r/dawsonscreek • • Jan 01 '24

Unpopular Opinion i hate joey and pacey and how it eventually became “the joey show”

0 Upvotes

i just finished dawson’s creek and i can finally come to this sub to say why i hate joey and pacey together (but mostly how much i hate joey)

i’m guessing this is an extremely unpopular opinion but i have to talk about this

they didn’t have to destroy andie’s character to break andie and pacey up. she had a lot of growth since her first appearance and even if things got difficult, pacey and andie were a strong couple. they could’ve broken up for a thousand reasons but cheating? it didn’t made ANY sense for her character. it would’ve been a thousand times better if she had said “i love you and i appreciate that you waited for me but with my treatment i realised i shouldn’t be in a relationship right now, i love you so much but i have to put myself first. don’t wait for me, go and live your life, i’ll be fine. i just want you to be happy even if it’s not with me” (and don’t even get me started with the whole thing of andie leaving the show cause i can’t)

it was rushed. they lowkey hate each other by the end of one season and by the beginning of the next they are best friends, in just a couple episodes they are flirting, and then boom! he is completely in love. really? i don’t like slow burns but oh my god they didn’t even have them time to actually create a TRUE friendship or courtship. what kills me is that enemies to lovers is one of my favourite tropes and this one was done sooooo poorly.

katie holmes was a terrible actress and it takes me out of the story every time she’s on screen. i have no idea if she got better with time like michelle williams (i’ve seen other michelle projects and thought she was great, i was shocked to see how bad she was on her early acting days but it’s amazing to see her growth) because the only other thing i’ve seen from her is first daughter and she’s bad on that too.

joshua and katie have no chemistry, idc how much everyone wants to convince me they do. they look awkward every time they are together.

everything good that he does is for joey. when he was with andie he would not only only be there for her, he would help jack, be there for dawson, worked on the relationship with his dad… after joey everything he does he does it FOR her.

“what he said wasn’t true” joey says this after pacey (finally) calls her out and it’s sooo annoying because it is true!!! she’s been treating him horribly and keeps toying with pacey and dawson while making pacey feel like less than

i hate how by season 5 it was the joey show, i think getting more screen time should be a reward to charismatic and talented performers, katie is none. the entire cast grew so much as actors but michelle and joshua were definitely the stars, the scene on the finale where they are talking and jen says that she’s so angry was BEAUTIFUL, the chemistry is good, her delivery was heart breaking and both actors seemed like they were in the zone while filming. i wish we could’ve seen more of them together. and don’t even get me started on jen’s dying wish being about joey’s love life ohmyfuckinggod

i have many many thoughts but i finished it literally 20 minutes ago and i’m still crying for jen.


r/dawsonscreek • • Jun 05 '24

Unpopular Opinion I HATE Joey Potter

2 Upvotes

Omg. I'm rewatching the series (I'm currently in season 2). Joey makes it so hard to get through the episodes. I dont think ive ever disliked a female character this much and i def dont remember disliking her this much ever. She is such a mean girl.She's so nasty to Jen and so judgemental in general. Maybe its because I'm in my 30's now but man oh man she is an embassment to the female population.

Her character has aged so horribly. I get that she's a teen but even for a teen girl shes a disgusting character. I cant remember most of the show so im really hoping she evolves soon. I really think the writers missed a great opportunity to have her have really good friendships with females.

I never realized how truly dated and mysoginstic this show was until now. I dont care if her personailty is rooted in trauma, Joey is one of the most one dimensional characters i've ever seen. And this is coming from someone with a ton of trauma.

Katie does a great job playing such a poorly written character tho.

TLDR: Joey Potter makes me want to vomit pretty much every time she opens her mouth.


r/dawsonscreek • • May 05 '25

Terrible writing

0 Upvotes

I was too young to be watching the show when it first aired, yet I did. I decided to rewatch it, but I’m 6 episodes in and it’s so cringe for so many reasons. The dialogue is so unbelievable. I know for a fact that no teenager was talking like that in the 90’s or now. No one talks like that!! It reads like a pretentious film kid wrote the entire thing. I know that Dawson is basically a pretentious film kid, but why does everyone talk like that? The way his mom confessed was so absurd and unforgivable. Dawson hands out judgment like candy on Halloween. I hate that no one points out how disturbing the Tamara situation is, not even Pacey’s own brother. Then Dawson doesn’t even have a modicum of empathy for Jen when she shares her trauma. I know that this was written in the 90’s, but it’s so damn bad.


