r/distributism • • Oct 21 '18

Albia. An r/200acres community proposal

0 Upvotes

Hello r/distributism. I wanted to share my permaculture community idea. I'm hoping that it will also have some distributionist values built into the project. I'm new to this sub but look forward to learning from you and more about distributism.

Here is the most current draft of the project.

https://imgur.com/a/6A52ByG

And here is a thread where the project is flushed out in more detail.

https://old.reddit.com/r/200acres/comments/9lxr6n/albia_a_200_acres_community_proposal_original/

Let me know what you think!


r/distributism • • Aug 06 '20

Dear Enlightenment Liberals

0 Upvotes

So you want to forcibly take land from hard working land owners such as myself and REDISTRIBUTE it to the common people? That sounds just like Socialism. I don’t see any difference at all between Liberalism and Socialism.

Besides, Liberalism would never work in Catholic countries since Liberalism is an inherently Protestant ideology.

And where exactly has Liberalism ever been tried? Liberalism has never been tried so there’s no point in trying to implement it.


r/distributism • • Feb 22 '16

Vote CNP in the Model House of Commons Election

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am from a rather odd and unique community called the Reddit Model House of Commons(/r/MHOC). Among this community there are several parties, of which I am the leader of the Crown National Party. We are the only party currently that has made an open effort to integrate Distributism, Monarchism, and 'soft' Nationalism with our policies. We desperately need your support, as we are the underdogs against the larger Left-Wing consensus. So we appeal to you to help us, to vote for us in this General Election. If you choose to support us, we are standing in

  • Central Scotland

  • Hampshire, Surrey, and West Sussex

Please, we want to bring a new Distributist Force on /r/MHOC, but in order to do that we need your help

VOTE HERE!

Manifesto


r/distributism • • Apr 02 '24

I'm 17, wanting to debate a teacher over Capitalism and what the US has done, but I really don't even know anything

1 Upvotes

(Originally posted to r/TheDeprogram)

So this teacher, he is an econometrics major who is teaching me macroeconomics. He is pretty alright, but he seems to put down socialism and communism. Honestly, I did not care about econ before taking his class, but when he mentioned that communism and socialism don't work because countries who adopt it either don't work or become capitalist, or because the pareto principle states that it doesn't work, it made me want to look into these ideas and look into these two econ ideologies.

So, I have looked into communism, socialism, and actually, a bonus: Distributism. I know that not everyone here is Catholic of course, some are Arab Islamic, atheist, etc, but i think that I align myself most with this particular ideology. I got convinced to believe in a free market, libertarian (in the sense that the state should be as small as possible) form of distributism, and I believe that private property should be allowed, since the church believes that the right exists. I template-copied someone, basically.

Though, I also have Anti American thoughts, and this mainly stems from anti communist coups that I know about (very vaguely) that happened in Cuba. I also have knowledge on the United Fruit Company that basically took of Guatemala. I saw a video over it all, and it genuinely made me cry a little. I really hated the us for doing this to my Hispanic brethren, as a Mexican.

Though, I feel like I can really say much to refute this guys views. I'm not an econometrics major. I barely know stuff about communism, distributism and socialism, but I really want to tell him that he isn't right, these ideologies aren't perfect, but that capitalism has people that suffer immensely because of it. I'm quite pro Russia and Palestine. I have a class that would hear me debate him, but I am worried I will sound incompetent in a debate with him. I really don't want to be called a commie, but I want to stand for what is right. I also don't know what I would say to if he said "well, the USSR fell, and the vast majority of people want to leave cuba". I really don't know what I would refute back. If anyone could help me out with my situation, it would be of immense help. Have a good day!


r/distributism • • Dec 25 '19

Are there any socially liberal/libertarian distributists?

1 Upvotes

So I've been interested in economic distributism for a while now, but I'm a moderate Protestant. So I don't share the anti-feminism, anti-LGBT, anti-sex views of most of the Catholic distributists. Am I alone in this? Socially, I'm extremely libertarian. About the only thing not libertarian about me, is I oppose abortion on the grounds of the consistent life ethic.


r/distributism • • Jul 26 '21

Is distrbitism lead to or connected with socialism? If so wouldn’t that make it condemned?

Thumbnail self.truecatholicpolitics
2 Upvotes

r/distributism • • Feb 27 '24

Will the capitalist class be supported under distributism? [Question from socialist]

2 Upvotes

Capitalists are people who 'earn' money from investing (stealing value from others), while workers earn money from their labour.


r/distributism • • Jun 18 '23

Could there be Communist Distributism?

