r/devops
•
u/suman087
•
Sep 12 '26
•
1
1
1
Architecture The end of Software Engineering
102
u/Mysterious_Pea_4042 Sep 12 '26
I'm curious why AI companies target software engineering specifically and no one create Claude sales or Claude Management as assistant to other roles
50
u/rayreaper Sep 12 '26
Companies have to sell to someone, and in B2B that usually means management or whoever controls the budget. Sales will probably be next, no doubt, but engineering is also a huge, highly visible cost centre. If the business sees engineers as an expense rather than a source of ideas and competitive advantage, they're inevitably going to look for ways to reduce that cost.
8
u/Jiuholar Sep 12 '26
Because the people making them are software engineers lol. It's what they know best. Makes sense for it to be the first field of focus.
5
u/Mal_Dun Sep 13 '26
It's not only this. Code is text. You can express is through pure text and problems in code can be dealt with with relatively little noise.
Pure math has a similar "problem". It leaves in a clean logical and formalized world.
Guess why autonomous driving isn't solved yet but code is more and more and millennium problems in mathematics are now solved with AI assistance.
The next frontier is our real world with all its noise and fuzziness which is alot harder to tackle for AI due to its complexity, but our formalized world which was accessible to only a few humans is now conquered by AI due to its nature.
However, I believe that does not mean the end. Now that we can tackle the idealized models like Programming and math with AI, we can allow now more fuzziness there too and use AI assistance to tackle ways of programming and mathematical problems that were not thinkable before.
1
u/morpt Sep 17 '26
exactly. code, and mathematics are easily verifiable so LLMs can train and train and verify results with little to no human input until they’re very good at their tasks. a solution is either right or wrong
other industries are a bit more amorphous
9
u/Dalailamadingdongs Sep 12 '26
Because you would need domain expertise in these fields
-3
u/Mysterious_Pea_4042 Sep 12 '26
AI has those knowledge, targeting SE probably has many other reasons. a visible one is the cost. coding rarely was bottleneck anyway. looks like coding tools earns most money for Anthropic and other providers
7
u/durple Cloud Whisperer Sep 12 '26
AI does not have knowledge. It has text prediction, a large body of learning material, and clever algorithms to turn that into something that is often quite useful but also is prone to errors. This is why the sane folks using AI keep chanting the mantra "human in the loop". The human makes the decisions, validates the AI output. They need the expertise.
3
3
u/True_Skin7151 Sep 12 '26
Off late, tech CEOs have been more willing to buy snake oil than anyone else. Blockchain, new frameworks, and now AI. And AI comes with the best promise of all ie getting rid of the biggest expense to a software dependent business aka engineers.
3
u/allo37 Sep 12 '26
Well, programming is kinda self-validating right? The compiler tells you if/where you screwed up, ideally you have tests to tell you if everything is working more or less right. Often you can validate your work right inside your computer and quickly. This is important for AI agents because they tend to fuck up...a lot lol. But since they can validate and iterate quickly, it works out.
For things with a much longer validation loop that involves going outside the computer (like marketing), it's much trickier.
At least, that's my theory / experience.
1
u/dovahkiin315 Sep 13 '26
This is not a theory but actual facts and also its not true just in the runtime context - when new model is being trained they are using exactly this logic to perform reinforcement learning training with coding examples which are completely verifiable (either it works or not) so its also much easier to train such model for math and coding insted of for example philosophy
3
u/gunsofbrixton Sep 12 '26
Nobody’s given you the real answer which is 1) abundant training corpus and 2) easily verified outputs for reinforcement learning
3
u/dovahkiin315 Sep 13 '26
People are mostly very wrong in other replies so I will answer based on what actual AI researchers are telling:
Reason: You verify if code is good by running it and seeing if it works or not. That makes it very easy to perform coding and math training on the AI models and make them good at it.
Reason: Programing LANGUAGE and scripting LANGUAGE are LANGUAGES and AI models we are dealing with are Large LANGUAGE models. I hope this is self explanatory.
Reason: If you automate creation of computer programs that leads in the long run to replacing all other people because you are gravitating towads infinitely fast and infinitely good development which leads to generation of high quallity programs like ones running in delivery drones, ones looking at X-Ray and CT images in hospital, ones overlooking sattelite images and locating natural hazards, etc. - essentially replacing other roles in society.
