I love Lynch, by the way, if you were scared of the title. I've been going through all of his main movies since he passed, because I never got the chance to when he was alive. I've only recently started doing the filmography thing where I focus on a single director and watch all of their works.
Anyway, I've been listening to The Blank Check Podcast after every Lynch movie I watch, and I've been consuming media related to him (not the stuff about wHaT tHe eNdInG rEaLlY mEaNs) and I feel like I'm not getting something that others do. Others (like the podcast, Redlettermedia, etc.) keep mentioning that Lynch's stuff is scary or frightening, or off-putting, and I just don't really see it. I've watched Twin Peaks the original series (haven't started The Return) I've watched Fire Walk With Me, Wild At Heart, The Elephant Man, The Straight Story, and Lost Highway and in each piece of media (except Elephant Man and Straight Story) I have found the tone to be incredibly wacky, and honestly pretty funny.
I like absurdist comedy, so I feel like Twin Peaks, Wild at Heart, and Lost Highway appeal to that, but again, people say it's creepy or scary. There are creepy moments, sure, but I think any horror aspect is undercut by absurd dialogue, acting, plot points, and honestly VFX.
Is there something I'm missing? Do other people feel something I don't? Is this a case where people interpret/feel about his movies however they do, and I've just fallen into a bubble of media that think his stuff is scary?
Edit: thank you to everyone who tried to explain what people find scary about his movies. Since reading the comments, I have found out that I am immune to the feeling of dread that others experience while watching Lynch's movies. I also realized that I didn't quite explain how I feel during his movies otherwise, given the few commenters that told me "yeah, rape and murder is scary." That was very helpful, by the way.
It's not like when Laura Palmer is being murdered in FWWM, I'm laughing my ass off. I'm mostly just sitting there, watching. I'm not afraid of Leland or Bob in that moment. I never felt the dread leading up to her death - everything leading up to it felt inevitable and I already got a good sense of what happened to Laura in the show. Any amount of other emotion - like disgust, hate, sadness, etc. - I had while watching the show. I found FWWM to be interesting - as a window into Laura's last week and what happened, but it didn't affect me emotionally, past getting me to laugh at goofy scenes like the gobble gobble scene.
To reiterate: I have felt other emotions for Lynch's work. Mostly, it's been hate and anger. I think he's very good at making villains - like Wild At Heart and The Elephant Man. I've felt sadness in his more normal movies like The Elephant Man and The Straight Story, I just don't really respond to his level of surrealism. I think there's also a disconnect with his characters that I guess others don't have.