r/developersIndia • • Oct 25 '25

General Is this problem solveable with a week/end hackathon ?

Post image

Assume data is on multiple different sites, PDFs. Let's design a HLD solution to aggregate the data, put it in a vector db, inferencing with light LLM.

Sites could be offical govt. ones, news article. Or data could be gather through people via small webapp.

7.4k Upvotes

370 comments sorted by

525

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

Ready to contribute if you really got access to data all over India

223

u/hello_friend_77 Oct 25 '25

developers need to file RTI to get this type of info i guess

31

u/Infinite_Explanation Oct 26 '25

We'll have to safeguard ourselves before we start filing RTI's, there has been cases of goons reaching to one's house before the RTI info

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

29

u/Comprehensive_Eye_96 Full-Stack Developer Oct 26 '25

I own a software company and I'm ready to put people on this if we have the data.

9

u/Available-Fee1691 Oct 26 '25

Data is already available publically almost all of the data like the delay they do, quotation they need etc etc. but the problem is it is decentralised,like I made this presentation in clg regarding this roadways and Highways, and i used to hop from place to place to collect it, from bills to annual some magazine thing they publish for NHAI, then we even got some invoices ig. 

So like it's a mine literally if some journalist or anyone dig this thing they can get a huge hypocrisy in the gov talks and deeds and like adhi gov ko nanga kar sakte hai.

9

u/thatDataWizard Oct 26 '25

Ready to contribute with data from a particular district as well - starting something nationwide in one go would be difficult, let's start small and scale based on requirement and data availability

→ More replies (1)

6

u/samarthrawat1 Software Engineer Oct 25 '25

I'm in too. Add me to the thread.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

761

u/Impossible-Mood9274 Oct 25 '25

This Idea was in my project list for long and problems that I figure out was

  1. Data to be decentralised.

  2. Total Transparency over who is giving the contract to whom proper billing documents and other paper work. 3.It will make them accountable and that will not be accepted by those corrupt babus

152

u/Key_Investment_6818 Oct 25 '25

exactly , i too have this idea and many others which i had to scrape because of govt doesn't provide us the fkin data

76

u/Impossible-Mood9274 Oct 25 '25

How will they give the data they also do know that it will be start of courption end

39

u/Key_Investment_6818 Oct 25 '25

Exactly..those assholes will never let it out...I think the best for us would be to find the foundation stone and see if it covers the required information 😂

33

u/A_random_zy Software Engineer Oct 26 '25

RTI and crowdsourcing. For example for my city my dad knows every thing that is being built who all are eating money which contractor's stuff is bad etc through connections. I could fill that data for my local area anonymously.

15

u/maa_ka_bigda_ladla Oct 26 '25

Anonymous data wont work. The data that we will show should be authentic and backed by proof.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/sadgandhi18 Oct 26 '25

We can't make it anonymous, because then rich people can influence it and make even more money

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

75

u/temporarilyyours Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Ok I had a thought about this, how to address the data transparency problem enough to atleast get this launched:-

A combination of Pull and Push data(Road-dit model):-

Pull: site scrapers (tender portals, MoRTH/NHAI/state PWDs, audit reports), RSS/press releases, sitemap crawlers.

Push: citizen uploads (PDFs, photos), RTI responses (file upload), newsroom partners. forms for “Upload RTI response” > auto-OCR > prefilled entities for reviewer.

You’d have registered users and some then admins. for each road/ highway, there’s pull data displayed and push data options to add entry, edit, request, report etc.

Every field shows a source badge (doc type, date, issuer) linked to the webpage or PDF etc

Secondly, Confidence scores. “Contractor: ABC Infra Pvt Ltd (0.92)”). Lower scores flagged for review to admins or a queue for regd users. Or you can have “Unverified”, “Verified by doc”, “Admin-verified”. Only verified claims feed aggregates.

Conflicts: if two sources disagree, show both with dates and let timeline/context speak.

Disputes: parties can submit corrections with documents; changes are logged and reversible.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/directionless_force Oct 26 '25

You forgot to include cost for your own protection after you make this a reality.

11

u/temporarilyyours Oct 25 '25

You can even use some open source map which has road networks of India and let users tag the roads with some form of supporting link or photograph

9

u/temporarilyyours Oct 25 '25

Ok I had a thought about this, how to address the data transparency problem enough to atleast get this launched:-

A combination of Pull and Push data:-

Pull: site scrapers (tender portals, MoRTH/NHAI/state PWDs, audit reports), RSS/press releases, sitemap crawlers.

Push: citizen uploads (PDFs, photos), RTI responses (file upload), newsroom partners. forms for “Upload RTI response” > auto-OCR > prefilled entities for reviewer.

You’d have registered users and some moderators. for each road/ highway, there’s pull data displayed and push data options to add entry, edit, request, report etc.