2
2
u/willitbechips Sep 12 '26
Software is just first in line as code is highly structured.
The others are already in progress and will catch up.
2
u/danekan Sep 12 '26
They definitely have. My husband is a cro. The podcasts I hear often reference ai as a 10x multiplier meaning a single person can now do the equivalent of 10 humans if they have a well laid out framework. The biggest problem is finding people who are good at it all. There’s a fallacy too where the best sales people are least willing to want to change to an agentic workflow but the worst are most receptive to it. And that goes back to still then finding good people who can manage it. The role is now a manager of ai for us all in the future
2
u/patrickpdk Sep 12 '26
Once you can build software you can build anything. I think once they conquer software they will start building systems for all the other knowledge careers
1
1
u/durple Cloud Whisperer Sep 12 '26
The AI providers are providing tools to build more AI.
Other companies are using that to build sales, management, and all sorts of other functionality.
1
u/BetterWhereas3245 Sep 17 '26
Engineering is a cost center for most companies. They see us as an expensive necessary evil, because most companies are not tech first. The same reason why outsourcing, contracting, etc. have been so popular decades before LLMs got here is that same reason.
0
Sep 12 '26
[deleted]
6
u/TehBrian Sep 13 '26
Fuuuuck. You’re so right. So if SWE could hypothetically be done by AI, as the rich business guys are hoping, what will be replacement position in society, one that can fill the role that SWE has filled for the last while? Based on skill alone, not connections, etc?
0
Sep 13 '26
[deleted]
3
u/TehBrian Sep 14 '26
:( What do I do then, other than be an activist for my beliefs, to set my future self up for success?
2
u/mirke93 Sep 14 '26
You reminded me of the main points why I loved IT. Unfortunately I already feel nostalgic. I was aware that we are probably living in golden era with free internet and everything. And also hoped corrupted politicians will not figure out how to destroy this very healthy economic branch. But yeah… eventually money and power finds a way to destroy nice things. I expect to speak to new generations how once we had equal opportunity and free internet. As I assume that will be more and more restricted…
0
Sep 14 '26
[deleted]
1
u/ProfanedArbiter Sep 19 '26
It still exists, just not where it used to
Communities like r/suckless, r/plan9 (ignore all the slop please), the BSD's, and others all have active members that really care about cool software and the communities they build.
It's not really on reddit anymore, but it's in weird little discord and xmpp groups, mailing lists, and irc
2
u/piminto Sep 17 '26
Really felt that plastic laptop and crappy Internet thing. I'd hotspot off my data plan and download the videos from udemy at the library back when I was learning.
65
u/m4nf47 Sep 12 '26
I'm already a plumber, it's just pipelines bloody everywhere full of other people's shit.
55
u/Justbehind Sep 12 '26
Well, we still need software... Who's gonna built that? Nurses, carpenters and mechanics?
69
u/IceMichaelStorm Sep 12 '26
AI is the official answer.
Or from business side: everyone!
flies away
18
u/defk3000 Sep 12 '26
Commoditized Coding is the new buzz word.. Quickly followed by an oldie but goodie Synergy.
1
u/Ok_Ambassador7752 Sep 14 '26
will there still be a place for the old nugget and favourite of many a project manager 'agile'?
15
10
u/Rojeitor Sep 12 '26 •
![]()
Everyone: "whats this post on x? Databases are dead, store your data with vibe coded local storage"
9
1
25
u/ninishi_224 Sep 12 '26
Let AI come and do their thing and then when it all comes crashing down, we'd be in high demand!!
13
u/Sinnedangel8027 DevOps Sep 12 '26
Yeah... but I don't want to sort through the shit to fix it. It's going to be a damn nightmare
5
22
15
u/Dry-Philosopher-2714 Sep 12 '26
I've read the code. I wouldn't trust those people with the pipes in my house.
5
u/admiral_nivak Sep 12 '26
It’s just a leak, all pipes have leaks, it’s normal. That will be another £50 per hour to fix the leak.
2
u/Dry-Philosopher-2714 Sep 12 '26
So, the leak is a feature, not a bug?
