r/discworld • • May 30 '26

Reading Order/Timeline Ban “Where should I start?” Posts?

6 Upvotes

Some days it seems like no one uses the search function and the sub is dominated by people asking where they should start their Discworld journey. While it’s absolutely an important question, how would it change the dynamic of the sub of these posts were banned and a sticky or FAQ created for the purpose?


r/discworld • • May 21 '26

Book/Series: City Watch Hang, Sam Vimes Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Reading Snuff for the nth time and had one of those STP revelations we love so much.

Toward the end, the goblin Stinky is saying his farewells to Vimes. It goes like this:

"Hang, Sam Vimes. Hang together or hang separately. Above all, hang on. Hang, Mr. Vimes.

Vimes sighed "I think it's quite likely that I might."

At first this reads like a throwaway line. Just Sam Vimes being Sam Vimes. Had Sybil been there she would have said "Oh, Sam" and swatted him playfully.

But then I got to thinking about the oft-foreshadowed, quite possibly inevitable, conflict between Vimes and Carrot. A very foreseeable result of this conflict would be Carrot executing Sam Vimes, and Sam Vimes voluntarily submitting himself to the law a la Socrates.

It'd be dark, but STP didn't shy away from darkness when he felt it necessary. Imagine Vimes committing some act that was criminal but also the "right" thing to do at the time. Like if something had happened to Sybil or Sam Jr. and the Summoning Dark broke through, just for a moment. You can see Sam finally snapping, but you can also see Sam insisting that he face justice for snapping. Or perhaps Sam takes out Vetinari (it runs in the family), who has finally taken realpolitik too far, and then King Carrot is on the throne . . .

You could even see Sam Vimes insisting that Carrot execute him, as the law requires. Sam would force Carrot to issue the verdict. Carrot would have tears in his eyes, but he'd do the just thing and send Sam to Mr. Trooper's warm embrace.

Obviously I have no idea if this was where STP was going with the Vimes & Carrot dynamic. But I think this rings true as a possibility and Vimes' "it's quite likely I might [hang]" was more than a throwaway line. It was foreshadowing.


r/discworld • • 7d ago

Book/Series: Witches Unpopular opinion: I don't like Greebo

0 Upvotes

I can't get behind liking Greebo.
Some of his antics as a human are amusing but I can't give a pass to an the incestuous rapist no matter how many times he says, "want milk."


r/discworld • • May 23 '24

Discussion Is Mustrum Ridcully…?

2 Upvotes

Hello All,

I have read around sixteen of the books and I’d like to ask and discuss, is Mudstrum Ridcully based on a Southern American redneck?

I’m from the American South, and I recall in one of the early books, perhaps the one where he is introduced that his language and hobbies indicate this. I can’t find much online so I figured I’d ask here.

If so, this is incredibly well done by Pratchett. As the series is so very British, I love this if that’s the case.

Thanks!


r/discworld • • Aug 26 '24

Discussion In a purely magical duel who do you think comes out on top?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Granny Weathwerwax or Professor McGonagall


r/discworld • • Jan 17 '23

LOCKED Reading Maskerade, suddenly remember all the fat shaming that put me off reading the witches again for so long.

0 Upvotes

How did such a great author think this was OK? Really putting me down, so I think I'll have to do likewise to the book. Literally every description of Agnes is grotesquely overdone, its really depressing to see my own thoughts about myself reflected by my favourite author about his character.


r/discworld • • Apr 18 '26

Book/Series: Death Jam Roly-Poly, who knew that this was a real thing.

Thumbnail
bbc.com
0 Upvotes

r/discworld • • Jul 03 '24

Discussion What would you change?

Post image
6 Upvotes

I saw this in another sub reddit and was curious what other Pterry fans would change.


r/discworld • • May 11 '24

Discussion Can we please stop posting cock shaped vegetables?

0 Upvotes

I'm sure you can find somewhere else to post your mutated carrot with a nutsack. It's not interesting or even funny, it's just bogging the sub down and drowning out actual posts

Pterry specifically criticises media that has nothing more significant to communicate to its readership than pictures of vegetables that look like genitals. That's literally the joke, it's in the book. Can we stop?


r/discworld • • Sep 02 '24

Discussion We’ve just discovered that the only rating on the web version of Apple Podcasts is a one star review. If you like the show and listen to us on Apple Podcasts, we’d greatly appreciate a rating and/or review!

