r/dfinity • u/Superb_Ad_4981 • May 06 '21
ELI5 please: what does Dfinity do?
I watched the technical explainer video and got the impression that Dfinity is like Torrent (distributed storage) with stablecoins. Is that right? Thank you!
8
u/Damienlgl May 07 '21
Calling them the 3rd revolution in crypto is just a joke, still don't really get why you should be adopt ? "Revolution" when you don't even create real evolutions - every "advantages" already exist in others cryptos... nothing new there don't waste your time
9
u/Superb_Ad_4981 May 09 '21
Good to be sceptical! Seems to me that the chain key tech is new - no JSON or mnemonic phrases needed, also it is fast enough to host websites on blockchain, enable 'liquid democracy' and automatic implementation of whatever proposals stakeholders agree upon.
2
u/coodyscoops May 13 '21
Im doing research on this too... did you get all your information from that site? Im watching this coin carefully and plan to buy a few...
You have any wealth to share? I would greatly appreciate it🥰
2
u/Superb_Ad_4981 May 13 '21
Hi there, I just watched their launch video and read the Medium posts :) Just getting started myself too
3
u/oojacoboo May 11 '21
2.5 BPS is fast? 1k BPS is fast? In terms of write operations, that's peanuts. When will the network hit 100M BPS? What VMs will this thing run? What kind of data can you store? Running websites? What does that even mean? I can write 100MB of business logic on the blockchain that can be executed at an affordable price? Not buying it.
4
u/Professional_Sun2048 Team Member May 12 '21
The key takeaway is there is no limit to how much the IC throughput for computation as well as storage can scale. The architecture is also completely different than other blockchains. The throughput scales simply by adding more node machines to the network. There is no reason to scale to 100M bps (supply) at this moment until the developer (demand) matches. It is technically possible as the Internet Computer is a network of interconnected blockchains (called subnets). It’s not storing 100 mb of data, it is about storing any amount of data on chain. The team has been working on it for 5+ years. Checkout the profiles and you will get a sense of the talent that has been building the project https://dfinity.org/foundation/
2
u/greyjumps May 12 '21
The key takeaway is there is no limit to how much the IC throughput for computation as well as storage can scale.
and how do you know that?
4
u/Professional_Sun2048 Team Member May 16 '21
You could check this overview for the architecture of the IC https://link.medium.com/Ggql8bICjgb. The high level idea is that the computations throughput increases by adding more node machines to the network.
2
2
u/TRossW18 May 19 '21
checkout the profiles and you will get a sense of the talent
Man, do you have any idea the level of talent that exists on some blockchains? We're talking award winning CS Professors, Nobel prize winners, big players in the tech-industry, etc...
1
u/oojacoboo May 12 '21
If I store a 5GB database on the “blockchain”. How am I going to determine query times, optimize those, and how are nodes going to handle this? Are you going to shard the data? How will dataset be joined across shards, if so?
There are too many questions, and your claims are total bullshit. You have nothing to show, only claims. In theory, some of this stuff is possible. However, in practice, in the real world, where the rest of us live, you actually have to make this stuff work, and there are lots of real world limitations, especially on a decentralized network.
2
u/No-Theme4118 May 13 '21
I'm petty sure the concept is something like docker containers on AWS, except with WebAssembly (they have the co-creator of the language on the team)
The protocol allows direct communication between the end user and the canisters, and the canisters can connect directly between each other and call shared functions.
This may explain a it more conceptually... dfinity.org/deck
I see it as a decentralized competitor to AWS with a streamlined framework. The goal seems to be to abstract away all the complexities, inconsistencies, and attack vectors as seen with traditional web development, just like a framework typically does.
If the end user can connect directly to a canister, which I assume is analogous to a virtual machine/docker container, I don't see why it couldn't be configured to where the end user could connect directly via SSH or whatever the analog is to debug it... I've never done docker development but it sounds a lot like how it works on AWS.
2
u/Professional_Sun2048 Team Member May 14 '21
Here is an app running completely on the Internet Computer dscvr.one. The network is still in beta.
I would encourage you to approach it with an open mind and do some deeper dive rather that simply claiming that it doesn’t work. The canister is like container in some sense but is able to host not just code and data but also it’s state. A user can query a canister directly and a canister can also query any other canister and as a developer you don’t need to do any special system design. Here is a technical overview: https://link.medium.com/6Ozrmlq3egb
The code and documentation is all open source on GitHub and you get to verify it.
2
2
u/StickyNoodle69 Jun 10 '21
Can’t Polkadot and EOS host websites on the blockchain?? I heard they’re also making social media apps on their platform. What’s the difference??
1
u/Floridamandadbod Jul 14 '21
Dfinity will replace centralized web service. Many blockchains will run on dfinity to get away from AWS and other centralized web servers
6
u/Plenix May 13 '21
I mean faster and cheaper should really ring an alarm bell for you. You want it to be trustless, fairly costly to spam transactions so attackers don’t congest it. And security you need to look into the consensus algorithm and really think about it. There is no perfect consenus. People will just use a distrubuted cloud database if speed and costs is all they care about
2
u/Superb_Ad_4981 May 13 '21
Great point! I cannot read code unfortunately - how can I assess the security and trustless aspects?
Is there an ecosystem you have in mind that passes the test of trustless + spam proof? The other day I was looking to get some AMPL on Uniswap and the transaction fee is 50% of what I planned to spend on the coins themselves, maybe due to the spam of the meme coins. Does this mean ETH failed the spam proof criteria?