4
u/admiral_nivak Sep 12 '26
Oh yes, leak, water feature, fountain, all the same thing, in fact, I should have charged you more! That’s another £200 please.
11
7
6
u/Jonteponte71 Sep 12 '26
I’m closer to retirement then the start of my carrier. I’m not sure I will be in this bussiness the full distance. I’m thinking about doing something completely different the last few years, like driving a bus or something. Nothing to physically demanding. I’m not they only one thinking about it either. I don’t think I know anyone who fully expect to go the distance and retire in this bussiness🤷♂️
5
u/NaranjaPollo Sep 12 '26
Haha, I actually had a colleague become a plumber back in 2019. He was just over engineering. He’s actually doing really good for himself at the current moment.
1
u/wyclif Oct 03 '26
As long as you're physically capable of doing the job and have good mobility, there's nothing about plumbing that can't easily be learned by someone who used to be an engineer. And I suspect the pay is better than people think, especially if you start your own business.
5
u/Hairy-Pension3651 Sep 12 '26
Wouldn‘t it make more sense to keep SW engineers and replace managers through AI?
2
u/wheresmyflan Sep 12 '26
Spoken like a true engineer. Of course that makes more sense. But when was the last time anything the people making decisions chose sense? They aren’t going to be laying themselves off any time soon.
5
u/bourgeoisie_whacker Sep 12 '26
This is just like how Uber is going to be the end of Taxi's. The only reason why uber had a shot of disrupting anything is because of the ridiculous amount of VC money backing. Now its just as expensive as taking a taxi if not more :/. Just like with Uber all these LLM's are heavily subsidized. When Anthropic or Openai need to start making a profit my company is going to weep crocodile tears at the bill.
3
u/Mal_Dun Sep 13 '26
You mean if these companies have a monopoly after getting anyone else out of business, they suddenly ramp up the prices?
Why did no one warn us about this? /s
9
u/WatercressNumerous51 Sep 12 '26
I been doing this for 40 years. It must suck to have just gotten a degree n the past few years and be outta work.
4
u/logicSynth Sep 13 '26
I really hope most of my time won't be spent trying to decide which to focus on... Practical plumbing or plumbing design patterns. As usual I have always been an advocate for real results, so a working plumbing system is what I should learn first.
2
10
u/elitesense Sep 12 '26 edited Sep 12 '26
I'm still not seeing it. All the AI tooling my org has experimented with writes absolutely shit software. It can't do anything distributed. It has no concept of high level architecture and keeping track of all the different moving parts beyond a very basic system. Not without constantly providing defined skills and expensive context.
It can lay down the tedious stuff but it can't actually "engineer" anything novel. The human still has to give the clear defined instructions and write contextual tooling for it. Maybe I just haven't seen this miracle toolset yet but Opus, etc is really just like a first year junior with no human reasoning/critical thinking.
At least with how the tech stands today: The only people that should be scared are probably the people that were always just going to be coders, not software engineers/architects.
EDIT: I should mention it is excellent at quickly knowing syntax specifics without lengthy documentation searches. Love that part of the tooling. Autofill on steroids essentially. It's also great at compiling data sets, organizing/summarizing data. Giving it lots of credit there. Trying to give it credit where it's due
2
u/Leasj Sep 13 '26
For log analysis it's insanely good
2
u/elitesense Sep 13 '26
Yes for sure. Anything that involves aggregating data together to present in a meaningful way (logs, metrics, fleet config dumps, or even things like commit histories/jira history/business intelligence). None of that is "engineering" though, which I guess is still my original point.
1
u/drosmi Sep 15 '26
Yeah we’re replacing our “oncall” alerting with an “incident management platform”. Can’t wait to dig in and see how well the ai sre is at aggregating incident data.
2
u/Intelligent-Mix5321 Sep 14 '26
My concern as someone coming into the field is that tenured experience has stopped being passed on. Junior devs are and even interns are immediately being expected to produce the output of senior devs. Meanwhile they are not in anyway in the same position as our senior devs were when they entered the field. We are being expected to operate on a much larger scale with a much larger blast radius than junior devs ever have. All while higher ups turn a blind eye and pretend theres nothing wrong with us running off hopes and dreams instead of tenured intuition
23
u/espirroeletrico Sep 12 '26
Well, it was good while it lasted.
