r/demonssouls • • Apr 22 '25

Discussion I think Demon's Souls is just not for me

7 Upvotes

Just uninstalled it off my PS5 and it's a damn shame because I REALLY wanted to like this game. Played the Dark Souls trilogy, Bloodborne & Elden Ring and loved them all, especially DS1 because of it's slower, more defensive combat. So I thought Demon's Souls would be my cup of tea too and on paper it absolutely should be. Everything I love about the other Soulslikes is here: Challenging gameplay, beautiful soundtrack, deep lore & the amazing world and enemy designs. But there are just some things that won't let me enjoy it. The half HP Loss feels way too punishing in a game where you're supposed to fail & die to get better (I know there is a ring at the begging that turns it to only 25% but still), the Bossruns are very long and for me it's super frustrating because I usually take a bit longer to learn a boss and it's moveset. Getting send back to the start of a level everytime you die and taking multiple minutes walking back just to die again or even earlier on the way is very rough, while there are some fair shortcuts like in the 1st castle (I actually really enjoyed that Dungeon) other parts have none like the run to the Tower Knight. I could still look past all that but then we come to the problems with the healing system. When I first heard of it I thought having this much healing grass would make it too easy, and for the first few hours this was true, but when you get stuck at a certain point you will eventually run out of them since they don't auto restock like Estus. So now not only do I have have to worry about the Boss + the annoying run, I also have to farm mobs for healing items (and they don't always drop) or spend my souls buying them instead of leveling up. I had to force myself to play it for 6 hours today and eventually realized I'm just getting frustrated instead of having fun like with the other FromSoft titles. I'm aware that I could make it much easier for myself by playing co-op or a magic build but that's just not the way I want to play and that's 100% my own fault. I probably would've liked it more if it was my first Soulslike, there are just some many quality of life improvements missing, so maybe I'm just spoiled from the newer FromSoft games lol. Despite all my criticism I still recognize that this is a GREAT game and I wish I could enjoy it like you guys, but it's just not for me and tha's fine. Wish all of you a great time playing, i'm just jealously watching from a distance


r/demonssouls • • Jul 11 '25

Co-Op got invaded and lost interest

4 Upvotes

basically got invaded and the dude destroyed all my equipment, i just defeated the second boss and i don't know, this sucks ass i need a ton of souls to get my shit back


r/demonssouls • • Dec 07 '25

Discussion Demon's Souls 2 - Game Awards Statue

0 Upvotes

The maiden like figure on the back of the game awards statue. Bluepoint Games cancelling the god of war project. Likely having a second project all along yet it will be new not a remake. Calling it now. Game Awards 2025 will reveal Demon's Souls 2 made by Bluepoint Games launching in 2026.

The Archstones are silent. Boletaria bleeds. New Demons stir.


r/demonssouls • • Jun 24 '25

Discussion What are you afraid of?

17 Upvotes

I played demons souls back when the PS3 version was out. Invasions were a thing and people would fight. If you lost you lost. Who cares. This PS5 version though? OMG.... Like 99% of the time when I invade someone they leave the game. Or I get a network error the second I spawn in. Bunch of running cowards. Learn how to fight... And take the L If you lose. Then I hear other people saying "what if I don't want to fight" THEN PLAY OFFLINE! What's the point of playing an online game if you are just going to disconnect Everytime the live aspect of the game kicks in? And people that say this is not a live game... Yes it is. This game was designed with invasions being a core part of the game. Play offline you losers.


r/demonssouls • • Dec 25 '25

Discussion Old King Allant is genuinely one of the hardest bosses Fromsoft has ever designed from a melee perspective without attack baiting/AI manipulation

0 Upvotes

I've been trying to no hit/no damage Allant for the last 18 hours using just melee and I've come to the realization this boss fight is extremely unbalanced (which makes sense since its the first souls game).

Allant as a boss is quite easy if you use magic. Even for melee, the commonly used strategy is to actually fight him at mid-range and bait out his lunge attacks, so it becomes a waiting game as you bait, hit, repeat. I've beaten him several times without getting hit with this strategy.

But I decided to try to beat him melee without cheesing by engaging him at melee the whole time and his close range moveset is actually insane.

He has a downward slash that has next to no windup and is nearly unreadable, which comes out of nowhere and the only way I can dodge it is to preemptively dodge but this leads to an issue where his triple slash that ends with a shockwave hits me because it has similar frames.