74
u/vrf5 Dominic Williams ♾️ May 16 '21
No ;) The DFINITY Foundation just works on the Internet Computer blockchain.
The Internet Computer is the first blockchain that can (1) scale capacity without bound (2) run smart contracts at web speed (3) run smart contracts that can serve web experiences to users (4) is efficient and low cost.
The DFINITY Foundation is a not-for-profit organization based in Zurich, Switzerland, with research centers in Zurich, Palo Alto, San Francisco, and Tokyo, and remote teams in places like Germany and the UK. It also has administration centers in places like Neuchatel (Switzerland). The purpose of this foundation is to research and develop technology supporting the Internet Computer, and to act as an advocate.
The Internet Computer Association is a not-for-profit members association that is based in Geneva. Its purpose is to support, coordinate, connect and advocate for Internet Computer ecosystem members - data centers, node providers, developers, educators, investors funding those building dapps, enterprises wishing to use it, regulators etc etc
Note that nobody controls the Internet Computer. The network hosts within its blockchain protocols an open, tokenized autonomous governance system called the Network Nervous System (NNS). The network runs under the control of the NNS, which manages and configures it in real time i.e. the Internet Computer is the world's first fully adaptive blockchain, which enables it to rapidly evolve, and manage complex tasks relating to scaling.
11
May 18 '21
Hey Dominic, I'm very interested in the project! I do have some questions and concerns (as I imagine is the case with many people), would you or anyone from your team be willing to host an AMA session to answer questions from the community?
9
8
u/Quatic Jun 10 '21
TLDR; it is like a cloud service provider (AWS, Google, Microsoft) but decentralised and not governed by a big commercial corporation
5
Jun 11 '21
Except it's proven to not be decentralised so now what?
6
u/Quatic Jun 12 '21
Elaborate
1
u/AmericanScream Jun 28 '21
They are operating a small, finite number of specific data centers.
I'm curious what happens when somebody posts some illegal content on the network, and others complain to the sites hosting their data centers. Do you think the data centers or the municipalities in which they reside have no ability to regulate what they're doing?
3
u/Quatic Jun 28 '21
Lol even two separate datacenters is decentralised. New datacenters are added and decentralisation is not only the servers but also the control
1
u/AmericanScream Jun 28 '21
Whoever stakes the most coins has control. And by design that control is in the power of the devs and their people. So it's not really decentralized. There's an illusion of lack of authority because of various non-profit groups but the real power is in the staking and that's been pre-allocated to certain authoritative figures.
7
May 30 '21
What is web speed?
3
u/readmore2022 Jun 27 '21
If you buy ICP , and you transfer your coins to the Nervous System, you will see how fast the transfer is and its speed. I use to use LTC as my way of payment and transfer and this is so much faster. WEB Speed. Not BTC speed, NOT ADA speed not DOGE speed. ICP wallet log-in and wallet is still in its Beta stages. Climb the Mountain.
2
u/ResponsibilitySea549 Jun 02 '21
Like how a webpage just loads.
5
u/joaquinsolo Jun 13 '21
In Ghana? South Korea? The US? Like where?
Are we talking dial-up, DSL, or Fiber Optic?2
u/ResponsibilitySea549 Jun 15 '21
Why not just create an identity and try it? all the apps and sights just feel like a regular web pages to me.
2
u/eric95s Jun 25 '21
It means the protocol is as fast as the current internet protocol.
So, if you access dfinity's protocol in Ghana, then the speed is the same as Ghana's web speed. If you access dfinity's protocol in South Korea, then the speed is the same as South Korean's web speed.
It's like saying "Algorithm A is as fast as Algorithm B", it means that given the same environment, both algorithms will run at the same speed.
1
u/joaquinsolo Jun 25 '21
so how does that differ from Ethereum, Polygon, or BSC for that matter?
1
u/eric95s Jun 25 '21
I’m not sure, but after trying to understand from their website, it’s basically “decentralized AWS” or “decentralized GCP”. CMIIW.
1
u/AmericanScream Jun 28 '21
It means the protocol is as fast as the current internet protocol.
Since this is a service that sits on TOP of that layer, it's impossible for it to be "as fast."
1
u/eric95s Jun 28 '21
Yeah, I personally don’t believe any decentralized solution to be as fast as centralized solutions.
1
Jun 02 '21
When someone says “at web speed” what should I take it as and why it’s significant, since the web pages can an load at many different speeds, depending on one’s connection speed.
2
u/ResponsibilitySea549 Jun 02 '21
I think that thier implying it will be indistinguishable from any other web page. I used open chat the other day and it was comparable to WhatsApp / regular messaging. Granted my sample of the network so far is small but NNS seems to be quick. When the fuel apps that I have tools around with seem to be responsive
1
u/ResponsibilitySea549 Jun 02 '21
I haven't used cancan but it seemed like exactly the same thing is Instagram from the demo video.
1
u/someboooooodeh Jun 16 '21
It functions at web speed as opposed to blockchain speed. If you've ever tried to use anything on eth blockchain you'd understand the significance of this.
1
u/xonasuchi Jun 18 '21
Sounds like a term with no actual meaning. Web speed is what 3 seconds? 5 seconds? 2 seconds with fiber optic networks? Changes depending on geography?
