r/DebateAnarchism • • Jun 11 '21

Things that should not be controversial amongst anarchists

1.1k Upvotes

Central, non negotiable anarchist commitments that I see constantly being argued on this sub:

  • the freedom to own a gun, including a very large and scary gun. I know a lot of you were like socdems before you became anarchists, but that isn't an excuse. Socdems are authoritarian, and so are you if you want to prohibit firearms.

  • intellectual property is bad, and has no pros even in the status quo

  • geographical monopolies on the legitimate use of violence are states, however democratic they may be.

  • people should be allowed to manufacture, distribute, and consume whatever drug they want.

  • anarchists are opposed to prison, including forceful psychiatric institutionalization. I don't care how scary or inhuman you find crazy people, you are a ghoul.

  • immigration, and the free movement of people, is a central anarchist commitment even in the status quo. Immigration is empirically not actually bad for the working class, and it would not be legitimate to restrict immigration even if it were.

Thank you.

Edit: hoes mad

Edit: don't eat Borger


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jul 27 '20

Dehumanization in Anarchist Spaces on Reddit

751 Upvotes

I am relatively new to anarchism, and I'm on board with a lot so far. I've started reading theory and I'm lurking more on anarchist spaces on Reddit. Something that troubles me, or turns me off a lot when reading posts and comments in these places, is the constant dehumanization of the enemies of anarchism.

I get it. Cops, Landlords, Business owners, Politicians, they play an active role in perpetuating hierarchy and capitalism that ultimately fucks most of us. I also understand the anger, the desperation and the frustration.

But fuck do I get uncomfortable when I read a comment saying the only good cop is a dead cop.

I prefer to attack institutions. I'm not a pacifist, I don't think capitalism will ever fall without bloodshed, but I don't enjoy that thought. I don't relish in the idea of a cop getting hurt or killed and sometimes it feels like a lot of anarchists do. They're still people to me, people who have lives, families, neighbors and friends. I'm not saying they're good people, mostly because I think the binary distinction between who is a "good person" and who is a "bad person" is useless, and I'm not saying they wouldn't hesitate to, for example, arrest a homeless person for sleeping on a bench and not see a damn thing wrong with it. But I don't want to kill them, or hurt them. I want to work towards creating a society that destroys the police as an institution, a society that is better for everyone.

Same with, for example, landlords. My good friend has parents who live quite comfortably because they bought up some property, flipped it, and now rent it out. I don't think action is at all ethical, I understand how its exploiting peoples material need for housing. But I also don't think his parents are scum of the earth.

I don't understand how there are anarchists who talk about restorative justice, see the evil in the prison industrial complex and retributive "justice", but then proceed to dehumanize people.

People are complicated. And I believe under different circumstances, any of us could have ended up being the people we claim to hate. I have a lot of empathy and compassion for people, and this is what led me to anarchism. I don't think there's anything to gain in dehumanizing the individuals who make the institutions that we want to destroy.

Thoughts ? Am I completely misinterpreting people ? Does anyone else think this is a problem ? Or am I just crazy and dumb ?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 02 '20

Anarchism is NOT "communism but without a transitional state"!

532 Upvotes

Will you guys stop letting ex-tankie kids who don't read theory—and learned everything they know about anarchism from their Marxist-Leninist friends—dominate the discourse?

There are a variety of very important differences between anarchism (including ancom) and marxist communism.

First of all, Marx and Engels have a very convoluted definition of the state and so their definition of a stateless society is convoluted aswell. To Marx, a truly classless society is by definition stateless.

Engels says, in Socialism: Utopian and Scientific:

Whilst the capitalist mode of production more and more completely transforms the great majority of the population into proletarians, it creates the power which, under penalty of its own destruction, is forced to accomplish this revolution. Whilst it forces on more and more of the transformation of the vast means of production, already socialized, into State property, it shows itself the way to accomplishing this revolution. The proletariat seizes political power and turns the means of production into State property. But, in doing this, it abolishes itself as proletariat, abolishes all class distinction and class antagonisms, abolishes also the State as State. Society, thus far, based upon class antagonisms, had need of the State. That is, of an organization of the particular class which was, pro tempore, the exploiting class, an organization for the purpose of preventing any interference from without with the existing conditions of production, and, therefore, especially, for the purpose of forcibly keeping the exploited classes in the condition of oppression corresponding with the given mode of production (slavery, serfdom, wage-labor). The State was the official representative of society as a whole; the gathering of it together into a visible embodiment. But, it was this only in so far as it was the State of that class which itself represented, for the time being, society as a whole: in ancient times, the State of slaveowning citizens; in the Middle Ages, the feudal lords; in our own times, the bourgeoisie. When, at last, it becomes the real representative of the whole of society, it renders itself unnecessary. As soon as there is no longer any social class to be held in subjection; as soon as class rule, and the individual struggle for existence based upon our present anarchy in production, with the collisions and excesses arising from these, are removed, nothing more remains to be repressed, and a special repressive force, a State, is no longer necessary. The first act by virtue of which the State really constitutes itself the representative of the whole of society — the taking possession of the means of production in the name of society — this is, at the same time, its last independent act as a State. State interference in social relations becomes, in one domain after another, superfluous, and then dies out of itself; the government of persons is replaced by the administration of things, and by the conduct of processes of production. The State is not "abolished". It dies out.

