I started this sub many years ago after going through a complete nightmare with miscarriages and pregnancy issues that I 100% knew were from sperm after endless research, and of course all the doctors shit on me and tried to continue to do things to ME instead of my ex partner to keep a pregnancy.
My ex had 33% DNA fragmentation and a varicocele with subpar motilty and 4% morphology, concentration of 40mil. He also denied he had issues.
I got pregnant 5/5 months I tried to get pregnant and the losses were random anywhere from chemicals to 12 week loss (normal NIPT) to another one causing severe neural tube defects anencephaly at 12 weeks which resulted in TFMR at 16 weeks. This was also caused by his sperm as sperm with dna fragmentation and low in folate can cause neural tube defects, it is NOT just a female folate issue. I took alllll the supplements. During the pregnancy itself the sperm is also responsible for placental function and formation, so if this does not form properly you can also have a loss AND you are at risk for preeclampsia, or other issues that develop from abnormal placental function. During the pregnancy the placenta excreted abnormal proteins which caused what's called diabetes insipidus of pregnancy to where I had to urinate 10 times in the night and could no longer sleep. I was vomiting non stop and I have never felt this bad in my life both times the pregnancy came to the 2nd trimester.
At this point, I decided to proceed with IVF and surrogacy. I didn't have trouble getting pregnant, but the pregnancies never resulted in live birth and I felt like I would die if I tried again. So I ended up doing 5 cycles of IVF with various results, 12 embryos in 7 transfers resulted in chemicals, no implantation at all in the surrogates, a miscarriage - (of note the embryos in a cycle done with ZYMOT + PICISI are the ones that worked and it was from the same cycle - zymot alone embryos didn't implant and also miscarried - this can also be a coincidence to the sperm sample at that time for another reason like better diet or vitamins etc although nothing was different than I can think of) and then finally live birth of my 2 kids after also abnormal placental proteins for both of them including a trisomy 18 in the placenta for one of my daughters. This required amnios for both of them, and they also had soft markers on the scans so I never really experienced anything normal, peaceful, just stress and loss and abnormal results for 4 years. Finally my kids were born and they are now 2 and are doing well.
I am now currently pregnant, my ex is not the father. I have had some nausea and vomiting but zero issues I had in my last pregnancies and it also worked the first time but is now hopefully progressing normally. My NIPT and sonos are normal. I finally am getting to experience a "normal" pregnancy for the first time in 5 years. And I am just still so sad and disgusted for all the women that get tortured by physicians, take drugs, injections, etc and it has to do with sperm and not them in the first place. I still feel like so few care about the sperm contribution to pregnancy is HALF. The male partner and their lifestyle, genetics, everything matters. This will be my only and last pregnancy, but I wanted to do just one more experiment in years of very sad ones on myself and although I am N of 1, I can live in peace knowing I was fucking right about everything from the beginning.
I still lurk this sub and hope that it has provided useful, scientific and relevant data for those who are struggling, and those who have not been heard. My biggest advice is to make sure you preserve your own fertility because you never know what will happen in the future. I am very glad I did a round with donor sperm and had those embryos because it could have been that none of the embryos with my ex worked and it may have been too late for myself to try donor etc.
WE DO NOT KNOW the cause of all or even FEW of the male factor infertility issues. For those with failed implantations of PGS normal embryos, multiple failed transfers, miscarriages and just no pregnancies in general - I am so sorry you are in this hell. I have lived it and to say that it's a complete nightmare that I will never forget and how it affected me and my well being, livelihood, and just life in general is an understatement. Keep pushing on your physicians, and do not settle for a response that is misogynistic. If that sperm analysis is abnormal and your labs are normal, there is a reason for that. If the DNA frag isn't normal, it can and DOES cause loss. IVF doesn't solve everything. Critical thinking and opening up your horizons of just how far and what you're willing to do to have a child and in what way just might.
READ THIS POST BEFORE ASKING QUESTIONS updated: 4/15/19
Sperm analysis ALONE is a very poor predictor of fertility for males. YES you can have a "normal" SA and still be infertile and have high DNA fragmentation.
It is now estimated that 50-70% cases of infertility issues are male factor related.
Sperm is 50% of genetic material and the major focus of Reproductive Endocrinology has been on oocyte (women’s reproductive) health. Given that 50% of embryo genome comes from the male, it is vital that we start paying attention to better work up of male infertility when it comes to couples that come in for infertility work up. Sperm DNA integrity (which is measureable by breaks in DNA strands as DNA fragmentation) is a must to do test and should be included in the primary work up of every couple struggling with conceiving or recurrent pregnancy loss.
As it currently stands in most reproductive endocrinology practices, females have extensive blood, genetic and structural work up while males come in for one sperm analysis. It is then compared to The Who guidelines of “normals.” What this sperm analysis report ignores is that the current WHO guidelines included sperm from males that have fathered children, but does not tell us how many miscarriages, chemical pregnancies, stillbirths, time to pregnancies (what if it took 3 years to get pregnant?) their partners had to endure prior to having their living child due to the fact that it was long believed that if sperm could fertilize the egg (or not) it was then up to the oocyte to progress the pregnancy, which unfortunately couldn’t be further from the truth. When looking at the low “normal” cut offs of WHO sperm analysis guidelines, it has been found that the lower the parameters become, the longer it takes to get pregnant, the more miscarriages women suffer and so on. So while some men fall into totally abnormal categories of sperm analysis results, we also have approximately 20% of males with “normal” sperm analysis that contribute to male infertility.
Sperm is made every 3 months and due to different lifestyle issues (such as poor diet, smoking, alcohol consumption etc,), structural issues such as varicocele (which is the most common male infertility issue that exposes testes to more heat, thereby increasing denaturation of DNA, increasing oxidative stress and decreased mitochondrial membrane potential that makes less ATP for cells to function correctly, divide properly and have energy to swim quickly which we can see as low motility on a sperm analysis), and many other various factors – can have detrimental affects on a couple’s fertility potential.
For example, we can correlate the male progressive motility analysis with percentage of nonfunctioning sperm mitochondria, meaning they do not make enough ATP (cell’s energy) to propel the sperm. So someone with 10% progressive motility likely has 90% of dysfunction in sperm mitochondria.
Correlation of MitoSensor results with sperm motility parameters of semen and distribution of data. A significant negative correlation was observed (R = –0.67, P < 0.001).
While many infertility specialists have not looked into this issue enough, sperm DNA fragmentation and internal DNA damage negatively affects natural pregnancy (by no pregnancy, miscarriage, birth defects, and increased risk of cancer) as well as ART procedures with decreased rate of fertilization (but only in extremely high DNA fragmentation cases with fragmentation over 50%), decreased blast formation, failure of implantation and progression of pregnancy even with PGS normal embryos. (Borini et al., 2006; Muriel et al., 2006; Zini et al., 2008; Aitken et al., 2009)
Once again, a “normal” semen analysis does not rule out DNA integrity issues and 18% of males with normal semen analysis will have high DNA fragmentation meaning high chance of failure of natural pregnancy as well as ART attempts. (Virro et al., 2004). Some studies that focus on fertilization rates report that DNA fragmentation does not affect these parameters, because the lower DNA fragmentation the further potential embryo growth potential becomes. The egg has capacity to repair some damage to the DNA structures of the embryo, but older eggs have less capacity for repair. This also potentially has to do with mitochondrial power to make ATP in the younger eggs vs older eggs. We see less miscarriage rates in younger women due to a higher capability to repair embryo DNA defects and the older the woman gets, the harder it is to repair the problems. Therefore, the higher DNA fragmentation of the sperm may be, the harder the oocyte has to work to repair the problems – and depending on the amount of missing DNA pieces, the embryo can stop development at any point from fertilization to stillbirth of a child. (2)
Recurrent pregnancy loss & “unexplained infertility” (RPL or another medical term for this as recurrent spontaneous abortion) has long been “unexplained” and anything from “relaxing, to TLC to many other holistic therapies have been advised for women while very little implication to male genome in RPL which is another crucial mistake. In cases where a younger female work up is normal it is even more important to look at the male work up closely. The make DNA fragmentation may be high enough that embryos stop progressing at these stages causing her to miscarry all the pregnancies. There have been instances of 3+ losses where women are constantly told to keep trying (I, personally myself am one of these patients) which has been detrimental to my mental health, my marriage and my overall well being because experiencing miscarriages, especially late term is one of the most psychologically devastating and life changing events that could be preventable in these cases. DNA fragmentation over 30% increases your risk highly for miscarriage naturally AND with ART procedures, even in cases where ICSI has been used. Latest studies show that 80% of couples diagnosed with unexplained infertility had DNA fragmentation of >25%. Again, please have your partner tested for this even if their sperm analysis is normal.
This bring discussion of ART and the use of ICSI and PGS testing in cases of infertility without testing for DNA fragmentation. The long thought of many clinicians has been that using ICSI for procedures would bypass issues because only “the best sperm possible is chosen” . Also, if the embryos were PGS normal then the pregnancy would be highly successful. We now also know this is not the case. In cases of DNA fragmentation this is misguided thinking that has led many couples in the direction of having to suffer through multiple rounds of ART procedures without success while getting “we don’t know why, or bad luck” explanations. This risk can be decreased by getting DNA fragmentation testing done on all patients coming in for infertility work up. It is important to understand the structure of sperm when talking about what DNA fragmentation means for ART and success rates.
PGS testing is available for couples and is a great tool for those with normal DNA fragmentation values. In this case, the embryo does truly have a better chance of survival after a transfer. PGS tests whole chromosomes for deletions. However, what it does not do, is test minor errors in the long strand of each of those chromosomes – which is essentially what DNA fragmentation tests look at. The small knicks and errors in repair of the original chromosomes can not be transcribed properly by machinery when embryo is developing. If there are double stranded breaks in the DNA, this can not be read and errors can be made.
When ART is used for procedures, sperm sorting is performed after the sperm sample is collected and has most commonly been sperm washing, swim-up and gradient centrifugation. The problem with these sperm sorting methods and embryology lab’s lack of understanding how sperm genome integrity contributes to embryo development can be detrimental to couples. These sperm sorting methods are not efficient and leave sperm with high DNA fragmentation, high ROS and also not the best motility in the sperm sample. Some of these procedures can actually cause MORE damage to sperm that’s already low integrity. There are now microfluidic sorting devices that are much better at sperm sorting that use laminar flow as the basis of sperm selection that do not cause mechanical or chemical stress to sperm during processing. This should be the proper sorting method for patients with any male factor infertile due to the fact their sperm possess inherent amount of damage in some area already and careful selection must be done PRIOR to any procedures.
"Existing sperm sorting methods are not efficient and isolate sperm having high DNA fragmentation and reactive oxygen species (ROS), and suffer from multiple manual steps and variations between operators. Inspired by in vivo natural sperm sorting mechanisms where vaginal mucus becomes less viscous to form microchannels to guide sperm towards egg, a chip is presented that efficiently sorts healthy, motile and morphologically normal sperm without centrifugation. Higher percentage of sorted sperm show significantly lesser ROS and DNA fragmentation than the conventional swim-up method. The presented chip is an easy-to-use high- throughput sperm sorter that provides standardized sperm sorting assay with less reliance on operators’s skills, facilitating reliable operational steps. "
Basically they have made these devices that function with various ability to help the motile sperm swim through pores of certain size that was discovered by trial and error to be optimal for the best motile and best DNA integrity sperm to swim in such a way as to get trapped by these devices. And it's SUPER cool.
It appears to be the best way to sort sperm available today and I am hopeful this technology will be put to use by all the REs because the best sperm is vital to conception and having live births because any damage of the sperm can affect fertilization, blast formation, embryo development, miscarriages, birth defects etc.