2
u/AmericanScream Jun 28 '21
Sounds like a term with no actual meaning. Web speed is what 3 seconds? 5 seconds? 2 seconds with fiber optic networks? Changes depending on geography?
not unlike "decentralized"... it's a generic jingoistic buzzword that has no specific meaning that can be interpreted however you want
1
May 31 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator May 31 '21
I´m sorry, your account age should be above 1 day to be able to post on this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/cindertop Jun 13 '21
"run contacts at web speed" what is web speed?
1
1
u/PB-Falcon Jul 25 '21
It runs at the speed we have grown accustom to when using any normal website. Most or all of the Dapps running on ledgers today do not do this because they cannot. ICP can and does. All the other ledgers are sharding and splitting and updating with a road map where transactions will eventually be fast. Eventually they endeavor to create what ICP just did.
3
2
u/AmericanScream Jun 28 '21
is efficient and low cost.
How does this work? If TCP tokens are also treated like a security and have extremely volatile pricing (like from $600 to $30 in two months) how can anybody say their use to pay for services if "efficient and low cost?"
Do you not see a significant conflict of interest creating a payment token for services that is also treated like an investment?
2
1
u/Kairoszone Jul 24 '21
ICP in its grand plan and roadmap is nice. But in reality, it is almost impossible to achieve.
In addition, there is a CONTROL issue.
It is the insiders who control and votes for the most important developments and this goes against the grains of distributed computing. Their marketing as distributed, impartial, non-centralized structured, but in reality it is controlled by few and thus only benefits the insiders.. and the VC who backs them up. This is evidenced by the Recent initial coin offering DUMPs by the insiders and non-transparency of the coin transactions. As a result it lost 90% of the value in less than 2 months. This is an ultimate , highly sophisticated deception and scam.....1
u/AmericanScream Jul 24 '21
Agreed. You can't call your system "de-centralized" when by design you've centralized the authority, but pretend it isn't centralized by hiding behind tokens. These tokens also give third parties the ability to buy consensus and control if they have enough money. That seems to be the epitome of everything the IC claims to combat. They also try to hide the centralization by giving a minority share of tokens to a seeded board of directors of a non-profit.
1
Jul 06 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/AmericanScream Jul 06 '21
One of the many simple questions that remains unanswered.
I've been reading on this and there's some sort of marketing doublespeak which implies there's some way to make payment systems more consistent than the speculative volatility of ICP in general, but I have no idea how that would work, or even if it would work.
The whole notion of staking ICP for governance means whoever is the richest, makes the rules. So that right away, makes the whole concept centralized.
Now, to further complicate things, those who want to use the network, have to choose between using their holdings to give the network value, or control the network's governance. This basically creates a conflict of interest, causing those who are paying the most to use the network, also have to pay even more to insure the infrastructure they depend upon isn't taken over by a competitive interest.
This really makes no sense whatsoever from the perspective of an app developer. If I want to deal with a power-hungry mafia over the infrastructure upon which I depend, I have plenty of other choices that are more stable and reliable, and don't have a casino integrated into their business model.
1
u/Zilla_OG3 Jul 08 '21
You have been in this sub for some time, I've seen your name and yet you say there are unanswered things that there are readily available answers to without having to ask questions. ICP can be instantly converted to cycles which the cycle token is not pegged to the price of ICP but pegged to the SDR for stability reasons.
0
u/AmericanScream Jul 08 '21 edited Jul 08 '21
ICP can be instantly converted to cycles which the cycle token is not pegged to the price of ICP but pegged to the SDR for stability reasons.
See what I mean? Lots of buzzwords and abbreviations, but nothing in actual human readable format containing the actual information asked for.
Can you imagine if someone wanted to have electricity wired in their home and when they called the electrians for a quote, the operator said, "It's all there in the NFPA 70E manual. Look it up. Make sure you have adequate ROMEX and the proper NEMA receptacles. You're welcome."
I'm a software engineer by trade and I don't have the slightest idea what half of this stuff means? If your "internet computer" is so complicated and convoluted you can't answer simple questions without bogging people down in proprietary lingo, what hope does anybody else have?
2
u/Zilla_OG3 Jul 08 '21
It would be more confusing if they called cycle tokens "computational tokens" because payment for computation isn't measured in computational power. You seem to think you are smarter than this project while understanding very little about why certain decisions were made and filling in those gaps with a lot of baseless assumptions.
0
u/AmericanScream Jul 08 '21
Wow, that went right over your head didn't it?
When this project completely fails, remember this moment.
Remember when you were so detached from the mainstream market you accused somebody of asking basic questions and not being satisfied with your indignant doubletalk as thinking they're "smarter than the project."
It's because of exchanges like this, that it's really hard to feel like anybody involved in this project really expects it ever to take off. Instead, you just need to bamboozle enough simpletons to blindly accept whatever tecnobabble you're spewing warrents them tossing money at it long enough for you all to make a cozy rugpull. That must be it. You can't be this detached from the fact that you're incapable of accurately describing what it is you're even selling?
2
u/Zilla_OG3 Jul 08 '21
You have made no attempt to understand why certain decisions were made and just making more assumptions, even after being explained you don't have any other questions, just more assumptions. Sounds more like someone who has their mind made up already and is here in bad faith.
3
u/theblockofblocks Jul 08 '21
Whoever they are, they seem incredibly set on the idea that the entirety of crypto is a scam and that there is no value in the space. I agree that 99% of projects will go to zero. But believing that there is no value in the crypto space whatsoever strikes me as being rather stupid. The word ‘Luddite’ comes to mind.