r/dawsonscreek • • Jan 10 '24

Relationships Pacey kinda sucks

3 Upvotes

Okay 10 days ago I made a post “Dawson kinda sucks” after watching Season 4 episode 3 for the first time. Now I am back for this Pacey kinda sucks post in the middle of season 4 episode 20. Pacey’s outburst to Joey at the prom. There are still 12 minutes left in the episode so idk how it ends yet but wtf was that? Pacey says he feels like nothing with Joey because she is checks notes smarter, harder working, and more determined than he is? I know Pacey doesn’t have a good support system at home but if you can’t be with someone bc they have ambition and goals then that’s on you. Joey and Pacey fight about every little thing and Dawson is a constant threat/insecurity in their relationship at every turn/event but THAT should be the reason they break up full stop, not because Pacey is insecure and Joey makes him feel less than. I am also confused bc he rose to the occasion with Andie as the smart goal oriented gf, what is different here? And yes I know Joey picks dumb fights with Pacey all the time so that doesn’t help. What are others thoughts on this???


r/dawsonscreek • • May 18 '24

Dawson May Have Autism

1 Upvotes

For context I'm also autistic which is why this even occured to me.

So I was rewatching the pilot of the show a while back and during the scene where Dawson is showing Jen his room and talking about movies I realized something...

Dawson is autistic

Think about it, he's overly passionate about one thing, movies.That is one of the most common autistic traits. There are only two thoughts in that man's head at all times, girls and movies. In literally every season Dawson makes a movie and takes pride in said movie. Back in season one he even saw his life through movies.

Even his flaws as a character ties into autism. Part of Dawson's flaws is his relatively rigid thinking patterns and his adherance to the status quo. All of season one is Dawson's world crumbling around him and his extreme reactions to them.

Even Dawson's overwhelming verbosity ties into this. The way he communicates is clearly abnormal, his social interactions when outside of his core friendgroup are awkward as all hell and within his own friend group he constantly misreads peoples emotions or doesn't even register them.

Is there evidence to the contrary? Definitely. Most of the moments that make me think he is autistic comes from the first 3 seasons, after that he doesn't show the signs nearly as much as before

Do I think this is intentional? Probably not, a lot of the points that go towards Dawson potentially having it could also just be seen as bad writing. The show has this annoying habit of letting Dawson grow as a character and then reverting him in the next episode for cheap drama, and then in the next episode he miraculously has already reverting from his reversion and no one really cares. Even my verbosity argument doesn't work that well since everyone in the show has hieghtened dialogue.

This definitely isn't an Abed situation where the character was clearly written with that in mind but a lot of Dawson's character just happened to line up with some of the criteria.

Anyways this is my theory lol


r/dawsonscreek • • 26d ago Heartwarming

Unpopular Opinion I wanted Joey and Dawson to end up together

9 Upvotes

I just started watching Dawson's Creek on Disney plus out of the blue, I'm on season 2 episode 5, I accidentally saw that Joey ends up with pacey and I'm not going to lie it made me a little depressed. For some reason I really love Dawson so far, and I have a crush on Joey. I also like pacey, but Dawson is the when I was rooting to end up with Joey. Joey is smoking hot by the way. If Dawson ended up with Jen then I would be okay with it, but I don't know how that ends


r/dawsonscreek • • Nov 04 '25

Unpopular Opinion Anyone else here that wanted Joey to be with Dawson?

0 Upvotes

Don’t get me wrong I loved Pacey, I just felt that Joey and Dawson should’ve been together. I see so many posts on here about J & P and wondered if any others like me were always rooting for J & D?


r/dawsonscreek • • Mar 09 '23

Unpopular Opinion An I the only one who thinks Joey and Pacey have no chemistry?

9 Upvotes

It was cute when they first liked each other and were realizing there was something there, but as soon as they got together, Pacey changed and became all insecure and macho. Other than their backgrounds, they had little in common and found each other annoying except for the making out and sex.

When they had started getting closer as friends and Pacey was there for Joey, it was cute and deep, but after that, it was boring and I don't see how they could have had a future.

On the other hand, I think Pacey and Andi were an unlikely couple at first, but both really seemed to help each other grow. She helped him get serious and more responsible and he helped her be more stable. They were opposites but not in a way that inhibited each other's futures. I thought they were really cute and should have been endgame.

I like Pacey well enough, but I think he's overrated. He's ok, but Dawson just shines to me. Dawson is beautiful to watch in every way. Sure, he had some growing up to do, but he was such an old soul.

