r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 15 '24

Why Veganism has Nothing to do with Anarchism

12 Upvotes

After seeing multiple, regularly recurring posts arguing that Anarchists must necessarily be Vegans… I decided to try to clarify a few things:

Anarchy is simply about the absence of authority, with Anarchism being a political philosophy/project aimed at achieving that goal. The notion that Anarchists must be vegan is incorrect because it conflates authority (as it is conceptualized in anarchist political philosophy) with violence or force, which is simply false. Anyone using a definition of authority that is synonymous with violence or force, is simply not talking about the same thing as what anarchist political philosophy refers to as authority. It's similar to how the "hierarchy" of a grocery list isn't the same thing as the "hierarchy" anarchists seek to end.

From the standpoint of opposing authority, it doesn't make sense to argue that anarchists should all be vegans as a form of anarchist praxis. Just as the animal products industry under capitalism makes use of authority, so too does the vegan industry under capitalism. See here for further reading on the Vegan Industrial Complex (there's a download link to the full paper on the right): https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/id/3052/

Veganism is fundamentally a liberal ethical philosophy, as it is rooted in presuppositions about ethical consumerism that just aren’t shared by anti-capitalists. And it has nothing to do with anarchism, because veganism is not fundamentally anti-authority (at least with regard to “authority” as anarchist philosophy conceptualizes it).


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 03 '22

Given that the Left are so removed from having any power, Anarchists should work with anyone left of centre.

0 Upvotes

r/DebateAnarchism • • Apr 07 '24

An Anarchist Case Against Veganism

0 Upvotes

Veganism is not inherently better for the environment than a diet that includes animal products. Vegan diets are heavily dependent on soy and palm oil, which promote monoculture and deforestation. The environmentalist argument for veganism is based on the fact that it takes less monocrop (e.g. soy) to feed humans directly than to feed livestock raised to feed humans. However, the solution to this isn't veganism. The solution is to raise and feed animals differently (i.e. without the use of mass produced monocrop feed).

For example, 1 acre of forest cultivated by a local community could raise 3-4 pigs on a diet of tree nuts, vegetable waste, and surplus milk. This results in a far greater quantity of consumable calories (i.e. far more food) than that acre being used to grow soy. It's also better for the environment to do this than to use that acre to grow soy, because it doesn't involve deforestation and the pigs can rejuvenate the soil (via rooting and via fertilizing it with feces).

If you're trying to minimize suffering across species, then the diet most likely to succeed at that is one that is least destructive to ecosystems (i.e. something along the lines of what I described above, not veganism).

See here for empirical research supporting this argument (The vegan industrial complex: the political ecology of not eating animals by Amy Trauger): https://journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/jpe/article/3052/galley/5127/view/


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jun 10 '22

Anarchism is ultimately not maintainable.

0 Upvotes

My position is that: Anarchism that rejects

  • all forms of involuntary and coercive forms of hierarchy

  • all forms of coercionis inherently not maintainable by its very design.

Let me present my reasoning:

Let us pretend that we all go to sleep and tomorrow when we wake up we live in an anarchist utopia. All humans would live in small egalitarian communities without any form of hierarchies or systems of coercion.

What prevents hierarchies and systems of coercion from reestablishing themselves?

I will demonstrate how an authoritarian state could reestablish itself within an anarchist utopia and how anarchism has no way of preventing this.

A commune working under a direct-democratic anarchist system holds frequent elections. The frequency of these elections prevent farmers, teachers, doctors etc. from working efficiently since they have to take time out of their day to attend these elections and to properly research all of these specific topics upon which to vote.

A suggestion is made to vote for representatives that will devote all their time to studying these issues and vote on them. This removes the burden of engaging extensively in the voting process from those who have other jobs to do.

We have now reached representative democracy and created career politicians.

Since anarchism rejects all forms of coercion it is powerless to stop this shift, since to do so would require coercion. There is nothing within the anarchist model that prevents the rise of voluntary, representative democracies. From a representative democracy the step is a small one to get to the political situation of Germany in 1939. It should be noted that Hitler rose to power through exploiting the democratic system and managed to become Chancellor completely legally. This is not a defense of his actions, but an illustration of how democracy can be used to undo democracy.

For those of you who would reject my argument because "anarchism implies the absence of rule and democracy is a form of rule" I would love to hear how you think an anarchist society would make communal decisions.

Edit- Down-vote if you wish. I would prefer if you argue for your position instead. This sub is called "debateananarchist" after all, not "downvotenon-anarchists".

Edit 2- It seems the hierarchy has seen fit to limit my ability to reply to all the fine individuals who so helpfully illustrated the merits of anarchism.