2
u/Zapzapparoo Jun 29 '21
level 2
Why have they not done more AMA's to get developers onboard? From the developers I heard trying to work on this they say it is vague, hard to pickup, and seems like a scam. I may be completely wrong and don't see the bigger picture. But cloud infrastructure isn't that insecure. Blockchain for finance is great, but is it necessary for changing the internet? I am not so sure. Other blockchains with smart contracts are going to take over markets by making relationships with specific industries. I just can't see this overtaking the big tech daddies I guess.
2
u/JesperGrip Jun 29 '21
$ICP is attracting a lot of new members even with the market wide negative price movement lately. If you are new here, the current price is likely to provide a great point of entry. However, I would recommend first reading up on cryptocurrency. Don't just jump in on fear of missing out. Make sure that you know what you are getting into first. You can use https://simplecryptoguide.com/how-to-buy-internet-computer/ to get started, it takes you through the process of buying on an exchange step by step. The additional articles in the guide should also answer most of the questions one might have starting out. :)
1
u/Kairoszone Jul 24 '21
ICP in its grand plan and roadmap is nice. But in reality, it is almost impossible to achieve.
In addition, there is a CONTROL issue.
It is the insiders who control and votes for the most important developments and this goes against the grains of distributed computing. Their marketing as distributed, impartial, non-centralized structured, but in reality it is controlled by few and thus only benefits the insiders.. and the VC who backs them up. This is evidenced by the Recent initial coin offering DUMPs by the insiders and non-transparency of the coin transactions. As a result it lost 90% of the value in less than 2 months. This is an ultimate , highly sophisticated deception and scam.....1
u/ynotplay Jul 29 '21
Is Dfinity able to do decentralized file storage? and do it more cost effective than centralized services like AWS as well as decentralized ones like Filecoin, Arweave, Sia?
1
8
u/hedgethewhales May 16 '21
I think the world will be tokenized inside the internet computer. Unlike eth it's a gen 3 blockchain which is compatible with eth evms and can host even ethereum dapps and other smart contract dapps
Also the dapps built straight on top of icp can scale unlimited with out the need for gas fees to the user transactions
1
u/AutoModerator May 16 '21
I´m sorry, your account age should be above 1 day to be able to post on this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
7
6
u/Electronic-Good-3169 May 18 '21
They have chosen to work with Sygnum as custodian - great sign that they are committed to running a quality operation with best-in-class partners for the long term 🦾
https://www.coindesk.com/sygnum-becomes-first-bank-to-offer-custody-of-dfinitys-icp-token
1
Jun 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 17 '21
I´m sorry, your account age should be above 1 day to be able to post on this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
4
u/itsthechampgodrepo May 18 '21
Why is this coin getting hit so hard
3
u/friendlysatan69 May 19 '21
Probably the massive valuation lol we havent seen something this big in a long time
1
u/StickyNoodle69 Jun 02 '21
Probably the massive valuation lol we havent seen something this big in a long time
ICO sell off.
2
u/homo_superior2021 Jun 26 '21 edited Jun 26 '21
because nobody wants to hold it. pure garbage. worst tokenomics ever.
Even if they have superior tech, they will need a large community for adoption. They have burned SO MANY PEOPLE the last month and this will continue for at least a year. After that this project will die because so many people got burned nobody will adopt it any more. If you just look at the tokenomics its obvious that they just want to make quick profits and not a real sunstainable community. And I also believe they are are not honest about their tech as well but we will never know because nobody will use it.
4
u/hydrogator May 20 '21
so many answers of mumbo-jumbo....
people want to know how do the dApps that run on this chain actually run? Are we still talking about people running their own database under their desk and just using this chain to process actions while anything of worth is on people's servers? So all this Internet Computer is doing is securing the actions not the content? As in, if you create and sell an NFT on the Internet Computer it is still on someone's file server and linked to a database but with permissions on the blockchain?
Calling this project the Internet Computer and saying it will replace all of big tech is silly if you still need people to run massive datacenters that they can turn off whenever they want while the chain keeps running and says, sure you own this or that once they turn their servers back on... etc etc
3
u/No-Theme4118 May 11 '21
Primer to Internet Computer Protocol https://youtu.be/xiupEw4MfxY?t=659
Tokenomics https://youtu.be/H2p5q0PR2pc
3
u/malabarbigou Jun 16 '21
52% of tokens for foundation grants, team and partners,
31% for big investors
And you call this "decentralized"?
Why don't use IPFS? Because it's free, without reward? So money should dominate and guarantee data security? With tokens centralised in the hands of a few investors? Is it really based on that?
It's realy a question, not a troll, because I discovered the very promising dfinity project a few years ago and when I see it now, it looks more like a bad competitor to the DeFi wave and a big scam.
So please contradict me and simply explain how the project is really different and realistic.
2
u/DigitalMutant3 May 20 '21
...the commitment of this project is very ambitious and IMO its goal depend only by the adoption ICP will get.
What do you think will be the key of its large adoption?
2
u/Edxactly May 23 '21
I’ve one question I’ve not seen about . Even thought the ID is tied in many cars to a biometric scanner , you can still have multiple accounts correct ? There is no way to know that there is only one I’d per person so to speak
2
2
u/AmericanScream Jul 04 '21
Correct me if I'm wrong but here's what I get:
The IC (Internet Computer) is an API that runs on top of existing TCP/IP structure, basically an array of proprietary [web] servers that accept a unique protocol that involves crypto-encoded instructions.
