r/dcss • u/ketsa3 • Sep 01 '22
Fun factor declining.
I can't put my finger on it, but I'm running a few games for the tournament, hadn't really played seriously since a few versions.
The game has become less fun.
52
6
1
Sep 01 '22
I was actually down on it the past couple versions, but this version I felt more able to get wins is weaker melee combos so I have been enjoying it.
1
u/ntrails Sep 02 '22
Can you describe what you previously found fun in the game?
So, for example, I enjoyed the flavour of not knowing what all the items were immediately. The risk of "will it be a cursed ring of attention or a free +6 stats on D:1"
I love the flavour of the new abyss, where you cannot get back up! It is a great intuitive gameplay solution to the concern.
In terms of gameplay, I have only been here since 0.26 - and it feels pretty consistent. So maybe earlier versions had different attractions. For me it is the combination of resource management and puzzling out safe plays in tough spots. I really enjoy it!
1
0
Sep 02 '22
[deleted]
3
u/oneirical The quokka hits you with a +9 glaive of flaming!! Sep 03 '22 edited Sep 03 '22
About your +9999 experiment, I, too, did something similar and was amazed to see how fast I would fall to floors I thought I was way too overpowered for with my cheated gear - when, in fact, playing normally without cheats in normal runs in these floors would have me clear them with ease.
I think that raw power isn’t enough to win Crawl. You need additional, more subtle tools, like the Blink or other supportive spells, a reliable ally, LOS control, hallway tactics… with the way AC/EV is calculated, it’s clear DCSS has “never let a character become unkillable” as part of its design philosophy.
Just look at torment, damnation and smites, which, combined, will eventually take out even a +99 million melee tank with 99 million hp.
And as for skill levels getting tighter, it’s important to consider just how OP some of the high level magic is. Just having Dragon’s Call online pretty much means you’ve won the game. If you could have that every game by the time you hit Snake Pits, I would have a 40+% winrate.
I have done smallish (3+) felid streaks in the latest version, one of them only 15-runes, so I think the game is consistently winnable without crazy luck or gear, and that’s with me being a fairly reckless player. However, I will say that the game has to be constantly relearnt, and what was good in one version may become trash in the next, and vice versa.
For example, disengagement tools like the Swiftness are very precious now. I feel like there’s still a lot of decisions and not a lot of luck - after all, the only things a felid has going for them are good spells and good jewelry, and I seriously believe I could win every game I played if I had a gun to my head. I’m a good player, but I disagree that the game requires luck to be won. Having OP gear will just melt your brain and make you die faster to hubris.
Devs are aware of the discontentment towards attacks of opportunity, I’ve seen them in the Discord occasionally mention letting melee shine a bit more in 0.30, or rethinking/replacing opportunity attacks.
If you don’t find the game fun - I advise leaving and coming back later, even the best game ever would feel stale after a while.
27
u/oneirical The quokka hits you with a +9 glaive of flaming!! Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
The Kikubaaqudgha rework has been some of the most fun I’ve ever had in any video game ever.
Clearing Tomb at level 18, only to go in Elf and instantly die to a single dancing weapon guarding the entrance is something else! It completely flips the game on its head, turning the dangerous into the easy, and the easy into the dangerous by having your power level depend on how OP the enemies are.
Maybe you’ve had the game come to the end of its lifetime for you. I don’t play some of my favourite video games of all time anymore because I’ve toured them enough, and DCSS is not exempt from this rule. When you’ve won the game 30 times, I don’t think just removing some controversial new addition will bring back the unparalleled excitement of your first win.
There’s so much variety in the indie, even free gaming ecosystem. Come play something else, and maybe when you’ll come back, DCSS will feel fresh!