Edit 3- It seems I was wrong about being banned and so I must apologize to the mods. I have gone through the 30ish comment you left the last hour and found nothing that has convinced me that this or any other kind of anarchist society is sustainable. If you feel like making a case for a specific form of anarchism please define it as precisely as you can and try to describe the organization of such a community. I am taking a little break. Thanks for your time:)

Edit 4- After roughly 24 hours of being called everything from an unenlightened idiot to a toddler I find that I am just hearing the same arguments over and over. I therefor thought I would list some of the most common "arguments":

"Direct democracy is not anarchism". - This is obviously subjective and I specified that the type of anarchism I am arguing against is the kind that incorporates direct democracy. I also love the follow up where the person then explains that in an anarchist society there would be no need for a governing boy, because there would be no laws, just consensus based decisions. Neglecting to account for what would happen if a consensus could not be reached or if someone changed their mind or violated the consensus...

"You obviously know nothing about anarchy" - This is not an argument, but it seems to be a common strategy non the less. Do I need to explain why this is not a convincing way to argue?

"Anarchism is unstable, but so is every other system of organization" - This is the "tu quoque" fallacy. You can't excuse your murders by pointing to the accuser and saying "well you are also a murderer". If you are guilty of murder, you are guilty, regardless of the various sins of anyone else.

"You should read X" - Unless you can summarize the salient points an author made or the points relevant to our discussion, I am not going to spend however many hours reading a book that may or may not be relevant to our conversation.

"Anarchism is sustainable if everybody could just..." - If your philosophy or idea for how to run a society is based on everybody "just doing x" it will never work. Everybody will never "just do" as you or anyone else says or hopes. If your philosophy relies on that in order for it to work, it never will.

This concludes the sadly rather mediocre collection of arguments. I'll keep this post open if anyone feels compelled to give me a real challenge, but try to avoid ad hominems, tu quoques and other logical fallacies. Either anarchism is valid or it isnt. Show me that it is and I will be convinced.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 06 '20

The Abrahamic religions are inherently anti-anarchist and have no place in anarchism or an anarchist society

2 Upvotes

The Abrahamic religions, Judaism, Christianity, Islam and their derivatives, all preach a hierarchy, one based in something that doesn't exist, that is incompatible with anarchism whilst also pushing reactionary ideals. Historically these religions, namely Christianity, have resulted in wars, slavery and other horrific things and it should be educated away in the same manner as capitalism should.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 08 '24

All Anarchists should go Vegan, there is no excuse for animal cruelty.

0 Upvotes

The ammount of suffering that animals in food Industries go through is inimaginable. Just try to think that since you being born, your whole life is already planned, for male chicks in egg industry it immidietly ends by gassing them or blending them ALIVE. For pigs for meat, their live ends when they are ONLY couple years old, often by electrocution or gassing them ALIVE again, they suffer, struggle for every breath before they pass out, to have a knife sliced across their throat, still often being concious, bc gass doesn't kill, only stuns for some time. Chicken body parts that you all see in KFC belonged to 6 week chicken baby at max, they were bread in horrible conditons similar to Nazi Death Camps, just scaled to chickens, when they walked they broke their bones due to being overweight by genetic modification, cows in dairy industry are regularly raped by farm workers to have babies, babies then are ripped from their mother and either made into another milk producing plant or sent to the slaughter house, if not immidietly murdered at the farm. That's a reality, reality that most of you probably take part in, you don't even have to be anarchist to recognize that it is the atrocity. We murder TRILLIONS (Including fish and sea animald) animals per year, if that is not an animal holocaust (term first used by the holocaust survivor) then I don't know what it is). There is no illness that prevents anyone from being vegan, in fact it's proven that going vegan can prevent some illnesses to occur.

Before you will say, that it's personal choice, just read it.

Personal choice is only a personal choice if there are no others involved in that choice, it's not a personal choice to go kick a dog just like it's not a personal choice to eat meat and eggs and dairy bc you actively take away non-human animals rights that anarchists claim to be for. Definition of freedom and self Determination (for what ALL anarchists stand for) is in direct conflict to take part in the biggest animal abuse on the planet.

And, before you say another thing like, "It's just HOW we do it is bad, not killing itself" let me ask you, does it matter if I kick my dog hard or soft? Does it matter if I only beat my child once a week or 7 days a week? Both of these things are bad, and shouldn't be accepted, so why is it accepted to murder these animals for no reason? No, making a living is not a reason to not abolish that thing, just like it wasn't when abolishing slavery, I care for real farmers not animal abusers. And again, look how it compares, just kicking a dog, most of the people would beat u up for it, but when it comes to MURDER of pigs, cows and chickens people will laugh when some want to protect them.

I don't call for people without means to go vegan, to go vegan, but dont treat it as if you are poor you can't be vegan, vegan diet is cheapest diet in the world if u eat whole foods, beans, grains, legumes etc.

That's a thing to think about, and act on what you can clearly see is better option. Go Vegan

https://veganuary.com/

https://www.dominionmovement.com/watch


r/DebateAnarchism • • Oct 31 '24

All Anarchists should go Vegan, there is no excuse to stop animal cruelty.