I do think he was a possessive jerk at times, but so was nearly everyone else. Joey kept messing with his mind as soon as he attempted to get close to anyone. She wanted her cake and to eat it too.

I do think Joey and Dawson should have been endgame. They had a natural chemistry that was based on mutual understanding and admiration. Sometimes they blew it, but I think that if they could have started seeing each other with fresh eyes, as adults, they could have turned out like Mitch and Gail or Noah and Allie (in The Notebook).


r/dawsonscreek • • Jan 01 '25

Unpopular Opinion Am I the only one who prefers Dawson/Joey and Pacey/Andie?

17 Upvotes

Granted, I'm only on season 3 episode 19, but I really think Dawson/Joey was a better fit. Maybe it's because I thought Pacey was better fit with Andie, idk. I know Dawson wasn't always the best guy, but I feel like he meant well.

I have seen how Pacey and Joey's relationship builds up, and to me, it feels like the writers were trying to sort of recreate the buildup between Pacey and Andie. I just really liked how good Andie was for Pacey. She brought out the best in him, and he really did everything he could to make her feel okay.

Do you think I'll feel differently after watching the rest of the series?

–please no negative comments –Edit:I'm now into the fourth season, and am not minding Pacey/Joey. Still not sure 100% if I love them as a couple, but they really do have a lot of chemistry

Edit 2: guys, I was totally wrong. I think Dawson/Gretchen is a better pairing. I love them together


r/dawsonscreek • • Jan 17 '26

Arguably Joey

3 Upvotes

I'm super addicted to this show. However, I'm getting really tired of Joey in her whining and arguing about everything! It would be nice to see her smile more. I'm in the middle of season 3 and even though I have considered quit watching, I'm hooked! 😂

Edit: I'm back tracking what I said about Joey! I can't imagine my life being as hard as hers with what she's been dealt with! Maybe my annoyance is actually for my challenge in life.

I apologize to the readers for not being sympathetic!


r/dawsonscreek • • Jul 25 '22

Relationships The Happiest she’s been!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/dawsonscreek • • Aug 19 '25

Changing D/J to make them endgame

0 Upvotes

I am fully on the D/J ship. I always have been from the very beginning. Unfortunately for me, the writers in the later seasons did not agree. I always enjoy reading fanfiction about how D/J reconcile and end up together. For me personally, I think it would have been perfect if D/J were to reconcile in Boston, after Dawson's father died. They could have make the story come full circle with Joey helping Dawson recover from his dad's death just like Dawson helped Joey when her mother died.

I would love to hear from other D/J fans, also P/J fans, if you can suspend your disbelief :) . How would you have changed the triangle and the D/J story to make them endgame? Or perhaps, what would have needed to happen in the story for D/J to reconcile?


r/dawsonscreek • • Mar 19 '23

Relationships The more I rewatch the show I realize…

4 Upvotes

That I love Dawson so much idc what y’all say he grows and grows Pacey wallows in self pity and it’s the most annoying thing to watch 👎🏾👎🏾. Also Pacey lost all his damn money. Dawson was right he can never just take accountability he always wants to be a damn hero.


r/dawsonscreek • • Oct 06 '23

Relationships Andie & Pacey > Joey & Pacey

0 Upvotes

I think Pacey was happier with Andie🤷🏻‍♂️


r/dawsonscreek • • Dec 24 '25

Joey is the most annoying TV character ever

0 Upvotes

she sucks. that’s all.


r/dawsonscreek • • Dec 24 '25

It's time for a dose of reality regarding Pacey

6 Upvotes

*bracing for the downvotes on the title alone*

So, I've been on the fence about posting this, but was literally having this discussion in my living room and then opened the Reddit and saw that post about people going too easy on Pacey versus being too hard on Joey. I thought good points were raised, but a lot were debatable, so that makes for a great discussion! The last comment was from a Killowatt59, I believe. This user essentially said Pacey is awful and the downvotes were piling up.

I'm Team Dawson, and I understand one in 10 people are. We're like Team Valor in Pokemon Go (IYKYK). But, Team Dawson for me doesn't mean I think he's a better fit for Joey. You can't deny the Pacey Joey chemistry. I just like Dawson as a character. That's all! On this Reddit I've seen the most severe things said about Dawson. I've seen him compared to the Devil, accused of believing he owns Joey, and every single negative adjective under the sun.