A token offering, called ICP is created in association with this project. The tokens have triple duty: They are bought/sold as some kind of speculative asset, they are used as a payment for hosting content, and they're staked as a way to exert control and influence over the future evolution and management of the project.
There's a combination of individual nodes and organized data centers hosting the project, which means to store primary data on a write-only blockchain-style database.
Supposedly, the underlying tech is open source and "public domain"
A number of impressive-sounding advocacy groups have been created that supposedly have some association and loose influence over the projects' development (through being given some ICP tokens for "governance")
The largest single lion's share of available ICP tokens still remains under the control of the development and management teams.
What I see here, is a project claiming to be "censorship resistant" and "distributed", but basically controlled by a central group of people. Using tokens that seem to be involved in an identity crisis, forcing people to decide whether they should be used for investment, governance or currency.
Interestingly enough, the double-duty of tokens being used for governance and also payment for services ironically makes it so that those who use the network the most, likely have the least influence (verses those who don't use the network and instead stake their tokens for governance).
I also see a project that seems to be based on a premise (let's find a way to generate revenue by taking advantage of blockchain and all the money pouring into DeFi projects) that has yet to find a "killer app" justifying its value and existence. There's talk of IC-based closed of popular apps like Uber or Chat rooms, but still no real justifications for how/why such apps would be better than what we have already?
Technologically, it does not seem possible that another layer of abstraction on top of the Internet proper will be faster, so that's out the window.
There's no way to tell if this new project is more "open", "free" and "censorship resistant" when it's fundamentally not any different from any other private interest-controlled tech: it's still governed by a small group of people. The notion of "censensus" in this project is misleading because consensus is not based on consensus of opinion, but consensus of staked token holders. In other words, whoever has the most tokens (money) can make the decisions. This doesn't seem any fundamentally different than what you seem to be competing against.
1
u/TheWorldofGood Jul 20 '21 edited Jul 20 '21
I think DApps on IC are more decentralized than apps running on AWS, Azure, or any big tech companies that can shut down any apps or services. dApps running on IC cannot be shut down by anyone because it’s already on the blockchain and nobody controls the content of what’s on there. Dfinity says not even they can delete or control contents on their blockchain.
IC is also faster and more scalable, thus more efficient than Ethereum technologically. There are already many dApps on Ethereum, so imagine a blockchain that has better technology and is easier to build apps on because it supports popular programming languages used by millions of programmers worldwide.
The criticism about the many promises they’ve made are valid. But I think IC is at its infancy where not everything is ready to be sold to public. That’s where the problem arises because some investors would see it as a quick cash grab scheme, which I think it’s not true based on the fact that Dfinity has some of the brightest engineers and scientists onboard to work on this blockchain. Perhaps I could even argue that we are witnessing a new birth of Google 2.0. Who knows.
My only concern with IC is the token itself and how its price might affect the operation of the blockchain, because ICP token is the fuel that runs the whole operation but if the token is too expensive, how can anyone afford to run dApps on it? I have yet to see an answer to this question.
1
u/AmericanScream Jul 20 '21 edited Jul 21 '21
Like many elements of the crypto industry, ICP is a contradiction. They want to use the same token to operate the network as well as dictate consensus, as well as serve as some kind of investment. Trying to create a tri-purpose token will result in it not being suitable for any of those aspects in the end.
I also think "de-centralized" is a largely meaningless construct. There will still be ways to shut down IC-based applications.. there has to be or else the first person who hosts child porn will be held up as an example of what the network was built for and render it an enemy of society.
So which is it? Is the IC a boon for pedophiles and drug dealers? Or something else? Who has this problem that they need more de-centralization that isn't doing something criminal? All my web sites and apps work fine. I'm not worried about "the man" shutting them down, but then again, I'm not doing anything criminal. So what market does the IC even pander to?
(and I don't think for example, "freedom fighters in communist china" is really what they're going for - plus China could probably filter the tech if they wanted - it's not as distributed as people think - any blockchain based network has to be able to advertise where its nodes are and it would be trivially easy to create a rogue node that entered the network and tipped off which IP addresses to block). For example, TOR is a great tool to try and bypass censorship.. or is it? I can get an instant list of all tor exit nodes any time I want. It's super easy to write a script to block access from these IPs. In a few minutes of work, I can make it so an entire network (or anything I serve) has no access to TOR. The same can be done with the IC. There's no way they can mask this and still be functional. Nodes in the blockchain have to be able to advertise. So at the end of the day, this "distributed" system is still subject to filtering.
2
u/Rq732p May 21 '21
Internet Computer sounds suspiciously like another scam, Iota. They also claim to have unbounded capacity, instantaneous confirmation, etc, etc.
2
Jun 11 '21
Who whoa hold up. IOTA totally rebuilt their flawed and overly ambitious system. They have ifnsct partnered with Fetch.ai recently. Fetch ai is legit and is ) was funded by Bosch Global
1
u/Rq732p Jun 23 '21
IOTA partnered with [put anything here]
IOTA is just one of the many suckercoins.
1
1
u/Thewalrusking2 May 12 '21
Does this coin even have its own chain yet? Or is this an erc20 token?