Here, Engels clearly explains what his understanding of a stateless society looks like; to Engels, there exists no conflict beyond class. Individuals can/will not have differing wills/interests once classless society is achieved, and so we all become part of the great big administration of things.

This fantasy of the stateless state exists in vulgar ancom circles aswell—among the aforementioned kids who learned everything they know about anarchism from tankies. To these people the goal of individuals living in freedom is not a primary goal, but an imagined byproduct.

When Bakunin critiqued the Dictatorship of the Proletariat, he was not attacking the bolshevik bureaucracy. Bakunin took Marx's arguments in much too good faith for that.

Instead, his critique was a critique of the concept of a society ruled by the proletariat, and that is the fundamental distinction between an anarchist and a communist with anti-authoritarian aesthetic tendencies.

The goal of marxism is a society ruled by workers. The goal of anarchism is a society ruled by no one.

This misunderstanding is embarrassingly widespread. I see self-identified ancoms arguing for what, in essence, is a decentralized, municipal, fluid democracy—but a state nonetheless!

In fact, this argumentation has become so widespread that the right has picked up on it. I frequently encounter rightwingers who believe the goal of anarcho-communism is to create a society where the community comes together to force others to not use money, rather than to, say, build the infrastructure necessary to make money pointless (and if necessary defend by organized force their ability and right to build it).

There are people who think anarchism involves forcing other people to live a certain way. That ancom, mutualism, egoism etc. are somehow competing visions, of which only one may exist in an anarchist world while the rest must perish.

There are self-identified anarchists who believe anarchism involves that!

Stop it! Please!


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 08 '21

Most anarchists dont even understand what ancaps-libertarians beleive in and that is why they fail to debate with them properly

498 Upvotes

Ok hear me out

I used to be an ancap a long time ago, but I lost my faith in the free market and converted to individual post left anarchism instead. While seeing anarchists debate with ancaps, I have noticed that anarchists generally dont seem to understand what ancaps and right wing libertarians want and beleive in, and that causes them to contradict themselves a lot in debates. So here is a good faith guide for how to debate an ancap:

Libertarians view as their early influences the founding fathers and specifically Thomas Jefferson (classical liberalism). Libertarians support a lot the Austrian school of economics, a school of thought that supports laizez faire free markets. Famous Austrian economists are Frederich Hayek a critic of Keynes and author of "the road to serfdom", Ludwig Von Mises author of many books his most famous being "Human action", Eugene Von Bohm-Bawerk author of Capital and intrest, Hans Herman Hoppe and of course Murray Rothbard.

Rothbard, influenced by Mises and the other Austrians expanded the classical liberalism that most of the economists supported into anarcho-capitalism. Ancaps beleive that all the faults that leftists blaime capitalism has done, has been instead caused by state interference to the market economy. Ancaps view the state as an unnecesary evil to society that should be retired in favour of free markets ruling the world. Another key subject in their theory is "praxeology" which basically beleives that humans inherently make voluntary choices and that the state is the one that doesnt allow humans to work voluntary. Ancaps beleive that only under laizez fair capitalism is the individual truly free to make completly voluntary choices.That above is a very brief summary of some of the basics that ancaps beleive in. There is a lot of bulk of work in ancap theory (Rothbard wrote an entire library of work) but I hope this helps.

Now on to some mistakes I see anarchists make when they debate ancaps.

Mistake number 1: Ancaps want corporations to run the world

You can use this argument to tell them that this is how their society is going to end. However they themselves beleive in basically small communities that would work under a free economy.

Mistake number 2: Ancaps and Ayn Rand

A lot of ancaps and libertarians DO NOT like Ayn Rand. They view her as part of their ideologies history but some do not like her entire objectivist philosophy. If you only bring up Ayn Rand during a debate with a libertarian he will understand that you have limited knowledge on their ideology. For ancaps and libertarians, their main influences are the austrian economists. THAT is who you should attack.

Mistake number 3: Libertarians and ancaps support Trump

There is a small minority of a type of libertarians (paleolibertarians) who might have favourable views for Trump. However if you tell that to a libertarian or an ancap he will laugh at your face. Ancaps hate all politicians, both left and right. They view them all as "statists".

Mistake number 4: Libertarians support the police and military

NOPE. They hate them. They hate EVERYTHING that has to do with the state. They literlly larp the ACAP atheistic non stop.

And here are some debate tips:

tip 1: Bring up the fact that there is a rabbit hole with ancap and fascism (It was one of the main things that turned me off from the ideology)

tip 2: Attack the austrian school. This is an entire topic for itself that deserves books written about it. Whatever you do ,dont skip all their theory. A large part of why I remained an ancap was because I would never see anarchists or communists attack the theory at all. The theory is a massive self assurance for ancaps. Its HUGE and it includes works of dozens of economists. When you all skip it it looks like you cant make an argument against it.

tip 3: Ok this is the big one and the most hardest one of all. Do NOT and I repeat DO NOT focus on the fact that they are not real anarchists for too long. You ever wondered why they even beleive that in the first place? Its because Rothbard has done A FANTASTIC JOB at creating pseudohistory and misinterpeting the OG anarchists. He has brainwahsed ancaps into beleiving that as long as they are against the state they are anarchists. I know that for you and me that is irritating but if you just focus on that for to long they will never listen to you. You have to attack the theory.

Thats all pretty much.

EDIT: Woah you didnt have to waste money on this.