Other than that, he has a rush slash that straight up has no windup and even after 18 hours, I haven't dodged it even once. Him using that move is straight up game over. Luckily he rarely uses, usually only once every 5-10 attempts, in which case I just chalk it up to luck and accept the loss.

His melee range moves are actually straight up unfair at times and you can tell in future games, melee range bosses were balanced better to not has unreadable attacks like this

I've no hit Isshin and Malenia using this same fighting style of staying close up in their face and Allant's downward slash is much harder to deal with any attack they have. His outdated AI is archaic and easy to manipulate and fighting at range is a very easy fight but attempting this melee challenge is definitely one of the hardest things I've ever done in a Fromsoft game.


r/demonssouls • • Jul 24 '25

Discussion Why was characters race swapped in the remake?

2 Upvotes

A game originally made by Japanese developers make a game centered around a fictional EUROPEAN world.

Why are characters race swapped to be black? This is a european style world.

More importantly if the change "doesn't matter" then why the change?

Hidetaka Miyazaki would not have done this because he respects Europpean culture and European Folklore.

He wouldn't just add random races to fit a political agenda.

If Hidetaka Miyazaki wanted to add a black character he would have done so if it made sense.


r/demonssouls • • Sep 19 '23

Discussion Anyone else thinks DS is leagues better than DS1? Gameplay and visuals.

0 Upvotes

My first souls was DS2, never finished it cause I played at a friend's house. Then DS1 and DS3, same thing happened. My first 100% souls was DSR, then ER, DS1/2 and og DS. When I played og DS I was flattered how better the game looks compared to DS1 and the feel of playing the game is way better as well, I had literally zero problems with shitty hit boxes through the entire game, while anything from DS1 and beyond have lots of shitty hit boxes (DS2 gets bad reputation for it, but I faced waaaaay more shitty hit boxes on DS1 and 3, and ER, than DS2). And I loved that the remake also had zero shitty hit boxes to the point I almost forgot they even existed.


r/demonssouls • • Sep 16 '20

I haven’t been so disappointed in a long time

1 Upvotes

I was very hyped by the initial trailer and screens. But today’s gameplay looked absolutely awful. Weird camera behavior, cartoony art style, weird breathing and grunting from the player character, janky walking/running animation. Really just deflated all my excitement. Please tell me I’m not alone?


r/demonssouls • • Feb 29 '24

Question PS3 or PS5 version?

0 Upvotes

So I finally decided to pop in the DeS remake for PS5 and noticed some subtle changes I'm not sure I'm ok with. For starters, every action or roll you do your character grunts, cinematics and music is different, and theres this extra fancy flair from performing backstabs.

Apart from the subtleties, the games engine and combat does feel pretty slick. I've only really experienced the first half of Boletaria with a Rapier so I've still yet to see other weapons and such.

Do people still prefer the PS3 version with the private sever, or is PS5 the definitive version and these just things to get used to?


r/demonssouls • • Nov 13 '20

Discussion Ongoing support will make or break this game.

1 Upvotes

If Bluepoint and Sony are willing to continue to work on / fund updates to this game, then some of the elements that people reasonably dislike can be changed, some of the flaws of the original can be improved, and missing features from the other Souls games can be added.

Currently we're almost at the worst of both worlds - changes to aesthetics and music that noone asked for, and many dislike, and much requested changes to gameplay and features are missing due to being "faithful".

It's often said that the original mechanics are running under the hood, which is why gameplay changes can't be done. Well, it's time to start tinkering with that original code, altering or replacing it.

I can only hope this game doesn't get abandoned as a nostalgia cash-in, like Dark Souls Remastered.


r/demonssouls • • Feb 09 '22

Discussion Of the last five posts, 2 are wanting invaders to let them be killed for PWCT and another is for a gold coin…. You know back in my day growing up-trophies are things you earn and they meant an accomplishment.

0 Upvotes

What is the point in a platinum if you didn’t earn it?? Brag falsities to people who don’t know any better??


r/demonssouls • • Sep 23 '24

Discussion The state of the sub

5 Upvotes

There are constant trophy and tendency posts, to the point where they are most of what I see from this sub in my feed. Users are either not reading the rules, not reading the automod comments on their posts, or ignoring both of them.