Every field shows a source badge (doc type, date, issuer) linked to the webpage or PDF etc

Secondly, Confidence scores. “Contractor: ABC Infra Pvt Ltd (0.92)”). Lower scores flagged for review to mods or a queue for regd users. Or you can have “Unverified”, “Verified by doc”, “Admin-verified”. Only verified claims feed aggregates.

Conflicts: if two sources disagree, show both with dates and let timeline/context speak.

Disputes: parties can submit corrections with documents; changes are logged and reversible.

3

u/hello_friend_77 Oct 25 '25

Actually the data is public but the problem is something else

2

u/cursed_with_blesses Oct 27 '25

It can be done. RTIs can be a tool. But then validity of RTI is in question and unnecessary delays

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Friendly-Web8816 Oct 29 '25

Let's create a group for interested people to discuss then

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

555

u/Aniket363 Full-Stack Developer Oct 25 '25

If you somehow end up making it, it would be taken down and pretty sure those scumbags might file fake FIRs too

166

u/iamrealfuckboy Oct 25 '25

can making it open source solve this problem?

159

u/kakashisen7 Oct 25 '25

No it has to be hosted somewhere and someone has to own it to host

A better approach would be to build a site that does this on demand own might be able to getaway by calling it just a data aggregator/ crawler

→ More replies (9)

57

u/Star_kid9260 Software Engineer Oct 25 '25

Like a Blockchain would make more sense and it has to be hosted in Pakistan or some country we absolutely hate like China.

61

u/IndianBarney DevOps Engineer Oct 25 '25

if someone host it in Pakistan , then phir to Gov will be like funded by OSAMA, turkey blah blah instead of taking accountability

13

u/lonelyroom-eklaghor Student Oct 25 '25

YOLO for a frenemy like Russia

38

u/PsySmoothy Oct 25 '25

But this will solve most if not all the corruption in Road making considering the public will have access to the contractor of the road before there's even an incident.

28

u/CaptainAwesome1412 Oct 25 '25

It's still worth trying. The information he mentions are part of public records and accessible by RTIs in most cases

If it gains some momentum and positive attention, it can gain support too

12

u/jadhavsaurabh Software Engineer Oct 25 '25

Yes fir will be filed

6

u/Quick-Car-5431 Oct 25 '25

have a plan Let's create this and I will handle the concerns about backlash and fir i have solutions for that. After we make it if anything goes wrong the government will face backlash too. But we need to build a strong community and collaborate with some influencers. and make content aon instragram around it I will handle this since I run a marketing and media agency and know how to do this. If anyone's worried, I can set up servers and handle data collection as well. So, let's form a group and make it happen!

2

u/Comfortable-Rock3733 Oct 26 '25

There are ways to host it without anyone knowing who did it using darkness, and bounce off sites across domains, something done by torrents and lot of free movie sites a lot, although what is planned here is legal, but this might be a safer approach to keep owner info hidden.

→ More replies (1)

131

u/Proud-Art5358 Oct 25 '25

Ask nitin gadkari to give that data, ask him to make it mandatory for all states to do this as well. No I'm not joking, ask him, we all need to ask. First step for this website is to ask him for data.

29

u/Proud-Art5358 Oct 25 '25

Tweet him, we got your back

13

u/Proud-Art5358 Oct 25 '25

If it's not available already, ofcourse

7

u/Still_Gene_ Senior Engineer Oct 25 '25

deploy malware

→ More replies (1)

93

u/lordphoenix81 Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

The 1st assumption "data availability". No conventional tech is gonna solve that.

You have different municipal bodies, one builds the road, another removes for their work & then someone else has to fix it.

The names used in contracts will be some dummy company unless it's a visible project.

That'll become a game of ringa ringa roses.

source: I know this from a person who files RTIs regularly. Few of those queries get a response, most will be ignored unless pushed hard. In one case it got dangerous, so now they just file & accept whatever response they get.

conclusion: I say this as an optimist, the actual situation is beyond fecked. Is there hope? 100%.

What is the solution?

hard choice/long term: "compound interest of deeds", what I mean by that is society is a reflection of the small deeds each & one of us does. Doing the right thing is often the hardest. Sow those seeds today, maybe 2-3 generations down the line they reap the harvest. Participate/be aware of your local politics.

easy choice/short term: unconventional means. That's all I can say.

8

u/mortyfiedr1ck Oct 26 '25

If we do this at a city level, it should be manageable? Also if multiple people ask for the same info through RTI, it'll be hard to bully, I'm guessing. I'm done just complaining.