EDIT2: Again, DONT waste money on my fucking post. Jesus Redditors


r/DebateAnarchism • • Feb 05 '21

On Cuba

464 Upvotes

I often see many anarchists badmouthing Cuba online, and as a Cuban anarchist I feel the need to clarify some things. We're not perfect by any means, and there are many, many problems to our present political system, but we're also not the totalitarian dictatorship western media portrays us as.

The Cuban Constitution after the revolution was a result of thousands of discussions in community meetings, involving more than 6 million citizens, which was pretty much the entire adult population of Cuba at the time.

The draft for this Constitution was to be either rejected or accepted via a popular referendum. The referendum had a turnout of 98%, and out of those 98%, 97.7% voted to accept the new constitution.

From 2017, a new constitution was written, also from the bottom up, which recognised same sex marriage and private businesses, which is ultimately better because they are now regulated.

Cuba has 169 municipal assemblies, and each one has an election every two and a half years. Every fifth year, three months after the municipal elections, there is an election to the parliament—the National Assembly of People's Power—as well as to the 14 province assemblies.

More recently, Cuba has created a Federal system subordinate to the State. This has created the position of governor in the Provincial level.

All Cuban elections have had turnouts of over 95% ever since 1976. It is not a requirement for you to be a member of the Communist party of Cuba to vote or to be elected to any position, and the Communist Party does not propose, support, nor elect any candidates. No one here has gone to an election and been presented a ballot paper and told, these are the Party members for whom you have to vote, nor is anyone nominated for being a Party member.

Anyone over the age of 16 can vote and can be nominated to be a candidate for election in one of the 169 Municipal Assemblies or one of the 14 Provincial Assemblies, however you must be at least 18 years old to become a candidate for a seat in the National Assembly.

Neither money nor political parties have a place in the nomination process. Instead, individuals directly nominate those who they think should be candidates. As a result, the Cuban Parliament has representatives from across society, including a high proportion of women: 48.9%

Furthermore, 88% of Cubans participate in what is basically a system of direct democracy. The Committees for the Defence of the Revolution (CDRs) allow anyone over the age of 14 to join, and they meet a minimum of once every three months to plan the running of the community; including the organisation of public health campaigns to promote good health and prevent disease; the upkeep of the area in terms of waste and recycling; the running of voluntary work brigades, and providing the adequate support to members of the community who are in need of help.

The CDRs also discuss nationwide issues and legislation and feed back their proposals to the National Assembly and other organs of popular democracy. But at the heart of the Cuban democratic system is the locally elected delegate.

Prior to the municipal elections, residents of all the neighbourhoods of that municipality gather to a meeting in order to nominate candidates. you're nominated, you're free to either accept or decline the nomination.

If several people are nominated, a meeting appoints a person whom the neighbourhood trust as their candidate via discussion and show of hands. Up to 8 adjacent neighbourhoods make up a constituency. Election promises or electoral pledges are forbidden.

On election day the elections are conducted via secret ballot like in most democratic countries. Then a minimum of two and a maximum of eight candidates from a single constituency are to be elected to the municipal assembly.

As an elected representative, you don't receive a special wage, but you also don't have to pay for related expenses out of your own pocket. You remain at your normal job, carrying out the civic duties in own time.

The duties of a delegate are many and varied and the role is demanding, requiring an understanding of public policy and finance, business and administration, and the ability to negotiate, explain, motivate and lead.

And because you're known to almost every one of your electors, and you live among them, people will call on you at all hours of the day and night with all manner of problems.

Delegates carry out the inspection and monitoring of services provided by the Municipal administration, and of the factories, shops and businesses in their area. The National Assembly is practically the parliament of Cuba.

Out of the Assembly's 612 seats, exactly 50% consists of nominated delegates from mass organisations (namely the CDRs, the Women's Federation, the trade unions, the Students' Association, and the Association of Small Farmers) and 50% Municipal delegates.

The elections to the National Assembly take place every five years at the same time as the Provincial Assembly elections. Deputies in the National Assembly are from all walks of life and like municipal deputies they do not receive a special wage for being deputies.

The National Assembly is responsible for electing the 31-body Council of State, which is the governing body of Cuba, like a Prime Minister's Cabinet. It contains one President of the Council of State, whom you can think of as the prime minister of Cuba, as well as 6 vice presidents, a secretary, and 23 additional members.

Can everyone vote? Yes, if you were born in Cuba you are automatically registered to vote. There is no need for you or your parents to do any paperwork or pay any tax. You can vote in all elections when you turn 16 and you can also participate in local elections.

Will everyone know who I voted for? Will the secret police come get me if I vote for someone the government doesn't like? No, voting is done via secret ballot, so no one knows who you voted for except you.

Do I have to vote? If you don't want to, then no you don't have to. Voting is completely voluntary.

If I'm super rich, can I spend all my millions promoting candidates that I like? No, it is illegal to spend money promoting candidates. Candidates' biographies and their reasons for standing are simply displayed on local notice boards so that every candidate is covered.

Political parties are permitted in Cuba, however they are not allowed to nominate or campaign for candidates. This includes the Cuban Communist Party which is forbidden by law from interfering in the electoral process.

The Cuban Communist Party is really a product of Cuban history. The Cuban Communist Party traces its ideological roots to the Cuban Revolutionary Party founded by Cuba's national hero, Jose Marti, in exile in New York in 1882. Its purpose was to free Cuba from Spanish rule by uniting into a single party all those who wanted Cuban self-determination.