When sperm sorting is used that does not solve the DNA fragmentation or oxidative stress issues of the sperm, there is higher probability that the sperm chosen for the ICSI procedure by human eye as “the best sperm” may actually and in fact be one with high DNA fragmentation since that does not always correlate to normal morphology or motility. Therefore, that sperm injection into the egg can still lead to fertilization but failure of the embryo to develop at any stage which is reflected in studies by very low birth rates from high DNA fragmentation couples. (4). Prior to Microfluidic sperm sorting the best procedure to lower risk of ART failure was to use testicular sperm for ICSI procedures which show decrease of 70% of sperm DNA fragmentation at testicular level rather post testicular level. The live births from doing a TESE increase significantly.
Patients undergoing T-ICSI (n = 77) had a significantly higher clinical pregnancy rate/fresh embryo transfer (ET) (27.9%; 17/61) and cumulative live birth rate (23.4%; 15/64) compared to patients using E-ICSI (n = 68) (clinical pregnancy rate/fresh ET: 10%; 6/60 and cumulative live birth rate: 11.4%; 7/61). Further, T-ICSI yield significantly better cumulative live birth rates than E-ICSI for men with high TUNEL (≥36%) (T-ICSI: 20%; 3/15 vs. E-ICSI: 0%; 0/7, p < 0.025), high SCSA® (≥25%) scores (T-ICSI: 21.7%; 5/23 vs. E-ICSI: 9.1%; 1/11, p < 0.01), or abnormal semen parameters (T-ICSI: 28%; 7/25 vs. E-ICSI: 6.7%; 1/15, p < 0.01).
CONCLUSIONS:
The use of testicular spermatozoa for ICSI in non-azoospermic couples with no previous live births, recurrent ICSI failure, and high sperm DNA fragmentation yields significantly better live birth outcomes than a separate cohort of couples with similar history of ICSI failure entering a new ICSI cycle with ejaculated spermatozoa.
(The ejaculatory abstinence ≤ 4 days group showed significant lower sperm DNA fragmentation index, and higher rates of fertilization, high-quality embryos on day 3, blastocyst development, implantation and pregnancy compared to ejaculatory abstinence > 4 days group.The implantation rate was significantly higher and the pregnancy rate tended to be higher with one day of ejaculatory abstinence, compared to 2-4 days of ejaculatory abstinence.)
Another detrimental step to achieving better success may be the fact that clinicians recommend longer days of abstinence to men before semen collection. The capacity of storage for sperm in the vas deferens declines within a few days and studies show that there is a significant increase of DNA fragmentation in sperm samples after 7 days even in normal sperm. Those numbers increase drastically and earlier for those who already have abnormal DNA fragmentation. Worse, is that the sperm that loose their ability to fertilize and swim well start degenerating, which causes ROS and creates damage to the healthy sperm thereby affecting the whole sample. In a way, more sperm is not better and is actually worse for fertilization capability and increases risk of fertilization with sperm that is of sub stellar quality. Yes, we will see increase of sperm concentration but decrease in other parameters and increase in DNA fragmentation. We do not want to use the defective sperm anyway, so there is no reason to recommend abstaining. This has been done prior to understanding that more sperm does not equal good sperm. This goes along with thinking that any and all sperm if pregnancy is achieved is optimal, which is not at all the case.
Longer abstinence increased DNA damage which causes apoptosis of the sperm. Dead sperm emit their own ROS and therefore cause damage to the newer sperm. Some studies suggest that daily ejaculations may have less DNA Damage. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3800522/
Reproductive Outcomes in IVF are Significantly Improved When Using Spermatozoa Derived after 1–3 Hours of Abstinence
“Reproductive Outcomes in IVF are Significantly Improved When Using Spermatozoa Derived after 1–3 Hours of Abstinence—Notably, as shown in Table 2, the implantation, clinical pregnancy, and live birth rates were significantly increased by 25.1%, 21.2%, and 36.7% from ejaculates after 1–3 hours of abstinence compared with 3–7 days of abstinence in frozen–thawed cycles, respectively. In addition, the live birth rate was also 33.9% higher from ejaculates after 1–3 hours of abstinence relative to 3–7 days of abstinence in fresh IVF cycles, and the difference approached statistical significance (P = 0.072).”
Motile Sperm Count is Significantly Increased after Reduced Male Ejaculatory Abstinence—Although the semen volume (Fig. 2A) and total sperm count (Fig. 2B) were significantly decreased, the sperm concentration (Fig. 2C) and motile sperm count (Fig. 2D) were significantly increased in ejaculates after 1–3 hours of abstinence compared with 3–7 days of abstinence. There was no significant difference in immotile sperm count between 1–3 hours and 3–7 days of abstinence (Fig. 2E).
"The data from this most comprehensive study of its kind challenges the generally accepted guidelines of the prolonged abstinence periods since the results show that 4 h of sexual abstinence yielded significantly better sperm samples from a functional point of view. Although this study was performed on normozoospermic men, future studies with infertile men might yield similar findings that could lead to employing short abstinence as a strategy to improve the outcome of ART and fertility preservation."
Increase in the sexual abstinence period influences sperm quality. This study reinforces the importance of the duration of ejaculatory abstinence on semen parameter variation. It highlights the deleterious effect of increased abstinence on DNA damage, which is most likely associated with ROS (mitochondrial damage/number of leukocytes). The increase in chromatin packaging can represent a protective feature for DNA."
Temperature and pH are known to influence on stability and developmental potential of gametes [89, 90], but as yet there is no developed sufficient good laboratory standards for incubation of sperm during the period between sperm preparation and fertilization. The duration and environment for sperm incubation vary from clinic to clinic. Peer et al. [91] found that a 2-h incubation of density-gradient-prepared ejaculates at 37°C led to increased nuclear degradation in terms of vacuolated nuclei in comparison to that at 21°C. Testicular sperm appear to be more susceptible to damage than ejaculated sperm, yet they are subjected to conditions under the assumption that they have similar resistance to injury. For example, incubation under aerobic conditions for 4 or 24 h at 37°C leads to marked sperm DNA damage [92, 93]. (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17481619 )
What are some of the causes of high DNA fragmentation of sperm?
1.VARICOCELE as #1 most common issue in male factor infertility. Fragmentation and most common issue of MFI. - 15-20% of humans have a varicocele, also commonly have decreased semen analysis numbers. But having a varicocele doesn’t guarantee DNA damage, but predisposes you to it. You can end up having normal DNA fragmentation even if you have a varicocele depends on how big it is and several other factors. Male with low normal or low sperm analysis results, poor motility or increased DNA fragmentation should have his varicocele repaired to avoid further possibly permanent damage to sperm production mechanisms. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/323761561_Effect_of_varicocele_repair_on_sperm_DNA_fragmentation_a_review
Treatment of a varicocele often results in improvement of semen quality: in 85% of patients the sperm parameters improve after the correction of the varicocele. Substantial improvement of semen quality is found in 50%–70% of patients.
First trimester RPL // Increased Pregnancy rates and decreased miscarriage rates post repair. "Mean sperm concentration, sperm progressive motility, and sperm with normal morphology improved significantly after elapsing 6 months from varicocelectomy by 75.0%, 15.9%, and 14.3%, respectively, versus the expectant group (P < .01). The overall pregnancy rate was 44.1% and 19.1% within a 12-month period in groups 1 and 2, respectively (P = .003). Of women who conceived in groups 1 and 2, 13.3% and 69.2% developed miscarriage (P = .001)." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22641495
CONCLUSION:
These results confirm that varicocelectomy improves sperm parameters and chromatin packaging, thereby improving the chance of pregnancy. Positive aspects of this study include the large number of patients studied, duration of follow up, one surgeon who performed all of the surgeries, and type of surgery (microsurgery). The spontaneous pregnancy results also suggest that if pregnancy is not achieved within twelve months post-surgery, an alternative approach such as assisted reproductive technology (ART) treatment should be considered.
Results suggest that varicocelectomy improves clinical pregnancy and live birth rates by intracytoplasmic sperm injection in infertile couples in which the male partner has clinical varicocele. The chance of miscarriage may be decreased if varicocele is treated before assisted reproduction.
There was a large decrease in DFI from a preoperative mean of 42.6% to a postoperative mean of 20.5% (P < 0.001). A higher preoperative DFI was associated with a larger decrease in postoperative DFI, and significant negative correlations were observed between the DFI and sperm motility (r = -0.42, P < 0.01).
Our data suggest that varicocelectomy can improve multiple semen parameters and sperm DNA damage in infertile men with varicocele. The patients with preoperative defects in those parameters showed greater improvement postoperatively. Further research in this area is needed to understand the exact mechanisms of DNA damage in infertile men with varicocele.
Fifty‐two men with left‐sided varicocele (grade II &III) were included. Sperm parameters, DNA fragmentation, protamine deficiency, oxidative stress and global DNA methylation were evaluated before and 3 months after surgery. Our data show that sperm concentration, percentages of spermatozoon with abnormal morphology, DNA fragmentation, protamine deficiency and oxidative stress significantly improved after surgery.
Treatment of a varicocele often results in improvement of semen quality: in 85% of patients the sperm parameters improve after the correction of the varicocele (7). Substanial improvement of semen quality is found in 50%–70% of patients (8, 9).
In men with a varicocele increased levels of reactive oxygen species and sperm DNA damage can be found. This is probably related to defective spermatogenesis in these patients. Seminal oxidative stress is believed to be the source of sperm DNA damage. Patients with a varicocele and oligospermia may also have a diminished seminal antioxidant capacity. After varicocele repair sperm DNA fragmentation decreases.
CONCLUSION(S):
Varicocele is associated with sperm DNA damage, and this sperm pathology may be secondary to varicocele-mediated oxidative stress. The beneficial effect of varicocelectomy on sperm DNA damage further supports the premise that varicocele may impair sperm DNA integrity.
2. ISSUES WITH TESTICLES AND OTHER REPRODUCTIVE STRUCTURES OF MALES (errors during the production of sperm cells in Spermatogenesis, errors in maturing of the sperm, sperm cells lacking apoptosis signals (meaning these sperm don’t know when to die if they are damaged), obstruction of ejaculation, retrograde ejaculation, absence of vas deferens etc
3. ROS (OXIDATING STRESS AND POOR MITOCHONDRIAL FUNCTION)– oxidative stress and methylation of DNA issues, which damages mitochondrial membrane potential and therefore not enough ATP is made In the cell, preventing cell growth.
Sperm with low motility show low mitochondria membrane potential which means they are not producing enough ATP. Mitochondria release ATP for the sperm to have energy to propel themselves. Low mitochondrial potential is therefore an issue with low motility on sperm analysis.
Those people with sperm that have low mitochondrial membrane potential experience longer time to pregnancy, Lower fertilization rates (Fertilization rate (%) 87 (high MMP) 80 (med MMP) and 60 (low MMP) More total fertilization failure 0 (high MMP) 0 (med MMP) and 15 (low MMP) and lower pregnancy rates 40 (high MMP) 40 (med MMP) and 23 (low MMP)
4.TIME FROM EJACULATION – thawing, cryopreserving, handling time, dilution can all increase fragmentation if not handled properly
DO NOT BRING YOUR SAMPLES TO CLINIC!!!! Ejaculate at the clinic AND do not wait longer 2 days to do so. 1 day or less is showing optimal, so best ejaculate the night before donation.
5.COLLECTION METHOD OF & SPERM PREPARATION - once again this can cause damage to the sperm sample or at the very least not produce an optimal sample.
6. INFECTIONS - Infections like chlamydia and gonorrhea – Antibiotics can treat
7. AGE - DNA frag increases with Age, significantly lower in men under 35
10. PAST OR CURRENT MEDICAL TREATMENTS Such as medications, cancer treatments, antidepressants such as SSRIs and other possible medications can affect sperm fertility
13) SMOKING – not only does it cause DNA fragmentation but also epigenetic changes in sperm that cause mutations and cancer causing mutations in offspring.