1 Upvotes

The ammount of suffering that animals in food Industries go through is inimaginable. Just try to think that since you being born, your whole life is already planned, for male chicks in egg industry it immidietly ends by gassing them or blending them ALIVE. For pigs for meat, their live ends when they are ONLY couple years old, often by electrocution or gassing them ALIVE again, they suffer, struggle for every breath before they pass out, to have a knife sliced across their throat, still often being concious, bc gass doesn't kill, only stuns for some time. Chicken body parts that you all see in KFC belonged to 6 week chicken baby at max, they were bread in horrible conditons similar to Nazi Death Camps, just scaled to chickens, when they walked they broke their bones due to being overweight by genetic modification, cows in dairy industry are regularly raped by farm workers to have babies, babies then are ripped from their mother and either made into another milk producing plant or sent to the slaughter house, if not immidietly murdered at the farm. That's a reality, reality that most of you probably take part in, you don't even have to be anarchist to recognize that it is the atrocity. We murder TRILLIONS (Including fish and sea animald) animals per year, if that is not an animal holocaust (term first used by the holocaust survivor) then I don't know what it is). There is no illness that prevents anyone from being vegan, in fact it's proven that going vegan can prevent some illnesses to occur.

Before you will say, that it's personal choice, just read it.

Personal choice is only a personal choice if there are no others involved in that choice, it's not a personal choice to go kick a dog just like it's not a personal choice to eat meat and eggs and dairy bc you actively take away non-human animals rights that anarchists claim to be for. Definition of freedom and self Determination (for what ALL anarchists stand for) is in direct conflict to take part in the biggest animal abuse on the planet.

And, before you say another thing like, "It's just HOW we do it is bad, not killing itself" let me ask you, does it matter if I kick my dog hard or soft? Does it matter if I only beat my child once a week or 7 days a week? Both of these things are bad, and shouldn't be accepted, so why is it accepted to murder these animals for no reason? No, making a living is not a reason to not abolish that thing, just like it wasn't when abolishing slavery, I care for real farmers not animal abusers. And again, look how it compares, just kicking a dog, most of the people would beat u up for it, but when it comes to MURDER of pigs, cows and chickens people will laugh when some want to protect them.

I don't call for people without means to go vegan, to go vegan, but dont treat it as if you are poor you can't be vegan, vegan diet is cheapest diet in the world if u eat whole foods, beans, grains, legumes etc.

That's a thing to think about, and act on what you can clearly see is better option. Go Vegan

https://veganuary.com/

https://www.dominionmovement.com/watch


r/DebateAnarchism • • Feb 15 '24

Why aren't you Vegan?

27 Upvotes

This post I dedicate to Non-vegan Anarchists. Please her me out! And sorry in advance for my spelling and grammar mistakes, I am a non-native english speaker.

As a Vegan and Anarchist I belive that granting animals a basic right - right to life, should be the core principal of Anarchism just as destroying patriarchy / sexism / racism and capitalism. You can't advocate for equality while eating a body of someone, that didn't wanted to die.

Most of you, because there is a minority, thinks that animal cruelty is bad and immoral. And isn't a needless killing of more than 150 BILLION animals every day just for consumption an animal cruelty act? Of course it is, every thing that is needless to kill an animal is animal cruelty.

There is no condition that will prevent you to go vegan, there is basically no circumstance outside of severe poverty that will stop you to go vegan, veganism is one of the cheapest diets you can imagine.

Let's also dive into a type of chauvinism. It's Speciesism, a discrimination on the basis of someones species.

Because, why most of you wouldn't eat a cat or a dog? Because they are intelligent? Or that they are house pets? Actually both of those arguments aren't true, it's a fact that a dog is more intelligent than a chicken, but a pig is more intelligent than cow, and also how do you define intelligence? Does it mean that if we would find hypothetical beings on the other planet, that have the intelligence of animals, would it be okay to eat them? If not, why do you think eating animals is okay?

The answer is why we eat pigs, wear cows and play with dogs is simple and always stays the same: Speciesism


r/DebateAnarchism • • Mar 28 '22

State capitalism is a variation of capitalism.

0 Upvotes

Every nation there ever was or will be, is capitalism. Every vanguard party is capitalist. The dictatorship of the proletariat is capitalist. Capitalism is the economic system of the state. The political spectrum of any capitalism ranges from full socialism to full fascism.

I bet Marx et al said things that the old-bread thinkers refused to consume at the time, because it's not what they've been fed. Take a seat at the table of fresh bread daily. The philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways. The point, however, is to change it.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 12 '24

Psychopathy makes hierarchy-less anarchy impossible.