Following the 1959 Revolution which swept out the US-backed dictator Fulgencio Batista, Cuba's progressive forces began a process of uniting into a single party, which finally came to fruition six years later when the PCC was formed in 1965. Today one in six of Cuba's eleven million people are Party members. To become a member of Cuba's Communist Party, a person must be first nominated by fellow workers or neighbours and then voted in by their local branch.

Now, if you really want to criticize Cuba, maybe do so more informed. Or criticize the really problematic stuff like widespread corruption in state run enterprises, or the shit judiciary system, but don't go on repeating western propaganda.


r/DebateAnarchism • • May 02 '20

ACAB is not a useful slogan

454 Upvotes

Im a fan of ACAB, its punchy and cool sounding but every time it is said in the presence of anyone that isnt already on board, somebody is going to bring up their uncle jimmy who is a "good cop" and now you gotta spend 30 minutes explaining that you dont mean each individual cop kicks puppies but that the institution is inherently bad, makes you a class traitor... ect. In the end, its not that useful a slogan if its not self explanatory for most people who hear it..

Thoughts?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 01 '20

You're not serious at all about prison abolitionism if the death penalty is any part of your plan for prison abolition.

438 Upvotes

I see this a lot, people just casually say how they don't mind if certain despicable types of criminals (pedophiles, for example) are just straight-up executed. And that's completely contradictory to the purpose of prison abolition. If you're fine with an apparatus that can determine who lives and who dies, then why the fuck wouldn't you be fine with a more restrained apparatus that puts people in prisons? Execution is a more authoritarian act than imprisonment. An apparatus with the power to kill people is more threatening to freedom than an apparatus with only the power to restrain people.

So there's no reason to say "fire to the prisons! But we'll just shoot all the child molesters though". Pointless. Might as well just keep the prisons around.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 03 '20

Anarchism has a gatekeeping and a purity problem that impacts accessibility

422 Upvotes

I want to preface this by saying this isn't a call for "leftist unity" with Marxist or anything.

This is just straight up something I see on this sub and other anarchist subs on reddit, including some really popular recent posts. For example, the recent post about the difference between ancoms and Marxist communists.

I actually for the most part agreed with and enjoyed the post but at the beginning, OP wrote about how we're "letting the discourse be dominated by ex tankie kids who hadn't read theory" or something. That strikes me as pretentious and unnecessarily gatekeepy. There are plenty of people who have a hard time reading theory. Maybe they don't enjoy reading, maybe the material is too dense, maybe they don't have time. When we speak like "oh, you haven't read theory" and use it as a dismissive it's really off putting to people who might be interested in anarchism.

There's also a popular post right now saying "you aren't an ancom unless..." and again, I don't think the content of the post is bad content. But the tone is so agressive and reeks of trying to maintain ideological purity. If OP had approached the topic from the perspective of "I think there are some common misconceptions about what anarcho-communism is, here's why I think that" that would be great. But instead its all about how I'm not an anarchocommunist because I don't hold the same beliefs as OP.

I get that reading theory can be a great tool for understanding anarchism. I also understand the reflexive defensiveness anarchists might have at bad faith actors in our spaces. But only engaging with people who have read theory, or claiming to be the ideological standard for a branch of anarchism is not helping to grow and spread anarchism.

At the end of the day I think we're forever doomed if we can't make our ideas more accessible to people. Not everyone is going to read theory, the ideal anarchist world is not going to come about because we made everyone read the bread book. Not everyone can read theory and make sense of it.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 17 '20

Democratic socialists are our true natural allies

399 Upvotes

I think we have an unjustified allergy towards demsocs. This (a) pushes them to ally themselves with social democrats and liberals who inevitably stab them in the back (see the current Sanders-Warren debacle); and it (b) inevitably pushes us to ally ourselves with tankies who inevitably stab us in the back (see all of left history).

What are we doing? I'm sorry, but Cornel West is my ally. Barbara Ehrenreich is my ally. The late Michael Harrington was my ally. I have a great deal of respect and affection for these people, even if I think their praxis is often naive. They think our praxis is naive. And that's OK. There's probably a kernel of truth to both stances.

I don't know about you lot, but I'm not donning a suit and tie to fight the good fight on some committee anytime soon. Yet when the fighting's in the streets, I'm there. No wonder we anarchists have palatability issues with the general public, some justified, some not. Demsocs can fill some vital roles that we're not as inclined to.

I often ponder the backdoor agreement MLK and Malcolm X had. White America was utterly terrified of Malcolm -- as they were right to be. By comparison, King was a welcome face. The deal was: King would push his demands nonviolently while Malcolm would wait in the wings with his people, clubs thumping in hand, ready to fuck shit up the moment the powers that be clamped down on King's movement. It was an effective strategy.

This, in my view, is how a libsoc-demsoc allegiance should work. They need teeth, we need branding. Bernie may be little more than a New Deal Democrat when you just look at his policy platform, but I think we all know he's personally much further to the left. He's just working with the Overton Window that he's been given, something I don't see anarchists doing. (Hell, every week there's someone on /r/Anarchy101 requesting IWW pamphlets that aren't so off-puttingly red and black.)