Freezing sperm can cause DNA Fragmentation damage by about 10 points in DNA frag. If they have low dna frag it doesn't increase as much though. So someone who initially has 5 become about 10, which is still normal. But if you have 20 to start it may be 40 when unthaw. Basically the worse you have in the beginning the worse it is during unthaw as well.
EVEN WITH DONOR EGGS, this can be a problem since donor eggs have better repair capacity, but can't fix everything.
Studies with high DNA fragmentation + Donated younger patient Oocytes show poor blastuation rates but no affect in fertilization.
Blast formation is severely compromised but does not affect fertilization. Eggs will fertilize but drop off severely before blast stage. If DNA frag was over 30%, blast rate was anywhere from 0-20% in oocytes and nothing more vs blast rate for low DNA fragmentation sperm was up to 100%
The oocyte has an important and redundant, yet limited, DNA repair capacity that decreases with age. However, the oocyte must also repair female genome DNA damage (Lopes et al. 1998 ; Zenzes et al. 1998 ), thereby contributing to an overall increase in the total amount of DNA needing repair. Approximately two million DNA repair operations are needed during the first 24 h following fertilization (Menezo et al. 2010 ). If the DNA repair capacity is overwhelmed, the embryo will initiate apoptosis and developmental arrest. However, a point of greater concern is that some sperm DNA damage, if not repaired, may lead to mutations. Therefore, paternal transmission of damaged DNA may compromise embryonic development and subsequently alter post-natal development (Ji et al. 1997 ; Zenzes 2000 ; Zini and Sigman 2009 ; Robinson et al. 2012 ). In animal models, ICSI using sperm with fragmented DNA leads to a high risk of genetic disease transmission and severe pathologies (Fernandez-Gonzalez et al. 2008 ).
Genetic Damage in Human Spermatozoa by Elizabeth Baldi
Make sure he is taking a multivitamin. There are many antioxidants that can help decrease DNA fragmentation, but unfortunately can also increase nucleus decompensating.
Study of deformities in children linking back fathers with high DNA fragmentation of their sperm
You can scroll to look at the DNA fragmentation chart in the middle of the study. All samples tested were >20% sperm DNA frag. In General population, DNA fragmentation is less than 10% in healthy fertile males. With out society struggling with obesity, poor health and environmental damage, it would not be surprising that there would be more and more sperm DNA damage issues reflected as increase risk in childhood cancer and predisposition to cancer later in life.
We really need more studies done, even if retrospective, on fathers of children with birth defects and cancer. The best studies would be done prospectively and DNA fragmentation testing would be done around the time of conception, but if that’s not possible, we could at least test at the time of birth or known defect. There is clearly a correlation and that is very important.
OPTIONS FOR TREATMENT IF HIGH LEVEL OF DNA FRAGMENTATION IS FOUND:
1. GET THIS TESTED BEFORE YOU START IUI OR IVF!!!! This should be a standard test for everyone because failure is awful, expensive and a few hundred dollar test at this point is ridiculous to deny to your patients. Just order the damn thing.
IF YOU CAN'T GET YOUR RE TO ORDER ONE BECAUSE THEY ARE STUCK IN THE DARK AGES: You can order one yourself, the only company that does that as a send in kit is here: https://www.scsadiagnostics.com/ You can request a kit and they send it to you, no physician order required. You can also call around reproductive urologists and see who does this in your area/town etc. Everyone does it now, just depending how far they are from you including Europe.
2. IF HIGH - Try to decrease sperm DNA fragmentation. You have to have a trained specialist that knows about male factor infertility and affects of DNA fragmentation on embryo development. See a fertility urologist to see if any varicocele can be repaired or any other structural issues can be solved. PLEASE SEE A FERTILITY UROLOGIST. Or several. If you have a varicocele and infertility get it repaired.
3**.** Start vitamins, cut out alcohol and smoking, stop any heat to the groin, wait 3 months since it takes 3 months to see a difference in DFI and sperm takes 3 months to regenerate
4. When RE tells you they will just PGS your embryos and they are chromosomally normal, that is FINE to make sure it has enough chromosomes but tells you nothing about how the embryo develops or the inside content of EACH of those chromosomes. PGS will only rule out problems of whole missing or whole extra chromosomes (any aneuploidy or trisomy embryos). This is very important to understand that a PGS normal embryo can still have issues with DNA integrity and therefore will not develop properly in utero. If You get a DNA fragmentation test and the test is NORMAL, you have much higher chance of embryo developing properly or you can try to figure out egg issues contributing if you still have miscarriages with normal sperm analysis and normal sperm DNA fragmentation. We know that Down’s syndrome which is trisomy 21 is directly related to egg age for example and increases the chances with woman’s age only, not the male. But this is one of a million issues that can happen, albeit major one we see since it’s not fatal most of the time.
5. During your first RE appointment when they start ordering all the labs for THE FEMALE, make sure they also work up the MALE properly. It’s 50/50. Sperm analysis does not rule male not having issues!
6. ICSI is the current recommended treatment but due to poor sperm sorting techniques the success rates are MUCH lower than regular normal DNA fragmented sperm. IF your dna fragmentation is high your pregnancy rate is 9% vs 30% with someone who has normal DFI.
ICSI does NOT fully solve this issue and you will continue to struggle.
If you are failing:
Your options are to try - if your DFI is >40% do a TESE ICSI. See above studies.
If it's 15-40%, you may try microfludic sperm sorting prior to ICSI.
IT IS possible to get pregnant with higher DFI with repairing varicocele, vitamins, etc - it is not impossible. BUT your chances are much much lower. So This does not rule out the fact that you can get pregnant naturally, or with regular ICSI. My goal is just to show you research and numbers and statistics. Anyone can have success regardless of their diagnosis we know this. Now, how to become that success with higher chances is the question here.
Just be aware of that if your only option offered is ICSI. You are likely to have several failures or no success or miscarriages unless you use microfluidic device or testicular sperm for the ICSI + PGS Cycle.
There are lots of egg issues too obviously but at least rule out sperm issues. It is very likely you will need to try to convince them that ICSI will not help you. You can use the studies here or just seek another opinion of someone that WILL listen. Bring the Microfluidic device sorting papers in the sub post here. Show them that TESE sperm is better and has more "normal expected" outcomes as the rest of IVF world. This is how I convinced two REs in our city to take it seriously, and then I chose one of them. ASRM presented Zymot posters and it will become more common soon. Hang in there. You will see change, but it may take some educating first.
Hey, just wanted to post about our story and hopefully give some insight on what has been a long road.
Husband and I started trying for a baby in summer 2017, when he was 40 and I was 35. Six months passed with no success so we went through all the basic fertility testing - hormonal panel and HSG for me, and when that was all clear, semen analysis for him. Azoospermia diagnosis. We suspected that this was due to him taking finasteride for hair loss, but he was otherwise healthy, with no indication of physiological or hormonal disruptions. He immediately discontinued the finasteride and started taking Profertil supplements and at the 6 month mark, even though the ordinary lab was still finding zero sperm, the IVF clinic was able to find 5,000 count. Still severe oligospermia, but at least we could proceed with IVF with ICSI.
Our first cycle yielded 8 "beautiful" eggs, but trigger was insufficient and they were all immature. Second cycle trigger was doubled and we got 8 eggs, 6 mature, 5 fertilized with ICSI, 4 day 3, 1 day 5, fresh transfer, resulted in chemical pregnancy.
We decided to get a second opinion and switch clinics for a more specialized look, and the new doctor ordered karyotype, cystic fibrosis, phenotype, clotting and immune testing. Everything came back normal, except an heterozygous MTHFR mutation I carried, which was nonetheless not active. DNA fragmentation testing was also ordered, but this required a count of 2 million, which we did not have. Instead, I urged hubby to get a second opinion on testicular ultrasound. There has to be a varicocele in there, I said. We saw two more urologists, and this time, both found a grade 3 varicocele. Surgery was done in May 2019, but semen parameters did not appear to improve.
We did a third cycle, got 15 eggs, 6 mature (my body has egg maturation issues and I also believe in hindsight that I was triggered too early), 5 fertilized, 3 excellent quality blastocysts. We PGS tested them, one abnormal, one euploid, one low level segmental mosaic. Transferred the euploid in December in a medicated FET, failed.
By then, chulzle and I met, and she said she strongly suspected DNA fragmentation issues with the sperm, possibly as a result of ejaculation. She told me to push for TESE, which my doctor wouldn't consider initially. In his opinion, we had good blast rates, so sperm must be ok. He did admit though that according to the embryologists, hubby was one of the most severe cases of oligospermia they had seen. A fourth cycle completely failed with again zero mature eggs yielded, and at this point I was emotionally and physically shattered and just about ready to give up. We had one mosaic left (they don't let you keep abnormals in Cyprus), and I just wanted to transfer it and get it done. Hubby was against donor sperm and in my despair and depression, I started questioning what I would choose if it came between saving my marriage or having kids.
"Get TESE done", insisted chulzle. "Otherwise you will keep experiencing miscarriages and failed transfers". "My doctor won't do it", was my reply. "Then get another doctor! I'm certain this is a sperm issue and they have to at least try!".
So, armed with confidence and a good dose of "I'm done", in summer 2020 I went back to my doctor and demanded three things: a hysteroscopy, a longer stim cycle since I know I ovulate close to CD18, and TESE. To my surprise, he immediately agreed as long as my husband was on board. I had begun to see chulzle's thinking, and agreed with her that the issue must be blockage, invisible to ultrasound. Sperm was getting attrition on the way out, I was certain. Hubby was so healthy otherwise, nothing else made sense. We both knew this was possibly our last cycle, having paid for everything out of pocket. A hysteroscopy came back all clear, and the longer stim cycle seemed to work better despite a lower AFC. 6 mature eggs, 4 fertilized, again 3 5AA blasts. At the same time as my retrieval, hubby had his TESE operation, where chulzle was proven correct: not only was healthy sperm found in the testes, it was found really easily and in good quantities. Having decided not to PGS test, we transferred the first of the 3 blasts, a gorgeous spontaneously hatching embryo, in a natural FET. This was October 16th, 2020 on our 4th wedding anniversary, and today I'm 20 months pregnant with a healthy baby boy, after stellar NT and ultrasound findings. My anatomy scan is next week but I'm really not worried.
Thank you chulzle, for always taking the time to talk to me, advise and push me to be better able to advocate for myself. I truly believe I would not be living this dream had it not been for you. For this, I will be eternally grateful, and baby Andrew will grow up knowing he has a cool auntie on the other side of the world <3
So I have posted a lot about DNA fragmentation and when we get out scores we know that over 30% is “bad”. So what does this actually mean?
I think most people at this point would assume that 30% dna fragmentation of sperm means that 30% are fragmented and therefore 70% are normal. Well… that’s actually not at all true.
Rather than thinking of this as normal or abnormal rate it’s actually a representation of a RANGE of how your sperm range is doing. This range represents the quantity of really good sperm (fragmented individual sperm) vs not so good sperm (highly fragmented missing lots of dna pieces). And by this we mean if you look at EVERY sperm … we can see just what percent fragmentation is THAT particular sperm.
