8
13
u/counters78 Oct 05 '20
Two possible reasons:
Difficulties in optimization: Sometimes, you cannot obtain the similar performance with authors
Naturally, people select the best images for the paper
5
3
u/Chintan1995 Oct 06 '20
This is so true. I worked on the celebrity face generation using GANs and my output looks nowhere near as good as the paper (or other video demos on YouTube).
2
u/stinkietoe Oct 05 '20
TecoGAN, anyone?
2
u/iamskeeet Oct 06 '20
What about it (besides being pain in the ass to train)?
2
u/stinkietoe Oct 06 '20
I used the same images that were shown in the readme and it did not produce anything close to the output. It should have performed excellently given that the images were either presumably included in the sample set or at least a high performing test set (and thus I shouldn't have to perform any additional training). It seemed like false advertisement.
2
-2
0
Oct 06 '20
[deleted]
2
u/CantoneseScott Oct 10 '20
This is what turned me off peer review, my brother (whom is doing his Phd in geomatic prediction models) and I believe that a paper is now only as good as its reproducibility.
24
u/lurk4all Oct 05 '20
I feel personally attacked by this post