92

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

I wish I could contribute but I don't know much about development but it sounds good but I think projects like these need time and patience so I don't think so that it can be completed in a hackathon

51

u/simple-weirdo Student Oct 25 '25

It's a simple crud but the issue is to get the "correct" data regarding this like.how much was spent and where and for that most needed thing is transparency

→ More replies (4)

19

u/cooooooldude1 Oct 25 '25

Was looking if there’s a database with this kind of info, came across this website: https://www.nhidcl.com/en/current-status/

I looked at a couple of random states and found it funny/worrying that a company which managed to get a project of 450 crores uses a gmail account :’)

14

u/takken_123 Oct 25 '25

Biggest challenge here is collecting trustworthy data from official sources—most info is scattered and not API friendly. But if we somehow crack that we can also add tracking of all the bids for each road/tender, it would also add real transparency, since government contracts should have this data public anyway.

13

u/Caplame Oct 25 '25

You need to file RTI for every project then.

3

u/SecretRefrigerator4 Full-Stack Developer Oct 26 '25

Can't be done by any individual it can be done by a big organisation with power, independence and right intent. Something that NGOs can do.

16

u/WomenRepulsor Oct 25 '25

It took me 5 years to realize Nitin Gadkari is all PR and no ground work. Man is only good at getting people to dream and give interviews where he isn't asked any questions which hold him accountable for anything.

12

u/WriedGuy ML Engineer Oct 25 '25

First let them make data public then will see into the implementation part

4

u/Amar2107 Oct 25 '25

Yeah, thats what i was thinking where are you going you find the data, then there are these challenges i can think of

  1. Data on multiple source will require scrapping, compiling data into a single file ,with god knows what weight logic.

  2. Constant update on data, if its multiple source then another headache.

  3. Weeding out illegitimate data.

Then we will talk about other(non dev) challenges.

6

u/jaisukku Oct 25 '25

I'm not sure if people are aware of opendata anymore. There was some noise around it say 4-5 years back. Most data that I've seen from it are aggregates. IMO, we should push the gov to publish more data through this. Especially raw data like companies registrations, tender transactions and so on.

6

u/Puzzleheaded-Year465 Oct 25 '25

No solvable, let me tell you - There is a Quadrilateral Nexus between Politicians, Babus, Police and Judiciary.

Let me explain how- Politicians are advised by the Babus to make the rules/laws which are in their favour, Babus make it fool proof so that they can derive maximum benefit from the people and cover loopholes.

The public has to follow it, if they fail they have to deal with the police and Judiciary which are again a part of the quadrilateral nexus, so a common man is struck in the nexus. No wonder the people belonging to all the 3 govt services are extremely loaded up.

14

u/Mediocre_Lead5119 Oct 25 '25

you can win a prize in hackathon but they never going to implement.

4

u/PsychologyNo7025 Oct 26 '25

We need JIRA to track govt projects.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Head-Program5299 Oct 26 '25

Solvable or not but do you think they really want to solve it ?

4

u/VacationOpposite6121 Oct 26 '25

I build the the simple frontend yesterday, now moving on backend will complete this in a month and post here

2

u/Available-Fee1691 Oct 26 '25

Man please also update on the issue you face for automatic data collection for backend. Like it's not easy probably whole collection process needs manual work ig.

7

u/Ok-Librarian2671 Software Engineer Oct 26 '25

I have been thinking of a diffrent version of this for a longer time. In my version we store data about every govt employee including politicians and then let people rate the them based on his works. People can anonymously add the amount of bribe they paid to that babu bit only issue is ensuring that people are not lying.

4

u/trillionstars Oct 26 '25
  1. You can only get reliable data for senior govt employees. It creates privacy concern as they are just employees.

  2. Some politicians have lot of money and influence which can screw the ratings. There literally fake actual election votes then screwing online ratings won't be big deal.

  3. As you said people can lie.

There is a website called myneta.info which has good amount of info about politicians including declared net worth and police cases filed on them. The reliability of the information is foremost for a platform like what you're describing.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/hillywolf Senior Engineer Oct 25 '25

The Data is pretty complex here. A lot of Governing bodies are responsible for different roads and not all data is online. It's certainly not a weekend project. India is a scalability nightmare.

Also, I don't understand why OP tagged Gadkari here.

3

u/jarvis_124 Oct 26 '25

We need to have centralized software which is used by all municipal corporations to upload data related to every contract which has been given not just roads.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Previous-Elephant626 Student Oct 25 '25

Better idea : put a stone at the side of road with all this info and the contractors helpline in case of reports and their address to protest , carve all the info on road, so bystanders can read.

3

u/Jarden103904 Oct 25 '25

There is a constitional provision called Citizens Charter. Each project must specify details of project, stakeholders, deadline and provision of penalty in case of not meeting deadline or poor delivery and grievance addressing steps.

The problem is CC is a two way binding or pulling system, much like RTI. Citizens should start asking citizen charter of each project just before commencement, and anyone can ask for it. Ryt now, no one asks for CC so government offices do not produce one, but constitutionally they must produce it even if not asked by anyone.

2

u/basonjourne98 Security Engineer Oct 25 '25

Isn’t all this public information already? Should be on NHIDCL website.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Even_Description_776 Oct 25 '25

I already own more VPS then i need.