0 Upvotes

I've done a fair bit of research since my last post trying to answer how crime is handled in an Anarchist society. So far, I'll summarize by saying that crime wouldn't happen, because humans are naturally kind and interdependent, understanding that neither side benefits.

I have not yet found a counter argument, or even a mention, of psychopathy and the effect it has on a person's logical reasoning, and how that would affect an anarchist society.

-‐-------------‐-------------‐-------------‐-------------‐------------

For definitions, here are some symptoms of psychopathy:

Psychopathy is a personality disorder characterized by lack of empathy, grandiosity, shallow affect, deceitfulness, impulsivity, irresponsibility, and disregard for the well-being or rights of others. 

https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/view/psychopathy-insights-general-practice

I don't want to try to define anarchism, because if I do people will inevitably debate about it, which isn't the focal point of this post. However, I believe pure anarchism means there are no hierarchies, no police, and no prison.

For statistics, here's a quote from the same article:

A prevalence of between 15% to 25% has been described in incarcerated populations, and approximately 1% in the general population, with a male to female ratio of about 3:1.

Psychopathy is generally described as a spectrum kind of mental illness, with most people being able to function normally and some being violently aggressive for no reason.

-‐-------------‐-------------‐-------------‐-------------‐------------

TLDR: How does an anarchist society, which doesn't have hierarchy, deal with people that are medically incapable of normal logical reasoning, empathy, or/and self control?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 07 '21

Property destruction is violence.

0 Upvotes

A belief that I have heard espoused by many anarchists is that property destruction is not violence because violence is something that can only be done to people.

First of all, what is violence? The Merriam Webster dictionary gives two essential meanings of the word violence:

1: the use of physical force to harm someone, to damage property, etc.

2: great destructive force or energy

Neither of these two definitions exclude property damage as a qualifier for violent action. But seeing as language is entirely subjective, technically, violence could mean whatever you wanted it to mean.

So for the sake of argument, let's take the first definition of violence, and focus on the "use of physical force to harm someone" part, since that seems to be closer to the definition of violence these anarchists are using.

So now we have our definition of violence- "The use of physical force to harm someone"

Now my first question is, does this definition of violence exclude property damage as a possible form of violence?

The answer to that question seems to be no. There are certainly scenarios where "the use of physical force to harm someone" could take the form of destroying property.

Here's an example. Let's say we have two people, Bob and Rob. Bob really hates Rob, because Rob always calls him names. Bob wants to get revenge on Rob. He knows that Rob has a nice, new, shiny car that he is incredibly proud of. Bob decides to go and trash Robs car. He brings a baseball bat, smashes the windows, breaks the headlights, and pours water in the gas tank. And just for good measure, he keys Rob's car too.

What Bob has just done, is an act of physical force, done with the intent to harm Rob, by destroying his property. This situation, and many others like it, certainly would qualify as an act of violence under our working definition.

Now, some anarchists might argue that this example is one of destroying someone's personal property, when the property damage they are talking about is damage done to private property.

But even with this more specific definition, there are still examples of violence that can apply here.

Let's say that Rob wants to get back at Bob for destroying his car, and Bob happens to be the owner of a big fast food chain. Rob goes with a gang of his friends, to destroy Bob's businesses. They drive around to each of the businesses he owns, and throw rocks through the windows when no one is working to make sure they don't hurt any of his employees.

They aren't trying to hurt his employees, but they are trying to hurt Bob in this situation by making him lose money and making him upset. And they most certainly are using physical force by throwing rocks through the windows.

So in this scenario as well, our criteria for what can be deemed a violent action are met.

If the intent of an act of property damage done by an anarchist is to harm someone, then in such a given instance, destruction of property could be defined as violent under our current definition.

Now all we need to do is figure out if Anarchists motivation for property damage are to harm others, like, say the business owners. The motivations of anarchists are going to be harder to definitively pin down and is going to have to rely on context, and I'm lazy so I'm just going to leave it at that.

Now that I've made my case. What do you think? Was there anything I overlooked?


r/DebateAnarchism • • Aug 08 '22

The paradox of "Hierarchy-less society" anarchy.

3 Upvotes

There are 2 types of Hierarchy based on consent - voluntary and involuntary.

As such, there is no way to eliminate voluntary hierarchy without automatically creating an involuntary hierarchy in the process.

The only way for no hierarchies to exist at any time, is if all participants voluntarily do not form hierarchies.


r/DebateAnarchism • • May 15 '21

Need some help understanding "Anarchism/Anarchy"

0 Upvotes

So, I'm a conservative. Your worst fear, don't attack me yet because of my views. I have a serious question for you anarchists and I need it answered because every time i'm on disc on a voice call with you all I get the same replies and we go in circles.

My question: In reality, you guys want true liberation and freedom. The ability to do whatever you want whenever you want with no holds barred or consequences right?

