r/dfinity • • Jun 23 '21

Compiling a list of questions and topics that Dfinity has refused to answer or discuss as well as any unverified claims.

1 Upvotes

Dfinity claims to value the community and fairness, but their actions tend to portray the exact opposite. So i'm putting together a list of things that have been asked but they've dodged, evaded, avoided, but have not, as well as any questions that should have answers but don't.

  • the definition that Dfinity is using for circulating supply

  • thoroughly documented and complete vesting and Unlock schedules with specifics of all rounds, all groups, all VCs and cointributors. so investors can accurately assess circulating supply

  • proof of the blockchain's performance abilities

  • the wallet/neuron addresses of the founder, the foundation, the internet computer association, not only as proof that their claims are true, but also as a gesture of goodwill and transparency to the community, showing that they aren't hiding anything nefarious. Has the team/foundation sold any tokens? if so, when?

  • where the 220m CHF developer grant fund come from? considering their claims that the foundation hasn't sold and this is more than the amount of money they raised

  • who supplied liquidity at launch?

  • how are they protecting this data, as well as all kyc data, from breach?

  • have they ever sold or otherwise distributed any of this data?

  • what comprised the 26% circulating supply at launch? how did they come to this number?

​ Why was the private sale held an extra month at launch from participating in the market?

*Please add anything that I missed, and if the thread gets locked for whatever stupid insecure reason, then feel free to PM me.*

edit: added some things brought to my attention


r/dfinity • • Jun 04 '21

When is Dfinity going to do a real AMA? "Ask me anything", not "Ask me about this extremely niche topic". You have removed all forum for any sort of non-technical support.

8 Upvotes

Title says it all. You've made it impossible for anyone to to get any sort of response from the team about anything other than the development and functionality of the tech part of the project. You delete any threads that do otherwise and there is no other way to get a response.

what are you afraid of? transparency?


r/dfinity • • May 10 '21

RIDICULOUS OPEN!

0 Upvotes

I made the mistake of going big with ICP with the opening price of $630. Seemed high but I had already decided I wanted to be a part of this long term. But to see it drop below $400 in just a few minutes really disappointed me. Dfinity made a money grab with small retail investors that was well above market. I thought highly of Dfinity and felt they were not playing that game. I will hold these and hope to recoup my investment but I doubt I will ever buy their token again. I have lost all trust in this team.


r/dfinity • • Sep 02 '21

Ha-ha ICpunks launch was a disaster

0 Upvotes

I think it was really bad launch.

They could have minting fee(1-2+)ICP for the 50% of clowns, Free to early adopters(30%), Free for all other 20%.

Because there was no mint fee now people paying a lot to the botters who got 5-10+ Clown for free by bypassing system. I don't want to give money to these creep dudes I would prefer the icpunks team for their future works.

Also there was hundreds of users who wrote stories about icpunks on their dc channel for the contest. That time there was 2K free spot on the early adopters, they could take all of contests participants to there but they took only 30. What happened to other 1970 IC Punk? taken by some creepy bots.

I don't want to believe they were that much stupid when launching, probably they did not release 7K clowns maybe just like 1K of them released and they are selling other 6K to the Entrepot market slowly, otherwise its unacceptable dumb launch and shameful.

They are buying and selling their clowns to increase the volume doing wash trade, do you really believe that someone paid 12K$ to the clown? Increasing volume to catch more dev funds... I know like 20-30 People follows ICP and NONE of them could claim.

There are tons of better ways to launch a NFT please come on wake up


r/dfinity • • Jun 19 '21

Where is Dfinity?!?

1 Upvotes

This project is in serious turmoil with its community and how it is perceived since its market entry a month ago and Dfinity has only tweeted a couple times and made almost no announcements or updates that might help pull out of this nosedive. It's starting to look bad- really.


r/dfinity • • Jun 16 '21

Why was the private presale round locked for an extra month after genesis? Why won't Dfinity prove that they didn't sell any tokens like claimed?

2 Upvotes

The private presale round was the only round of ivnestment that was not allotted any tokens on genesis. The VCs got 1/12th, the ECT got 1/30th, the SEED got 1/49th, the airdrop got 1/12th, the private presale got 0. The private presale paid the most per coin for the least amount of supply, and was not allowed to sell.

Why? I'm going to keep asking this question till I get an answer

Dominic claims that Dfinity and team didnt sell any tokens https://medium.com/dfinity/the-community-led-governance-of-the-internet-computer-b863cd2975ba but offers no proof of this, and ignores every request for proof on twitter, unless i have missed something which is definitely possible.


r/dfinity • • Nov 22 '21

Will Internet Computer experience high inflation?

0 Upvotes

I did my own research and found out that the Internet Computer has a fairly high inflation. Every month the circulation grows by 8-9%. There is periodic unlocking every 10th of the month and last month over 4 million ICP coins were released on that day. In the two weeks that followed 7 million more ICP coins were available to trade.

Right now, there are people who are staking their ICP coins and getting as much as 28% return but this is adding to the inflation. People have talked about in order to make an actual profit, they have to stake because the price is stagnant. At the same time though, we are seeing more node operators and Dfinity plans on minting more coins to pay them instead of using their own budget. There are now over 474.8 million ICP coins. Most of them are presumed to be locked in neurons. But within an 8 year period, they will be released. By that 8 year mark we would have close to 1 billion ICP coins.


r/dfinity • • Mar 21 '18

Dfinity Rated 4.67/5.0 on CoinGecko

Thumbnail
coingecko.com
1 Upvotes

r/dfinity • • Feb 06 '22

The Internet Computer is completely centralized?! What's the point of it?