The dude isn't perfect. I get it. None of them are! But that's my point here, because the revisionism of Pacey as this great romantic whose charm is undeniable is just laughable. It's like people either didn't watch the show or just dismiss every one of his missteps.

I'm going to list those missteps here, and they range from small to major, and obvious, plot-point actions to more obscure things. You can still love Pacey and still be Team Pacey and Joey, that's fine, but please acknowledge that the character does a lot of awful things and isn't this knight in shining armor. So disagree! But these are concrete facts from the show. I'm not going to get into the debatable motivations and mind read the characters. If you have to down vote me because of concrete acts from the show, so be it.

Here we go (in no specific order at all).

1. He knowingly has an affair with that married woman in S6 (The ruse is that they keep meeting for her to redesign his restaurant menus. This is no longer kid Pacey. He's an adult business owner and the version of himself who ends up with Joey and who people seemingly adore. But, again, he knows a woman is married and is banging her)

2. Peeps on Joey changing after they hunt snails (A smaller one, and he's a teenage boy, so I get the character choice, but craning your neck to look in a mirror to get a peep at your female friend changing clothes doesn't scream Romeo)

3. Tells Andie he doesn't dance, then dances with Cristy (Also obvious. But again, put yourself in this situation. I think most of us lurkers here are adults. You wouldn't be crippled with sadness over this, but if your sophomore dance date told you he doesn't dance and then you caught him dancing in the hallway with the hot, popular head cheerleader, you'd still be telling the story to this day [probably laughing about it now] and calling the guy a complete douchebag.)

4. Deliberately calling Dawson 'Oompa Loompa' in front of girls (A small one, and yeah, high school boys being competitive. But for a best friend to be taunting his friend with the one childhood nickname that you know encapsulates all of his insecurities is pretty low. Particularly doing it in front of the girl he likes)

5. Promicide (Obvious. But my god, is this the worst any of the main characters treat each other in the series? Screaming at Joey in front of everyone at prom and blaming all of his insecurities on her. I'm not even going to elaborate because people know this one well, but I have seen people say the writers messed that up and it was so out of character for him. Well, I'm here to tell you that what the writers have the characters do is what defines the characters. And, foreshadowing of my list, it's not the first time Pacey yelled at her in public! Gross.)

6. Manipulates his way into sleeping in the bed with Joey at the aunt's house (To be fair, it wasn't 100% his fault, but he was talking to half asleep people and presented them with the poor options. "Hey, Dawson. What do you say you give Joey your sleeping bag?" Oh how chivalrous of you, Pacey! Why wouldn't you ask if you can take the sleeping bag?His offer is to put Joey on the floor? So romantic! Dawson says he doesn't want to hop in the sack with Pacey, and he of course could've proposed Pacey takes the sleeping bag, but he's half asleep. He then smells Joey in the morning, and it's a little weird. I get lying next to someone you love for the first time, but still).

7. Makes Dawson do all the labor to repay Mr. Brooks for the boat damage (This one flies under the radar, but it's a wild one! Dawson, who this Reddit frequently compares to Satan, stole a boat and took it into the eye of a storm to rescue Jen and Pacey, the guy who is dating the love of his life. He only has to risk his own life here because Pacey was foolish and took his boat out into a severe storm. So for many, many episodes Dawson is painting at Mr. Brooks' house and doing various chores to repay that debt. And... Pacey just never helps? He never helps. Incredibly selfish when someone is repaying a debt they owe because they damage a boat while risking their own life to save yours)

8. Just destroys Doug over his job in that one scene (It's S3 or S4, but I forget. And I get it, they're brothers and they have an odd relationship, but mostly out of nowhere Pacey just starts dogging Doug over his job when he's on a ride along with him. When I most recently watched it I was kind of shocked, because Pacey is kinda going for the jugular and basically saying his job as a small-town cop is nothing and all he does is help people get cats out of trees.)