I can host it for you.

Got VPS location like Russia, China, Indonesia etc

→ More replies (1)

2

u/EntertainmentOnly96 Oct 25 '25

As an indian i am happy that developers are discussing this.

2

u/Horror_Implement_411 Oct 26 '25

Hi...iam.already working on open governance forum...https://github.com/Drewraw/social-record-platform/ ...please check it...we need to see why roads are given to specific person or company first

2

u/Terzaghibitch Oct 27 '25

My insights to this as a civil engineer working for the state government in a small city. You could maybe get data for roads made by NHAI or similar central govt dept. But getting information for roads made by the state govt, district road and building dept., Municipal Corporation, or other smaller dept. is a very difficult task. Moreover, even if the govt. engineer was not involved in corruption, getting one's name on some list is always a long-term headache because in smaller departments, usually one officer is put in charge of 2-3 posts, due to lack of recruitment, so continuous monitoring of quality is difficult.

2

u/Cool-Stuff-5771 Oct 27 '25

Government won't do for sure but an NGO can

2

u/Cool-Stuff-5771 Oct 27 '25

Easiest can be through Google map

2

u/Bottle_Necked Oct 27 '25

You can go to the rti page and request for that info ig

2

u/According-Archer4506 Oct 30 '25

Yeah sure the gov gonna do something LMAO

2

u/Embarrassed-Way-1350 Nov 01 '25

If whatever you think is true to at least a percent, then cpgrams portal would've been useful. State governments like to keep it offline without proper documentation. Very hard to achieve what you're doing without submitting an RTI every hour.

3

u/zeau_ki Oct 25 '25

Gonna try to do this in my next ideathon

3

u/notdank07 Oct 25 '25

Seems like a great project to flex on

1

u/MarzipanOther9535 Oct 25 '25

But how would we even get the info from, even if we wish to web scrape i think it has to exist in the internet atleast and publicly accessible.

1

u/Low_Apartment_1996 Oct 25 '25

I got exact same idea a month back.

1

u/Fury801 Oct 25 '25

Even if you built the application, updating the data and maintaining it and getting govt data would be a herculean task

1

u/No-Suggestion-6734 Oct 25 '25

Yeahh ! Gadhakari should definitely do this !

1

u/fang__yuan_ Oct 25 '25

Dont host it online . Just make it and have it within youself

1

u/BluebirdOdd2708 Oct 25 '25

You can build the platforms in a week but getting the data is a very tedious job especially from the government where they still log books and files.

1

u/Key_Investment_6818 Oct 25 '25

i don't think we have data anywhere , if yes then let me know

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

This is always been part of my imaginary plans . These ,external audits on infra ,rating points for work on infra like credit score ,decentralised data on blockchain etc etc.

1

u/SingerZestyclose3426 Oct 25 '25

Damn.. AI hype is real . People be shoving it everywhere irrespective of the requirements

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ok_Procedure_4690 Student Oct 25 '25

I am in. Every single life is at stake and if gov does not want to do anything, FINE WE WILL DO IT OURSELVES.

1

u/Alone_Ad_348 Oct 25 '25

Bhai tune point toh accha bola hai but ye log usme bhi fabricate karenge

1

u/Ok_Signature_6959 Oct 25 '25

I can make detailed design doc for this and further instructions to develop it via Codex/Claude Code and deployment but I am not gonna take a risk to build it by myself, its too risky and will attract attention from youknowwho people.

1

u/lilkidlj8 Student Oct 25 '25

if anyone actually wants to brainstorm/try building this, im so down to join and help in any way

1

u/Ill-be-remembered Oct 25 '25

Not only roads but all other contracts that govt gives !!!

1

u/apjadhao22 Oct 25 '25

In Maharashtra such data is displayed on all toll plazas

1

u/SKYlikesHentai Oct 25 '25

Dont they release pdfs on this , should be easy to make one

1

u/Interscopian2099x Oct 25 '25

I did make something similar to this in my hackathon. But alas it will never be implemented irl

1

u/avgdick-69 Oct 25 '25

All data should be decentralised! Willing to work on something if anybody comes up with some idea. Somehow it should reduce corruption

1

u/NotAnNpc69 Backend Developer Oct 25 '25

Somebody check if she's still alive and well after this tweet

1

u/Sure-Tax107 Oct 25 '25

We can start small, target mai city like mumbai, bengaluru.

1

u/SigmaCode9 Oct 25 '25

How about making it decentralized? Like using Blockchain

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Aromatic_Display1116 Oct 25 '25

But that would require us to run a llm inhouse .

1

u/twoturtls Software Engineer Oct 25 '25

I am today years old now, but I saw this same idea thread with very similar comments 10 years ago. Back then, some chap actually created a repo on GitHub. I did not follow what happened after, but here we are..