Well, doesn't that counteract itself with history and human behavior? Naturally humans will come together and form groups. And those groups form leadership and rules which will basically be laws. Which in reality restrict you from those very freedoms and liberations you call for.

It just doesn't make much sense if it just counteracts itself, I mean we went from the stone age to today's society. Human advancement comes with time and eventually ideologies will start, grow and spread.

There will always be people lurking and wanting power, and will gain followings and form nations or countries like we have today. History has proven this time and time again and it aligns with natural human behavior.

The most common arguments i've heard is, well people will form miniature groups and go by there own rules. Well that is still counteracting what you preach, and those groups will grow. And leadership is formed.

You can't sit here and rationally and logically say well if we disband all laws,governments and countries to do whatever they want will make everyone free and benefit society.

Crime rates go rampant, there is no law,police force or military to enforce these rules or give people a reason not to do something bad or do something that they shouldn't. The working economy and flow of a society would come to a halt, we'd be trading resources at some point. People wouldn't go to work as a lot now don't, people would steal way more and not care whatsoever. Sure, there'd be a bunch that work but there'd be a bunch that don't. The hundreds of millions of jobs worldwide would come to a halt, the very things you love and use and regularly take for granted today would go away, production would halt etc.

I mean even after that, you'd have to somehow convince planet earth that that very ideology would be more superior and beneficial to society which sounds crazy to me.

And if your argument for this is well the world today is corrupt. Sure, every society in itself will have problems. Humans aren't nor will they ever be perfect or create the most perfect government or society. But we can do our best to try. And in America I believe we have one of the best if not the best worldwide. Collapsing the government and political system and economy won't fix anything, it will just make it so much worse. And along with that, capitalism is by far the best economic way to run a society. It's the only method that's ever worked through ought history as all others have flawed time and time again.

Now, I doubt I will get anyone to reply because I am too much of a big brain. But if you guys do reply, please actually be intellectual and use realistic scenarios or responses. Not a minority valuable of an argument. Not sitting here swearing and yelling, act grown and be mature is all I ask because a lot of people just rush to petty insults and bullshit strawman arguments.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Mar 09 '24

It is non-reasonable to claim to be a Green Anarchist or just plainly Anarchist and not being Vegan

0 Upvotes

" I oppose factory farming but there is nothing wrong with killing animals outside of capitalism. i.e. “Killing and eating animals is not the problem, killing and eating animals under capitalism is the problem.”
This objection to veganism assumes that under capitalism factory farming is the only harmful experience attributed to non-human animals. While yes, slaughterhouses look better up in flames, at the core of speciesism is a hierarchical relationship between human and non-human animals (which is reflected in their everyday use for entertainment, pharmaceutical testing, and fashion trends involving their skin and fur) which justifies their oppression beyond just capitalism. Since the social relationship to non-human animals has been heavily shaped by capitalism, they are viewed as manufactured commodities rather than living beings capable of experiencing pain and suffering. While the elimination of capitalism and factory farming will end the institutionalized manifestations of speciesism, only an elimination of human supremacy on a personal level will create new relationships with non-human animals-relationships based on respect for their right to bodily autonomy and freedom from human domination.

or " Veganism is only a consumer activity and not inherently anti-capitalist. Boycotts don’t change anything. i.e. “There is no ethical consumption under capitalism.”
All too often this objection comes from a perspective that mistakenly assumes liberal veganism represents veganism as a whole. On an organized level, radical vegan groups and cells like the ALF, Animal Liberation Brigade, Animal Rights Milita etc. have destroyed hundreds of thousands of dollars in property and terrorized the state into creating the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act. On an individual level, veganism is an attack on the day to day speciesist power structure, a power structure invisibilized by social normalcy.

"Imposing veganism is a colonial practice because killing and eating meat is an essential aspect of many indigenous communities. i.e. “Killing and eating animals is not the problem, a colonized relationship to killing and eating animals is the problem.”

This is a common position we have seen many anarchists take. Interestingly enough, we find it is most often evoked as a response by white anarchists assuming a position as an “ally” to indigenous people. Many anarchists believe they are somehow speaking on behalf of indigenous people or seeking to further the traditions of indigenous people. This simplistic use of identity politics is nothing new. One need not look far to realize that there are a great number of indigenous people who are vegan today as well as a number of indigenous people whose customs never centered on consuming animals. There is no monolithic indigenous culture to evoke and therefore the gesture is meaningless. There are only multitudes of indigenous people with their own beliefs and customs. Attempting to justify hunting and/or non-human animal consumption by romanticizing Indigenous people only plays a role in homogenizing the experiences of all indigenous peoples.

Anyone who has attended enough anarchist gatherings that excluded vegan food knows how quickly discussions/arguments over speciesism and non- human animal oppression disrupts the atmospheric peace surrounding the consumption of animal flesh and secretions. While it seems tempting to dismiss veganism as merely a consumer activity, veganism challenges the oppressive hierarchy (speciesism) in radical spaces by acting as a wrench in the gears of speciesist conformity. By existing as such, dialog is created which brings the issue of non-human animal oppression to the surface and calls for an extended examination of internalized oppressive tendencies and behavior.