My criticism of demsocs still stands. They vastly underestimate the lengths the ruling class and their fascist attack dogs will go to in repressing a groundswell of working class action. They will murder us, and as of late have done so increasingly. The US government can't even tolerate a democratically elected socialist leader in a small Latin American country. Ask Salvador Allende. Ask Manuel Zelaya. Ask Evo Morales. What makes them think the oligarchy will tolerate a socialist POTUS?

But, for Christ's sake, they should continue trying. And we should support them.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Dec 10 '20

Hope should be a core anarchist message

388 Upvotes

Let's be realistic here. We're fucked. Capitalism is getting worse and worse. A lot of people are going to lose their homes. Fascism, in on itself a death cult, is rampant. Our world is fucking dying and taking us with her. Electing liberals at the very very best will slow this proccess down a tiny bit, at worst wil make people not care because they done all they can.

If you never questioned yourself what chance do we have to quite literaly save the world, I'm not sure how you've done, but congratulations. Our situation, on a global scale, is dire.

Anarchist propaganda usualy focus on talking about those issues and how they're destroying us slowly but surely, but I think we have a problem here of not talking about a bright side. Fear and despair can make people stagnant, and I make a case here that we should talk more, a whole lot more, about hope.

That's not to say that anarchists never talk about positive things we can achieve, but we could do better in this. Messages about a better world, winning against difficult odds, and similar discourse could help the cause quite a bit.

Hope can be a powerful motivator, especially if cultivated with care as to not end up burning out. To be honest, lot's of emotions have power to mobilize us. Anger and compassion both prove their value in each protest. I just think that hope should be more explicitly present.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 28 '20

Unpopular Opinion: Go vote.

384 Upvotes

So let me explain. The most important goal is liberation of the people and if voting helps liberating, because now a opressing party is at power I think its our responsibilty to vote them out. I know all parties are opressing but there are these which are less opressing than others. For example SocDems are less opressing than conservatives. I cant speak for Anarchists in the USA tho. Political range is a joke there. What are your opinioins on my thought. Pls enlighten me if you agree or not and when, why so?

Edit: OK so this didn't go as planned. I wanted a general discussion which didn't happen and I said I can't speak for the Americans yet there are a lot of comments suggesting I doing propaganda for Joe Biden. I'm not. I'm sad this didn't go the way I wanted to. A discussion which is not country dependent. Thx for those who tried tho ^


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 19 '21

Anarchists spend way too much time caring about Ancaps.

337 Upvotes

They will never have any political relevance nor would anyone pass the age of 19 would take them serious. They are terminally online young kids who found a cringey outlet they will hopefully grow out of or they will just become a regular right libertarian. I don’t understand why the anarchist left spends so much time fighting with Ancaps.

As a Marxist Honestly I’m really jealous Anarchists have to deal with something as ridiculous as Ancaps. I’d gladly take that any day over the millions of fucking Stalinists and Dengists.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Apr 24 '21

You changed my mind

311 Upvotes

So this post isn't exactly a debate but I hope it'll be considered appropriate. I'm an ancapoid who used to post here a bunch. This place was pretty much the first contact I had with ancoms, and I came here because despite the consensus of all my ancap circles, I refused to belief that people who called themselves anarchists were so far gone as to be less worth going after than statists.

So I tried for a couple months. I tried so many times. I had a couple good debates, but most of it was terrible. Total bad faith. I learned one major thing (I stopped believing in homesteading), thanks to u/the3schatologist, and I also learned that the pragmatic comparison between anarcho-communism and anarcho-capitalism was a lot more two-sided than I thought. But that didn't matter much to me; a disagreement about moral legitimacy is more important than a disagreement about practical viability. As the average quality of debate was so low, I decided I didn't have anything left to learn here, and I stopped sinking the hours in.

It's been 11 months since my last post. My beliefs about the legitimacy of property haven't fundamentally changed since then, but over the last few weeks, I've decided that the pragmatic comparison really does favor communism. My preferred vision of a voluntary world is one without property. I hate profit and its consequences. I hate money. I hate rich people. One of the most appealing avenues of change to me is to decrease our dependence on landlords. I feel that anything that is not free is something I don't want to be involved with, on either side.

So, I am a communist now in that sense. Special thanks to u/the3schatologist, u/heartofabrokenstory, and u/KrimsonDCLXVI.

But also, Jesus Christ all the rest of you suck at this. 90% of my replies were flames, endless streams of egregious strawmen and ignoring my arguments, or "go away fascist". I could've been a communist 11 months ago if you all had've argued in good faith. No one's obligated to debate, but if you don't want to debate, what the fuck are you doing on a debate sub?

Anyway, one of my reasons for making this post was to prove you wrong: ancaps can change. If you learn this lesson, you can convince more of them to change.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 22 '21

No, littering is not praxis.

297 Upvotes

No, littering is not praxis.

It does nothing to build class consciousness.

It does nothing to raise awareness of humans pollutive tendencies.

It does nothing to scare the bourgeois.

It does nothing to alleviate what we’re putting in landfills.

It does nothing but pollute more and dissuade people from anarchism.

I pray that this group is fake, but if it’s real, I’m going to have a seizure.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 18 '20

Why not just vote and continue to do praxis afterwards?

288 Upvotes

At the very least, it would give us four years for leftists to safely organize. It'd give us some breathing room at least. I don't expect it to solve anything, but Trump being out of the way would make it easier for direct action and mutual aid to actually solve some problems. My biggest hope for Biden is that he just stays out of the way.

And if it doesn't do anything, it doesn't do anything. We'll just keep fighting regardless.