1

u/Wooden_Medium Oct 25 '25

Chee toh sahi bole bt galat admi ko tag kr diye

1

u/maha_Dev Backend Developer Oct 25 '25

The reason no one will let it happen is because government contract is the bread and butter of the entire chain that manages or executes the contract. All the way from the minister, to the bidding machinery to the clerc that approves the billing and the contractor that builds the project. They are so corrupt, what do you think they do when they have to change something in the project? They make the billing pretending like the whole part was executed, raw materials were used, labour was used. So if a statue’s leg was built and then later the plan changed, they charge for the whole statue, not just the leg that was built and pocket everything else. If a JE refuses to play ball, they are intimidated, money is transferred to their account without their permission to blackmail them like they were complicit. A 1 lac project snowballs into 10 from the time the minister approves it, to the time it comes to the contractor because everyone takes their share of taxpayer money.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TheLame0ne Oct 25 '25

We can implement this on top of OSM. Count me in.

1

u/ArticleTotal212 Oct 25 '25

Which company is benefitting from 20% carcinogenic etanol mixing in Petrol and fooling Indians.

1

u/V1P3R_2776 Oct 25 '25

If you find the data, I'll help with the the anonymous hosting side of things.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Impossible-Mood9274 Oct 25 '25

I see there are many Dev's that want to make some change in society let's first create a Telegram Channel and discord then see where It goes dm to join the channel. I am not very good at managing these Telegram or Discord so I will Create someone admin or if you can make the channel then go ahead create and send the invitation link.

1

u/Darksoul00777 Oct 25 '25

Please file rti..it will genuinely take action if..they went to find these information and corruption for that rti and other related to it will come out and people will get arrested. I have seen with my eyes

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

im in if you get the access to the data, I have been thinking about the same for months now

1

u/forlang Oct 25 '25

Bring it on chain so it can’t be tampered and even if does we will have record of it!!

Would love to build it!!

1

u/Sameer_A_Shaikh Oct 25 '25

I'm not a developer and i don't know how to contribute but long in the comment section, i am very proud to see the enthusiasm in all of you guys. I just want to say that even if we can't make it perfect it's worth giving a shot. Why don't we make a mega thread for this and open-source the project so that everyone can contribute in building it. I don't know if I'm making any sense but this idea is too good to be lost in the archives of reddit. Please let's make it happen.

1

u/bradhri Oct 25 '25

One more thing, address and contact info of that contractor must also be made public. Also fire babu and contractor if potholes appear within 5 years

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25

Shouldn't this be done for every penny we pay ? Not just roads.

1

u/NoAd9362 Oct 25 '25

This idea is golden! Instead of pointing fingers like detectives in a soap opera, let’s make a flowchart that proudly displays who did what complete with arrows, cartoon faces, and maybe a dramatic "Not Me!" bubble for extra flair.

1

u/Eastern-Ad4408 Oct 25 '25

Broo I have this idea since I was in my school days long back, but in reality it doesn't gonna happen. That's why I always hope someday all the hidden hackers come together and build such platform and maintain it thats the only way.

1

u/gmsd90 Oct 25 '25

The problem is not the means, its the conviction of the government. 

1

u/crypto3ye Oct 25 '25

Govt should work on public blockchain(s).

1

u/Slight_Loan5350 Oct 25 '25

What makes you think these people won't show fake bills that they are already doing it? Who is going to validate it? Money makes everyone bend in India lol nothings gonna work if you want to make government accountable.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

No we need roads with warranty included within contracts if you want roads to last. If it can be done once it can be done again . Traffic will also have to be systematically diverted and it would take a decade or so before every inch of a city or a town is covered . It still won't solve underlying issues though , so its gonna just be more monkeying around with blame game if implemented and x reasons will be put up. The reason we have crappy roads is because they're designed around fast construction and recurrent maintainence(even if it may not feel fast) . Both can only be solved if you build a city with proper planning . You can make really good roads that won't wash away in the rain but it'll make maintainence infinitely costlier in both time and money especially the haphazard way roads are dug up for random ass things .

1

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

If anyone’s looking for something to start with, You can see Tamilnadu tenders in this portal. You won’t need a tender ID, you can search with for example a city name like Coimbatore.

https://tntenders.gov.in/nicgep/app?page=ResultOfTenders&service=page

Edit: looks like every state has one.

https://onsiteteams.com/eprocurement-login-portals-state-wise-e-procurement-portal-link/amp/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Quick-Car-5431 Oct 25 '25

i have a plan Let's create this and I will handle the concerns about backlash and fir i have solutions for that. After we make it if anything goes wrong the government will face backlash too. But we need to build a strong community and collaborate with some influencers. and make content aon instragram around it I will handle this since I run a marketing and media agency and know how to do this. If anyone's worried, I can set up servers and handle data collection as well. So, let's form a group and make it happen!