2 Upvotes

I saw an image of the hound in what struck me as communist red and it got me thinking.

Would a system with a 100% death tax and government distribution of the capital necessary to live and work to individuals, once they finish their education/ apprenticeships and move out from under their parents, that they would then own untill their death, be called Communist Distributism?

I am not saying this would be a good system or that it is in any way the ideal way to implement Distributism.

I am asking would that be a valid lable for such a system.


r/distributism • • Apr 26 '20

How to Spread Distributism

0 Upvotes

Every night ask yourself “What have I done for Distributism” if your answer is “nothing” then be ashamed.


r/distributism • • Mar 22 '21

New Distributist nation in the US

2 Upvotes

I an creating a new monarcho-Distributist society in the midwest US through dual power. We are currently in the planning stages so anyone interested can join via discord https://discord.gg/pPbHUKka


r/distributism • • Aug 03 '22

Top 10 list!

1 Upvotes

Top 10 countries ranked by how friendly they are to distributism, go!


r/distributism • • Dec 20 '24

Marxist Distributism? Is it possible?

5 Upvotes

I've been reflecting on the ideas of communism and distributism and wondering if there is room for synthesis between the two. For clarity, when I say "communism," I'm referring specifically to left-communism, and not the state socialism most lolberts and distributists usually seem to think about.

Left-communism is a branch of communist thought that critiques both capitalist structures and the more centralized, party-led approaches of Marxism-Leninism. It champions worker self-management, decentralized decision-making, and the abolition of hierarchical state power. Instead of relying on a vanguard party or a transitional "state socialism," left-communists advocate for a direct transition to a stateless, classless society through the self-organization of the proletariat. Central to its vision are workers' councils and a global, collective restructuring of production to meet human needs rather than generate profit.

Distributism, on the other hand, proposes a decentralized economy where ownership of productive property (like land, tools, and businesses) is widely distributed among individuals and families. It critiques both capitalism and state socialism, aiming for a middle ground where economic power is neither concentrated in corporations nor the state.

At first glance, these ideologies might seem incompatible: communism seeks the abolition of private property, while distributism emphasizes its wide distribution. However, both share a disdain for centralized control and aim to empower people within their communities. Could there be a synthesis that aligns the communal focus of communism with distributism's emphasis on decentralized ownership?

For example, could we envision a society where productive property is communally managed at the local level, blending the distributist ideal of localized control with the communist principle of collective ownership?

I also think this synthesis could work towards a more viable and actually-existing form of communism. After all, we already know about primal communism in human history, and we’re aware that proto-capitalism stretches far back as well. Why not imagine the natural end-result as a synthesis of Marxism and distributism? Could such a blending provide the practical framework needed to realize a modern, sustainable communism?

For instance, could productive property be communally owned but locally managed, combining distributism’s emphasis on decentralization with communism’s commitment to collective ownership? Could this balance create a society that fosters both autonomy and cooperation, aligning with Marxist ideals while addressing the challenges of scale and sustainability?

Or are the premises of these systems irreconcilable? I’d love to hear your thoughts on this—can these ideas come together to refine communism into something more resilient and grounded, or do they ultimately lead in opposite directions?


r/distributism • • Apr 22 '20

Soo...what separates you from, say democratic socialism?

6 Upvotes

r/distributism • • Nov 23 '21

We need a new name

3 Upvotes

Honestly, the term Distributism is too confusing, awkward and points to something ng different than what it represents.

Weneed a new term that captures the beliefs better and sounds better to the world.


r/distributism • • Feb 26 '25

YOUNG DISTRIBUTISTS: would you like to see a parallel world in which the GOP represents a classical, Distributist, pragmatic brand of economic Liberalism, speaking both to the many voters tired of Neoliberal Corporatism as well as the growing number of Distributists of a Catholic perspective?

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/distributism • • Sep 14 '21

Small-scale production only in small town with less 100 people

2 Upvotes

Distributism is based in small-scale production. But this would work only in small towns. But how the small-scale production would feed a city with 100,000 people? To feed the population of a city, is necessary to produce in large scale or there will shortage and hunger.


r/distributism • • Nov 10 '24

I’ve always liked to think of myself as a Marxist-Distributist, with a little Market Socialist mixed in.

7 Upvotes

As a Marxist Distributist, I believe limited market socialism offers the best way to combine the ideals of social justice and widespread ownership. By fostering worker cooperatives, small family businesses, and individually owned enterprises, we can prevent wealth from concentrating in the hands of a few, while empowering people to take ownership of their labor. Markets can serve a role here, offering room for competition and innovation on a smaller scale, but they must be carefully regulated to avoid monopolies and prevent exploitation. For larger, essential industries, I believe in collective or municipal ownership so that these resources are accountable to the public rather than to private interests.