I'm still in the middle of an existential life crisis because almost a decade of my experience became obsolete over the last year, and now I'm basically a glorified push button operator instead.
On a more positive note, I think the key to the next stage of all this is balance, and forcing myself to do some things "manually" every now and then to keep challenging myself.
3
3
u/Most-Comparison-1674 Sep 12 '26
I thought devops and infra side was faring much better than traditional software engineering?
Recently seeing a lot of platform engineering roles
3
u/Gainncome Sep 13 '26
DevOps engineers becoming plumbers is barely a career change. We’ve been fixing broken pipelines for years.
3
u/BlakkMajik3000 Remover of Deployment Friction Sep 13 '26
I learned to write software in the early days of .NET.
We had just came off the dotcom crash that also promised to kill mainframes. Or was cloud going to kill mainframes?
My point is, every major shift starts with insane promises and massive investment that eventually makes a few people insanely wealthy and leave the rest to pick up the pieces.
Happened with:
COBOL
Agile
DevOps
AI
Etc.
Just have to wait it out(which sucks doubly for someone like me).
1
u/Zealousideal_Tie_426 Sep 13 '26
This is profoundly different though.
2
u/BlakkMajik3000 Remover of Deployment Friction Sep 13 '26
If you cut past the hype, it’s really not.
1
Sep 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/BlakkMajik3000 Remover of Deployment Friction Sep 24 '26
How so? I’ve watched this industry evolve through the last 30 years and read about the rest.
Do you realize people use filing cabinets when databases exist? Because the need for something doesn’t magically go away because something else better comes along.
You won’t get rich from selling databases. You won’t get rich from blockchain. You won’t get rich from AI. A select few companies will profit immensely and the rest will go back to filing cabinets, event based systems that don’t expose your ENTIRE ledger to the internet, and regular old CI/CD practices that have been getting the job done for the last 10-15 years.
2
2
u/mcloide Sep 12 '26
Interesting. I'm sure I seen the same book a while back when Dreamweaver was released.
2
u/Tricky_Ordinary_4799 Sep 12 '26
"How to compete with all other engineers who went to plumbing while customer base (people displaced by AI) is shrinking"
2
2
1
u/ctwg Sep 12 '26
Would Claude give you a blueprint to launch an anti-ai hate campaign to sway public opinion away from ai?
1
u/nemofbaby2014 Sep 12 '26
While ai can code it’s not every so you still need someone to guide it also costs way too much currently so is heavily subsidized by private equity
1
Sep 25 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/nemofbaby2014 Sep 25 '26
For now until it becomes way too expensive then it’s cheaper to just hire humans using cloud agents costs a crap ton already but once the bubble bursts I imagine that price will double or triple and if they go local then that requires techs to keep it running so you’re still hiring more people either way
1
u/Amazing_Prize_1988 Sep 12 '26
The plumber, electrician fallacy is just the learn to code! Saturation and robotics will kill trades!
1
u/adda_with_tea Sep 12 '26
we will make good plumbers tbh. a whole lot of code was indeed just plumbing and connecting systems.
1
1
1
1
u/pluviofiele Sep 13 '26
AI makes implementation cheaper. It doesn’t make system ownership cheaper. In production, the difficult part is usually preserving behavior across auth, state, migrations, dependencies, failure paths, observability and rollback. If code output increases faster than our ability to verify those things, software engineering becomes more important, not less.
1
1
u/Strong_Draft_588 Sep 16 '26
I would request watch what happens if we completely out source to AI in above very funny video
1
u/PikeSyke Sep 16 '26
Well to be completely honest this feels likes ragebait, especially on this sub :)))))) The knowledge you have on this job will easily allow you to convert Infra or Datacenter maintainance guy and these jobs will be desirable even in the AI era, especially in the AI era. I love also the software part and building software, that's one of the reasons I am in this job but if I'll have to switch to just infra and let some AI build the software that's fine as well, I get to eat everyday, fuck it, we ball.
1
1
u/james-ransom Oct 06 '26
At this point there are two groups.