0 Upvotes

ICP uses a form of proof of stake. That means that those who hold tokens on the network have all the power.

Yet like 90%+ of all the tokens were given away to insiders. Doesn't this completely destroy the uses the internet computer has? I want to build apps on a trusted, decentralized, immutable network - but how can I trust ICP to be that when insiders literally hold everything?!


r/dfinity • • Mar 28 '22

Is ICP ignoring decentralization?

1 Upvotes

When people I talk to say ICP, they say project that ignores decentralization. What do they say about asking validators for KYC? They say that such structures go against the philosophy of cryptography and are meaningless. What are you thinking?


r/dfinity • • May 07 '21

No launch till Monday the 10th, as just stated in the presentation. GG

0 Upvotes

This is really getting absurd. Someone else in this subreddit claimed they wouldn't launch anything on the 7th but I can't find the thread anymore.

the genesis launch event doesnt actually involve a launch...event. seriously dfinity, you guys have no idea disappointing it is that you pulled this crap again after doing it so many times already. Keep it up till no one cares


r/dfinity • • May 27 '21

Really not meaning to FUD around here! However I had some serious concerns about icp which were cemented by the coin bureau video. Anyone else feeling this way?

2 Upvotes

Main factors here are the high level of centralization of the coin - along with the governance (pls don't tell me, there's special hardware required to run icp, which happens to be provided by the dfinity foundation). Then somewhat entirely lacking the incentive of creating new content on the internet computer - other Smart contract platforms have that "hard coded" in their genes, as well as the whole feeling of this being some kind of anti-crypto - a wolf in sheep's clothing so to say. I wish these were the only ones...

I cannot express how much I pity this circumstance, as the whole idea sounds so fascinating, so pure, so complete.

Still, at least as of now, I cannot explain the three digit price (and the place in top 10) other than through hype. I do seriously hope that is subject to change, as more and more of dfinity's milestones become reality. For now, I hope that icp will experience some major losses in price so that also retail investors will get their fair chance of getting in at a fair price. :/

But that's just me, another ape that might very well be very wrong in its opinion for various reasons! ✌️


r/dfinity • • Jan 30 '22

One word.

2 Upvotes

TAGGR.


r/dfinity • • Jul 27 '21

I want to know more about ICP

2 Upvotes

ICP is like an new ethereum?I mean people deploy tokens cere?


r/dfinity • • Jun 26 '21

If you don't like this project, please talk about it in another sub

36 Upvotes

Risking ruffling some feathers here, which I really don't like, but I have to express this:

I joined this sub because I'm excited about this project. Why are so many people taking time out of their day to come here and complain about price and claiming that it's a scam? Do you still hold ICP? If you don't believe in the project, sell your tokens and move on. Do you not hold ICP? Then why are you here? 🤷

You're just polluting my feed with negativity.


r/dfinity • • Feb 17 '22

ICApeVentures - The First Apes On The Internet Computer 🐒

9 Upvotes

r/dfinity • • Jul 26 '21

Refund time

0 Upvotes

r/dfinity • • Jun 18 '22

Clarifying ICP Burn Rate

0 Upvotes

Is the ICP Burn Rate for cycles fixed or variable?


r/dfinity • • Jun 11 '21

Sell before it’s too late! It’s going to hit 40 possibly after this token unlock later today

0 Upvotes

r/dfinity • • Jan 12 '22

Hey Dfinity, please stop censoring negative posts and instead let the community clear the FUD and downvote.

0 Upvotes

I’m a huge fan of the project and have been since June. I have been investing most of my salary into ICP every month and I can’t be happier with how the community and development evolved over the months. I’m actually using multiple dapps daily and so far they work pretty well.

However I’ve seen some rather reasonable posts being removed from here. Dominic is a big proponent of free speech and censorship free communication. Let this subreddit be an example. FUD and misinformation will be downvoted and corrected by the community just as it is on r/ICPTrader. The only way to grow this community huge is to be transparent and face stupid attacks head on. And you the mods and Dfinity doesn’t even need to yourself, trust me the comments will do the job for you.


r/dfinity • • Sep 09 '21

Claim your first IC LOOT in DSCVR

0 Upvotes

r/dfinity • • Aug 13 '21

Unstaking ICP

0 Upvotes

If I place a 8 years dissolved delay for staking ICP in NNS, but decide to dissolve und unstake ICP just after 1 month of staking.

How long do I need to wait to unstake ICP completely ? 8 years or 1 month ?

Your response is appreciated in advance.


r/dfinity • • Dec 19 '21

Boundary nodes

0 Upvotes

Hello, is it true that all boundary nodes are currently ran by the Dfinity foundation?


r/dfinity • • Sep 10 '26

Built an ICRC-7 NFT: Infinity Anons

0 Upvotes

images are rendered live by the canister every request.

generating the images is free, no wallet/login needed.
https://yochp-maaaa-aaaag-azaoq-cai.icp.net/

also, the more you transfer, the wearier it will get.

will integrate it with my Pearl Cove game next to give it utility :D


r/dfinity • • May 10 '21

What a joke

5 Upvotes

You had FOUR YEARS to tell us that our tokens would be vesting for 12 months, but you waited until launch day?

Not that it matters, since you can't actually withdraw or trade on Coinlist right now anyways.

Do you really have that little faith in your vaporware project?

Pathetic.