1

u/Amazing_Wheel6246 Oct 25 '25

sure a weekend hackathon can get a MVP but getting that messy, govt‑style data? that’s a whole other hackathon in itself. better start by getting a single open API or a PDF dump and stop whining about the rest.

1

u/No-Artichoke9047 Oct 25 '25

The information on contractors might not be available, but we could build an app where users upload a video of their road and we use that to rate the condition to score it. Could use few other sources like pictures from maps etc. this way we can rate and shame at mp/mla level and that will put pressure on the contractors

→ More replies (1)

1

u/uhs198 Oct 26 '25

I am in for this project.

1

u/Green_Ice3516 Oct 26 '25

Ask someone like dhruv rathee to do it, sitting in foreign and giving gyan to others Is not a social work put some actual work if you want the country to improve.

1

u/kid_dark Oct 26 '25

Classic way to get Yeeted of the surface of the Earth by exposing corruption and fraud.

1

u/shitnotalkforyours18 Student Oct 26 '25

Let's go it.

1

u/romanminati Oct 26 '25

NHAI makes or authorises to sub contractors for most of these roads.

They already have a data lake. With all these data points. Toll related data is also with them - even with a granular details. Getting this data sorted should not be a problem.

1

u/AlphaSeeker_07 Oct 26 '25

Tbh - it's time for youth to come together and form party for bharat nirman

1

u/PawPawNeWaarKarwaDee Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

I remember a reporter guy, who tried to do similar thing for a single road in an area of chattisgarh, in more old school way, and later, his body was found in septic tank.

Learning: These kind of things need a huge group effort and unity among people to bear any fruit, like what happened in Nepal. Otherwise, few handful people doing it will get easily picked off by the powerful people.

1

u/BuggedButWorking Frontend Developer Oct 26 '25

Would love to contribute

1

u/Creepy-Dog-848 Oct 26 '25

Just read a news that more than 200 people died in Pune in last few months due to bad road conditions. We don’t have system to file a case against contractors who are responsible for bad roads. Potholes appear on road in few days as soon as roads are made.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

If anyone willing to develop I can design it for you

1

u/rocks_naruto Oct 26 '25

I am so in to contribute. The tricky part is freshness and authenticity of this data.

1

u/Weekly_Cry_7 Oct 26 '25

I'm in for backend work

1

u/ChromaVeil Oct 26 '25

nice idea but if you really wanna hack it in a weekend you gotta start with a single dataset, get that scraped, put it in pinecone, then call a GPT‑4 API and hope nobody hits a data‑access wall.

1

u/kaychyakay Oct 26 '25

What is going to be 'solved' here anyway?

The name will have to be obtained from the govt. Will the local municipalities provide them? Currently on Twitter, people from Pune are raging about the guardian minister Murlidhar Mohol's links with top builders and how the govt., despite strong opposition from citizens from all economic levels, is still bulldozing the proposal to allow builders in whom Mohol is financially invested in, to build apartments on ARAI Hills, which are basically the lungs of Pune.

There's already a site that is making transparent the funds allotted to MLAs in cities across India and how they are using it (https://www.empoweredindian.in/). But how many of us are actually using that data to go question our representatives?

Let's just say that the local political bodies do co-operate and provide data. What are we going to do about it? Almost all road contractors are related to the local politician. Everyone involved in that operation is corrupt. Even if someone files an FIR against the corrupt contractor, they will be protected. Are we, as citizens, going to take this data and bang the local corporators' offices or personal doors for not giving us our taxes' worth?

Are we going to remain united if one of those contractors threatens any one amongst us with dire consequences if we report them in the future?

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

Data sources:

  1. Details of contractors, amount awarded: RTI

  2. Engineers/Babus/authority: Combination of RTI and state government posting lists (they maintain official posting infos on respective websites)

  3. Ministers/MLAs: Geographical area of project

  4. Firms responsible: RTI

1

u/Yeagerisbest369 Fresher Oct 26 '25

The only real hurdle is Acquisition of the Data as well as verifying if it is correct , trusting government is the last thing anyone should do !

1

u/ConversationLow9545 Oct 26 '25

its easy project, problem is the data

1

u/teriyaki7755 Oct 26 '25

You will make some dangerous enemies. Rich contracts as enemies are no joke they have influence and muscle

1

u/captainivar Oct 26 '25

I am a Software Developer, more than happy to help and collaborate with anyone doing this. Just one question, what is the legal compliance process, this needs real world implementation more than just a development project.

Ps: love all the ideas and brainstorming being done on the idea.

1

u/lemmeguessindian Data Engineer Oct 26 '25

CPWD already has their own pms

1

u/FlatFriendship380 Software Engineer Oct 26 '25

If you need help with android app, I'm here.

1

u/RiseProfessional9792 Oct 26 '25

Why is LLM needed here?