Speciesism is normalized through individual participation in a broader social program that objectifies non-human animals and places them below humans as commodities to consume. Taking part in this process of objectification normalizes the existence of oppressive thinking and ideology in anarchist spaces. It is an incomplete observation to say veganism is only concerned with food; it opens new avenues of thinking in terms of our relationship to non-human animals, while challenging a socially constructed hierarchy of human supremacy that normalizes our consumption of them.
Veganism is not merely a dietary choice, but a challenge to the dominant anthropocentric narrative. It is not about purchasing different products but cultivating new relationships with non-human animals which are not based on hierarchies and oppression. While there are still anarchists who feel waiting for the collapse of capitalism and supporting the ALF is a sufficient enough approach to anti-speciesism, many of us recognize the social and dietary framework which enables speciesism and the need for its total destruction.

Veganism is not merely a dietary choice, but a challenge to the dominant anthropocentric narrative. It is not about purchasing different products but cultivating new relationships with non-human animals which are not based on hierarchies and oppression. While there are still anarchists who feel waiting for the collapse of capitalism and supporting the ALF is a sufficient enough approach to anti-speciesism, many of us recognize the social and dietary framework which enables speciesism and the need for its total destruction.

Anarchists are quick to recognize that racism, sexism, and homophobia will not simply go away upon the collapse of capitalism and they must be fought here and now. These same anarchists, however, are often unwilling to apply this logic to speciesism. If we want total freedom, we must cultivate new relationships in our everyday lives. This means fighting oppression on every line, including the line of species. Refusing to do so is not coherent with anarchist and autonomist practices.

We are not asking for bigger cages but the destruction of all cages along with the ways of thinking that create them. Towards anarchy through individual and collective negation of this society and all its internalized roles, in solidarity with the wild against the prison world of human supremacy: vegan anarchy means attack everywhere!
Definitions:
Anthropocentrism:
The moralist belief that human beings are the most significant entity on earth.

Speciesism:
Speciesism, like many other isms, is based on a line of thinking which views certain unchosen traits as inherently superior over others. Racists think they are superior because of their race, sexists think they are superior because of their sex, speciesists think they are superior because of their species. Speciesism arises out of an anthropocentric view of the world in which an individual holds the belief that the human is the most important animal and therefore has the right to subjugate other animals based on species.

Veganism:
The avoidance, as much as possible, of cruelty to and consumption of non-human animals and products derived from them for food, clothing, and entertainment. Vegans view all animals (human and non-human alike) as beings with their own desires and potential for freedom.

Radical veganism:
is a logical extension of anarchist thought which recognizes the situations faced by all beings under attack by oppression, not only the human. Veganism in this respect proposes the constant reflection and deconstruction of personal positions, behaviors, and actions in the forever changing relationships between individuals, the world around us, and the dominating systems imposed onto us.

source: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/biting-back-a-radical-response-to-non-vegan-anarchists


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 19 '22

"You're not a real anarchist if-"

0 Upvotes

I eat meat. I invest my savings. I care for my family first. I have nationalist ties outside of America. I have religious tolerance that verges on support. I don't spend my time fighting for LGBT issues. I don't spend my time volunteering in the local community. I don't spend my time fighting for Religious issues. I don't vote. I don't think a radical change for the better is happening any time soon and I don't spend my time pretending it can. I accept money. I accept personal property. I don't make a distinction from personal and private property.

Whenever I talk about these issues to other anarchists (online) I get impassioned responses that I am not really an anarchist if I do these things and I could xyz instead. It's like you can't be pure enough. This isn't a religion.

I believe in a future where we all have access to an open and total education and at an extremely small cost due to technology.

I don't like politicians - they are all liars or turn into them in the profession.

I don't deny heavily researched scientific data (which can be said to be fact in common conversation)

I don't pick sides on every issue.

I don't like corporations - they are all empowered by the government through taxation, law, land zoning and other means.

I don't trust people who demand obedience or belief without question.

I treat every human the same and with the same standards. I approach everyone in a calm, gentle, nice, receptive manner unless they prove, as individuals, to not deserve it.

I believe in unrestricted speech.

I belive in unrestricted gun rights.

I don't support borders and militaries and all the state sanctioned violence.

In one word: I am an Anarchist.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Feb 27 '23

Is revolutionary Anarchism justified?

0 Upvotes

As an Anarcho-communist, it makes me sad when I hear anarchists justify violence and revolution.

In Spain, to name an example, we have an anarchist political party, the CNT, that hardly anyone votes for, which I find sad too. But the party is there, and people can vote for it.

