A belief that I have heard espoused by many anarchists is that property destruction is not violence because violence is something that can only be done to people.
First of all, what is violence? The Merriam Webster dictionary gives two essential meanings of the word violence:
1: the use of physical force to harm someone, to damage property, etc.
2: great destructive force or energy
Neither of these two definitions exclude property damage as a qualifier for violent action. But seeing as language is entirely subjective, technically, violence could mean whatever you wanted it to mean.
So for the sake of argument, let's take the first definition of violence, and focus on the "use of physical force to harm someone" part, since that seems to be closer to the definition of violence these anarchists are using.
So now we have our definition of violence- "The use of physical force to harm someone"
Now my first question is, does this definition of violence exclude property damage as a possible form of violence?
The answer to that question seems to be no. There are certainly scenarios where "the use of physical force to harm someone" could take the form of destroying property.
Here's an example. Let's say we have two people, Bob and Rob. Bob really hates Rob, because Rob always calls him names. Bob wants to get revenge on Rob. He knows that Rob has a nice, new, shiny car that he is incredibly proud of. Bob decides to go and trash Robs car. He brings a baseball bat, smashes the windows, breaks the headlights, and pours water in the gas tank. And just for good measure, he keys Rob's car too.
What Bob has just done, is an act of physical force, done with the intent to harm Rob, by destroying his property. This situation, and many others like it, certainly would qualify as an act of violence under our working definition.
Now, some anarchists might argue that this example is one of destroying someone's personal property, when the property damage they are talking about is damage done to private property.
But even with this more specific definition, there are still examples of violence that can apply here.
Let's say that Rob wants to get back at Bob for destroying his car, and Bob happens to be the owner of a big fast food chain. Rob goes with a gang of his friends, to destroy Bob's businesses. They drive around to each of the businesses he owns, and throw rocks through the windows when no one is working to make sure they don't hurt any of his employees.
They aren't trying to hurt his employees, but they are trying to hurt Bob in this situation by making him lose money and making him upset. And they most certainly are using physical force by throwing rocks through the windows.
So in this scenario as well, our criteria for what can be deemed a violent action are met.
If the intent of an act of property damage done by an anarchist is to harm someone, then in such a given instance, destruction of property could be defined as violent under our current definition.
Now all we need to do is figure out if Anarchists motivation for property damage are to harm others, like, say the business owners. The motivations of anarchists are going to be harder to definitively pin down and is going to have to rely on context, and I'm lazy so I'm just going to leave it at that.
Now that I've made my case. What do you think? Was there anything I overlooked?