It’s important to note that eggs repair DNA damage within their own oocytes AND the DNA damage in sperm when they come in contact together during fertilization. Most of this work is done in the first 48 hours of fertilization. ("The oocyte has an important and redundant, yet limited, DNA repair capacity that decreases with age. However, the oocyte must also repair female genome DNA damage (Lopes et al. 1998 ; Zenzes et al. 1998 ), thereby contributing to an overall increase in the total amount of DNA needing repair. Approximately two million DNA repair operations are needed during the first 24 h following fertilization (Menezo et al. 2010 ). If the DNA repair capacity is overwhelmed, the embryo will initiate apoptosis and developmental arrest. However, a point of greater concern is that some sperm DNA damage, if not repaired, may lead to mutations. Therefore, paternal transmission of damaged DNA may compromise embryonic development and subsequently alter post-natal development (Ji et al. 1997 ; Zenzes 2000 ; Zini and Sigman 2009 ; Robinson et al. 2012 ). In animal models, ICSI using sperm with fragmented DNA leads to a high risk of genetic disease transmission and severe pathologies (Fernandez-Gonzalez et al. 2008 )."
Sperm are not able to perform repair on themselves. So the question how much sperm damage of its DNA in form for fragmentation of the genome can our eggs repair? THIS is actually what goes down with age among other issue like the mitochondrial membrane potential that provides oocytes with energy to divide. We stop being able to repair the DNA breaks in our own eggs and the sperm efficiently and to a greater capacity.
There are no known human studies in which a sperm with known fragmentation has been inseminated into an oocyte. We have an idea of what happens when “an average total” DNA fragmentation score sperm is used but that actually doesn’t mean anything for the sperm that fertilized the egg. It could have been one with 5% fragmentation or 25% fragmentation. Which one can actually lead to a pregnancy? The total dna frag score can be helpful in understanding just how much of the good vs bad sperm is available to make things happen.
Simply because currently the only way to see what one sperm’s dna fragmentation is, the sperm has to die due to dyes used in evaluation. However, in animal studies it has been estimated that the animal’s capacity to repair sperm DNA fragmentation of that particular sperm is around 8-10%. When higher fragmented sperm is injected to oocytes, it can lead to miscarriage, birth defects, increased cancer rates or failure of implantation or fertilization in said animal models.
LETS ASSUME WE ARE LIKE OTHER ANIMALS and are able to also repair 8% of the DNA damage. (yes the argument can be made we are not mice or rabbits clearly, but what if humans are able to repair less damage for example? It maybe more, but it would be immoral to do these experiments, so lets follow animal studies on this one for now until further notice from our science community) That means any other sperm that’s highter than 8% fragmented will lead to the above failures. Does this mean you need a DNA fragmentation of 8% or less score for success?
No. Here’s why.
So when you get a dna fragmentation score, it is an average of a sort of the amount of dna damage in all sperms measured separately. This graph gives a great representation of what this means.
So keep in mind, the number that gets thrown around is the AVERAGE TOTAL DNA FRAG score and we say 1-15% is normal, 15-30% is high risk, and above 30% is abnormal and leads to difficulty with pregnancy naturally and with ART. All the tests are a little different with somewhat different “normal” but the comet average for the population is 16%. For Halo and SCCD test it’s around 12%.
So the below is an actual report from a patient. As you can see, their average TOTAL DNA frag score is 28%.This does NOT mean that the other 72% are normal. IN fact very opposite is true. We have to look at the first one or two bars in green from the graph that represents 5% -10% ACTUAL sperm dna fragmentation of each sperm… so for a patient that has TOTAL DNA FRAG of 28% the ACTUAL LOW and NORMAL sperm with below 5%-10% fragmentation is only 7%. This means that if the egg’s capacity to repair sperm that is 7-10% fragmented, only those sperm will lead to a healthy baby. Getting pregnant with the other green bars, does lead to a pregnancy but they may miscarry. The yellow bars may lead to no fertilization or no blasts, and the orange are too slow too get anywhere.
So for example when someone has a TOTAL dna frag score of 16% there are 20 percent of all sperm with less than 5 percent damage and can give a healthy baby. That’s 5 times more healthy sperm in someone that has a total dna frag of 16 vs 28.
For someone with DNA frag of 33% and only 3% of sperm are actually normal so.... almost 7 more times greater chances at pregnancy success than someone with dna frag of 33%.
This has a patient with total DNA frag score of 32% on the right, and they only have 3 percent of their whole sperm have less than 5% actual sperm fragmentation. So it drastically decreases the amount of good sperm able to give you a baby as the numbers go up. Over 40% dna fragmentation usually means that there is very little to no sperm that has extremely low fragmentation in the sample that’s going to give life birth and that's where IUI's do not usually work and proper sorting needs to happen to get those FEW sperm that are actually normal integrity.
So that brings me to another point.
Can someone with a total DNA frag of 28% have a live birth naturally? Yes, but all of the sudden your risk are that much lower, so less than 7% pretty much. Can someone with dna frag over 40% get pregnant naturally and have a live birth? Maybe, but very rarely. THIS is really why. Otherwise it’s easy to think well… if we have 45% dna frag aren’t the other 55% normal? Well, no they are not.
So. Why does sperm sorting and ICSI matter? Well, for the patient above who has 28% of dna frag, if you used a microfluidic chip only sperm with less than 5% dna fragmentation are able to swim through the chip. So you’re pretty much choosing from the most viable sperm. Then you are using ICSI to ensure you are also choosing sperm that has the best morphology and confirming that it’s swimming well. ICSI is also though to have improved MFI issues due to the fact they choose fastest swimming morphologically normal (or at least you hope your lab is good to do that) sperm and that's thought to have lower dna frag in those sperm. However, if you are using IVF with ICSI without proper sorting, the sperm in green may all swim well, BUT the lab director may choose a sperm that has 15-20% fragmentation instead of less than 5%. He can’t tell really. They both have normal morphology and normal motility. BUT what we do know is that the younger you are, the more capacity of fragmentation repair we have. So someone with eggs that are 20 may be able to repair a sperm that’s 15% fragmented? Just throwing out the number for an example since we actually don't know individual oocyte sperm repair capability, and does that vary egg to egg, month to month? etc.... However, if that same sperm came in contact with an egg from a 38 year old woman, she can only repair up to 5% per se and therefore pregnancy would not ensure or miscarry. We know 100% that these repair mechanisms diminish as women age, but physicians have always placed OOCYTE OWN errors as the excuse of why things didn't work out. Everyone needs to remember that eggs are doing double the work here for both egg and sperm.
I made this graph to simplify and understand how total dna frag relates to actual normal non fragmented sperm in the sample.
To the left is the percent of "good normal low fragmented sperm in a whole sample" and to the bottom is your DNA frag score. We just need to get the sperm that is low dna frag sperm out of the sample.
This is a linear graph to see an example but the relationship is actually curvilinear - in that at low DNA frag total score the good sperm are probably very high, and the higher dna frag total numbers have actually little to no good sperm...
As you can tell, someone with 5% dna fragmentation would probably have around 40 percent actual normal low fragmented sperm vs someone with a score of 50% dna total frag would hardly have any.
It’s important to do all we can to lower dna fragmentation and understand how it can be implicated in fertility issues and ART procedures.
Hope this helps to explain what DNA frag results could mean for you and why 30% is actually bad.
Here’s what current research shows about how sperm contributes to placental development—and how sperm-related issues can lead to placental problems and miscarriage:
⸻
🧬 1. Paternal DNA and Imprinting Drive Placental Growth • Imprinted genes like IGF2 (paternal-expressed) are critical for placental development. Maternal genes often act to limit growth—creating a balance. Disruption can impair placental structure and function . • Classic experiments show that embryos with only paternal genomes develop placental tissues but not embryos, while those with only maternal genomes do the opposite .
⸻
2. Sperm Epigenetics (Methylation, Histone Marks, ncRNAs) • DNA methylation: Older age, obesity, or toxins can alter sperm methylation patterns. These changes, especially in imprinted genes, can affect early placental gene expression and viability . • Histone modifications and ncRNAs: Errors in chromatin packaging or sperm RNA content due to lifestyle or environment can influence embryo and placental gene activation, increasing miscarriage risk ().
⸻
3. Lifestyle, Age & Environmental Exposures • Advanced paternal age is associated with increased sperm DNA fragmentation, de novo mutations, and epigenetic disruption—linked to higher miscarriage and placental complications . • Obesity, diabetes, toxins (e.g., dioxin): In mice, paternal exposures caused placental growth restriction, gene methylation changes (e.g. Igf2, Pgr), and increased preterm birth . • Lifestyle factors like smoking and poor diet impact sperm epigenetics and may lead to pregnancy loss .
⸻
4. Sperm DNA Fragmentation & Recurrent Pregnancy Loss (RPL) • Many studies link high sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) with recurrent or unexplained miscarriages. Sperm integrity tests are now suggested in male partners facing RPL . • Even without major chromosomal abnormalities, sperm epigenetic changes (from age, health, environment) are increasingly recognized as contributors to recurrent loss .
⸻
5. Seminal Microbiome Influence • Emerging research suggests that bacteria or RNA in seminal fluid may “program” paternal effects on placenta and embryo development, though it’s an evolving field .
⸻
🔍 Summary
Sperm Factor Placenta/Miscarriage Impact Imprinted genes (e.g., IGF2) Essential for placental growth; disruption = dysfunction DNA methylation / epigenetics Alters gene expression—can lead to growth restriction, miscarriage DNA fragmentation Poor sperm integrity linked to recurrent miscarriage Lifestyle & environment Age, obesity, toxins can epigenetically impair placenta via sperm Seminal microbiome New area—pathways still being mapped
⸻
What Comes Next? • Clinically: Testing sperm DNA fragmentation and epigenetic markers could improve recurrent miscarriage diagnosis and intervention. • Research: Assessing how modifying paternal factors (diet, stress, weight loss) can repair sperm epigenetics and prevent placental dysfunction. • Mouse models: Show ancestral exposures (like toxins) can impair placental development for generations through sperm epigenetics.
⸻
If you’re dealing with recurrent miscarriages, consider involving a reproductive specialist to evaluate sperm DNA fragmentation, paternal age, and lifestyle factors. These are growing areas of interest in both research and treatment.
One of my closest friends (38) recently entered a relationship with a 44-year-old partner diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). He is otherwise considered “healthy.”
Because of what I’ve studied and written about for over a decade, I suggested she have him undergo a full semen analysis.
The results?
One of the most pristine semen analyses I’ve ever seen - even compared to donor samples.
• 250 million sperm/mL
• 70% motility
• 9% morphology
• Well above WHO reference ranges
• “Perfectly fertile” per urologist
Most clinics would stop there. We did not. Because sleep apnea is not a semen parameter problem. It is a hypoxia problem. She proceeded with DNA Fragmentation Index (DFI) testing. (SCSA) is the most widely used, gold-standard, and highly accurate diagnostic test for measuring sperm DNA fragmentation (broken DNA strands), typically reporting a % DNA Fragmentation Index (DFI). It came back elevated at 40%. Even I was shocked.
They’re both excited about the future and have been talking about starting a family. But here’s where things get real: he has a diagnosed case of obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). This is why I write here occasionally still even though my life is an absolutely different stages and is a lot more complex after surviving this whole nightmare, that’s why I summarise all the research in a book that’s about 30 pages for everybody for a dollar. When you’re told you have perfect fertility and you have hope and a perfect sperm analysis in your 38 - guess who’s going to get blamed for miscarriages and infertility problems if you don’t check the DNA fragmentation?
I fought with people online in clinics for over 10 years about this until main stream caught up, probably because they’ve been reading my work for about 10 years but still won’t give me credit. That’s fine. I know what I contributed to the world of fertility over the last 10 years here and other places.
Male fertility problem is a crisis - having a sperm analysis better than many donors I’ve seen. We’re talking 250 million sperm per ml, 70% motility, and 9% morphology, way above WHO standards. Wow. Amazing by all standards. Thrilling.