It is very clear to me that Anarchism would never come to be by violent means and that any such means would obviously be counter-productive. I consider myself a democrat even more than an anarchist.

Such as it would have been utterly absurd to achieve most of the rights we have now in the Middle ages. I think that currently, most people consider Anarchism a crazy anarchic system not worth thinking of. It happens even with Socialism, let alone Anarchism.

I’d appreciate opinions.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 07 '21

The state has to exist in some form for individuals to be free.

0 Upvotes

(tl;dr of points at bottom)

Courts, civil defense, law enforcement, disaster relief, environmental protection, and poverty relief are all tasks that all require a relatively robust civic body to carry out. They're massive, manpower intensive, nonprofit operations that absolutely have to be carried out under heavy oversight. Some kind of democratic state seems like the only way to achieve these infrastructure projects, for lack of a better term.

It's also worth considering that we're more likely to reach the ideal if we take it step by step instead of trying to overhaul the world all at once. I'm not a total incrementalist, but an entire planet of armed nation states can't be healed overnight.

As I see it, the best path forward starts with large scale reform within nation states. Once a state has stability in its budget, its democratic institutions, and its protection of civil liberties, its people will thrive. It's not full liberation, but it's enough for a populace to become wealthier, more educated, and more vocal. After a critical mass of nation states achieve this kind of reform, then we can seriously talk about achieving WMD abolition, world peace, eroding borders, and decentralizing government infrastructure down to the regional or municipal operations.

But before we can achieve any of that, we need strong nation states operating on anarchical values, to pressure their neighbors to stop pointing guns and nuclear missiles at each other, and then to convince them by trade restrictions and diplomacy that they'll make more money anyway, and be better liked, if they embrace liberation. There can't be such a thing as a borderless world until I know that walking across a border doesn't change what my rights are.

And, even when we do live in that ideal world of universal liberty and freedom of movement, to keep that state of affairs intact, and to carry on those infrastructure projects, we'll still need some kind of municipal, regional, and global level democratic institutions with constitutional structures, a means of funding, and authorization (under strictly defined circumstances) to use force.

tl;dr -- the state is the best tool we have for preventing hierarchies of power, we're just using it wrong. It's also pretty good at preventing starvation and death by hurricane, which are cool bonuses.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 08 '21

Why do anarchists side with the imperialists on certain topics?

0 Upvotes

I think the most obvious example is the so-called Uighur genocide allegedly being committed by the CPC. This is something I used to believe in myself, but reading more into it, and noting that almost every western media's source was a far-right evangelical "led by God" against communism, by the name of Adrian Zenz, I immediately grew skeptical.

Looking much more into it I've even found publically available writings from high ranking CIA officials (Graham E. Fuller) from the early 2000's suggesting using a "Uighur Card" in the event of confrontation with China.

Source: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/30301/01_Xinjiang_Problem.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjQlKveyYj0AhWagXIEHZ01C4IQFnoECFEQAQ&usg=AOvVaw2OHKVhxi4OSMHdfZ2pr47x

(This is a pdf download, if you'd rather not click the link you can google "The Xinjiang Problem" and it should come up)

We all know the United States and CIA have a long history of doing exactly this, so:

Why do anarchists still defend this, and why are anarchists so quick to throw the "genocide denier" accusation at anyone who, in my opinion, rightfully shows skepticism towards these claims?

EDIT: I appreciate all of you who made solid thoughtful replies/arguments, I see a lot of you have more nuanced views on this than I previously thought. I don't have the time or energy to reply to everything but thank you (most of you) for engaging without immediately getting hostile and name-calling things like "CCP shill" lol


r/DebateAnarchism • • May 23 '20

Direct democracies are not compatible with anarchy

10 Upvotes

Many of you folks are advocates for the concept of a direct democracy; some because you believe it alleviates the issues with consent that other types of democracies have. You are wrong. Direct democracies only alleviate the use of proxies. They still involve creating a state, and initiating force against those individuals whom do not consent.

Understand that voting, under any circumstances, can only serve contrary to the consent of others. If everyone consents to a thing, there is no reason to vote in the first place. And, without this universal consent, you must be acting against the will of those that do not consent.

To implement any decision gained by this process, there still must always be a state to execute that will against those whom do not consent..which are ever-present. The creation of this state negates the possibility of anarchy.


r/DebateAnarchism • • May 03 '22

Roe Vs Wade shows the failings of federalism

0 Upvotes

If you haven't been living under a rock lately you've probably noticed that Roe Vs Wade is probably going to get overturned. This will enable states by themselves to vote on whether or not abortion should or should not be legal. Here we have a scenario wherein a central authority forces communities to enshrine something essential like abortion rights, and the central authority passing these decisions onto states threatens the existence of these rights.