6
2
u/No-Theme4118 May 13 '21
This explains about everything.
dfinity.org/deck
7
u/Cryptobagchaser May 16 '21
And a developer recently created a decentralized Reddit on chain called dscvr I literally just registered today it’s awesome and only the beginning to where ICP is going with mass adoption 💎 https://h5aet-waaaa-aaaab-qaamq-cai.raw.ic0.app/post/5/introducing-dscvr-a-platform-that-belongs-to-its
5
1
1
1
1
u/PairCurious Jun 25 '21
Let's talk about what is unique about dignity, it is by far the most unsuccessful launch of a crypto currency, furthermore they have absolutely nothing new that has been adopted by business or developers to give it any desirability over anything else listed. On coinmarlketcap. It has been conceived from a standpoint of superiority and present all others to be obsolete. If that wasn't enough already they also are setting records for alienating their own crowd with a deafening silence on their shambolic failures, but hey,.... They are rich nor and don't care whatsoever, to be out with the garbage that's what it is.
1
1
1
1
u/Zealousideal_Arm5018 Jun 30 '21
Need help from somebody familiar with ICP specifically the NNS App wallet....
I have my account # and I have my key and seed phrase however I cannot log in to my account on my phone. I try to sign in and it asks me to sign in using my secure key however I do not have one.... I can use my seed phrase to “recover access” however this really gets me nowhere and I am unable to actually get in to my account and see my coins. They should be there but it’s definitely concerning
1
u/CreationArts Jul 04 '21
Is your problem fixed?
Not sure if I can help you, but I do know that on iOS mobile you need safari (Brave browser only works on desktop).
And you need to login to your account using the same machine and browser you used to setup your identity (http://identity.ic0.app). When logged in you can add new devices. Or add recovery devices.
When you use a (biometric) security key like Yubi, you can use any device (and any browser) you plug that key in.
Hope this helps..
2
u/Zealousideal_Arm5018 Jul 04 '21
I was on the same device I signed up with. Still acting weird but so far I’ve really just left it alone I assume my coins are still there and it’s a long term hold anyway but I would love to get it fixed.... I’ll try again and try on come back with results
1
u/CreationArts Jul 04 '21
Okay cool. Yes this is definitely a long term hold, but I am a strong believer in this project. I also never had any problems with my account. Keep us posted!
By the way, did you know you can top up your staked Neurons, instead of creating a new stake. You can transfer ICP to the wallet of your staked Neurons. The bigger (and longer) the stake, the higher the rewards 😉
1
u/Zlatan4Ever Jul 05 '21
I have aquestion about cyber security and IC. The hacker group Revil has hacked the software company KASEYA. Would IC be a safer alternative to the centralized systems we have today? Could we see companies like Kaseya move to IC? Banks? Institutions?
1
u/AmericanScream Jul 06 '21
Code is code. Except when it comes to blockchain, which is write-only. So if blockchain was hacked, the damage would be even worse, because it's not able to be rolled back. If the IC was hacked, any associated transactions would be permanent, due to the nature of the tech.
1
u/BeeFabulous5585 Jul 09 '21
Dfinity Pad provides amazing opportunity for new project makers to launch their apps using internet protocol faster and safer. Wish all the best to this project.
1
u/tyoarrie Jul 09 '21
Great project and great chance to join with your give awap #DfinityPad #gem #giveaway $DPD
1
u/Kairoszone Jul 24 '21
ICP in its grand plan and roadmap is nice. But in reality, it is almost impossible to achieve.
In addition, there is a CONTROL issue.
It is the insiders who control and votes for the most important developments and this goes against the grains of distributed computing. Their marketing as distributed, impartial, non-centralized structured, but in reality it is controlled by few and thus only benefits the insiders.. and the VC who backs them up. This is evidenced by the Recent initial coin offering DUMPs by the insiders and non-transparency of the coin transactions. As a result it lost 90% of the value in less than 2 months. This is an ultimate , highly sophisticated deception and scam.....
1
-2
May 11 '21
If you guys are this good than why didn’t you just create Bitcoin back in the day?
4
u/coodyscoops May 13 '21
They needed the innovation first.... btc was the land that provided the foundation for icp...
3
u/Professional_Sun2048 Team Member May 12 '21
Bitcoin is The Godfather 🙌
2
May 12 '21
haha, it probably because they needed things to copy/paste and massively exaggerate its capability.
This space is so reminiscent of the behavior prevalent among university professors. What's hilarious is that a lot of the "next generation" token are in fact being started by professors. That is what they do though, repackage and sell things using their name. The gullible masses eat it up.
3
1
u/10folder May 22 '21
Don’t have to be first to everything to be the best. Google offered itself to Alta Vista before going on to become worlds greatest search engine.
0
May 06 '21
[deleted]
13
u/Superb_Ad_4981 May 06 '21
And how does Dfinity manage to be so fast? Is it through distributed storage or...? Looking forward to the Genesis event!
1
1
u/Zapzapparoo Jun 29 '21 edited Jun 29 '21
Who hosts the databases that all these canisters sit on? I can't figure that part out. So the ICP investors are giving their money for ICP to burn tokens to keep the chain operating? In the "operator buys ICP" part of the diagram I am confused who the operator is? Then data center sells ICP... Is there a good video anywhere describing that ecosystem of tokens and how that keeps the data center functioning?
0
May 06 '21
[deleted]
15
u/BuffDarkKnight May 06 '21
It means when you visit a website built on top of dfinity. You won't even notice is on a blockchain. That's how fast dfinity is.