Here is the problem with sleep apnea. Sleep apnea causes chronic cycles of hypoxia (low oxygen) and reoxygenation, which ramps up oxidative stress, mitochondrial dysfunction, reactive oxygen species (ROS), systemic inflammation (think elevated TNF-alpha and IL-6), increased sympathetic activation, and cortisol spikes.
Sperm are particularly vulnerable here, they have limited antioxidant defenses in their cytoplasm, and their membranes are loaded with polyunsaturated fatty acids that oxidize easily. They rely heavily on healthy mitochondrial function, which gets hammered by this. As women age (like my friend at 38), eggs have a reduced ability to repair damaged sperm DNA, so the burden falls harder on them, often leading to blame on “it’s your eggs” when it’s actually the partner’s sperm issues.
She listened and pushed for a DNA fragmentation index (DFI) test anyway. Why? Because sleep apnea doesn’t just stop at the basics, it hits testicular function twofold. First, direct testicular damage from hypoxia boosts ROS in the testes, messing with developing sperm during chromatin packaging… think about it this way the sperm when it’s made it needs to be folded correctly and two basically what sperm looks like. It also needs to unfold the DNA inside it correctly when it’s combining with the Egg. This leads to defective protamination and double-strand DNA breaks, which are tough for the egg to repair (unlike single-strand breaks). This is where the problem with DNA fragmentation is and what I discovered about 10 years ago and why embryos stop even if though things look perfect on the surface. You cannot see it on the inside and you cannot examine every sperm if it’s fragmented or not he can look perfect from the outside that’s why I CSI in cycles fails.
This is what doctors don’t understand and keep telling patients the wrong information about normal embryos versus abnormal embryos. Single strand or double strand breaks do not show up on PGS testing this is a completely different problem. That’s too small to be noted on any test that we currently have.
Studies show elevated 8-OHdG markers (a key sign of oxidative DNA damage) in OSA patients, backing this up. Second, there’s post-testicular damage as sperm mature in the epididymis over about 15 days (the full sperm cycle is around 74 days). Stress, inflammation, and more ROS during transit can fragment DNA further, which is why testicular sperm extraction (TESE) sometimes works better in IVF for these cases, bypassing the epididymis.
CPAP treatment can help reduce DFI in some men after 3-6 months of strict use, but not everyone—especially if the OSA has been longstanding, or if there’s obesity (BMI over 30), metabolic syndrome, or persistent inflammation.
Diet and antioxidants alone won’t cut it if the root hypoxia cycles aren’t addressed; they can only mitigate so much.
In my friend’s case, the DFI came back high despite that flawless analysis, and now they’re navigating options.
I’ve predicted this scenario for over 10 years: perfect semen parameters, sleep apnea lurking, high DFI, multiple miscarriages or losses, then the woman gets blamed for her age. It’s not a science disagreement; it’s a mismatch in understanding biology.
Snoring doesn’t guarantee OSA, but get it checked. If you’ve had miscarriages with a “perfect” sperm analysis, demand a DFI test. If CPAP doesn’t drop the DFI and antioxidants fail, TESE discussion is key, don’t feel defeated; it’s about getting the full picture.
Be aware, be vigilant with your providers. A perfect sperm analysis is NEVER the end of the story. Foresight, like embryo banking or donor sperm backups, can save heartbreak. Fertility is more than meets the eye.
I could go back in time, I would never have pursued that nightmare path. I survived five miscarriages and 12 failed embryo transfers into three surrogates—who also experienced miscarriages, only for everything to resolve with a single donor sperm transfer. I understand the deep pain of losing the chance for a fully biological child. But I refuse to believe that torturing women for years, or telling them they’re “infertile” while their own fertility window closes, is ever acceptable.
This isn’t hypothetical for me, it’s what happened. And it’s happening to thousands of women worldwide.
What I did (and what I urge every woman in this situation to consider): Do a cycle with donor sperm if your partner has high DNA fragmentation (or any red flags like sleep apnea, even with “perfect” semen parameters). Plan for your future fertility regardless of what happens with the relationship.
• If your plans work out? Great—amazing.
• But if time runs out, if you age out, if your partner leaves, or if issues persist… you don’t lose your chance at a child related to you biologically. That’s a complete nightmare I’ve seen too many women endure.
Fertility treatments often involve suppression protocols, endless cycles, and blame shifted to women’s age or eggs, when the real issue is often hidden male factors. Sperm problems like DNA fragmentation (caused by oxidative stress from things like untreated obstructive sleep apnea) are frequently undetectable on standard semen analysis. We don’t even have full testing for every underlying issue yet, and male fertility is in decline globally (sperm counts have dropped dramatically over decades due to environmental, lifestyle, and other factors).
Physicians still resist acknowledging this crisis fully, but the evidence is clear: untreated sleep apnea links to higher infertility risk in men, increased sperm DNA damage, lower testosterone, and poorer semen quality via chronic hypoxia, inflammation, and ROS. Even “perfect” counts don’t rule out fragmentation leading to recurrent loss.
I will keep advocating for women everywhere to fight for themselves and their fertility. Protect your timeline. Get the full picture—demand DNA fragmentation testing, consider backups like embryo banking with donor options if needed. Don’t let outdated views or incomplete testing steal your future.
You’re not alone in this. Be vigilant, be proactive, and prioritize your own biology. Share if this hits home—too many stories like mine stay silent.
Second experiment with donor sperm worked too first transfer. It’s not your eggs with recurrent loss and implantation failure lesson. //
An update to my post to those who want to try donor sperm.
As I said, i had 5 losses with my ex. Then 5 Ivf cycles and 12 embryos from 3 cycles didn’t work in 3 surrogates either and didn’t implant or miscarry. Eventually 2 worked out of 12.
I got pregnant first try and was able to have a wonderful pregnancy with someone else and no loss. I had donor sperm embryos I created during that time as a back up since ours weren’t working and donated them to a couple and they got pregnant first transfer after theirs never working. So my eggs + anyone else’s normal sperm work first time.
If donor sperm is an option and you’ve had so much loss I would go back in a heart beat and just do it. I wish I never went through the kind of hell I did when I never had to apparently.
And again, sperm testing is limited. It’s archaic. If someone is struggling with loss and you’re “unexplained” or testing normal it’s probably sperm.
I thought I would put a few that regularly publish papers and guidelines for proper work up in the US since apparently it’s like mining for diamonds. I will pin this.
If you’ve have a good experience with someone feel free to DM me their work / credentials so I can take a look what their opinions are on MFI work up and DNA frag.
Cleveland clinic urology department Ashok Agarwal is the most published and ahead of his peers my a million years. He started publishing about dna frag issues and doing studies 10-15 years ago about this. I’ve read all his work and thank him for basically all my knowledge in this area that’s granted me the ability to help others along the way.
I will preface this with saying I have 0 affiliations with any of these people or any personal gain from anything like the rest of my reddit post/subs/ history. All information is free and clear from the sick money making machine that is medicine is America. I genuinely want people to understand and get proper help and advice and not be screwed over by the system.
James Hotaling, MD, assistant professor of surgery and co-director of the Fertility Integrated Practice Unit at the University of Utah School of Medicine in Salt Lake City.
Mary Samplaski, MD, an assistant professor of urology at the University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine in Los Angeles, b
Several factors lead to this damage, said Ashok Agarwal, PhD, director of the Cleveland Clinic Clinical Andrology Lab and Sperm Bank
Amin S. Herati, MD, assistant -professor of urology and director of male infertility at the Brady Urological Institute at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine in Baltimore.
Dr Ramasamy MD - Miami
American Center for Reproductive Medicine, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, USA
Department of Urology, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Department of Urology, Loma Linda University, Loma Linda, CA, USA. Division of Urology, Southern Illinois University School of Medicine, Springfield, IL, USA. Department of Urology, University of Miami, Miami, FL, USA. Austin Fertility & Reproductive Medicine/Westlake IVF, Austin, TX, USA.
Paul Turek San Fransico
Dr Diebert at Nebraska med in Omaha.
ENGLAND (Department of Metabolism, Digestion and Reproduction, Imperial College London, London, UK.)
hi guys, hope my post would be helpful to people who just received news of high dna frag. My husband (age 33 now) did semen analysis twice, once in end 2021 and again in early 2022, of which both had normal parameters apart from low morphology at 1-2%. He did a dna frag test as well in early 2022, which came back with 40% dna frag. This devastated us as based on our research it seems as though natural conception is impossible.
After reading countless research articles I found out that varicocele is one of the reasons that causes high dna frag. My husband visited a urologist and indeed he had one. He decided to undergo varicoceletomy even though many told us it is not guaranteed. In fact our fertility specialist told us it is unlikely that varicoceletomy would help and suggested ICSI. We still proceeded with the varicoceletomy and in the following month, we got pregnant naturally! We were told that the 3-6 months after varicoceletomy would be the most crucial (although success is not guaranteed) because that’s when there would be a surge in sperms. Because we got pregnant shortly after, my husband did not perform another semen analysis so I can’t share how the parameters changed.
We are now heading into our third trimester and can’t wait to see our little one soon. Fingers crossed everything will be go well and smoothly. I hope this post would bring a little hope to people who are in the same situation as us and to bring attention to the possibility of varicocele being the obstacle to your conception.
Thought I'd share some good news to give others hope!
After an SA that showed a 1% morphology and a DNA frag test showing 33% average we were getting prepared for the TESE/ICSI route.
After reading about the 3 hour method on here (ejaculate 3 hours before intercourse during the fertile window) we gave it a go and just had a positive pregnancy test!
Feeling very cautious about higher chance of miscarriage, but also hope that it is at least the most possible it's felt in a while.
Just again pointing out that if you have Recurrent pregnancy loss RPL, get your partner tested. A lot of RPL cases are due to sperm aneuploidy. In women with RPL, men have very high abnormal sperm that is trisomic WITH NORMAL SPERM ANALYSIS. You will need full work up and sperm analysis is not enough.
This is looking at at ONLY 5 chromosomes in males with female partner with RPL. Meaning, it's much higher if they looked at all chromosomes. Women with RPL, their partners sperm were 40% abnormal with aneuploidies with normal sperm analysis (this is much much higher if all chromosomes were tested, this only looks at 5 of the most common trisomies) and 50% abnormal if something was low in SAs'.
"Normal" fertile males were only 5% abnormal.
Extrapolating to all chromosomes instead of just 5 tested would make RPL male partners have most of the sperm be aneuploid due to errors in meiosis divisions in the testicles.
"Aneuploidy in these chromosomes was screened because they are prevalent, also able to reach the term. In control group (Table2), totally 132 cells (5.2%) were abnormal, including 106 nullisomy and 26 disomy. Abnormalities were detected in (41%) of analyzed cells in RPL men with normal semen and (50.6%) of cells in RPL men with abnormal semen. "
Semen analysis does very little for RPL work up. PLEASE have them see a fertility urologist, have them have sperm analysis, dna fragmentation and sperm aneuploidy testing at the very least (along with sono and labs).
Sperm can have abnormal chromosomal issues which do not show up in SA's. This can cause RPL in women along with dna fragmentation, sperm aneuploidy is a must for RPL women.
Hello, I thought I’d share my experiences with DNA fragmentation in case it’s helpful for anyone.
We started trying in my late 40s, and I’m now 50. Unfortunately, we experienced a few miscarriages early on. Initially, I had only undergone a standard sperm test, which gave me an “OK/average” score. Based on this, our consultant at the time assured us there was nothing to worry about, so the doctors focused their investigations on my partner.
It wasn’t until we changed doctors and went to the Lister Hospital in London that I was recommended to take a sperm DNA fragmentation test. To my shock, the results revealed I had a high level of DNA fragmentation, which essentially classified me as infertile.
