poverty pay’ you need to reassess your spending.

As an ST5: I’m now taking home nearing 100K with my banding and on-calls. To claim that isn't a good salary is pure delusion.

Private sector delusion

Stop comparing us to the top 0.1% in finance or tech. We don’t work in that sector. We work in healthcare, which is never going to be paid as well. Look at nearly all European countries. Non consultant doctors are not paid as well as what we’re paid now and they work longer hours. Stop using Australia/New Zealand as the competition – you’re cherry picking the highest paid countries out of a pool of around 200. If they were truly the competition, you’d have moved already. Compared to European coutries, we’re paid well.

Our actual competition is the UK labour market, and if we make the wage bill unaffordable, the government simply won't employ us. They will employ more noctors. Yes the standard of healthcare may suffer, but you wont have a job regardless. You are asking for short-term gains that will lead to long-term pain for everyone. You are emulating the ladder pullers we all despise.

CPI is an appropriate measure of inflation.

We are pretty much back to 2008 levels if you go by CPI. The BMA's obsession with RPI is a ridiculous argument when everything else in the economy (except our student loans) is based on it. I agree that student loans being based on RPI is a scam, and I’d strike to change the student loan interest calculation to CPI, but demanding our entire salary be indexed to an outdated measure of inflation that the ONS literally calls a ‘bad measure’ is bad faith.

3.5% + Exam Fees is a win

We are being asked to forgo four days of salary over a 0.1% difference (the gap between the offer and RPI). That is financially illiterate. The offer also includes reimbursing two attempts of mandatory exams. As someone who has spent thousands on my Royal College exams, this is a massive sweetener we never had before. It’s a win. We should take it

We are losing the room

Public opinion is turning. The Labour is looking to show strength by standing up to what they’re calling a "militant" BMA. Every time we walk out now, we give them a perfect excuse for why the NHS is still in a mess. We are playing a silly game and they are winning the PR war.

I’m done with the FPR or bust mentality. We’ve made massive strides. The pay is good. We’re now being unrealistic.

If you’re also considering crossing the picket this week - you aren't alone, and you aren't "the devil" for being realistic.

Thank you. I will now take your downvotes and abuse 


r/doctorsUK • • Sep 01 '23

Pay and Conditions Is the BMA going soft ?

2 Upvotes

Many colleagues have expressed the same - we should have a 5 day walkout , everyone from FY1s to consultants. This is the way forward. This will put pressure on the government. The " Christmas day cover " strike is weak. We need to give it our all!


r/doctorsUK • • Mar 11 '26

Medical Politics Vote DoctorsTogether in the BMA UK Council Election

Post image
0 Upvotes

The BMA is electing its National Executive Committee: UK Council, which sets the overall direction of the BMA. We are a group of BMA reps with a proven track record of success. 

Collectively, we have delivered wins locally and nationally. We have delivered emergency legislation on UK graduate prioritisation, a whole jobs campaign, and delivered a 22% pay rise (with more on the horizon!)

We have transformed the BMA in recent years, and we cannot allow the BMA to become complacent now. If elected, we will work with all elected council members and branches of practice to ensure the BMA wins for its members. Our key priorities will be:

  1. Tackling medical unemployment at all levels: 

We delivered UK graduate prioritisation, forcing the government to introduce the Medical Training (Prioritisation) Act as emergency legislation. We will continue to be led by the data and ensure the legislation maintains sustainable competition ratios. For 2027 onwards, the answer is clear, five years must be used to define significant NHS experience.
 
However, this legislation is only the start. We will campaign for a sustainable increase in speciality training posts tied to the necessary investment to prevent post-CCT bottlenecks. We must ensure a smooth pipeline so that current medical students and foundation doctors can become the consultants and GPs of the future. Residents not in training are on exploitative locally employed doctor (LED) contracts. We will work to ensure that LEDs have better terms and job security. 

2. Full Pay Restoration for all branches of practice and protecting our pensions

Full pay restoration was where we started, the campaign that reinvigorated the BMA. We have made progress, but that must continue; we are committed to ensuring all doctors in every branch of practice across the UK achieve full pay restoration. We must also acknowledge that a significant part of our remuneration comes from our pensions, and so they must also be protected for the benefit of all doctors. 

3. Student loan forgiveness for doctors and medical students.

Many of us are graduating with £100k+ debt, an effective 9% extra marginal tax we have to pay for the rest of our working lives. This is a huge hit to the take-home pay of thousands of doctors. Ending the unfair system and campaigning for full student loan forgiveness for all doctors is a key priority for us. Student loan forgiveness must be separate to, and not instead of, full pay restoration.

4. Prevent doctor substitution by PAs and ACPs to protect patients and safeguard training opportunities.

To protect patient safety and safeguard training opportunities for doctors and students, we must tackle the growing problem of doctor substitution. We will ensure doctors are not replaced by ACPs or PAs, and that this will remain top of the BMA’s agenda.  