Post image
0 Upvotes

Also We are hard at work getting our next episode to you but it is unfortunately being delayed by the fact that my (Nigel) copy of Unseen Academicals has not been delivered despite being ordered weeks ago


r/discworld • • Aug 14 '24

Discussion This may be controversial but I don't care for Cohen the Barbarian. I find him annoying and just boring. Are there any popular characters that you hate?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/discworld • • May 03 '24

Art Granny Weatherwax and Sam Vimes as ponies

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/discworld • • Jul 06 '24

Discussion Neil Gaiman NSFW

41 Upvotes

I am absolutely shook to the core about the new Neil Gaiman sexual assault claims for many reasons. I am a survivor of CSA and adult molestation and rape, so I understand my experiences might cause bias, and not everyone will agree, which I understand, and this might be the wrong sub for this. I found Discworld because of Neil Gaiman, along with Doctor Who. Gaiman is my favorite author, but Discworld is my favorite series. I suffer from MDD, C-PTSD, ADHD, OCD, and GAD. I connected so hard with Vimes in Thud!. I fight to keep the darkness out. I have the Summoning Dark tattooed on my wrist. I am terrified that other people are going to tie Neil and Terry together as much as I do and that I'm going to have to defend my tattoo. I know this might be irrational, but see my list of mental illnesses above. Is anyone else struggling with this today?


r/discworld • • May 20 '25

Book/Series: Gods Just found an origin for Om

Post image
5 Upvotes

I never thought about it before, but seems the name comes from religious terminology


r/discworld • • Oct 06 '13

Eyes: Teatime and Moody.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/discworld • • May 02 '22

Discussion The fact there's no black characters in discworld makes the whole monster racism angle weak as hell.

0 Upvotes

"Racism was not a problem on the Discworld, because -- what with trolls and dwarfs and so on -- speciesism was more interesting. Black and white lived in perfect harmony and ganged up on green."

But how can they live in perfect harmony if black people seemingly don't exist. It would be weird to think all people on ank are white I feel as though the fact vampires, werewolves, trolls etc are supposed to be a real world stand in for racism is weak as hell when there's only white people main characters in the books. It gives the message that white people can only emphasize with marginalized groups if they are fantasy races and not actual black people who actually exist.

Also I don't know if the whole idea behind the quote would even work. In America after after 9/11 we had a whole "I'm American" identity going on. Where black and white people were unified against a enemy who was against us all. This obviously bred so much Islamophobia. Chris Rock actually has a bit about this. if monsters actually existed. Humans would've band together for a time but eventually that unifiedness will dissolve as it has always done after the whole unknown enemy luster has worn off.


r/discworld • • May 16 '26

Audiobooks I've been listening to The Colour of Magic, and I don't think it's entirely for me. Is there a point to continuing the series?

15 Upvotes

So I'm new to discworld. I'll preface this with the disclaimer that I don't mean to be disrespectful or attack anyone. I'm almost done with the colour of magic, and I listened to the Nome trilogy right before starting it, and the experience was pretty similar. I can see that the books are well written, and I think I get most of the jokes, I just don't find them very amusing, I guess. Truth be told, I've done very little research about discworld before starting to listen to it, and some part of me maaaay have expected a straight forward fantasy instead of the satire.

I'm just not sure if this a case of the series having some books be hit and miss for some people or if its just not for me personally, and if anyone else had a similar starting experience of being mostly indifferent about the first book before enjoying the rest of the series to the point of loving it.

Edit: thanks everyone for commenting. The replies came in a lot faster than I expected, it's kinda overwhelming. I mostly listen to books while commuting, and I'll continue listening to discworld instead of looking for anything else for the time being, and I'll keep the books everyone recommended in mind


r/discworld • • Mar 19 '24

Question I didn't like Good Omens :( Should I bother with Discworld?

0 Upvotes

It hurts to say because I know it is so beloved, but the writing style was difficult for me to follow, so humor fell flat. Do you think Good Omens is a good representation of how the rest of Pratchett's works are written?