This news was obviously devastating for both of us. My partner’s gynaecologist then suggested we see an andrologist / urologist, as there could be underlying issues like a varicocele—a common abnormality in the veins of the testicles that can affect semen quality and male fertility. I was initially skeptical, thinking I’d notice if something like that were wrong. However, that turned out not to be the case.
After further testing with the andrologist (Tet Yap, who is brilliant), it was confirmed that I did indeed have a varicocele and also low testosterone levels. The treatment began with a procedure to remove the varicocele, followed by Clomid to boost my testosterone production. The procedure went smoothly, and I responded very well to the Clomid. In fact, my testosterone levels at one point were comparable to those of a teenage boy! They’ve since stabilized at an optimal level.
Three months later, my latest sperm test showed significant improvement—I’m now well within the normal range. It’s such a relief to finally have a bit of positive news after everything we’ve been through so far.
To summarize what I believe worked for me:
Addressing the varicocele and low testosterone – The varicocele removal and Clomid treatment helped a lot
Adjusting my exercise routine – I think my previous long-distance running habit may have negatively impacted my testosterone levels and increased heat in the groin area, so I replaced it with weightlifting and jogging.
Lifestyle changes – I reduced alcohol and caffeine intake, but still allowed myself the occasional treat (a glass of red wine or coffee now and then is fine in moderation).
Avoiding excessive heat – I completely avoided saunas and hot baths, as well as anything that might overheat the groin area.
Using a standing desk – Sitting for extended periods can also be problematic, so I set up a standing desk to help mitigate this issue.
I just wanted to share that we received our results from a repeat SCSA DNA fragmentation test. Our first results came back high at 25%. Our repeat result shows a decent improvement at 18%. The changes we made include the following:
600mg Ubuiquinol, 268 mg Vitamin E, 1000 mg Vitamin C, FertilAid, 5000IU Vitamin D (3x/wk)
Healthy(er) eating and regular(ish) exercise
Icing the nuts every night and avoiding heat in that area
Cutting alcohol consumption by about 90%
Short abstinence, specifically clearing the pipes every day/every other day in the two weeks leading up to the test. The test sample was provided on a ~20 hour hold. I know even shorter can be better, but 20 hours is the sweet spot for us as his count will take a nosedive if we make it any shorter than that.
My partner has really enjoyed how much control I currently wield over his masturbation schedule /s. But I am pleased that our efforts did make some progress.
We have had two miscarriages from unassisted pregnancies and are gearing up for our first IVF retrieval featuring ICSI, Zymot, Omnitrope, the works. This result is encouraging and gives me some hope. Much appreciation for all of the information provided in this sub.
I wanted to share our story as it was posts like this that gave me light and hope in my darkest times navigating infertility.. Scientific facts don’t take into account a large sample size and there are other outcomes for incurable high DNA fragmentation.
Me and my husband started trying in June 2023 when we were 29F and 30M. We had gotten pregnant quickly before so never imagined we would have difficulty conceiving again together. When my husband got tested we found out his sperm parameters were very low and this was due to an infection. It was suspected he had chronic prostatitis for possibly 2 years. He had antibiotics which slowly improved his parameters over a year but Dr Jonathan Ramsay recommended we check his DNA fragmentation. It was extremely high at 54%. He then used zymot and retested to see if it would come down, hoping like most, that it would drastically improve things. It went down to 49% - not the improvement we had hoped for.
My husband is fit and healthy, doesn’t smoke or drink. He did not have a varicocele (checked 3 times). Treating the infection didn’t work either. The Dr said that he doesn’t think lifestyle changes will improve the DNA fragmentation as he believed there had been damage to a mechanism that produced the sperm probably from a chronic infection.Many posts on Reddit about DNA fragmentation mentioned that the DNA fragmentation was made better with treating an infection, lifestyle changes or getting treatment for a varicocele but unfortunately we were not in that position. I desperately searched to see if someone had a similar story but it was hard to find! Sometimes there is DNA fragmentation that just can’t be fixed.
We were advised to go forward with IVF. We did this privately at a clinic called Ark IVF in Greece (absolutely fantastic consultant who was trained by Dr Ramsay and specialises in male infertility). But before we went ahead my husband did want to try 3 months of supplements. Unfortunately, his DNA fragmentation only reduced to 51% as the Dr expected.
Fast forward - it was an extremely nervous wait to hear back about how many embryo’s we made. The Dr said we may get 1 or 2. We got 8 good quality embryo’s! We couldn’t believe it. We used PICSI and Zymot. No one was expecting this outcome, not even the Drs.
Today I sit here nursing my 1 month old. The first transfer did not work but the second did. I have also found out I have adenomyosis on the IVF journey. It is a true miracle she is here. We were not faced with good odds at all. We were advised we could not fix the DNA fragmentation and we didn’t. We were told our chances were slim but it still worked with 51% DNA fragmentation and adenomyosis. It is possible. I hope this success story gives anyone out there struggling for hope in their darkest times.
My husband (48) and I (30) decided to get a DNA fragmentation test done before we started TTC, on account of his age leading to the increased chances of there being poor quality sperm. We had decided that the small price to pay for the test was negligible compared to the possible heartache of having to endure a miscarriage. We didn’t expect a poor result as he is very healthy and fit (he’s done marathons, does an annual triathlon etc.)
Needless to say, we were floored when the result came back at 48% fragmentation. No issues with regular semen analysis. We were basically told that there was no way we would ever be able to conceive a child together, and that was it- the end of our consultation. We were too shell shocked and heartbroken to ask any questions.
He had a physical exam with a urologist who couldn’t find any issues.
We then did a huge amount of research and he made the following lifestyle changes:
-Introduced more foods containing antioxidants into his diet- dark chocolate, goji berries etc.
-Ate around 100g of a variety of nuts and seeds per day (cashews, almonds, sunflower seeds etc)
-no more hot baths
-no more heated seat in the car
-no more phone in his pocket
-ran more often and further (instead of sporadic exercise we ran much more regularly and for slightly longer)
-Switched to decaf coffee, and herbal tea
-Gave up alcohol
-More sex. Went from an average of twice per week to about 3 times per week, and at least once a day during fertile week
-Stopped cycling
We didn’t really have much hope of things changing for us but we waited 6 months and had a few retests, which we just got the results for. We were intrigued by the posts on here about 3 hour abstinence and 24h abstinence, so we decided to experiment. We paid for a DNA fragmentation test after a short period of abstinence and one for after a day, with a few days in between each test.
In the week prior to the 3hr abstinence test we had had sex on 3 of the days (twice on one of these days) and obviously on the day of the test. So in the 7/8 days before the test we had had sex a total of 5 times.
In the week prior to the 24hr abstinence test we had had sex on 5 out of the 7/8 days, but twice on 3 of the days. One of the days was the day he did the 3hr abstinence test, so a total of 9 ejaculations in the week or so prior to the test.
Results:
3hr abstinence- 33% fragmentation
24hr abstinence- 20% fragmentation!!!
We did the Comet test which says that 0-26% is fertile. We are over the moon. We have been TTC for 6 months now (since the lifestyle changes and first result) and still not pregnant, but this gives us hope.
One thing we really struggled with was finding information out there where there was a fragmentation result as high as ours, coupled with a successful ending. Hopefully this will bring hope to others out there in a similar situation to us.
I just wanted to drop by this forum that has helped me so much, to share my positive results in case they can help to anyone else. I have been there, and i would have appreciated some optimism by the time :)
Some data about me: I am a 36 yo man, 1.86 and 98 kg that was tested with a high double strand damage fragmentation as the root cause of our infertility by a fertility clinic in Spain. This was diagnosed after having a COMET test.
We had 5 miscarriages in 2 years, all of them in around the 5th week, and doctors were not able to identify the root cause until I had my COMET test. The result was that the single Strand breaks were fine, but the double strand breaks too high. Therefore, they suggested to us to think about ICSI and FERTILE treatment.
The fact that I have a 4yo child naturally conceived, made me think that the fragmentation was an environmental factor caused by something. Therefore I started to read literature and this is what i found:
- Some studies reveal caffeine has a dramatic effect in DNA fragmentation, and despite I don´´'t take any coffee, i used to drink around 1-3 daily cans of Coke Zero.
At the light of those studies, i stopped to drink any Coke.
- Again, some literature suggest that sitting in the office for long periods could entail high fragmentation rates. Something related to heat in the testicles. As i work around 8-9 hours daily in an office, i just had a short walk 5-10 min for every hour sitting.
- Also, i was told that Oxidation played a major role so I increased the amount of fruit I ate. Specially, orange, Kiwi, strawberries and raspberry.
- At the same time, I tried to reduced my stress at work and do some exercise. I was not doing any exercise at all before.
After 3 months implementing this changes to my routine, I performed another fragmentation test with another clinic. This time, they told me that fragmentation levels were perfectly normal. Only oxidation was a little bit high. Still I continued with my routine.
5 Months after implementing this new habits, we managed to get a pregnancy and so far doctors say to us that everything is evolving perfectly.
I’ve been explaining PGS to people for a long time - there are many reasons it’s not accurate. The biggest problem is a diagnostic tests needs positive predictive value which PGS doesn’t have because positive predictive value of a test needs to come from live birth data. Re biopsy studies are not the same thing at all as live birth data since not every cell is examined. 2% of all placentas have abnormal trisomy / monosomy cells as well and need at the very least 4 biopsies to even catch it. This means that some still miss it because some biopsies may only have 1/4 quadrants affected so it’s likely more common than what’s being biopsied anyway.
Abnormal cells during early embryo development are common and is a normal process.
PPV of PGS with regards to mosaic embryos is 0% so 100% of reports of mosaic embryos have been pointless and do not lead to adverse outcomes. This is an interesting study from Johns Hopkins.
—- 80% of all embryos on day 5 are actually mosaic according to new John Hopkins study that actually performs Genome sequencing on every cell in the embryo versus just random biopsies which is what is usually done (a 5 day biopsy of 5-6 cells). Mosacism in embryos from mitosis errors are normal and functional correction mechanisms in both humans and embryos.
“Euploid” Embryo only means 6 cells were normal and doesn’t say anything about the other cells. Then they either correct or not.
“Mosaic Embryo just means some cells were normal some were not”
“Aneuploid Embryo” means all 6 cells were abnormal but can also be mosaic which is why transfer of abnormal embryos still results in live births after correction mechanisms
http://m.genome.cshlp.org/content/early/2020/07/02/gr.262774.120.abstract “Abstract Less than half of human zygotes survive to birth, primarily due to aneuploidies of meiotic or mitotic origin. Mitotic errors generate chromosomal mosaicism, defined by multiple cell lineages with distinct chromosome complements. The incidence and impacts of mosaicism in human embryos remain controversial, with most previous studies based on bulk DNA assays or comparisons of multiple biopsies of few embryonic cells. Single-cell genomic data provide an opportunity to quantify mosaicism on an embryo-wide scale. To this end, we extended an approach to infer aneuploidies based on dosage-associated changes in gene expression by integrating signatures of allelic imbalance. We applied this method to published single-cell RNA sequencing data from 74 human embryos, spanning the morula to blastocyst stages. Our analysis revealed widespread mosaic aneuploidies, with 59 of 74 (80%) embryos harboring at least one putative aneuploid cell (1% FDR). By clustering copy number calls, we reconstructed histories of chromosome segregation, inferring that 55 (74%) embryos possessed mitotic aneuploidies and 23 (31%) embryos possessed meiotic aneuploidies. We found no significant enrichment of aneuploid cells in the trophectoderm compared to the inner cell mass, although we do detect such enrichment in data from later postimplantation stages. Finally, we observed that aneuploid cells up-regulate immune response genes and down-regulate genes involved in proliferation, metabolism, and protein processing, consistent with stress responses documented in other stages and systems. Together, our work provides a high-resolution view of aneuploidy in preimplantation embryos, and supports the conclusion that low-level mosaicism is a common feature of early human development”
Hi Everyone, I wanted to post in this community because I often see so many great tips and stories that helped me along my journey. Especially at times when I thought all hope was lost - this community gave me some great suggestions - not all worked but enough to keep me going. Wanted to post an update to whoever it may help out there. Here is my journey and its not over yet....