I'm open to other opinions, so please let me know what you think.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 14 '21

The stupid AOC dress is NOT an example of capitalist realism.

273 Upvotes

"Tax the Rich" is demonstrably not an anti-capitalist message. Social democrats such as AOC, among raising living conditions of their constituents, view this as the only viable way of SUSTAINING capitalism.

A picture of a liberal politician in a "Tax the Rich" dress is not what Fisher was talking about when discussing how capital produces media that performs the audience's anti-capitalism for them. His direct examples including the punk and hip-hop movements becoming commodified, pacifying the audiences into consuming their resistance instead of performing it. Another example being WALL-E, a movie about endless consumption ruining the planet only for the solution to completely ignore the notion of wider systemic change to avoid repeating the problem. This is just a performative spectacle because that's probably just as effective as anything else AOC could accomplish within the bureaucratic labyrinth that is the American political system.

I wish Mark Fisher was still with us so he could clear this up. If I see another meme with his writing pasted over her ass I'm gonna spit.

Edit: Here's one of the memes in case anyone's unfamiliar - /img/rpi7u5gi9hn71.jpg


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 23 '21

Anarchists let the perfect become the enemy of the good.

267 Upvotes

Whenever I read about an Anarchist or semi-anarchist society such as Zapatista Autonomous Municipalities, Popular Indigenous Council of Oaxaca, and Slab City to name a few, everyone gets WAAAYYY critical. Whether it’s the Zapatistas breading cattle, having any degree of bartering, and wages or Slab City having any degree of property rights, everyone wants to nit-pick and claim “they’re not real anarchists”. Okay, but they’re doing good work....

Look, I’m not saying that these societies aren’t deserving of criticism, I’m saying that we should support them while critiquing them. If the statists can love their systems but believe it is important to criticize it, we can do the same. Let’s not put down our comrades for the sake of seeming authentic. That isn’t productive, it’s just condescending.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Mar 05 '21

The "dry, boring" texts from "dead white guys" are read because they are good and working people are perfectly capable of reading them.

262 Upvotes

For a long time within left-wing movements there's been a sort of anti-intellectualism, a push back against the "dead white guys." Every remark about propagandizing, educating, and all of the suggestions of introductions to anarchism and left-wing politics is met with don't read them, they suck, or they're old and no longer relevant or the worst of them all the dead white guys are bad and it's racist and classist to read them.

After too many years of hearing it I just want to say: Read the classics because they are good.

There's certainly aspects of them that will be dated but this is no different from the referential knowledge that anyone needs to read or do anything else. Picking up a brand new video-game you can assume that X or A will more than likely be Jump, but that's referential knowledge that comes from having played games before, if a game were to have R1 be jump a brand new player might not think anything of it but to you it would feel weird. The movement button being a left-dominant keypad is not innate to anything in particular but a historical precedent. Humor is the same, there are few things innate about humor not modified through a lens of the culture and social understandings you were brought up within. Being a good cook or wine-maker requires a certain knowledge of cuisine that will be beyond the understanding of a lay-person, I may not know why the grapes of some particular valley in southern France taste any better than any other, but I know when I drink it, it tastes good; should I want to be a producer I would need to learn thing that are currently outside of my current understanding.

Books are no different. There are referenced situations we may not know, there are types of phrases or syntax used in certain cultures, languages, and contexts like academia we may not initially understand, but these things are not wholly out of our grasp. If that uncle of yours with no history of reading books can also remember every single baseball pitcher for the Giants since 1945, he has the capacity to other things you're not giving him credit for. And even if we may not understand all of the references we can understand the purposes of the arguments being discussed. (I don't believe many need to have a firm grasp on the specifics of the Sisyphus fables in order to understand the analogy Camus is making in Myth of Sisyphus for instance).

The worst of these is a "working people can't understand this" or "don't care" about this stuff which is just so goddamn infuriating to me. I'm a working class person for one and I really don't need anyone speaking on behalf of me. History is filled with people with far less formal education being perfectly capable of doing incredible and extraordinary things. Illiterate factory workers had people bring in and read newspapers to them as they worked. Peasant farmers in Vietnam in the middle of the horrific violence from the United States, still had the capacity to sit around to discuss Capital and Marxism, the Panthers had reading and educational groups, radical newspapers were spread and read all over every revolutionary country: the PLM's distribution to Mexican farmers and factory workers, the social reading groups of Barcelona's factory councils. Fuck outta here with that condescending bullshit.

Cognitive issues? Perhaps but so often these are overblown. Stop saying you have ADHD just because you'd rather spend time playing games and watching TV than reading a book, in the same way that being clean and tidy does not make you OCD. I have literal ADHD diagnosed from multiple doctors and I can read, I just have to read differently than others (NO MY DIAGNOSIS DOES NOT SPEAK ON BEHALF OF OTHERS) And just like the factory workers having their works and papers read, we should be focusing on accessibility of ideas and not focusing on this backwards approach to ideas, that certain ideas need to be kept away, like all of us ADHD working class folks are just too stupid to understand things.

At the end of the day, if books aren't your thing, that's fine. Some of the closest comrades I've had were not voracious readers and they understood authority and capital just fine, (Haywood never having read Capital but having the marks of Capital on his back rings true). But let's drop the insulting, negative, condescending bullshit please.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 17 '20

The case for voting

259 Upvotes

You know who really, really likes to win elections?