3
0
May 06 '21
[deleted]
11
u/diego_DFN Team Member May 06 '21
This doesn’t quite address all of your questions, but it’s 60% there: https://www.reddit.com/r/dfinity/comments/mum43f/how_fast_is_dfinity_exatcly/
TLDR:
0. We are giving demo and explanation of static website hosting at genesis event: https://dfinity.org/mercury/
Broader context: There are no pure dapps that have all of the front end and backed on chain. They usually have some if not most of their code on a centralized cloud platform. Imagine going to an app that used smart contract as backend and every request took minutes. That’s why developers from traditional backgrounds see the IC as a project that can bring in the world of apps currently outside blockchains compute. After all, crypto has been around for years... apps in production using blockchain backends are still in the thousands. Not millions or tens of millions it could be.
The IC can host these things because of its consensus protocols and layered architecture means it’s really really fast. (I realize that’s a vague answer but I’m on my phone in between coffee breaks 😎)
3
u/block_and_chain May 11 '21
I know I’m a little late to the party here. But how do you keep it very fast in a super competitive space? What kind of scalability advantages are there using this system for millions of users and potentially trillions of transactions per day?
5
u/shayaaa May 11 '21
Yes the network is “infinitely” scalable and unbound. The more nodes are added to the network it’s capacity and power increase as well.
5
1
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 13 '21
Can you please elaborate instead of just using more of the same buzz words...
6
u/shayaaa May 13 '21
Sure, most blockchain get added security when adding nodes to its system (more validation) and not much happens from a compute and processing standpoint increase. With each new node on ICP it’s computational power and network capacity increases. So as more people add nodes the system gets stronger and faster.
2
u/mobijet May 13 '21
lol, so much this. While I personally have some crypto myself, I find the whole crypto scene is throwing buzzwords around like no tomorrow. Feels like dotcom bubble really.
2
u/coodyscoops May 13 '21
I agree with this... i been in crypto for a while now and some of the things im seeing makes so many things that used to be simple much more confusing... crypto really just did its own thing but now its just getting out of control... its like watching a city turn mechanical...
1
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 13 '21
Somewhat but seriously, these guys are among the worst. But because it's such a new and unregulated space right now, you get a lot of scams and stuff. It's sad because there are legitimately a lot of good projects out there right now but this kind of stuff casts the whole space in a very negative light...
0
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 11 '21
It's seriously not. Slow maybe on ethereum but there are plenty of layer-2 solutions that are extremely fast and then you have blockchains like Cardano that can process transactions faster than Visa! Their full of nonsense. Scam. Scam. Scam!
3
u/alecs_stan May 07 '21
It means no more waiting for transactions to settle. Everything should be instantaneous or close to it for end users of dapps.
2
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 11 '21
It doesn't mean anything lmao this is so crazy. This is like the biggest scam coin I've seen so far. Second only to Safemoon. I had to ask that same question because it's nonsense! Look it up and look up their history. This is all a sham. A very elaborate one, but a sham nonetheless.
2
u/Hydraulic_IT_Guy May 13 '21
Absolutely, the buzzword soup these guys are spilling is insane. I can't believe these guys discuss this straight faced.
1
u/PB-Falcon Jul 25 '21
You know this protocol already exists and you can go set up an app on it right now right? The idea that this is a scam is nothing more than a reflection of the fact that you are well out of your element. They just launched decentralized exchange. Is that something you can do with a scam? Do you even know what that is?
1
u/Hydraulic_IT_Guy Jul 26 '21
Yes bud, 'internet computer' is just virtual machines and containers running on their hardware. Blockchain is just a public database. It is all just a different spin on the same thing, locking providers and users into a different vendor/platform.
1
u/Opposite_Form3855 May 13 '21
Dear scam haters.. I know you’ve been hurt in the past! Try telling me the opposite of this statement. If you judge a coin based on 3 days of speculation.. then I believe you’re not an intelligent investor. The definition of scam is the act of giving false promises in order to take your money and vanish. Why are you accusing safemoon and icp for being scams. If you can’t tolerate the Volatility of cryptos and calling every coin that drops is scam. Boy you had me going!!
1
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 13 '21
I do NOT call every coin a scam first of all. There are several very valuable coins and projects out there really pushing this fantastic technology forward! I have not once yet bought into any scam coin and it's precisely BECAUSE I do my research (not just speculate as you say).
I've done some digging and this company is doing a top notch job at using the best keywords and buzz phrases it can think of and has executed and phenomenally well done plan to make as many idiots or new, inexperienced retail investors to see this and think the price is skyrocketing in the attempt to get people to FOMO in.
Fact of the matter is almost NO one has heard of them before a few days ago. Vitalik has NEVER said they were the closest thing to Ethereum or whatever. And the audacity of this "company" is absurd calling themselves "the third big innovation in blockchain technology. They never give technical details, only key words like "web speed" which is the most nonsense thing I've ever heard of. I could seriously go on and on.
If you look up YouTube videos about them and sort the videos by number of views, There isn't a single video with more than a few thousand views and they are all relatively very new videos added somewhat recently. If they're everything they claim, mainstream commentators on the crypto space wouldn't be just discovering them along with the rest of us suddenly a few days ago. It's a scam.
And don't get me started on all the things that make Safemoon a scam. Why don't you invest in a real project that brings actual value to the world and showcases it on a massive scale like Cardano does and has been for a long time now? Or maybe Polkadot, Solana, Cosmos, VeChain... I could keep going on and on about how great the REAL projects out there are and show you YEARS worth of history behind them. You don't need to dig so hard to find info about projects that are actually worth a damn.