First cycle at 38, old clinic where RE could only access one ovary (right ovary was "inaccessible" because it was behind the uterus) 9 egg retrieved, 9 mature, 4 fertilized, 0 zero blasts.
Second cycle at 39, we discovered my husband had DNA frag (24%) and very low count, motility and morphology but our doctor insisted that PICSI would fix the problem so we went into cycle 2. Only 1 ovary was accessed 10 eggs, 8 mature, 6 fertilized and 2 Day 7 embryos, zero normal.
Third cycle, switched clinics to CCRM (which added HGH - omnitrope), 13 eggs retrieved, zero fertilized. Yup you heard it here - ZERO fertilization. We were shocked and CCRM suggested that we get a sperm donor because our sperm was low binding.
We decided to take some measures to address Sperm DNA fragmentation, including husband getting varicocele surgery. We also started shorter abstinence windows where my husband would “clear the pipes” every day over the course of a couple months. husbands sperm improved significantly within 4 months. Count and motility tripled, and DNA frag came back at 12 %. We decided to do one more round using husband sperm before giving up. For the egg retrieval day, we moved to a shorter abstinence of 12 hours based on recent studies showing lower dna fragmentation. Fourth and final round at 39, 16 retrieved (HGH omnitrope), 15 mature, 8 fertilized and we got 4 embryos. 3 were biopsied and 2 came back normal!!
I know the journey is not over, but I wanted to post this in case it helped someone out there. Please take sperm issues seriously, so many times on here I've seen women blame egg quality and little attention is given to sperm. Push for more testing early on is the advice I would have given myself. Good luck!
This study is done in patients with solely high dna frag issue which is big! Since men with Normal dna frag density gradient does fine and Zymot isn’t really needed. Howver, my question was very specific - will Zymot increase pregnancy rates vs DGD sorting. By this study alone the answer is yes. Unfortunately there aren’t any other ongoing study’s other than Pelermo that I know if that’s looking into high dna frag and microfluidics specifically.
Interesting data that yes implantation is really low with high dna frag and the even the euploid embryo miscarries with regular sorting for ICSI in their trial which was PGS normal. Overall, I like this study from briefly looking at it. I still think Zymot is probably not the best for very high dna frag cases over 40% for sure go have a TESE instead which is proven to increase pregnancy rates and decrease miscarriage rates. But. This is great since it was done with patients whose dna frag is 20-30ish% which is very common.
Just a reminder - got get your dna frag and oxidative stress levels checked people!
Objective
To test a novel method to select spermatozoa with high chromatin integrity.
Design
Specimens with high sperm chromatin fragmentation (SCF) were selected by density gradient selection (DGS) and microfluidic sperm sorting (MSS).
Setting
Academic medical center.
Patient(s)
Ejaculates from consenting men were processed by DGS/MSS. Couples underwent ICSI cycles with spermatozoa processed by DGS/MSS. Clinical outcomes were evaluated after embryo transfer.
Intervention(s)
SCF was measured by TUNEL. ICSI with spermatozoa selected by DGS and MSS was performed.
Main outcome measure(s)
Fertilization, embryo implantation, and pregnancy outcomes were compared between DGS and MSS.
Result(s)
A total of 23 men had an average SCF of 20.7 ± 10%. After DGS and MSS, the SCF was 12.5 ± 5% and 1.8 ± 1%, respectively. In couples who underwent ICSI, the average SCF was 28.8 ± 9%, which fell to 21.0 ± 9% after DGS and 1.3 ± 0.7% after MSS. Four couples underwent 11 ICSI cycles with DGS and achieved one (25%) pregnancy that resulted in pregnancy loss. In four subsequent ICSI cycles with MSS, an ongoing clinical pregnancy rate of 50% was achieved. Five additional couples underwent 12 cycles of ICSI with DGS. After preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy, 30.3% of the embryos were euploid. One pregnancy was achieved, resulting in pregnancy loss. With MSS, 31.5% of the embryos were euploid and 4 couples obtained a pregnancy. Finally, sixteen couples underwent 20 ICSI cycles solely with MSS at our center. Of these couples, 8 had failed 13 ICSI cycles with DGS elsewhere. These couples achieved an overall implantation of 34.5% (10/29) and a pregnancy rate of 58.8% (10/17).
Conclusion(s)
Microfluidic selection yielded spermatozoa with optimal genomic integrity and improved chances of obtaining a euploid conceptus.
I have been hesitating to write this post for sometime, but I have promised myself that with a positive outcome and god's will to have everything work out, I would write it as a reminder of hope to fellow men and women in this subreddit.
I apologize for the long post in advance, but I hope you take this as me getting something off my chest.
My wife and I have been married for 4 years, with the exception of the first year due to her being focused on her Masters and I'm starting a prominent career, we have been very eager to have a baby! We are young, were healthy to that point to a large extent, even she was on her to the Olympics a couple of years before our marriage.
The story begins with my wife finishing her master's panel and we decided that we want to start trying having a baby. We tried and then surprisingly, the first month of doing so, she was pregnant! We were excited, happy, and relieved, we thought that the scary part was over.... but it wasn't. We went in to confirm the pregnancy through a blood hcg test and we got a positive, then we started going to a family's OBG and he recommended to do a quantitative hcg test twice with 48 hours in between and come back with the numbers. The first was 104 and the second came back 145. This number was worrying, as we have read during the 48 hours that the number should ideally double, more or less. We went through a very scary day or two, until bleeding started.... Confused and scared we lived through one of my worst memories to date. We went after a week for a 3rd test, and the number more than doubled! We were back to excitement as that was an indication to things being normal. Little did we know that the bleeding would start again.... It was inevitable at this point, and going in for an emergency ultrasound, we were given the news that she should be around 6 weeks pregnant, while the baby sac is empty and would've been normal only if she was around 4 weeks pregnant. Reality started to sink in and she was scheduled for a dnc the following day. We lived through depression largely for a couple of months, my wife even travelled to Australia to visit her family in order to try and get some of that distance from the painful incident. We simply were introduced to the harsh reality of miscarriages that for some reason, no one really talks about.
Fast forward 3 months, we are just back from Dubai and she was pregnant again! (We never stopped trying in this whole story and I have to give very high credit to my wife.) Only this time, we were cautious. We went in for the hcg quantitative test right away before even seeing the OBG, the first came 100, and the second came back a 50. At that point, the biggest shock wasn't the miscarriage itself, despite that being so painful to go through again (only it was called a Chemical pregnancy by the doctor this time) the biggest realization was "Are we bound to have this happen over and over?" we read that the more miscarriages you have the less chance you have for a pregnancy. Around that time was when Corona hit massively and lockdowns started to take place. Depression went back into the house with an added lockdown for a very grim period of time. My wife before that pregnancy had made all possible tests to ensure that everything was ok and the response we always got was "we were just unlucky and it happens" a couple of weeks passby and I wake up to the though of "If she did all the tests, why am I assuming that I'm fine?" And so I scheduled with an Andrologist, gave him all the history and he recommended A LOT of tests! (I believe tests cost around 700$ in total! Crazy, but any DNA related tests were just really expensive) Anyway, everything came back normal apart from Testosterone being a little low (which he regarded as no problem as long as I'm not feeling anything odd) Semen analysis were exceptionally good! But there was this little line "DNA Fragmentation" and it read 32%... I tried to look for reference, but there was none and I had to wait to know any information regarding that. We scoured the internet trying to find any info. and we came to the realization that this number is extremely high. My wife was actually the one that stumbled upon this subreddit and suggested that I give it a read, and we had nothing in mind after a while here but IVF and all the alternatives as everything seemed grim for a natural conception.
I was able to go to the dr. again after 3 weeks and he was surprisingly calm about this whole issue and didn't even want to talk about any form of IVF or so, he wrote some medications for 3 months as follows:Thioctic Acid 600mg (once in the morning)Kitotifin 1mg (once before sleep)Pentoxifylline 400mg (Once in the morning and once in the evening)Epifassi 5000iu amp. (twice a week)Devarol S amp. (once a month)Neruobion amp. IM (twice a week)
I asked the doctor if we should hold off trying until the medicine course is done, and he said no while also recommending more frequent sex (3 times a week at least)
I kept on these medicines for the first month with a bit of hope and still the IVF route was the center of our our talk. During the beginning of the second month, my wife came across a topic called "3 hours method" so we decided, why not? So 2nd month of the treatment as soon as the window began, we tried every other day, and on the day we tried I basically ejaculated around 1-3 hours before the intended intercourse.
There wasn't really much to feel then, but the only thing I remember was that one of our best friends were having a baby (She was pregnant on the same week my wife got pregnant the first time, the only difference is that my wife miscarried) And the only thing I remember was going to to the hospital for their delivery and seeing my wife genuinely happy for them, she was excited and she kept by her side for every moment.... That scene broke me into pieces. I just couldn't even fathom the courage and will my wife had going through that experience, but she was VERY emotional and happy for them! Our best friends had their baby and it changed our lives. the next day I had a dentist's appointment and my wife came along, and out of nowhere she started giving the dentist a very rough talk on how he's careless with his time management as he took more than double the time he intended for a lab mistake in my crowns. Going home, I was surprised and was telling her that she were very inappropriate, but we blamed it on her upcoming period.
One day later, I get up to go to work, and I find my wife running at me "I'm pregnant!" all excited, and again a second scene that broke my heart based on previous history. But this time I was excited as well, I told her to go to the hospital to get the hcg test done, while I go to work. She went in and the number came back 600. We called the OBG and he told us to call him after 2 days with the repeat test results. We did and I couldn't believe the lab when they said "Yeah the test is out, it's at 1,900, almost triple!" This was it! we beat the scary number that haunted us for the past 2 pregnancies, and from then onwards every test was as scary, including a test that was swapped by mistake that showed my wife was sensitized! (that gave us a day of hell, yet were surprisingly calm)
2 days after the heartbreak of seeing my wife being happy for our friends' having a baby while knowing that she is more than torn inside, we found out that we had a baby. Fast forward 1 year, and we have a healthy 4 months old baby boy! I cannot really pinpoint the reason to anything as I truly believe that was nothing but god's will, but I went through painful injections multiple times every week for months, we went through heartbreak and depression and my wife went through the scare of this whole experience, yet it still happened! I would definitely recommend the 3 hour method, while recommending to try and adjust your lifestyle as well as get on medications that your doctor would prescribe, and all is left to do is pray. 32.5% was just a number, a lot of factors made us believe it was impossible, but it was.
Her running towards me as I was about to leave to work with "I'm pregnant!" will forever be engraved in my memory, and that was the only image I saw in my head whenever I was worried through this pregnancy.
I apologize again for this long post, and I sure hope it doesn't come off as anything but a positive story for other people. I want to truly thank brave people on this subreddit as some of the stories, the information and the posts in general either gave us ideas, information, or more importantly, assurance! We hope that everything works out in the end for each and everyone as it did.
Here is research that may help others with severe male factor infertility with increasing their chances of having a healthy live birth. They claim to not be certain about why short abstinence windows result in better quality sperm, but I think they are suspecting a decrease in the DNA frag, as all of us already suspect.
For obvious reasons denaturing or damaging sperm on purpose in humans isn’t possible, but we see impacts of this best studies in animal studies.