1

u/newkerb Oct 26 '25

Why not use mediawiki software

1

u/anoushk77 Oct 26 '25

I have an idea for this, I remember seeing a project at a hackathon where someone made agents go through google street view to analyse if that location was accessibility friendly, we can do a similar thing, agent uses street view to crawl through streets, find potholes, then look up area contractor on govt website and store the data in the db, the front end to display the data is pretty simple

1

u/zoomstate Oct 26 '25

This should be in smart india hackathon problem statement

1

u/Substantial_Bird_683 Oct 26 '25

Add me to if it's a project!

1

u/A_random_zy Software Engineer Oct 26 '25

make it an open-source project I'm sure some cloud provider will be ready to host it for free

→ More replies (1)

1

u/One-Judgment4012 Backend Developer Oct 26 '25

The one building it will disappear 😂😂

1

u/Mean-Gate-1033 Oct 26 '25

What would the cost of hosting something like this? 

1

u/boberkurwa27 Oct 26 '25

Anyone could make it if one has the data. I dont know about usability for the end user interface but thinking it from backend side, it's easily doable. Even the AI stuff for so called retrievals and all. But I appreciate your efrts on thoughts for accountability. It would also do wonders on scraping news articles like Mint or something on a click when a user is further interested to get their growth in figures.

1

u/Agnigarbhyan Oct 26 '25

push it in Blockchain

1

u/RaktPipasu Backend Developer Oct 26 '25

Let's say we build this... What next, how will this data help

1

u/dushmanta05 Oct 26 '25

Reading the comment section, I am happy to know most people have had the same thought of solving this problem, even I have. Let's truly build this, as mentioned by someone getting the data is crucial. And at this point since it's public infrastructure why not make all the data public, it's a democratic country right, every person has the right to know about it, so why not make this data public.

1

u/Easy-Impression-7529 Oct 26 '25

I'm in, those who can't help technically, can help offset the infra cost.

1

u/starlight_Hyena4610 Oct 26 '25

If we became successful in the future, it would be dengerous for the MP's and other ministers and leaders😂

1

u/InternalLake8 Software Developer Oct 26 '25

File RTI for data

1

u/sajalsarwar Software Architect Oct 26 '25

Problem is not tech I feel, the problem is the data sourcing and maintaining it.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

Imagine asking help and accountability from the boss of these corrupt Like he doesn't know what happens and how its happens

1

u/Resident_Year_6097 Oct 26 '25

Count me in, whoever is initiating building it

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ankit9856 Oct 26 '25

Itna kuch magg loge to Anti National bolne lagenge ye log ..

1

u/Horror_Implement_411 Oct 26 '25

what if i find a way to link politician profile -public works of state -MCA corporate affairs....do u guys ready to contribute ..there are apis available ,,we can test them on past tender results at state level and link and verify if any politician or his family is linked to it

1

u/satishkumar_sajjan Oct 26 '25

There is no official public data. You have to file RTI. A bloody hoch poch.

1

u/mace_guy Oct 26 '25

put it in a vector db, inferencing with light LLM

lmao

1

u/Party-Reception-1879 Oct 26 '25 edited Oct 26 '25

Yess this kind of site or app for all kind of government contract based work.

(Assuming the government already does have one)

Maybe the first version could be simple excel.

I was thinking how about a blockchain to put this data on.

1

u/Select_Jellyfish9325 Hobbyist Developer Oct 26 '25

I believe this can be built, especially with the aid of AI. Build the website, then whoever can upload the papers of the road, AI can filter out the necessary information and then display it. We can even create an API to do it, which can then also be pointed to other service providers.

By adding ways so that people can upload what they know about the roads, especially anonymously, we can also crowdsource information. I might even build this XD (a prototype or an MVP ofc)

1

u/ExcellentAd4757 Oct 26 '25

Look at this video once: Video

The solution discussed at the end may not be completely identical with your approach but still there may be things to learn from it. He explained how digitization can reduce or end corruption in India.

1

u/onlypanky4u Oct 26 '25

Can contribute if data is available.

1

u/Busy_Respect_7999 Software Engineer Oct 26 '25

Hey i am down to contribute

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

It's doable but the real challenge is data...

1

u/OkJuice1897 Oct 26 '25

I m ready to contribute in developing the websites

1

u/climatebygaurav Oct 26 '25

you cannot have a tech solution for what is fundamentally a public policy problem, you can only build tech on addition of a good policy.

1

u/Alt_578 Oct 26 '25

Not all problems are solved with a fuckin app. You can make it but no one's gonna use it.

1

u/SociallyElectric Oct 26 '25

I am interested

1

u/Gloomy-Breath-4201 Oct 26 '25

Its a problem people will kill to avoid it being solved. We are oblivious to what happens behind closed doors. Dont you remember the guy who tried to expose road contractor corruption being shot in early 2000s?

1

u/sandy7823 Oct 26 '25

Let's give a ranking to those construction companies like NIRF ranking for colleges.