9. Cheats on Audrey with Alex, his awful boss (Not much to say. Sure she was coming on to him, but he definitely indulges. They didn't have sex, but he still made out with her)

10. Takes Emma to that party where his scummy work team is betting on who has the hottest girl (Buys her a dress, takes her to this party trying to win a side pot that he has the hottest date. He then just kinda gets off the hook by saying he thought she could win the competition and flatters his way to safety. But objectively that's a crud ball move)

11. The way he treats Joey after they have sex for the first time (It's painfully obvious how insecure Joey is about sex. Measuring up to Pacey's vast experience, her privacy, etc. Like, of course she doesn't want Dawson to know. She doesn't want anyone to know! Not because she's embarrassed of Pacey, but because she's a teenage girl who is very reserved and doesn't want everyone knowing about her new sex life. So what? But the way he treats her that morning about Dawson is gross. Even worse is him saying "You know something. You haven't touched me all morning." So? Give her a second, dude. You love her. You know who she is. She needs a moment. He raises his voice to the point those people near them at the train station notice)

12. Yells at Joey at the dive-in movie (This is right after they've gotten back from their extremely romantic, all-time summer together on the boat. Of course the issue of seeing Dawson again comes up. Why wouldn't it? Everyone knows that's going to be a point of tension with her best friend. I'm sure you can debate whether Joey should've waited to talk to Dawson, and that's fine. But what's not debatable is that Pacey raises his voice at her in public. Imagine seeing a teenager out in public yelling at his girlfriend. You'd get the ick. And this was hours after they got off the boat. That's three times I've recounted here where he yells at her in public)

13. Takes Joey on this weird, double date in S6 trying to lay the pipe with the other woman? (What even is this? I'm sure most people don't even acknowledge this because it the start of the Castaways episode, I believe. But the episode begins with the two on this weird double date scenario. It's unclear. At the very least Joey thinks they're just out to dinner with some friends? It's not explained well, but we quickly find out Pacey told the woman, who he is definitely hitting on, that Joey is his sister, and he did not tell Joey about this ruse! She's put off by the whole thing and demands they leave. It's a bit messy and isn't even that big of a deal... until later in the episode he tells Joey he still has these immense feelings for her?! What? So you're still in love with Joey, but you're willing to not only hit on other women in front of her, but use her as some sort of pawn in a double-date scenario to get near this other woman. What kind of move is that?)

14. Commits felony by stealing his dad's car and impersonating an officer (There is absolutely zero in the show that suggest Pacey's dad would be cool with him taking the squad car out. He's a dick to Pacey and thinks he's worthless. He'd never. So we can only assume he's taken his dad's car -- or maybe Doug's -- out for a joy ride, then wrecks it, then capitalizes on Andie being the anxiety-ridden person that she is who immediately assumes the doomsday scenario where he's a real police officer. Now, this one is easy to dismiss as just a fun little thing in the show. A goofy cute meet for Pacey and Andie. But int this post I'm talking about the holistic view of Pacey as this stand-up guy. Be real, fellow Redditors. If you knew a guy in high school who banged his teacher and who would take his dad's cop car out for fun, you wouldn't take that guy seriously at all. You might find him kind of funny, but he'd be disregarded as just a loser buffoon who's probably going to flunk out (and he nearly does)

15. The Tamara story line (Obvious. TV has definitely and thankfully changed the way it handles these storylines, and numerous people here have pointed out how troubling the number of age-gap relationships on the show is. Make no mistake, ultimately Tamara is at fault because she's the adult and it should have never happened, but this is not a case of an adult grooming a minor like a lot of shows or movies portray. Pacey fully pursues her and is really gunning for it to happen. It's not a strong mark against him, because he's a dumb kid and the adult is in the wrong, but it's still weird, because, and here's where people need to be honest: If you went to a high school with a kid who everyone knows banged a teacher, that would always taint that person and I'd imagine it's very unlikely girls are looking at him a couple years later as this charming romantic. I bumped this down the list so that it's less prominent, in the hopes people will actually discuss other points brought up! I know people have feelings about this weird plot thread)

16. Not telling Dawson about him and Joey (The biggest one in terms of plot, perhaps. Yes, he tried on that little camping trip, but he didn't tell him. He had all the opportunities, and never told him. He started dating his best friend's soulmate (in Dawson's eyes) behind his back and didn't have the spine to tell him)

---

So there's an easy 16 items for you guys, and I've left numerous out. Once again, I'm not saying Joey should have ended up with Dawson. I'm not saying Dawson is perfect. I'm just saying that it's a joke how extolled Pacey Witter is as a character when he's done all of the above across six seasons. The worst part is that a lot of those directly relate to how he treats women, but he gets this reputation as the world greatest romantic.

He buys Joey the wall, beats up a bully for her, is an excellent brother to Gretchen, helps out at the Potter B&B and is wonderfully supportive of Andie when she's going through her mental health crisis. There's no doubt his character has some great moments, but enough with pretending like he's God's gift to women.


r/dawsonscreek • • Feb 15 '26

What are your thoughts on James Van Der Beek?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/dawsonscreek • • Oct 30 '25

Watching the whole show from start to finish properly for the first time and I have to be honest: I don't like Pacey with Joey

0 Upvotes

I watched the show here and there growing up but me and fiancée are finally watching the whole thing properly and I have to be honest - this pairing just isn't working for me the way it seems to for everyone else.