This highlights a great failing in the principles of federalism and a great risk to anarchist federalism. There is no guarantee that communities will be immune from reactionary ideas, and there are times when a strong central authority is required to protect rights. Anarchist federalism provides no guarantee for the protection of essential rights.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Mar 20 '19

Why attempt to silence fascists?

4 Upvotes

I hear this one all the time from anarchists. Why is there so much emphasis on not allowing the "fascists" a platform to speak? If they're not allowed to express their views,how does an average person know that they're a fascist? Are people supposed to take your word for it?

Furthermore, the concept of suppressing speech really doesn't sound anarchist to me, as it would require some form of hierarchy. You would have to use power over these people to be able to prevent them from talking.

It leads me to believe anarchists are scared of having other viewpoints heard. If what these fascists are saying is so bad, people will find that out quickly after listening to them.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Sep 26 '20

Communism is NOT one of the goals or the main goal of anarchism.

34 Upvotes

Hello there folks, Yesterday I started a debate on r/anarchism which let to a lot of personal attacks and while I remained calm and explained why this is the case, I kept getting personal attacks and how I "should be ashamed for being an ancap troll", and in the end got banned without doing anything wrong. Well guess what? I AM NOT AN ANCAP! I just oppose the theory of communism as I believe it goes against the pre-ancom theorists! People don't realise that anarchists before the Ukrainian ancoms did not in particular theorise a communist or collectivist society. The problem is that ancoms get exposure more than individualists or egoists. What do you guys think? I believe anarchism is incompatible with communism because for an anarchist society to exist, you need to get rid violent coercion.

I consider myself almost individualist anarchist in a sense.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Jan 09 '21

Without resorting to reactionary, speciesism, or manifest destiny-esque arguments, please explain how it’s NOT selfish for humans to reproduce

29 Upvotes

I’m a staunch anarchist/lib leftist but one point of contention I often have with almost all leftists, and people in general, is that they really don’t want to hear about how we’ve been killing the planet since we were cavemen which implies, to me, that humans are directly incompatible with life on Earth, and that if we want to get serious about preserving the planet for the planet and other species’ sake we should adopt a VHEMT mindset and voluntarily stop reproducing.

However, bringing this up with almost anyone besides other VHEMT supporters or antinatalists is akin to saying that you enjoy eating babies. The vast majority of people don’t want to hear it, and even my own sister called me an alien for bringing it up. Most leftists will just plug their ears and fallaciously decry any conversations of human overpopulation as an ecofascist myth, even if the person discussing it wants nothing to do with eugenics, which tells me that they just don’t want to question the life script and why they feel the need to give birth instead of adopting. I fully expect to get my shit downvoted to hell just for bringing this up.

Any arguments consisting entirely of reactionary, speciesist, or manifest destiny talking points will be blocked and ignored; anyone trying to push those will only be wasting their time. If no one can come up with a valid reason for reproducing that isn’t selfish then I’m just going to assume that everyone who calls overpopulation a capitalist lie or mocks antinatalism is willfully ignorant.

Edit: I’m also blocking and ignoring anyone who insults me, so don’t bother.

Edit 2: Linked to the actual article instead of just a screenshot. Couldn’t directly link the article in the OP so I just linked to a comment where it works correctly.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Feb 22 '24

All the answers I saw from reddit anarchists on the topic of psychopaths are shit and they have no answers

0 Upvotes

I searched the r/anarchy101 sub for what anarchists have to say about the potential of psychopaths causing problems for people and I'm disappointed in the answers that were there. All they were doing was dodging the question and saying how the diagnosis was "ableist". Even if you could argue that these medical labels are just constructs, they exist because experts notice patterns with these people. Their traits are observable and useful to understand. The most recent thread I saw on this were full of answers that would dodge the question by reducing it to mental illnesses in general and talk about how they're "the real victims", or just say that they'll simply just prevent psychopaths from appearing because there will be no bad and manipulative people under anarchy.

If you don't want to believe it's real, fine, let's just say we're talking about people who's brains are wired in a way where their empathy works differently than everyone else. I saw a quote from the Anarchist FAQ about how we should reorganize society to reduce the impact these sorts of people will do which sounds great, but that is all in "the anarchist future", but I'm not concerned about how it would work in this hypothetical anarchist society. What I and many others would want to know is the control of harmful people that exist today. I think the best way is to beat them to death. Cull them like the pests that they are. Destroy the wreckers that bring disharmony on the peace. Not enough anarchists are saying that.

The best antidote to psychos is either an object you can swing, an object you can pierce with, or an object you can shoot.


r/DebateAnarchism • • Nov 18 '23

Voter abstention "because anarchism" is as serious as "anarchism is no laws"

0 Upvotes

People died for the right to vote, by not voting you're thowing away the rights people fought and died for. A lot of anarchist theory revolves around making sure the community is represented, if you can you should use your vote to speak that right. Choosing not to vote is a privilege and a waste. If you disagree, let me know why