1

u/vanishinggradient Oct 26 '25

as someone who has worked with the government in the past, trust me "the government" doesn't want you to have this data - at best they will make it obtuse and incoherent on purpose (remember what happened when SBI was asked for electoral bond data)

satyender dubey was killed for attempting to blow the lid on even larger instance of corruption

1

u/Tall_Front1781 Oct 26 '25

Who paid how much to whom? We need this also

1

u/benydrillcumbersome Oct 26 '25

The problem is that the system is so rotten that even if you obtain the data, it will just be a bunch of John Smiths and XYZ Pvt Ltd in there.

1

u/kiner_shah Oct 26 '25

A small prototype should be possible in a weekend.

1

u/longndfat Product Manager Oct 26 '25

and what will happen with this data ?

1

u/hexc0der Backend Developer Oct 26 '25

Problem is data. They don't give correct data. Even AQI is fake 😬

1

u/Creepy_Candidate_323 Oct 26 '25

As civil engineer this should be done its high time you can get data from tender documents of the work

but its easy to blame contractor people forget that the contractors got the contract of that work in first place because he has paid cm, pwd minister and the local mla maybe and not to forget the babu of our country who proposed the work first place so after paying so many people how he has manage his thing if doesnt pay someone else will get the contract

1

u/technovast Full-Stack Developer Oct 26 '25

Are the data points available openly?

1

u/Nis_0208 Junior Engineer Oct 26 '25

Interested to contribute in any way. I'm a junior engineer with ~2 yoe in backend work. Would be willing to join anyone who's started this project

1

u/gsk-fs Oct 26 '25

Lychee7 if you have plans to build that solution , i'm in

1

u/Straight_Jaguar8316 Oct 26 '25

Use esri argis for map and selection on particular price if road, add when was built which was the final contractor.

Its a problem to companies do take cut and sub lend, sub sub lend the contracts, like multiple layers of drop servicing

1

u/Mission-Comedian6567 Oct 26 '25

A Blockchain based system for tracking everything from tax collection to spendings should be proposed by someone

1

u/Actual_Reality_ Oct 26 '25

If government want details on ₹1 toffy or biscuits packet then why not on crores of road and architectures, this is must to do. I know this will never happen from government side until public do something crazy to force government to do, if anyone have idea or roadmap im willing to involve and support

1

u/International_Toe230 Oct 26 '25

Yeah it will be solvable but for the parties mentioned in the post, they will 'hack'(verb) the person thinking about this, it's a nexus and a deeply rotten system I don't think there's no coming back, roads, canals and water supply are the golden egg laying goose, they will protect it with others life if necessary, even if that means opposition of that particular region gets the power.

1

u/No_Sea839 Oct 26 '25

Ready to contribute:-)

1

u/Fun-Manufacturer9094 Oct 26 '25

sure, if you wanna roll a weekend hackathon, just promise the govt to pay you a medal for showing them how easy it is to hack their own transparency. if not, good luck hiding from the FIRs.

1

u/e-Syrup Oct 26 '25

TRUEEEEEWW

1

u/AmbientRune Oct 26 '25

yeah if you can get a legit data dump from the govt, a weekend hackathon will do a MVP; otherwise you're just chasing ghosts in PDFs

1

u/[deleted] Oct 26 '25

If this is somehow possible and somebody gets this done, an LLM can also be used to look for any discrepancies or issues (corruption) with the data.

1

u/Adventurous_Tone_836 Oct 26 '25

This is so stupid. She is tagging the Minister responsible for Roads, and wants all that information to find out "who is responsible"! The Minister has ALL this information available to him to act. Vote the Minister out, the next time you get to vote.

1

u/Adventurous-Cycle363 Oct 27 '25

If by the problem you mean the tech aspect of it then sure.. A weekend may be with some LLMs is fine.

But if you meant the actual issue related to govt systems then it is not solvable even in 1000 years.

1

u/therajatg Oct 27 '25

This kind of app can be built if a database which holds this info is made public (either by exposing API routes or maybe at a place from where scraping can be done).

1

u/Ok_Reference_9137 Oct 27 '25

With AI this can now be build in a month at the minimum

1

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '25

How would they even find these details ? The costs and bills are inflated to siphon off money and never published anywhere.

1

u/madhu_23 Oct 27 '25

The reason they are becoming rich is Young People especially software engineer are not interested in developing something which can show the data to public then if they do something wrong media can broadcast them. These many years they are doing all things without anybody getting know what's actually happening. Even if they get cash under table nobody gets to know.

1

u/ajstudd31 Oct 27 '25

I already have a project like this.
https://www.proactiveindia.site/

1

u/Alarmed-Height7249 Oct 27 '25

This is called asking someone to dig their own grave.. 😀

Btw, a good idea for the new jumla - HAR GADDHA KUCHH KEHTA HAI