SWEs that are smart enough to know it's over and
SWEs that are going to go practice python harder.
Most employers will ban hand written code soon.
1
1
1
u/Zestyclose_Fun_2963 Oct 11 '26
Joke’s on them, I’ve been doing plumbing for years. Finding leaks in a system someone else built, with zero documentation, and getting paged at 3am when it floods. :)
0
-7
-13
u/deepturned180isdeep Sep 12 '26
AI implementation is simply a newer practice of determining new standards of automation.
Figure it out
-5
u/AdmissibilityScience Sep 12 '26
Maybe things improve from here and people or systems become elevated.
4
0
Sep 12 '26
[deleted]
215
u/IT_Grunt Sep 12 '26
Well you see, with AI, managers and leadership know all the codes.
131
100
u/trannus_aran Sep 12 '26 •
![]()
Just like with low code, now regular people can code and we don't have to pay these icky programmers! Sorry I meant no code, sorry I meant UML, sorry I meant java, sorry I meant cobol, sorry I meant fortran, sorry I
65
u/generic-d-engineer ClickOps Sep 12 '26
Right? Don’t forget Visual Basic, Microsoft Frontpage, and Power BI.
I honestly think the demand for software engineers is going to go up, not down. It’s just the demand for coders goes down, but coding stopped being the secret sauce of good software a long time ago.
Any good software engineering book talks about architecture, methods, all of that, and the last thing they actually talk about is code.
The paradox here is that the amount of output is going to go way up, and the amount of entrepreneurship is going to go way up. This creates more opportunities for everyone.
Dude even using the latest and greatest models, people still have to chase around prompts just to get the freakin submit button on the right place in the page.
9
8
4
2
u/Ornery-Concentrate-5 Sep 12 '26
the submit button thing is way too real. watched an agent burn like 4 tries clicking a button that had moved because a modal hadn't finished animating in yet. it just kept confidently clicking the old coordinates
0
Sep 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/VariationSimilar3354 Sep 13 '26
They spend 20 million to do that. It's powerful but the money it's burning is unjustifiable
-1
Sep 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/VariationSimilar3354 Sep 13 '26
Tech roles will merge and change but it won't go away, It'll evolve as i see it… evolve into a gracious turd that will linger on the butthole as a residue that the management can't just clean it no matter the amount of tp you throw at it.
Some are saying it'll be a person that knows business that can turn into a product job type role will last but i think you'll still need technically competent people that know how to save cost. Throwing millions in token to make a substandard system will always have a massive tech debt later, it'll fail on prod, on scale, on security and worse at the phantom places that we can't map to.
I don't know if ai will be competent to do that with gpt 69 version.
2
u/Embarrassed_Aside576 Sep 13 '26
OpenAI just robbed Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge
1
Sep 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Embarrassed_Aside576 Sep 13 '26
I think that won't happen unless they make an (actual) AGI. In my opinion, they are just pretending they could make it.
2
Sep 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/trannus_aran Sep 13 '26
From everything I've read, it looks like it's very much not the case that it solved it in any real way
→ More replies (0)1
14
u/InterestedBalboa Sep 12 '26
With AI we are all managers, you were an engineer now you tell AI what to do….
1
27
u/SevenM Sep 12 '26
By and large, those people exist to give themselves a job. They are all trained in taking every opportunity they can to protect their position. There was no way they would let AI benefit anyone but themselves.
40
7
u/LonelyBuddhaa Sep 12 '26
Ikr its really interesting how the agenda is against SWE but it should be other way around.
4
u/Dry-Cod7297 Sep 12 '26
Why would middle management ever get if of themselves they control the hiring process
3
u/xagarth Sep 12 '26
You have HR bros? Where I am it's sis all the way. One sis, two sis, three sis go! No bros there.
1
u/BuHoGPaD Oct 17 '26
Hey, sorry to bother you, but I'm curious how did this turn out ?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/kxc3ru/5950x_crack_is_this_lethal_it_works_just_fine_forDid it work alright afterwards?
3
5
u/Candid-Cup4159 Sep 12 '26
Was it? Then why was it taught to do art and code first?