Fascists.

They are cowards. They need to know that they are backed by the community before they start the violence.

Winning elections validates their hatred, emboldens them, and emboldened fascists kill.

When some right-wing authoritarian wins the elections, hate crimes increase.

Yes, centrists and liberals kill too.

But fascists do the same killing and then some.

That "and then some" is people.

You know real people, not numbers, not ideals.

I like anarchism because, of all ideologies, it puts people first. And I like anarchists because most of them put people before ideology.

Voting is not particularly effective at anything, but for most people it is such an inexpensive action that the effect to cost ratio is still pretty good.

I get why people are pissed about electoralism. There's far too many people who put all their energies into voting, who think that voting is some sort of sacred duty that makes the Powers That Be shake in terror at night and it very much isn't.

Voting is a shitty tool and in the grand scheme of things it doesn't make much of a difference.

However, when fascists look for validation at the pools, it's pretty important that they don't get it.

I'll try to address the reasons for NOT voting that I hear most often:

-> "Voting is not anarchist"

Nothing of what I read about anarchism tells me I should not consider voting as a tactic to curb fascists.

But more importantly, I care about what is good and bad for people, not what is "anarchist" or not.

If you want to convince me that you put people before ideology, you need to show me how voting actually hurts actual people.

-> "Voting legitimizes power, further entrenching the system"

Yes and no. I get where this comes from, but thing is, the system doesn't seem to give much of a fuck about it. Take the US, where so few people actually bother to vote, it doesn't really make much of a difference on legitimacy.

-> "A lot of people don't have the time or money or health to vote"

This is a perfectly legitimate reason to not vote, I agree.

-> "Ra%e victims should not vote for a ra%ist"

This is also a very valid reason to not vote.

-> "Whoever wins, I'm dead anyway"

Also very valid. =(

-> "You should use your time to organise instead"

If voting takes only a few hours of your time you can easily do both.

It seems like in the US "voting" also means "campaign for a candidate". That's probably not a good use of your time.

-> "If the fascists win the election, then the revolution will happen sooner"

AKA "Accelerationism". I find it tempting, but ultimately morally repugnant, especially when the price will be paid by people who can't make the choice.

-> "Voting emboldens liberals"

Yes. Better emboldened liberals than emboldened fascists.

EDIT:

To be super clear, I'm not arguing in favor of "voting and doing nothing else": that's what has fucked all "western" democracies.

If you have to choose between "vote" and "anarchist praxis", you should choose "anarchist praxis" hands down.

However most people don't have to choose and can easily do both.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 29 '19

The Left has a pseudoscience problem (GMO fearmongering, homeopathy, nuclear power).

259 Upvotes

TL;DR: Some elements of the left seem to be strangely favourably inclined towards alternative medicine and other scientifically unsupportable ideas. Why is this?

First of all, this is not the entire left, obviously. I am on the left and I am complaining about it now, but I still feel as though there exists at least a sector of the left that has a strangely irrational approach to analysing the world. In my experience this is especially prevalent in the "green" left, but not exclusively.

The most prominent example is GMO paranoia. Obviously the mere act of changing the genes of a plant, through breeding or splicing, does not actually make it dangerous and even tends to improve its quality (though obviously the subjective definition of "quality" means that this isn't necessarily doing good under capitalism). There seems to be a rampant fear of GMO's on the left either way, when, as with any technology, it is the people in control of it that actually decide wether it is a force for good or not.

Another example is alternative medicine. I'm a big fan of the writings of Peter Gelderloos, but was rather shocked by the following passage in An Amarchist Solution to Global Warming:

In most cities, people hold periodic or ad hoc neighborhood assemblies to maintain the gardens, paths, streets, and buildings, to organize daycare, and to mediate disputes. People also participate in meetings with whatever syndicate or infrastrucutral project they may dedicate some of their time to. These might include the water syndicate, the transportation syndicate, the electricity syndicate, a hospital, a builders’ union, a healers’ union (the vast majority of health care is done by herbalists, naturopaths, homeopaths, acupuncturists, massage therapists, midwives, and other specialists who make home visits), or a factory. 

Hold on, homeopaths? The practitioners of a thoroughly disproven pseudoscience with Lysenko-level revisions to natural science? Why does one of the most reputable anarchist authors alive refer to homeopaths as "specialists" rather than "charlatans"? Additionally, what is up with the skepticism towards just a regular old modern physician? "Herbal medicine" is not somehow magically better than medicine that comes in pills, especially when you consider contamination and cleanliness. It is not as if modern, clean medical science is about making pills out of magic juice of evil. In fact, many modern medicines are herbal medicines that have been studied scientifically, a well-known example of course being aspirin, which is extracted from tree bark.

"Alternative medicine" is scientifically just medicine that has failed to prove that it works better than a placebo. Do you know what they call alternative medicine that has been proven to work? Medicine.

This bizarre, near pathological fear of doctors feels very misplaced in a movement of nominally free thinking rebels.

Then there is the issue of solarpunk versus nuclear power.

There is no clean energy at the moment.

Wind turbines require fifty meter factory made polymer blades, solar cells require big mines pumping black smoke into the air, and power grids, especially at the points of transformation between various voltages, are incredibly wasteful.

Is nuclear power a viable alternative? It is true that most nuclear fuel like uranium requires all sorts of horrible processing, but it seems once more like a large sector of the left has abandoned nuclear power simply in favor of the solarpunk fantasy.