Edit: Of course discworld fans will recommend discworld! I'm asking because you guys would know better than anyone if Good Omens is a good representation or not :)


r/discworld • • Aug 14 '26

Book/Series: Industrial Revolution Do you think Moist might of bankrupted some parcel delivery/courier companies by getting the post working right again?

0 Upvotes

I mean, wherever there is a niche theirs gonna be someone who tried to profit off it. I could totally imagine some small delivery courier companies, people who will just take parcels from place to place in the city, existing before the Post came back and made them obsolete via a more centralized, government-backed system that was probably cheaper and more reliable.


r/discworld • • Sep 02 '26

Book/Series: Death Death created the Death of Rats on accident

83 Upvotes

I’m not sure how I’ve never realized this before, but Death directly creates the Death of Rats on accident in *Reaper Man*.

The rats are what he kills as Bill Door in a Bill Door way. Sure, he kills the one chicken for dinner, but he clearly taps into his nature as Death to pull out the soul/spirit/whatever. But the rats?

Miss Flitwick’s poison. And he “felt like a murderer.”

This is what called the Death of Rats to be near him, so if he hadn’t killed the rats in such a human fashion, it wouldn’t have been nearby to take on its particular form due to morphic resonance. And if it hadn’t, it wouldn’t have been able to hang on and wouldn’t have caught his attention and led him to save it.

…Which technically makes Susan the niece of the Death of Rats. Thanks for coming to my TED talk.

ETA: Dear grammar Nazis, “on accident” and “by accident “ have the same meaning and the former has no other meaning than the same as the latter, which is being used increasingly by a younger generation who understand that such distinctions are often meaningless and silly. But if you really feel the urge to comment about this, others already have. This is like being angry about ending a sentence with a preposition. Get over it, because (as someone else wisely pointed out) linguistic diversion is a thing… and Terry would be the first to mock you for this behavior.

(And since I don’t want to deal with it further, anyone coming here to try to be a dick about regional grammar is getting a block. Like, why behave this way here? It’s so unnecessary.)

FINAL EDIT: I am now going to completely mute the replies because people have chosen to be such jerks here about not liking my choice of one word, rather than replying to the substance of what I said, for the most part. But let me just say this: if you think that is a real rule, then ask yourself why we do not say that we did something “by purpose?” BECAUSE IT’S FREAKING ARBITRARY, AND IS NOT A REAL RULE. Use logic, FFS.

OKAY, ONE MORE EDIT: A mod is trying to state that calling someone a grammar Nazi is the same as calling them an actual Nazi and banned me for that. I was directly told in a comment that using the word “Grammar” doesn’t change what it means. Everything else aside, that is offensive to state the two statements are the same. I could not let that pass without comment; for shame.

(And, just to be clear, I also don’t appreciate you trying to threaten me with “the admins” based on your assumptions. Way to show your real nature, pumpkin. This isn’t you being a mod, this is you engaging in personal attacks. Pathetic. Almost as pathetic as claiming you are the arbitrator of what it means to act like him because you met him once. Yikes. You’re a real peach, too: a rotten one.)


r/discworld • • Apr 14 '26

Book/TV: Good Omens Good Omens and Discworld are in a shared universe?

0 Upvotes

I just recently re-listened to the audiobook of Good Omens, and was surprised to hear a mention of the Necrotelicomnicon.

This may be old news, but as I only started reading the Discworld books a few years ago, I thought it was a nice touch.


r/discworld • • Dec 04 '25

Boardgames/Computer Games My cover mock up for the Discworld RPG session Im running this December

Post image
0 Upvotes

Made with Nano Banana (over quite a lot of time…)


r/discworld • • Sep 11 '15

"I've read Pratchett now: it's more entertainment than art"... you cannot say: “Pratchett writes really ordinary prose yet is a literary genius.”

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
1 Upvotes

r/discworld • • Nov 23 '21

Discussion Are Vimes and Vetinari romantically involved?

0 Upvotes

Obviously there's nothing in canon to 100% support/confirm this. However. I've met quite a few people who pick up on some sort of sexual/romantic subtext between Vimes and Vetinari, and the majority of them agree that Sybil is also in on it. Anyone else picking up on these vibes?