0
Sep 12 '26
[deleted]
-1
u/elfwriter Sep 12 '26
There are many books written about how to manage people well.
7
u/VariationSimilar3354 Sep 12 '26
Did this literature ever reach the management?
3
2
u/alexklaus80 Sep 13 '26
I think the argument here should be more about the direct effectiveness of the data to the actual job they do. Coding is much simpler in terms of direct relationships between those recorded knowledge and what they actually need to do, whreas maangement work has higher complexity.
And that doesn't quite line up with your first statement "AI was supposed to kick these guys first" - I always thought what it was supposed to kick first is those that AI can replace easily and quikly, which is coders and designers for the reason you have mentioned.
1
u/zomiaen Sep 13 '26
There are not exceptional verifiable data sets that can mark an output easily "good" or "bad". Code can be verified. A lot of results can't, which means reward training is very hard.
2
u/p1xlized Sep 12 '26
Management/ HR bros on average have room temperature IQ, but because our society is run on nepotism all of these bottom feeders for some reason always survive...
1
u/derprondo Sep 13 '26
In my org it's the sales bros, and now we the platform team have to do support for sales bros doing vibe coding. So of course we just use AI to auto respond to them to tell them to open cases with the cloud platform providers 😂
-14
u/TotallyObviousBot Sep 12 '26
you're basically just admitting that the only reason you got paid is because you knew how to work the machine, and now that the people above you can just directly work the machine they don't need you anymore
why would AI replace the people who actually get paid to have ideas instead of the people who are just getting paid to translate the ideas into technical language? people can now make things on their computer without needing to spend a week reading documentation and suddenly your experience is worth nothing
congratulations, you've become an automobile assembly line worker circa 1974
9
u/rayreaper Sep 12 '26
Crazy to think that engineers don't have ideas, and that management or the C-suite are somehow the only people capable of coming up with them.
A huge part of tech's history is engineers and scientists coming up with ideas, building things themselves, and eventually starting companies because they wanted the freedom to pursue those ideas.
Silicon Valley is full of examples of this. The whole startup ecosystem wasn't originally about putting business people in charge of engineers. A big part of its history was actually about giving technically minded people the freedom, funding and ownership to turn their ideas into companies. Obviously, businesses need good management to scale but treating engineers as people who merely execute ideas handed down from the C-suite completely ignores a huge part of where the technology industry came from.
-7
u/TotallyObviousBot Sep 12 '26
repeat that to yourself to keep your shanty warm on those cold san francisco streets
5
u/VariationSimilar3354 Sep 12 '26
having ideas =/= creating products, anyone can come up with bs ideas, not everyone makes a product.
knowing code is like the 10% of the problem, there's scaling, error handling, testing, auth, cost optimization etc that ai still struggles despite of bazillion tokens and context.
I'd love to see them make a product and see it shat itself when users try to do anything with it.
-3
u/TotallyObviousBot Sep 12 '26
so like basic engineering principles that have been well known and easily learned for decades now? wow sure hope none of them have YouTube
0
Sep 12 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Charming-Animator866 Sep 12 '26
it’s like he’s paying you directly from his pocket, and become so happy when he sees you online off hours
-1
Sep 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/james-ransom Sep 12 '26
As a SE of 20 years... sure bro. There is zero chance corps will want human code in a matter of months. Even right now, human code is being rejected at many corps.
0
u/phxees Sep 12 '26
AI is able to design and implement solutions to some of our most complex problems. It’s only a matter of time before AI can solve the rest.
Today people with no experience in software engineering don’t know to ask for a solution with tests and code coverage checks or to implement a solution with scalable micro services and a reliable gitops pipeline, but tools are on the way which will help with that part.
0
u/Scholes_SC2 Sep 12 '26
Yes and no. Software engineers are still needed but in a very very reduced proportion. It really sucks, i really liked this profession

312
u/Independent_Sign_395 Sep 12 '26 •
Sam and Dario are very good marketers. They have created so much hype and convinced too leadership that ai can 10x their productivity, just like it did for them. As a result top leadership expects unreasonable deadlines and we as developers are forced to just prompt and paste. This feeds their illusion that ai is indeed 10xing their productivity, tech debt keeps piling up until it blows up. But we haven't seen this yet