Yes the actors have chemistry, but Joey is such a miserable, joyless character all the time, all they ever seem to do is bicker and bring out the worst in each other. Pacey is less charming to watch when he's with her imo.

When Pacey was with with Andie, you could feel both characters becoming better people by working together to overcome their flaws. AND they had great chemistry together. Their breakup still feels like the most cobbled together contrivance of the whole show, like different writers stepped in and started a radical course correction for some reason.

Pacey and Joey just feel mired in Joey's weird symbiotic relationship with Dawson all the time and even when they finally get away from that they don't really seem to enjoy themselves. It's melodrama for melodrama's sake.

And yes, obviously Dawson and Joey are a lot worse, water is wet!


r/dawsonscreek • • Jun 23 '24

I hate Joey so much

0 Upvotes

She lies and lies and lies and pretends to care and when she gets caught throws a whole ass tantrum. I'm on season 4


r/dawsonscreek • • Jul 25 '22

What should have happened.. Anticipation… #OTP

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/dawsonscreek • • Mar 15 '24

What should have happened.. The Love Triangle

1 Upvotes

I honestly don’t see why people hate Dawson , I get he has some outlandish qualities but he had every right to feel how he felt when Joey and Pacey started dating. No “real” friend would date their bestfriends ex at all. And Pacey knew everything about the two and how Dawson felt about Joey. Dawson is very mature for letting Joey go and be with Pacey, because he honestly could’ve hated both of them cause what they did was wrong. I honestly feel Dawson and Joey should’ve been giving a better chance rather than what we seen. They could’ve allowed them to grow together , because that’s what high school is all about growth and finding what you really want to do. I just feel Dawson had the right to be upset about their relationship because it was messed up what they did to him


r/dawsonscreek • • Oct 23 '24

I wished pacey witter and andie mcphee stayed together instead of him being with joey she's a little boring for me

0 Upvotes

r/dawsonscreek • • May 28 '25

Joey Potter has to be the most insufferable character in Dawson’s creek

5 Upvotes

It’s my first time watching Dawson’s Creek and I’m on season 4. I just can’t get over how ANNOYING Joey is right now, come to find out, she’s one of the fan favorites?!

First of all, Joey was absolutely insufferable in season 1. Always wanting people to feel bad for her because she’s “poor” and Dawson didn’t like her. It made me so angry how she took her feelings for Dawson out on Jen when Jen didn’t even do anything wrong, and the fact that it lasted for a whole 2 seasons. Joey is not a girls girl at all. She would rather be the center of attention to a group of boys than have an actual good girl friend. Joey is never satisfied with who she dates and constantly emotionally cheats on both Dawson and Pacey. I don’t understand how either of them put up with that. All she cares about is being able to date Pacey while also having the attention of Dawson on the side.

ALSO, I don’t understand what was going through her head when she decided to tell Dawson that her and Pacey had sex. That’s NONE of his business. It’s so annoying how everyone in the group always babies Dawson (especially her). Joey always feels the need to put Dawson in the center of her and paceys relationship and make sure he knows everything. She constantly lets Dawson sweet talk her while dating pacey and never sets any boundaries. She always feels the need to criticize everyone’s mistakes even when they have NOTHING to do with her, like when she caught pacey and Jen making out.

Joey Potter never stops complaining about something, she’s so weak that she always has to make everyone feel worse just so she can satisfy Dawson. She constantly worries about her ex feels instead of how Pacey feels. She never stops obsessing over Dawson…”I don’t wanna do that because Dawson…”. Everyone constantly talks about how Dawson is SO annoying, but Joey might just be way worse. I don’t get how Pacey, Jack, or Jen could be friends with either of them. She’s such a brat and gets all over dramatic about every situation.


r/dawsonscreek • • Jun 16 '25

Unpopular Opinion Pacey and Joey

2 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion I see but I didn’t love their pairing. I really liked Pacey and Andy. I don’t like Dawson for Joey either but I just don’t get all the hype for J and P. It makes sense why they were into each other but I don’t feel the mind blowing chemistry everyone else to see. Also gotta let this out, J and D can be really insufferable but especially Dawson. But yeah help me understand why you guys like them so much