r/demonssouls • u/therealLOC • Apr 22 '25
Discussion I think Demon's Souls is just not for me
Just uninstalled it off my PS5 and it's a damn shame because I REALLY wanted to like this game. Played the Dark Souls trilogy, Bloodborne & Elden Ring and loved them all, especially DS1 because of it's slower, more defensive combat. So I thought Demon's Souls would be my cup of tea too and on paper it absolutely should be. Everything I love about the other Soulslikes is here: Challenging gameplay, beautiful soundtrack, deep lore & the amazing world and enemy designs. But there are just some things that won't let me enjoy it. The half HP Loss feels way too punishing in a game where you're supposed to fail & die to get better (I know there is a ring at the begging that turns it to only 25% but still), the Bossruns are very long and for me it's super frustrating because I usually take a bit longer to learn a boss and it's moveset. Getting send back to the start of a level everytime you die and taking multiple minutes walking back just to die again or even earlier on the way is very rough, while there are some fair shortcuts like in the 1st castle (I actually really enjoyed that Dungeon) other parts have none like the run to the Tower Knight. I could still look past all that but then we come to the problems with the healing system. When I first heard of it I thought having this much healing grass would make it too easy, and for the first few hours this was true, but when you get stuck at a certain point you will eventually run out of them since they don't auto restock like Estus. So now not only do I have have to worry about the Boss + the annoying run, I also have to farm mobs for healing items (and they don't always drop) or spend my souls buying them instead of leveling up. I had to force myself to play it for 6 hours today and eventually realized I'm just getting frustrated instead of having fun like with the other FromSoft titles. I'm aware that I could make it much easier for myself by playing co-op or a magic build but that's just not the way I want to play and that's 100% my own fault. I probably would've liked it more if it was my first Soulslike, there are just some many quality of life improvements missing, so maybe I'm just spoiled from the newer FromSoft games lol. Despite all my criticism I still recognize that this is a GREAT game and I wish I could enjoy it like you guys, but it's just not for me and tha's fine. Wish all of you a great time playing, i'm just jealously watching from a distance