This below has some good explanations. It’s sad this info has been available for 15-20 years and clinicians are still so behind In Understanding how sperm is vital to embryo development and that getting just an SA alone really doesn’t guarantee any fertility. Maybe one day they’ll stop blaming eggs on everything especially when it’s clear males have issues in any of the sperm parameters or dna frag/ oxidative stress / sperm aneuploidy etc.
Impacts of sperm damaged by oxidative stress on embryonic development There is no doubt that damage in the sperm can impair fertility and disrupt embryo development (Fig. 2). High levels of oxidative stress induce sperm plasma membrane alterations and hamper motility with the consequence of failure of fertilization. However, at lower levels of ROS, sperm may retain their ability to fertilize oocytes (Aitken and Baker, 2006). Through fertilization, not only the haploid paternal genome is transferred into the oocyte, but the entire content of the sperm, which may contain damaged molecules or toxic metabolites. Much of the content is disassembled, as it is not required for development (Cummins, 2001; Krawetz, 2005). Sperm mitochondria, for example, are degraded by the ubiquitination system (St John et al., 2000). However, other components of paternal origin are stable and have been followed until much later in embryonic development, including DNA, centrioles, some transcription factors, signalling molecules, and even ribonucleic acid (RNA) (Shalgi et al., 1994). Consequences of oxidative damage of paternal-derived molecules are extensively described for DNA. Effects of oxidative modifications in paternally derived centrioles or cytoplasmic factors on embryonic development have not been investigated. However, errors in microtubule assembly resulted in human fertilization failure and may contribute to a form of male infertility (Asch et al., 1995; Cummins, 2001). Several studies investigated developmental consequences of sperm DNA damage induced by oxidative stress. Aitken and Baker (2006) demonstrated that exposure of sperm to low levels of hydrogen peroxide only marginally affected oocyte-sperm fusion, despite causing substantial DNA damage in sperm (Aitken and Baker, 2006). Thus using oxidatively damaged sperm for embryo production can lead to numerous developmental abnormalities. Low levels of pro-oxidants in bovine sperm cells had negative effects on blastocyst formation, but not on cleavage. Exposure of sperm to more severe oxidative stress reduced the blastocyst rate, cleavage rate and embryo quality (Silva, 2007; de Assis et al., 2015; De Castro et al., 2016). Simões et al. (2013) classified semen samples according to their sensitivity to OS and reported that increased susceptibility of sperm to OS compromised sperm DNA integrity and consequently reduced embryo quality.
Bollwein and Bittner. Impacts of oxidative stress on sperm and embryos. In addition to negative effects on pre- implantation development, it is widely accepted that damaged sperm can support embryo development, implantation, and even pregnancy up to term, although development may be severely impaired. To the best of our knowledge, there are no reports in cattle on this topic. In mice, following IVF of mice using hydrogen peroxide damaged sperm, embryos developed, but were less likely to implant, were lighter, had a smaller crown- rump length, and female fetuses had metabolic abnormalities (Lane et al., 2014). In human assisted reproduction, fertilization with oxidatively damaged sperm, especially in regard to DNA damage, has been associated with loss of pregnancy or diseases in the offspring (Gavriliouk and Aitken, 2015). As sperm cannot repair their genome before fertilization, DNA repair in newly fertilized embryos relies entirely on messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) and proteins stored in the oocyte (Ashwood-Smith and Edwards, 1996). It is suggested that a newly fertilized oocyte can cope with at least 10% of sperm DNA damage. This was derived from a study on trout, in which sperm with more than 10% tail DNA (based on a COMET assay) produced embryos, suggesting damage was either repaired or tolerated (Pérez-Cerezales et al., 2010). Over 150 DNA repair genes have been identified in humans (reviewed by Jaroudi and SenGupta, 2007). Most belong to one of the four main DNA damage signaling and repair pathways: nucleotide excision repair, base excision repair, mismatch repair, and DNA double strand break repair. One of the earliest steps for DNA double-strand break repair is phosphorylation of the histone H2AX, referred to as gammaH2AX, which recruits DNA repair proteins (Celeste et al., 2003). Many DNA repair pathways are already active in early developmental stages. DNA damage repair pathways during early development interact with cell cycle progression. A cell with a damaged genome has three choices; remove the lesion, survive despite the lesion (with potential functional consequences), or undergo cell death. The importance of these repair mechanisms has been demonstrated by Barton (2007), who has used damaged sperm for fertilization or blocked DNA repair pathways in the zygote. When male rats were treated with cyclophosphamide, known to induce DNA damage, zygotes had enhanced gammaH2AX staining in the male pronucleus, compared to the control. In addition, Poly (ADP-Ribose) polymerase 1 (an enzyme which mediates DNA single-strand break repair in the base excision repair pathway) was upregulated in both pronuclei after fertilization with damaged sperm (Barton, 2007). Rahman et al. (2012) studied the influence of oocyte quality on embryo production with damaged sperm in cattle and reported that bovine oocytes with a larger diameter were able to support embryo development after fertilization of sperm incubated in media with hydrogen peroxide better than their smaller counterparts. However, factors other than oocyte size can also influence oocytes repair capacity. Conclusions Bovine sperm are exposed to OS under different conditions, causing damage to various cell structures. In particular, damage to sperm DNA can affect embryo development and increase embryo mortality. Whether disturbances of embryo development affect postnatal health of cattle, documented for other species, has apparently not been reported. It is well established that exogenous antioxidants can reduce negative effects of oxidative stress on sperm function and embryo development. However, there is still a knowledge gap regarding how oxidative stress can be avoided without inhibiting essential physiological effects of reactive species on fertilization.
Hi everyone. I'm hoping reading about my experiences might be beneficial for those of you who are still struggling. I have a bit of a longish history but I'll try to make this brief without too many unnecessary and boring details.
My husband and I started trying for a baby when I was about 26 years old. We gave it the recommended year but when nothing happened I spoke to my gynecologist who told us to give it a little bit more time. Still nothing. Had the usual type of tests (HSG, blood work) everything was normal with me. My husband had a semen analysis some time after which showed a shockingly low count. Every semen analysis he's had shows he makes about one million sperm per day. So if he abstained for three days, he would have about three million sperm. A more detailed analysis with a reproductive endocrinologist would show normal parameters (motility, morphology, etc) but the count was always very, very low. He had one DNA frag test which showed moderate amount of 13%.
Fast forward a couple years and we go to an IVF clinic, specifically CNY Fertility. I was 29, almost 30 years old during our first retrieval. We had 16 eggs retrieved, 8 of which became blastocysts; Three day five blasts, four day six blasts. All but two of those blastocysts would fail to implant, and the ones that did implant I miscarried at seven weeks, though they had stopped developing around 5w5d.
Round two of IVF: 23 eggs retrieved. All 11 which were fertilized with ICSI arrested around day three. This was a huge shock and I was absolutely heartbroken. Our RE put my husband on clomid and hcg and recommended, like I had seen on this sub before, a sperm extraction because the quality was so poor. It was either that or donor sperm.
Round three of IVF: By then I was having serious doubts that any form of ART would work for us. I was 31 and just wanted this awful ride on the infertility roller coaster to be over. Went in with serious doubts. My husband had his TESA four months after being on HCG and clomid. Those medications didn't end up raising his count even though his testosterone improved quite a bit. I think that the meds may have helped with the quality of his sperm, but who knows. It took two tries with the spring loaded syringe to get sperm or enough sperm. I had 23 eggs retrieved again, but this time only had nine that were mature (I had a few that grew way faster than the others). Eight of those nine were fertilized with ICSI. We decided to do a fresh transfer, which I had never done before. On day three I had two embryos put in, and the rest were frozen.
I am currently 12w5d pregnant with twins. They've had good growth and heartbeats so far. When I last saw them at exactly 12 weeks they were still doing well. Everyday I worry, but I suppose I will keep worrying for the rest of my life.
We don't know why my husband has such low sperm count. His (really wonderful urologist) ruled out things like varicocele, undescended testicle and Klinefelter syndrome. We would have to do a karyotype to get more answers, but couldn't get it covered by insurance, and the doc didn't see the point if we were doing the TESA/ICSI anyway.
It was a really bumpy road, but I'm still standing, though I'm not sure if I would be if I wasn't currently pregnant to be honest. I like to think I would be. If I can get through it, I really think anyone can. The information and support from people like u/chulzle was incredibly helpful and important to me when I was so confused and so hurt. I am so grateful for the research and support.
Please feel free to ask me any questions at all. I am happy to answer them.
PS: If you are located anywhere near Syracuse, NY I highly recommend Dr. Trussel at Upstate Urology if you're looking for a Urologist. I wish we had seen him years earlier.
*Sorry this was so long.
TL;DR: Three rounds of IVF. TESA made this pregnancy possible. If your partner has severe oligospermia insist on a TESA. It would have saved us a lot of money and heartache if we had done it the first time around.
Research indeed shows that paternal factors—including sperm quality, diet, environmental exposures, and epigenetic marks—can increase the risk of neural tube defects (NTDs) in mouse offspring. However, mainstream narratives often focus on maternal causes like folate deficiency, which can obscure paternal contributions. Here’s an overview:
⸻
Paternal Genetic Variants Impact NTD Risk • A human/mouse study linked a paternal variant in the folate‐metabolizing gene MTHFD1 G1958A to significantly increased risk of anencephaly and spina bifida — pointing to fathers not just mothers in folate-related defects  .
⸻
2. Paternal Diet Alters Sperm Epigenetics & Offspring Defects • Mice fed a folate-deficient paternal diet before mating sired offspring with more birth defects—including craniofacial and musculoskeletal malformations—and increased pregnancy loss. These effects corresponded with changes in sperm DNA methylation and histone marks . • In another study, fathers given methotrexate (a folate antagonist) transmitted altered sperm small RNAs to embryos, which, when injected, caused cranial cartilage abnormalities in offspring .
⸻
3. Environmental Toxicants and Epigenetic Placental Effects • Paternal exposure to TCDD (dioxin) in mice led to epigenetic modifications in sperm and subsequent placental dysfunction—though not necessarily NTD per se, it demonstrates paternal influence on development via sperm-transmitted epigenetic changes . • A bioRxiv preprint found paternal DDT exposure reprogrammed the sperm of mice and altered placental growth in offspring .
⸻
4. Mouse Neural Tube Defect Models Often Overlook Paternal Effects • Most mouse NTD studies investigate maternal folate deficiency or genetic pathways (e.g., maternal folate, VANGL1 mutations) . • Yet paternal effects clearly exist, particularly via sperm epigenetics, but are less emphasized in mainstream discussions.
📌 Mainstream Bias Toward Female Causes • Studies primarily emphasize maternal factors like folate deficiency, diabetes, obesity, or environmental exposures . • Paternal effects—while scientifically validated—are often underreported or overlooked in public discourse and clinical guidance.
⸻
🔭 Moving Forward • More research is needed on paternal causes of NTDs, especially how sperm epigenetic and RNA changes contribute to neural defects. • Clinical awareness should expand to include male preconception health—like folate intake, exposure to toxins, and lifestyle—to mitigate developmental risks.
⸻
In summary, there’s strong evidence from mouse models that paternal influences can contribute to NTDs, yet public and clinical focus remains heavily skewed toward mothers. Recognizing and investigating paternal roles could improve prevention strategies and understanding of embryonic development.
I’m sure the science will catch up in 20 years to what I said 6 years ago when I kept having miscarriages due to male factor and also Anencephaly. It came from male contribution, not me. I don’t have health issues and I took prenatal and folate. The sperm caused all the issues including neural tube defects and anyone who is a younger female should pay attention to these factors and look at your partner.
In fact, there has been NOTHING I have ever said online that didn’t even up being proven true 5-10 years later. I understand science and prejudice. When there is no interest in either, you and up looking at the wrong part of infertility or developmental issues.