5. Local disputes and strike action to fight illegal rotas, locum/WLI rate caps, and unsafe staffing, and reinstate the phone line for employment advice.  

The BMA has had huge success nationally; the next step is organising locally. On council, we would work to empower local reps to run local disputes and strikes to fight local issues. We would ensure these disputes are resourced, and local reps are supported via expanded local organising training. These campaigns can range from rota disputes and underpayments to fighting locum rate cuts and the stagnant London Weighting.

We know BMA members struggle to access individual advice, and so we would commit to reinstating the employment advice phone line and reforming the first point of contact service to deliver value for money for members’ subscription costs. 

6. Prioritise training over service provision and reduce excessive rotational training. 

Hyper-rotation is unnecessary; too much of residents' time is spent in service provision rather than training to be a future consultant or GP. We will fight for wholesale reform of postgraduate training.

We also need to see change to our recruitment processes. We must see doctors valued as real people, and not lines on a spreadsheet.

We will be pushing the BMA to demand an end to blanket MSRA recruitment, interviewing all candidates, and seeing a return to competency based training - seeing accelerated progression for those working 48hrs and normal progression for LTFT doctors.

Why Vote for Us?

As a group, we have decided to run together as we trust each other to deliver for members. We will make decisions democratically. We will not have a whip. We are independent doctors/students from across the UK, from different branches of practice, who all share the same values. Our sole aim is to deliver wins for members. 

We have already transformed the BMA, and if elected, we will continue that fight.

You’ve heard of DV and DU, now it’s about DT.

You will receive your voting pack in the post this week. It is essential that you rank all 24 DoctorsTogether candidates in the order on the slate and return your ballot paper via post to maximise your chances of electing candidates who will fight and win for you. Voting closes on 27th April so make sure you send it back in the post ASAP!


r/doctorsUK • • Mar 05 '25

Quick Question Patient without a parotid gland referred for parotitis??

3 Upvotes

ENT JCF here, recently started working at a new hospital. Received a referral earlier today from an A&E consultant regarding a patient with unilateral R-face swelling for query parotitis. Went and assessed the patient. Had a total R-parotidectomy 3 years ago, no facial swelling, apyrexial, has a tender what felt like a pea-sized lymph node right below the angle of mandible (on the R-side). Genuine question: Do A&E doctors actually see the patient before making referrals?


r/doctorsUK • • Jun 17 '26

Medical Politics DoctorsVote are also embarrassing

41 Upvotes

Making this from a new account because I cba to get doxxed.

This infighting between the BMA committee is frankly embarrassing.
I’m not a fan of Jack and this is not why I’m making this post. But quite frankly, DoctorsVote need to pipe down.

This is not the same DoctorsVote Rob and Vivek brought us. The new DoctorsVote, may I remind everyone, also faffed around for ages and wasted the mandate and brought us an even worse deal. Everyone here seems to have a short term memory and have forgotten how bad DoctorsVote were last year during the last mandate.

DoctorsVote themselves are currently making (frankly embarrassing) posts on here slagging off the current committee when they did nothing - they’re just riding off Rob and Vivek’s coattails and acting like they did something.
How does it look when they are resorting to petty actions like making Reddit posts saying “we told you so 🤡” every other day? As if they’ve done anything?

Y’all are embarrassing. Please cut it out.

Edit: I’m seeing a whole bunch of replies trying to be funny, but no one has actually disputed any of my points. Please I’m basically begging to get my mind changed at this point - PLEASE someone tell me why the current DoctorsVote are good??

On a side note - the doctors.united instagram page is pretty good for a non-biased neutral overview of current offer and what is going on. Whoever runs the account said they’re voting no but at least aren’t resorting to childish petty karma-farming Reddit posts


r/doctorsUK • • Sep 17 '24

Pay and Conditions BMA is played by the government (again)

22 Upvotes

Right at the start, the government leaked out the figure of 22% way before the BMA can communicate with its members. Most people i know did not bother to look into the details of the deal and falsely think that if they earn 100 today, they will earn 122 tomorrow.

Secondly, this deal is to divide us so that we will break from within (old school tatic from the government, and yet it works). Look at the previous referendum results when more than 90% of us voted the same and united, and now we are splited into 60/40. It will be much more difficult to pull off another strike in the near future.

Thirdly, the government is now in a very strong position, they can pretty much do whatever they want in the next few years, i dont see any incentive for them to offer any above inflation (or even equal to inflation) pay rise in the next few years, just look at the government’s position of not even willing to promise in FPR in words.

BMA is an union, and as an union, the government (the employer) is NOT your friend. Between the union and the government, it is a zero sum game, we cant have win win situation.

I dont think the BMA has betrayed us like in 2016, but i think the BMA is played by the government this time.