Rule 10 exists for a reason, that being to keep these posts from cluttering up the sub and people's feeds. If I wanted my feed to be filled with people asking for help in Demon's Souls, I would join a Demon's Souls help sub.

This sub is supposed to be for more than help posts. Help posts having their own containment post should be proof of that. But nobody respects this, and you will be downvoted and disrespected for pointing it out. The people doing that are jerks, to put it lightly. Enjoy the state of the sub. I'm out.


r/demonssouls • • Jun 22 '26

Discussion flaws with the remake im tired of ignoring.

0 Upvotes

i feel like this is a point that NO one brings up. But its the attack and movement animations, they feel so realistic (which some animations are so dumb they dont feel like attacks but a kid playing with imaginary swords), the light weapons have no feel weightless and the heavy weapons feel TOO heavy, and some attacks just feel sluggish like the rapiers, what used to be such a nice and strong feeling jab, seeing the elegance and feeling the stab, feels somehow slow, feels harmless, and somehow lost its elegance. another one is the straight swords, used to feel so good and nice, feel so BAD. and a small thing i also hate is the roll animations, the rolls also feel sluggish.

another flaw i wanna mention is just how cartoonified the weapons look, they dont look real. they look stylelized and have that "blockbuster" look to them, like props. and somehow the fantasy weapons look alr, but then the animations ruin them. just another thing why the OG i feel is better than the remake.

had to get this off my chest, thanks for reading


r/demonssouls • • Nov 28 '23

Discussion Goodbye demons souls subreddit!

0 Upvotes

I just got the plantium for demons souls but unfortunately theres nothing left for me to do this game changed my opinion of hard games

Whenever i died i felt like giving up but a spark kept me playing and before i knew it the game ended.i made skme close friends from this subreddit which shows how nice and great this sub is

I remembered buying it and thinking it was a bold move best bold move i ever made honestly im sad its over and now i dont know what to do i think i will kove onto other souls games if anyone had ideas for games pls say btw

Remember struggling for boletaria but then i made a post here and got so much help with great tips phalanx was slain and before i knew it the other hosses were slain too

Thank you demons souls and demons souls subreddit i will never forget you goodbye my friends UMBASA ❤️


r/demonssouls • • Jan 06 '26

Discussion It’s really a shame what’s happened to Demon Souls Remake. After being away from the game for years and just recently getting back on it the game is completely dead. I remember back in 2021 having the fight clubs for PvP. It was so fun back then.

0 Upvotes

I know this is probably old news to many but it was quite shocking to me after being away so long.


r/demonssouls • • Jul 19 '24

Discussion Where the hell are the Bonfires?

1 Upvotes

Okay, so I'm new to Demon Souls, having played Dark Souls 2, 3 and Elden Ring, and I'm really starting to get narked with it.

I'm trying to cross this bridge with a wyvern quite literally breathing down my neck, and, aside from the check point after Phalanx, there's literally nothing. No Bonfires, no shortcuts, just a run across a bridge, maybe get murdered by a pack of wolves under said bridge, just to get to the boss fog to find it surrounded by enemies, with no short cut back to where I came from. I've had 20 or so run backs so far, and only made it to that oversized pincushion of a boss twice. And I've figured him out - Bite his ankles then hit the blue bits for a whopping 15 points of damage.

Not to mention there's no healing items, and those I have heal, what, 10 HP? Yeah, thanks, I hate it - Where do I get my flask? There is a flask, right? Cause if I'm stuck shovelling my face full of grass that does dick and balls for my health, I might cry. They're way too expensive for how little use they are, and it's not like anything drops any meaningful amount of souls to buy them anyway - I'll be here for days.

I should mention this is the PS5 remake, cause I hate myself and decided to buy a PS5 just to play the game. And I know I sound really negative, but I am actually having fun with it, I'm just getting pissed at this fucking wyvern and these so-called 'healing items'.

Is there a shortcut somewhere, or another Bonfire, or somewhere I can actually get healing items worth a damn? Cause I'm at a total loss.

And tf am I supposed to do about that boss? 15 damage seems pretty pathetic; they don't expect me to bite his ankles for 30 minutes, do they?


r/demonssouls • • Aug 09 '24

Discussion Most of the messages in the ps5 remake are stupid/useless

1 Upvotes

I have finally gotten into souls after buying this game 3 years ago when I initially got my ps5 and finally understanding what people mean when they talk about “satisfaction” after beating tower knight for the first time a few days ago.