As it stands, nuclear power kills far fewer people, generates far less waste (and the waste is far more manageable; compare several thousand tons of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere to a glowing rock in a vault under a mountain) and actually serves a decent chance of replacing coal and oil here and now, but for some reason it is only silicon valley tech bros who are pushing this, while the left seems to draw back in fear at even the thought, with little justification.

Again, I am not levelling any of these accusations against the entire left, but I hope that some of you are at least somewhat aware of this subgroup, and could someone please explain what they're doing?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 09 '19

No revolution will look like it's "supposed" to, stop alienating yourselves from every revolt when it fails to meet those standards

248 Upvotes

No revolution has ever looked ideal. Every revolution has had a variety of actors all claiming legitimacy and attempting to come out in power over others or claiming power for their own. And every single time people stop participating when they begin to see other groups being involved, further alienating themselves and harming the overall movement by their non participation. Can't support Hong Kong because of people UK-US flags, can't support the Arab Spring in Tunisia because of the Arab Spring in Libya or the outcome of the Arab Spring in Egypt, can't support Occupy because too many trot-newspapers and liberals, can't support Extinction Rebellion because of politicians and liberal pacifists, can't support...

No revolution started on purely perfect origins. The Paris Commune started after a French military defeat in Ardennes. The Russian revolution started with women's strike and march. The yellow vest started with a gasoline tax. Each of these became something else that was only tangentially related to the initial issue, even if you disagree with what they became.

Most of all, each of these little acts of rebellions became a possibility for something else, but if we're constantly on the sidelines because there's too many tankies, liberals, conservatives, or whatever other else, that possibility will never come.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Aug 30 '20

Left unity can suck my testies (I'd like your opinion on left unity and the relationship between all kinds of leftists)

245 Upvotes

I ain't gonna look at a maoist or Pol Pot fan and think "oh yeah, lovely state violence and repression of minorities right there". Ain't gonna watch at what Stalin did and think it's something I'd remotely like to live in. The CCP and his socialism with Chinese characteristics, the north Korean hereditary dictatorship is not socialism, it's monarchism, where the government officers literally have billions. I can understand a Sankara, a Castro, a Che Guevara, at least I can look at them and not see imperialism and genocide, mass repression. You can't slap a hammer and sickle on a turd and expect me to like it. Fuck Venezuela too. Hating capitalism doesn't mean you can't hate the statist as well. They betrayed the revolution one too many times.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jul 01 '21

How do you justify being anarchist but not being vegan as well?

244 Upvotes

If you fall into the non-vegan category, yet you are an anarchist, why you do not extend non-hierarchy to other species? Curious what your rationale is.

Please don’t be offended. I see veganism as critical to anarchism and have never understood why there should be a separate category called veganarchism. True anarchists should be vegan. Why not?

Edit: here are some facts:

  • 75% of agricultural land is used to grow crops for animals in the western world while people starve in the countries we extract them from. If everyone went vegan, 3 billion hectares of land could rewild and restore ecosystems

  • over 95% of the meat you eat comes from factory farms where animals spend their lives brutally short lives in unimaginable suffering so that the capitalist machine can profit off of their bodies.

  • 77 billion land animals and 1 trillion fish are slaughtered each year for our taste buds.

  • 80% of new deforestation is caused by our growing demand for animal agriculture

  • 15% of global greenhouse gas emissions come from animal agriculture

Each one of these makes meat eating meat, dairy, and eggs extremely difficult to justify from an anarchist perspective.

Additionally, the people who live in “blue zones” the places around the world where people live unusually long lives and are healthiest into their old age eat a roughly 95-100% plant based diet. It is also proven healthy at every stage of life. It is very hard to be unhealthy eating only vegetables.

Lastly, plants are cheaper than meat. Everyone around the world knows this. This is why there are plant based options in nearly every cuisine


r/DebateAnarchism • • Dec 12 '20

Being called a “bad anarchist”

242 Upvotes

I really find it annoying how some anarchists I know call me a “bad anarchist” because I say I would rather fight Biden than Trump. I acknowledge that they are both bad, but one is a neoliberal and the other is a legitimate wannabe fascist. I’m not worried about Biden locking me in a camp for what I say negative about him online, and I’m certainly not as concerned about him sending his stormtroopers to Portland to shoot at us, including shooting my best friend in the head. Not to mention, Biden im sure at least will not attempt to subvert the process we have in place currently while claiming it’s “American.” Am I crazy here?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Apr 21 '20

The "no unjust heirarchies" versus "no heirarchies period" conversation is a useless semantic topic which results in no change of praxis.

232 Upvotes

As far as I can tell from all voices on the subject no matter which side an Anarchist tries to argue they, in the end, find the same unacceptable relations unacceptable and the same acceptable relations acceptable. The nomenclature is just different.

A "no unjust heirarchies" anarchist might describe a parenthood relationship as heirarchical but just or necessary, and therefore acceptable. A "no heirarchies period" anarchist might describe that relationship as not actually heirarchical at all, and therefore acceptable.

A "no unjust heirarchies" anarchist might describe a sexual relationship with a large maturity discrepancy as an unjust and unnecessary heirarchy, and therefore unacceptable. A "no heirarchies period" anarchist might describe that relationship as heirarchical, and therefore not acceptable.

I've yet to find an actual case where these two groups of people disagree in any actual manifestation of praxis.