3
u/hunterwaterford May 14 '21
How do you explain the almost instantaneous listing on Coinbase pro, Binance and Kucoin just to name a few exchanges? If it were a scam then they dupped 3 of the largest volume exchanges. Highly unlikely and impressive since safemoon can't even get a retweet from CZ and they are exclusive to BSC. There has to be some there there is all I'm saying. I'm trying to find out more about their tokenomics myself. I will say this at that marketcap the whales definitely got in before retail on this one.
2
u/PhoenixKamika-Z May 14 '21
Their listing like that is why I say they are so well put together as far as scam type coins go. I don't know exactly how they pulled that off but it's very fishy to me. There's no other coin in history other than Bitcoin that I can think of that got listed everywhere, simultaneously on the same day and time to every exchange possible. That mere fact alone though tells me something weird is up with that. And if this is supposed to be "the third big innovation in blockchain" (whatever the hell that means) why was there no build up to their release date? Why are there still no noteworthy news articles about them from the top cryptocurrency news agencies?? Why do none of the biggest crypto YouTubers (e.g. Crypto Capital Ventures, Coin Bureau, Benjamin Cowen, Digital Asset News, JRNY Crypto, Sheldon Evans, Crypto FOMO, Alex Becker's Channel, etc. etc.) ever talk about them, let alone even mention them??? Crypto Capital Ventures even sent out a tweet the day they got listed (along side Shiba Inu btw so really the bar can't be too high to get listed IMO) and expressed his shock at these two coins he'd never heard of and asking how the hell do they just appear over night in the top 10-20 cryptos! And for some reason, that's only on Coin Market Cap. Coin Gecko doesn't list them in top coins for some reason and I find that they're usually more accurate than CMC.
Anyway, I just don't know man. I don't trust this project as far as I can throw it. But if you want to invest in something you've never heard of until just recently like everyone else and fall into their FOMO trap, be my guest. I hope I'm wrong and it works out for you. There's just too many red flags in my opinion I can't just overlook, even IF they're listed on mainstream exchanges somehow.
1
2
1
May 12 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator May 12 '21
I´m sorry, your account age should be above 1 day to be able to post on this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
May 18 '21 edited May 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator May 18 '21
I´m sorry, your account age should be above 1 day to be able to post on this subreddit.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
45
u/diego_DFN Team Member May 07 '21 edited May 07 '21
Hi u/Superb_Ad_4981,
Thanks for asking. I can try to help answer.
First, my usual nit: The DFINITY Foundation is a not-for-profit organization based in Zurich, Switzerland, and oversees research centers in Palo Alto, San Francisco, and Zurich. I believe what you refer is to the Internet Computer. I do understand your actual intent, and it is not your responsibility to make that clear. It is ours.
To understand what the Internet Computer is, it really helps to have concrete vantage points. I will choose a developer:
1.From the POV of a dapp or Smart Contract developer:
The Internet Computer gives you key and concrete benefits: 100x faster, 100x cheaper, can host your entire app.
The Internet Computer is built to host applications first and foremost. This means it needs to be 10-100x richer and more complex than a settlement layer.
You can have a Canister (read: smart contract) that can store data at orders of magnitude cheaper than say ETH. For context, rough estimates are that it would cost $5-$50 what would take hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars on something like ETH.
You can have a canister that serves up its own front-end (JS, HTML, CSS) so you can have your entire app on decentralized computing. The dirty secret of most dapps is that they have their front-end code served from centralized providers like AWS, Azure, IBM, and most of their backend, all of which then talk to a smart contract. We want the entire app to be able to exist "on-chain".
The Internet Computer is WAY faster. Our aim is to have query ("reads") and update ("writes") that are comparable to what consumers expect. This means the IC has to be orders of magnitude faster than other blockchains. See: How fast is the Internet Computer
You can use tokenization to create mechanisms to create open internet services
You could make an argument that other benefits (like censorship resistance) and tamperproof ALSO exist in other blockchain platforms so I focused on the ones above
The computational model for the Internet Computer makes it possible to build modern app. In contrast, traditional smart contracts are actually quite limited.... or put simply: Since smart contracts are Turing complete, you theoretically could build Uber by chaining LOTS of smart contracts... practically speaking, you wouldn't do that just like it’s theoretically possible go build software app using excel... but you probably wouldn’t as app gets beyond the basics.
Source: https://medium.com/dfinity/a-technical-overview-of-the-internet-computer-f57c62abc20f
2. From the POV of a blockchain enthusiast:
The Internet Computer can update itself by on-chain governance. That sounds silly, but is actually quite amazing and no other project can do this at this scale. Tezos has governance (and is a pioneer on governance), but it is compute capacity is very limited.
A centralized app like Facebook probably has hundreds of deploys and updates to production. In a decentralized world, it takes a lot of time and energy to convince enough people to move across versions. Sometimes even years. The Internet Computer is designed to be easy to update. All that needs to happen is that token holders vote on-chain for a proposal to update and voila... it updates. No having to convince miners or having conventions or anything. The IC can update anything about itself using the Network Nervous Systems. In the IC, the token holder's control. The consensus of the project is not by the infrastructure (or miners), but by everyone who has tokens, the entire community. The Computer has tamperproofness so infrastructure providers do not make 2 + 2 = 5, but everyone is part of the direction.
Did that help? I don't think I nailed ELI5 so tell me where I fell short so I can help clarify.