When I first started the game there were several messages on the ground about using firebombs on phalanx or being aware of the fat officials use of magic and I fell in love with the messages portion of the game and learning the lore implications of messages, bloodstains, and the penalty of dying.

However since beating a few bosses and really getting into the game 90% of the messages are fucking stupid. I think every message I saw in prison of hope said some dumb shit like “time for upvoting” and “a little upvoting never hurt” while I fell into bottomless pits I probably could have been warned about.

Like what drives a person to beg for likes in demons souls. The posts are anonymous and you don’t get any fame or recognition for it. Most of these messages have 10s of thousands of upvotes too. Who is upvoting these and where are the helpful ones.

Love the game overall just kinda miffed that people would beg for likes on a platform that isn’t even social media.


r/demonssouls • • Apr 01 '24

Discussion Did anyone else find Allant more trustworthy and sympathetic than the Maiden?

3 Upvotes

I went with the bad ending precisely because of this. The Maiden is the traditionally good support character, but her motivations felt cryptic and the monumentals seemed very untrustworthy. True Allant is the villain ultimately, but his dialogue suggests that he’s not hostile at all (even if he attacks us in gameplay), greets us with courtesy even if we attack him and his nihilistic motivation seems a lot more believable.

There’s immense suffering, decay and corruption wherever we go. Maiden Astrea seems to echo these thoughts as well. Seems almost more merciful to let the Old One finish it all than to forcefully extend the plight of this corpse of a world.


r/demonssouls • • Jul 04 '21

PVP If you were stuck on Old Monk for a bit... that was probably me :^) - Raindrops Keep Falling on the Tower

1.6k Upvotes

r/demonssouls • • Jun 14 '23

Subreddit Announcement We hear you, /r/DemonsSouls will stay online

39 Upvotes

Hey all,

First and foremost - We feel like the API protest would've done a lot of good - just as your guys' protest and comments got us back online. People's voices matter.

We were seeing a lot of misinformation on our "indefinite announcement" posts and that's on me, the one who wrote the initial posts up, for not better explaining the reasoning behind it all.

Overall - moderating requires a shitload of tools in order to be effective. Without Reddit's API access, these tools (and a myriad of other features) will begin to disappear in time and make it more difficult to curb a lot of the things that many of you aren't even aware of that pops up in these subreddits

From the more simplistic things that come in such as T-shirt selling bots that attempt to steal user's Credit/Debit card information to even more nefarious things that I've seen over the years of moderating - these tools allow us moderators to better tackle these issues and keep these communities great.

What we didn't expect was the vast flip from support for the protest to near-unanimous backlash.

At the end of the day though, your voices were heard. The overwhelming vast majority of you all made it loud and clear that this is your community - something we all agree on.

Welcome back.


r/demonssouls • • Feb 18 '24

Discussion Why is the sub so dismissive towards criticism of the remake?

0 Upvotes

I’ve noticed in nearly every thread critical of the remake whether it be smaller changes like the new ui or larger changes like the various visual changes or the remade soundtrack instead of any actual discussion it’s often just dismissed.

Generally someone will say something like just play the original, you’re just blinded by nostalgia, or something else along those lines rather than addressing the criticism in any meaningful way whether agreeing or disagreeing.

I’m not saying all the criticism is good or worth addressing but just the sheer prevalence of this in seemingly every thread that focuses on a particular criticism or number of criticisms of the remake makes this place feel like a bit of an echo chamber. Which I guess isn’t surprising since it’s Reddit but still it leads to boring discussions.


r/demonssouls • • Oct 11 '21

PVP Everyone who quits the game when they get invaded…

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/demonssouls • • Jun 13 '17

My proudest gaming memory is finally giving in and starting to play demons soul´s. After a week of farming mobs, a friend who was over told me the last boss steals your levels. I turned off the game and never looked at a souls game again.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/demonssouls • • Jan 19 '25

Discussion So instead of working on a 6th archstone DLC or a Demon’s Souls 2, this is what they were working on. How disappointing.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I know it was a long shot, but those should of been infinitely better options. But Sony just wants the DeS IP to die and not do anything with it when there’s potential.

I love PlayStation but come on man.