Limited market socialism, for me, isn’t the end goal; it’s a stepping stone toward a society that values cooperation over profit and social welfare over individual gain. By implementing wealth taxes, profit-sharing, and fair wages, we can dismantle exploitation and create a system that rewards labor fairly. I envision this evolving into a cooperative economy that embodies both local autonomy and mutual aid, a society where resources are distributed equitably, and people feel a real stake in their work and their communities. This approach, I believe, perfectly combines the Distributist respect for personal property with the Marxist dedication to social ownership and class equity, building a fairer, more humane world.


r/distributism • • Jul 18 '24

Where would Distributism end up on this political triangle?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/distributism • • Apr 27 '20

How would we form a coalition or alliance

1 Upvotes

So we’ve talked about forming a coalition/alliance with other movements and ideologies but what would such a coalition/alliance look like? How would we form it how and would it function?


r/distributism • • Oct 29 '15

Help?

1 Upvotes

I'm looking in a way to package a short definition and several helpful links about the idea of distributism. I'm planning on sending it to a comedian guy who does a lot of political satire but also has a pretty good podcast but he hits on some things that I think would tilt him to an interest in Distributism


r/distributism • • Mar 22 '22

The intersectionality of Libertarianism and Distributism.

3 Upvotes

I know that there is a lot of disagreement between libertarians and distributists, particularly when it comes to economics. But I know that there is a lot of agreement on some issues as well. Off the top of your head, what are some things that libertarians and distributists have in common?


r/distributism • • Nov 09 '19

Universal Basic Income

5 Upvotes

Distributists should support a Universal Basic Income because capital is one of the means of production that we need to make more distributed. A well done UBI will work as a safety net to allow people to build their own business. I call for

  1. The poverty level to be set after every census to the lowest amount at which a person can afford the basic amounts of clothing, food, healthcare, shelter, education and transportation needed to participate in society.

  2. The poverty level to be increased with inflation and decreased with deflation annually between censuses.

  3. The abolishment of all existing welfare programs (including corporate welfare), for social security programs to stop accepting new participants, and for the removal of minimum wage laws.

  4. The establishment a universal basic income of no less than the poverty level for every citizen (including children).

  5. Free relocation to fill demonstrated gaps in the workforce of rural communities.


r/distributism • • Mar 21 '22

Minimum Wage

5 Upvotes

I am researching a lot about distributism. Having been a libertarian for the vast majority of my life, I cannot seem to find a good argument for minimum wage. I have heard a few distributive arguments touch on it, but they haven't addressed the main issues which are:

  • Minimum wage laws are actually just laws forbidding employers from hiring anyone who won't provide enough value to the business for it to be worth it. This eliminates most opportunities for apprenticeship-like jobs where the worker is paid more in training and education that in coin and greatly hurts impoverished communities.

  • Without the ability to subsist off one's own land (which is doubtful that we'll ever return to) how could a minimum wage be set? It would make sense to set it to the approx minimum value a small family farm could produce, but how would we calculate that if that is not the current state of affairs?

  • Minimum wage laws promote automation. How would you stop people from being replaced if it is cheaper to get a machine to do the job for them? Is this a desirable outcome?


r/distributism • • Dec 11 '24

Big corporations are already publicly owned

0 Upvotes

So many people go on about the need for the workers to own the means of productions. But capitalist economies, such as the USA, are dominated by *public* corporations. The workers are already given the opportunity to own the means of production.


r/distributism • • Mar 07 '22

I’m very skeptical and very curious

8 Upvotes

I grew up as a neocon, I became a libertarian in college, and now I don’t know what I am.

During my libertarian stint in college I was exposed to the writing of Thomas Woods, who also brought me to traditional Catholicism. In my time in traditional Catholic circles I was exposed to distributism.

It sounds like a very utopian system that could only lead to tyranny, much like communism did. And Dustributist critiques of Capitalism feel very uninformed. Sure Capitalism isn’t perfect, but it seems foolish to throw the baby out with the bath water. And most of the time it feels like distributists aren’t critiquing Capitalism at all, but cronyism/corporatism. A system that involves political and business leaders working together.

It also seems that a distributist society would trample subsidiary the first chance it got despite all claims that it won’t.

I’ve also read plenty of thorough critiques of distributism from Austrian school adherents that make it very difficult for me to take the system seriously.

That being said it still interests me for some reason. So maybe you guys can prove me wrong.